Does Abstinence Only Curriculum Make A Difference?

1896 words - 8 pages

Does Abstinence Only Curriculum Make a Difference?
David A Zanis, an Associate Professor of Social Work at Temple University in Harrisburg, PA published a study of the “Use of Sexual Abstinence Only Curriculum with Sexually Active Youths” in 2005. The study was of a group of 31 ‘high risk’ students ranging in age from 12 to 16 who voluntarily participated in the program. The results showed that the Sexual Abstinence Only curriculum was unsuccessful in reducing sexual activity among this particular group of young people.
The study (1) featured in Zanis’s paper was very limiting, the 31 students featured were all classified as ‘high risk’ and were referred to an alternative school-based ...view middle of the document...

The number of sexually active students who would say ‘yes’ if asked to have sex dropped from 68% at the pretest to just 11% posttest. But saying and doing are two different things as all of the sexually active students reported that they had engaged in sex in the 30 day period after completing the SAO program. The sexually active students wanted sex education, but wanted information about sexuality not abstinence they wanted information on where to obtain contraception, how to use it, and the effectiveness of it. Abstinent students completing the same SAO program wanted to continue abstinence education as well as a desire to remain abstinent. The abstinent students felt overwhelming pressure to engage in sex from their sexually active peers, but after the program one student said “I now know that I can say not to boys about sex because I know that they know that it is OK not to have sex”.
The students that had been sexually active before the SAO program reported that they had continued to engage in sex after completing the program. This does not mean that abstinence education does not work, rather that it may not be the best choice for youths that are already sexually active. It is difficult to have a true reading due to the small sample of students and the potential bias of the researcher in interpreting the data.
Another study (2) that looked at abstinence only education for sixth and seventh graders showed greater success at keeping the kids from having sex within a two-year period. The study featured an 8 hour abstinence lesson and showed that 2/3 of the sixth and seventh graders remained abstinent for 2 years, and 1/3 had engaged in sexual intercourse in the same time frame. In comparison more that half of students that were taught about safe sex and condom use engaged in sexual intercourse within the two year period. 40% of students who received 8 to 12 hour lessons that incorporated both safe sex and abstinence education reported having sex at the two year mark. Students who received only instruction on good health, but not involving sex reported 47% having sex in the two years after the class. This study shows that abstinence only education can be effective in delaying sexual activity among kids that have not had sex yet. The study involved 662 African American students from four public middle schools in a city in the Northeastern United States. It was conducted between 2001 and 2004. (3)
In recent years the federal government has invested greatly in abstinence-only education. Established in the 1996 overhaul of welfare, it did not allow talk of any forms of birth control other that to explain their limitations. Critics claimed that by denying education on contraception led to a lack of knowledge among young people and in 2010 President Obama cut funding for abstinence-only education in his budget.
The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy stated “It is unreasonable to expect any single...

Other Papers Like Does Abstinence Only Curriculum Make a Difference?

How Does Achebe Make Okonkwo Such A Striking Central Character In The Novel? Support Your Answer With Close Reference To The Whole Novel

583 words - 3 pages How does Achebe make Okonkwo such a striking central character in the novel? Support your answer with close reference to the whole novel.Achebe made Okonkwo into a striking character by presenting him as a very complex person who is driven by his emotions and at the same time suppressing them. Out of this suppression comes his anger for his father which he channels to the people closest to him and to events that happened around him. Yet he is

How Does Fitzgerald Make Gatsby a Mysterious Character

567 words - 3 pages way we rarely receive information about his younger years; however, when we do it is very disjointed from the text and it is difficult to understand the full story of Gatsby’s life. And when it does in fact arrive the way Nick constantly analyses the preceding information suggests to the reader that the information given to us must be taken with a pinch of salt. For example, Gatsby tells Nick in chapter six that he was ‘educated in Oxford

Abstinence Education

963 words - 4 pages , comprehensive sex education is the most effective protection against teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases and infections. Only by providing various information and interventions to adolescents does it allow them to make responsible decisions about their sexual behavior and sexual activity. Some argue that abstinence is the only way to prevent teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Those who believe this argue safe sex does not exist

There Are Other Ways Than Abstinence Until Marriage for Teens

828 words - 4 pages provide missing information to adolescents and hold information needed for adolescents to make informed choices. These programs also neglect real health needs for contraceptive methods and STI testing among sexually experienced adolescent, putting them at higher risk for unintended pregnancy and STIs, including HIV. Abstinence is a very healthy choice for teenagers, but it is not the only message to teen. Sex education for teenagers needs to give

How Can The High Teen Pregnancy And Sexual Transmitted Disease Rate Among Mississippi Teens Be Solved?

