This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Does Rumination Hinder Forgiveness In The Context Of An Interpersonal Transgression

2223 words - 9 pages

Does rumination hinder forgiveness in the context of an interpersonal transgression?
Forgiveness theory has been widely researched in the social psychology arena in recent years. The role of rumination in forgiveness has received much attention, with several important studies by prominent researchers attempting to measure its effect. A dominant theoretical perspective on the relationship between rumination and forgiveness in the literature suggests that rumination is detrimental to forgiveness, and that changes in rumination are the antecedent to changes in forgiveness. This paper outlines the prevailing theoretical perspectives on this relationship and presents a critical analysis of a ...view middle of the document...

Several authors have investigated the relationship between rumination and forgiveness, resulting in a large volume of research which supports the underpinning theoretical perspective put forward by early research into this area. On the whole, there is a widely held consensus that rumination by the victim following a transgression is detrimental to achieving forgiveness. One of the most important early attempts at explaining the role of rumination in forgiveness is the framework of forgiveness put forward by McCullough et al. (1998). This framework presents rumination as one of the key and most proximal determinants of forgiveness (together with empathy), and posits that the mechanism by which rumination affects forgiving is via the “rumination revenge sequence” (p.1598). Rumination is thought to lead to increased motivation by the victim to seek revenge, independent of other factors such as the victim’s level of empathy or the presence of an apology by the transgressor. The increased motivation for revenge is in turn correlated to a decrease in forgiveness.
Worthington and Wade (1999) present a complex model explaining the process of forgiveness and unforgiveness, which differentiates between interpersonally active (external actions) and passive (not communicated to the transgressor) responses. Rumination is classified as a passive response, which enhances the victim’s motivation to seek revenge and to avoid the transgressor, leading to a state of unforgiveness. In order to break through the unforgiveness, an event that is emotionally dissonant with unforgiveness must occur. Once the emotional dissonance is resolved, forgiveness can then result (Worthington & Wade 1999).
Several studies have corroborated these theoretical perspectives. In an important longitudinal study, McCullough, Bono and Root (2007) hypothesised that rumination about a transgression by the victim leads to re-experiencing of the incident and surrounding emotions, which results in a heightened readiness to avoid and/or seek revenge against the transgressor. They operationalised this hypothesis by measuring the victims’ “transgression-related interpersonal motivations” (TRIMs), (p. 491) during the transition to forgiveness over several weeks following an interpersonal transgression. This was measured by means of the TRIM Inventory, a self-report tool developed by McCullough et al. (1998). Their findings strongly support the hypothesis that rumination leads to increases in avoidance and revenge motivation, thereby decreasing the likelihood of forgiveness. This conclusion was further supported by temporary increases in avoidance and revenge motivation found in study participants after they ruminated about the transgression more than was typical for them. A limitation of this study is the difficulty in determining causality between rumination and forgiveness, due to the possibility that a third variable could explain this relationship in a non-experimental setting. This...

Other Papers Like Does Rumination Hinder Forgiveness in the Context of an Interpersonal Transgression

Context Of The Crucible Essay

772 words - 4 pages CONTEXT This play takes place in Salem, Massachusetts, in 1692.We are in the home of Reverend Parris, whose daughter, Betty lies apparently unconscious in bed after being discovered at midnight dancing in the woods outside Salem. Her father had witnessed this scene, which involved the house black slave Tituba, and Parris' niece Abigail, and one other unidentified naked girl.It later transpired that this naked girl was Ruth, the daughter of Mr

Nonverbal Communication in the Context of Managerial Communication

1370 words - 6 pages Nonverbal communication in the context of managerial communication Introduction Communication is exchanging and sharing information, ideas and message. Each and every day, in every social interaction, we communicate our feelings, attitudes, thoughts and concerns using a definite medium or pattern. Communication has two major forms namely Nonverbal communication and Verbal communication. In our conversation we use both verbal and

How Does Knowledge of the Foundations and History of Nursing Provide a Context in Which to Understand Current Practice? Identify at Least Three Trends in Nursing Practice from the "Nursing Timeline of...

764 words - 4 pages . To fully be able to comprehend and combat Alzheimer's disease, one must know what it does to the brain, the part of the human body it most greatly affects. Many Alzheimer's disease sufferers had their brains examined. A large number of differences were present when comparing the normal brain to the Alzheimer's brain. There was a loss of nerve cells from the Cerebral Cortex in the Alzheimer's victim. Approximately ten percent of the neurons in this

The Social Context of Childhood

3576 words - 15 pages .(2008) Modern Childhood. Out to play. Daily Telegraph 29. Sandefur, G. and Wells T. (1999). “Does Family Structure Really Influence Educational Attainment?” Social Science Research 28:331–57. 30. Schoon I. (2006) Risk and Resilience: adaptations in changing times. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 31. Smith I.(2011) New Approach to Child Poverty: Tackling the Causes of Disadvantage and Transforming Families’ Lives. Norwich: TSO 32. Thin N.(2012) Social happiness: Theory into policy and practice. Bristol: The Policy Press 33. UNICEF (2007) Child Poverty in Perspective. An Overview Of Child Well-Being In Rich Countries.

