“Double Edged Sword”, Emotional Labour Essay

3262 words - 14 pages

THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTERMANCHESTER bUSINESS sCHOOL |
“Double-Edged Sword”, Emotional Labour |
:The examination of the extent to which emotional labour is harmful for workers |
|
|
BMAN31430: Human Resource ManagementCourse Coordinator: Dr. Isabel Tavora799264112TH NOV 2013 |

This paper aims to explore fundamental concept of emotional labour, based on the empirical case studies in order to attempt to answer the question, “Is emotional labour really harmful for workers?”, and also investigate the contradictory claim that it is not harmful, including the practical recommendations for problematic emotional labour. |

CONTENTS

1. Introduction………..………………………………….…..…… ...view middle of the document...

As the number of employees in the service industry is increasing, research has placed greater emphasis on considering the psychological impact on employees performing labour that involves emotional display and managing feelings. In 1983, Arlie Hochschild popularised the concept of “emotional labour”, referring to the expression component of work roles. “Emotional labour” requires “face-to-face or voice-to-voice contact with the public and the workers are required to produce an emotional state in another person and allow the employer to exercise a degree of control over the emotional activities of frontline employees” (Hochschild, 1983, p. 147).
The purpose of this paper is firstly to provide empirical research explaining the concept of “emotional labour” in order to support the claim that “emotional labour is harmful for workers,” and also to clarify the claim with objective case studies. Secondly, the paper will investigate the contradictory claim that emotional labour not harmful for employees, based on evidence from relevant literature. Subsequently, it will shed light on counteractions that organisations or managers could take against the problem of emotional labour, and finally, a brief summary of the findings and limitations of this research will be provided.

2. Emotional Labour

Most of an employee’s emotional displays are considered to be a public performance rather than a private matter under their employer’s control. This notion particularly applies to organisations in the service industry where daily routine involves consecutive interactions with other people. The process of complying with social norms by controlling one’s emotions is referred to as “emotion work” (Hochschild, 1983). Generally, people tend to manage their emotion, if their job requires them to display certain emotions and suppress others. Hochschild (1983) coined this regulation of one’s emotions to follow occupational or organisational norms as “emotional labour”.
“Emotional labour is the management of feeling to create a publicly observable facial and bodily display; emotional labour is sold for a wage and therefore has exchange value” (Hochschild, 1983, p. 7). The theory of emotional labour is associated with emotion that arises from workers, or where a worker pretends to feel a certain emotion in order to comply with their working conditions.
Hochschild (1983) argued that there are a certain set of emotions that should be displayed during a service encounter between service providers and customers. In 1973, Ekman defined such expectations as “display rules”, outlining expectations of which emotions should be expressed and which should be suppressed. The role of “display rules” is to encourage the portrayal of the desired company image to the public in order to elicit the desired responses, such as satisfaction and trust, from customers.
Researchers proposed that employees use three types of action mechanism to conduct emotional labour;...

Other Papers Like “Double-Edged Sword”, Emotional Labour

Social Essay

330 words - 2 pages our lives. Entertainment and media always go hand in hand, but in addition to the entertainment, mass media also remain to be an effective medium for communication, exchange of information, advertising, marketing, and in general, for expressing and sharing views, opinions, and ideas. Mass media is a double-edged sword which means that there are positive as well as negative influences of media. Advantages : The common man gets the latest

Samurai And Sword Essay

1892 words - 8 pages into a little bit of the history of the sword itself. The sword was split into about four different time periods. However, some say that the sword dates back as far as 1300 years ago. The Japanese sword was a double edged blade, which originated from the Chinese sword, the Jian. Thus, the Katana - Japanese sword – was born. Around the same time period, during the Heian period, when the samurai came about, the Japanese sword slowly began to

The Great Depression Was a Government Failure- Do You Agree?

769 words - 4 pages intervention with issues like relief to the unemployed, all seeming to point the finger of blame at the government. One of the main causes of the depression was the issue of overproduction and the fact that there was nowhere to sell all of this surplus to. Tariffs put up by Coolidge to protect American goods was a double edged sword and it fell back badly, many other countries who were recovering from the war also put up tariffs to prohibit American

Biology, Bad Genes: A Relationship For Crime

933 words - 4 pages embraced this as the coming age of “neuroprediction” (Connor, 1995). This may become the double-edged sword we will get. To be able to use information obtained more efficiently and target social resources to preventing violence in at risk children. Also labeling any child as a “future criminal” is likely to have consequences. The advancement that society has made through scientific research with adults and children have paved the way for that

Organisation

1231 words - 5 pages Differences 41 (2006) 959–970 961 mitted to various facets of the workplace including the job, occupation, and organization (Cooper-Hakim & Viswesvaran, 2005), and such foci-specific commitments do not necessarily have to be congruent with each other (Reichers, 1985). Furthermore, Openness to Experience should not relate to affective commitment because research has noted that it is a ‘‘double-edged sword’ that predisposes individuals to feel both the

Re: Week 10 Discussion

1699 words - 7 pages respond to emergency situations, which can cause the libido to decrease. CAUSES AND EFFECTS * Erratic sleep habits: Students suffering from stress might swing between exhausted and fatigue from hormonal overloads, or they might experience sleep disruption, which can lead to a cycle of increased stress and insomnia (Brown, 2015). Conclusion For students, stress can be a double-edged sword. Some types of short-term stress can give students the

Why Cops are Different

1643 words - 7 pages the routine patterns that are needed in healthy marriage and family development. Strong marital and family development is based on rituals, like dinners together, "inside jokes," repeated activities, etc. The rotating shift worker has less chance to develop these rituals and his relationships suffer. This predisposes the officer's family to potential problems ranging from divorces, to children acting-out. 5) Camaraderie can be a two edged sword

Purple

712 words - 3 pages the 1920. Therefore colored women had a double edged sword, they had to fight for freedom, but not be to dominate as to effect the men. The Color Purple is a good example of colored women's plight. Three obstacles black women had to overcome to be able to express themselves were Racism, the lack of education, and the stereotype that women are inferior.The movie is about a black girl, Celie, who gets molested by her father and has two children

Global Inequality

579 words - 3 pages technology. There is no way for someone born into an impoverished nation to be able to keep up with someone born into a developed country when it comes to technology because of mere exposure time between the two. The health issue is a double edged sword because although many diseases that haunted the past like polio have been eliminated, new ones emerge that cause even more disastrous effects like AIDS. The government now offers incentives to drug

Discuss the Contributions of Iron Technology to the Process of State Formation in Bantu Africa

657 words - 3 pages adopted many cultural aspects of their neighbor at the expense of abandoning their culture. This was because the Bantu culture was continually being exposed to new cultural practices and norms. The ability of the Bantu people to adapt seamlessly to a new situation, new notions, and new regions later turned out to be a double-edged sword. Were it not for this ability, the Bantu would not have found it so easy to abandon beliefs and practices they had

Derivatives

624 words - 3 pages , arbitrage, types of risks, overleveraging and derivatives as a double edged sword and the various terms that will be used during the course of study. Executive Summary The basic objective of this project is to understand the working of derivatives, its uses and risks associated with it, the extent to which they should be used and how they should be used to be beneficial to the corporate investors. After understanding the basic working of derivatives

Related Essays

Surveillance: A Double Edged Sword Essay

577 words - 3 pages Surveillance: A Double Edged Sword As citizens of a free nation our constitution has granted us certain basic rights. The expectation from preservers of law and order is that they will help us to exercise and enjoy these powers. Security from threats is another expectation that we demand from the keepers of law. Obviously, in order to provide us security from outside threat the law keepers need to exercise some special powers and the basics of

A Double Edged Sword Caffeine Essay

1425 words - 6 pages : Pregnant women or nursing mothers are suggested have no more than 150mg caffeine per day; Elderly women who don’t get enough calcium should limit their caffeine consumption under 200mg per day; People with high blood pressure shouldn't get more than 200mg caffeine per day; People with panic and anxiety disorders ought to control their caffeine intake. Conclusion Caffeine is a double-edged sword. Benefits of caffeine make it

Eating Disorders Essay

562 words - 3 pages tool in turn they become obese then they use eating to deal with their depression which works as a double edged sword. What they love is what is destroying them physically as well as mentally. This can also be considered emotional eating this is eating when you’re angry, sad, or even anxious. Many cultures have different views as what is considered attractive these variables play a large part in what peoples diet habits are this can be seen in the

Asian American Essay

1318 words - 6 pages . The more appearance of Asian Americans in visual culture can be a double-edged sword, indicating the consumption and repercussions among U.S society. On the one hand, it’s encouraging to see Asian American faces in the mainstream media being associated with positive traits — intellectual, well-educated, knowledgeable, etc. (P.Farhi, 2011, p14). For example, in Verizon’s 2011 commercial, Belt of Technology, a kid walked in a Verizon store and