How Does an Increase in Life Expectancy Effect the Economy

614 words - 3 pages As the life expectancy of the U.K has increased and peoples career opportunities have increased therefore not many people are having as much children, if any, there is an ageing population in the U.K. The ageing population which the U.K is facing can cause great problems socially, politically and economically. The social problems with an ageing population are that there will be a greater strain on the NHS and also the care available will

“The Statutory Company Auditor Is Not An Employee Of The Company”. Discuss This Statement In The Context Of The Appointment, Duties, Remuneration, Resignation And Removal Of A Company Auditor In...

2726 words - 11 pages Registrar may make the appointment of auditors on a written application of any shareholder of the company if the directors do not appoint an auditor as per required by this section.It is a common practice for companies to appoint an auditing firm as auditors of the company. All resident partners of the firm must be approved company auditors and shall not knowingly consent to be appointed as auditor if he does not meet the requirements in Section 10 (1

The Role of Effective Communication and Interpersonal Interaction in a Health and Social Care

1261 words - 6 pages children, the ill and working class citizens from infancy to later adulthood. For each setting under the Health and Social Care field there is a different user and situation, so the method of communication depends on the situation and the service user. For example, in a GPs surgery, the method of communication used would be one-to-one communication as the interaction generally only happens between two persons (the doctor and the patient). An advantage

How Does An Understanding Of Local Culture Give Managers An Advantage In Working In Business Competition?

422 words - 2 pages How does an understanding of local culture give managers an advantage in working in business competition? In order for a business to be competitive in a foreign country, it is important that the managers have an understanding of the national and local culture of the country. This must include the religious practices and laws governing the people. And since business involves people, and is regulated by people, it is important to understand

Explore Priestley's Dramatic Methods in Act 3 Pages 50 – 56 Demonstrating How an Understanding of the Historical and Social Context of the Play Might Help Shape the Audience Response to This Scene and...

1054 words - 5 pages Explore Priestley’s dramatic methods in Act 3 pages 50 – 56 demonstrating how an understanding of the historical and social context of the play might help shape the audience response to this scene and the play as a whole. Throughout An Inspector Calls, Priestley uses the Inspector as a way of warning the audience to address many problems that are occurring, or have occurred in society. The fact that the play is set in 1912, and written in

The Aesthetic Innovations In A Modernist Context

1584 words - 7 pages William Faulkner, T.S. Eliot and Robert Frost all had an amazing ability to write and were at the forefront as literary authors of modernism which was not a period, but a faction, an attitude that focused on individualism, randomness of life, etc. Their writings were based on a worldly position that included most poets. They contributed intellectually to literature as well as made aesthetic innovations in a modernist context. Their uniqueness

Invisible Hand In The Vietnamese Context

3465 words - 14 pages Invisible Hand in the Vietnamese context Introduction Adam Smith is an infamous political economist in the UK and around the world. He has many valuable arguments among which this essay will refer to the theory of "invisible hand" which was coined in The Wealth of Nations. The invisible hand is essentially a natural phenomenon that guides free markets and capitalism through competition for scarce resources by maintaining equilibrium between

Related Essays

P1 Explain The Role Of Effective Communication And Interpersonal Interaction In A Health And Social Care Context

1621 words - 7 pages them feeling uncomfortable or unaware. Different contexts of communication are used in many different care setting situations such as; *One to one – One to one conversations may take place between the service user and the member of staff. One to one conversations allow the member of staff to be heard clearly giving the service user an easier job listening without the distractions from around the room. Especially with this type of conversation

Role Of Effective Communication And Interpersonal Interaction In A Health And Social Care Context

725 words - 3 pages Task 1 Question : Explain the role of effective communication and interpersonal interaction in a health and social care context. (P1) Effective communication and interpersonal interaction, are used in many aspects of our lives and are fundamental skills for health and social worker and the service users. Professional care workers have to be able to know when the appropriate type of communication in different situations, with people of

Assessment In An Industrial Context Essay

900 words - 4 pages ASSESSMENT IN AN INDUTRIAL CONTEXT The assessment process in an industrial context Three broad areas in assessment in industry * First concerned with psychological measurements of attributes of individuals in the workplace. Measures used here can be classified as psychological measures or techniques * Second and third is concerned with assessment of groups and organizations and measures used are not classified as psychological measures

Every Organisation Has To Prepare For The Abandonment Of Everything It Does"( Peter Drucker). Discuss This Statement In The Context Of Change Management And Strategy

2993 words - 12 pages operate in an environmental context , which is meant to naturally change throughout time due to external forces which could take the form of competition , customers , technology and so on. Also some organisations might find themselves bound to change campaigns due to expansion , addition of branches or relocation of their primary headquarters.Moreover , the need for change can arise as a result of pressures both within and outside the organisation. In