695 words - 3 pages . Abstinence plus will also reinforce positive feedback. This class would not be about drilling children to think that sex is wrong, which is what abstinence only classes does. It would teach them that sex is something that comes with adulthood, which means to abstain from it until he/she are grown and mentally ready. Studies show promise in abstinence plus programs, with 23 of 39 trials showing a statistically significant protective effect on at least one

Birth Control

1058 words - 5 pages all; one Heritage Foundation study argued that the typical "abstinence plus" curriculum devotes six times more space to promoting contraception than promoting abstinence. But you could argue that the evidence points to the value of a combined approach, that far from being mixed, the messages belong together: experts argue that the combination of more kids delaying sexual activity and more use of contraception once they become sexually active has

Children Having Children: Why Is It A Problem, And What Policy Changes Can Help Prevent It?

2548 words - 11 pages ). Education reduces the rate of risky sexual behavior. As mentioned before, however, the current federally funded policy of "abstinence-only" education is ineffective. A Kaiser Family Foundation poll in 2003 showed that educators, parents, students, and public policy makers most desired the "abstinence-plus" plan. This curriculum stresses the value of abstinence, but failing that, it teaches youth the importance of contraception (NPR, KFF, Harvard

Contigency

3031 words - 13 pages providing tangible reinforcers, usually in the form of vouchers exchangeable for retail goods and services, whenever abstinence is noted. Substantial evidence suggests that such CM treatments reduce drug use. For example, Higgins et al. (1994) found that more than half the cocaine-dependent patients who were randomly assigned to a voucher contingent treatment achieved at least 2 months of continuous abstinence, compared with only 15.0% of

Abstinence-Only And Comprehensive Sex Education And The Initiation Of Sexual Activity And Teen Pregnancy. Society For Adolescent Medicine

977 words - 4 pages right to know and what they feel is right. There are many ways to teach sex education the first being the Conservative’s way to teach it which is abstinence only until marriage. Then there is the Liberal’s way to teach it which is a comprehensive break down of everything a teen should know when engaging in something that can be life altering.The main research asked in the article “Abstinence-Only and Comprehensive Sex Education and

Teen Pregnancy

2715 words - 11 pages are not effective. “At present, there does not exist any strong evidence that any abstinence program delays the initiation of sex, hastens the return to abstinence, or reduces the number of sexual partners” (Kirby, 2001). Regardless, one might think that implementing an abstinence-only program is more effective since the idea of comprehensive sex education sends a mixed message to students promoting sexual activity by covering safe sex practices

Recovery from Active Addiction: Is It a Personal Choice?

1286 words - 6 pages Melissa Currie February 11, 2014 Recovery from Active Addiction: Is It a Personal Choice? Addicts are more likely to achieve long-term recovery from active addiction when the choice to abstain is made by them not for them. Recovery is a choice that only the addict can make, but some may need persuading. More often than not, complete abstinence is not achieved until after many failed attempts. “Treatment does not have to be voluntary to be

Related Essays

Teaching A Way To Make A Difference

737 words - 3 pages Teaching - A Way to Make a Difference To me teaching is a way to make a difference in someone’s life. If it is emotional, knowledge base or physical, we as professionals should help the student be all they can be. The reason that I want to become a teacher is so that I can make a difference. I want to help students open many doors to their future. I feel that a teacher should be the person that twenty years down the road that we

Do Food Labels Make A Difference?. .. Sometimes

2725 words - 11 pages labels” and make deductions about unlabeled products. For example, confronted with one can of tuna labeled “dolphin friendly” and one with no such claim, consumers would likely assume that the unlabeled tuna was caught with dolphin-endangering practices. In a competitive marketplace, the presence of a label is a signal of quality, and the lack of a label on competing brands implies the absence of the quality attribute. Consumers’ ability to

Six Little Things That Make A Huge Difference

706 words - 3 pages Pointers to Ponder, Part II March 23, 2011 Last edition I shared with you three of the little things that make a huge difference in our lives. After contemplating all the many things that came to mind, I finally narrowed my list down to what I believe to be the six little things that make a big difference. I did not include money in my list because I have seen how money can subtly deceive people and cause them to be so engulfed in it to the

Making Black Grape (Vitis Vinifera) As An Ink (Not A Real Investigatory Project! Only Made Up By An Amateur! This Is Only An Example! Hope That It Can Help You To Make An Ip! )

716 words - 3 pages . Use a formal font/type face and regular font size: Tahoma, size: 11. 2. Use ONLY black ink 3. Use a plain white short bond paper. 4. Use 1 1/2 inch margin-top and left, 1 inch in the bottom and right side. 5. Chapters 1-V should be double-spaced. 6. Indent the beginning of a paragraph 5 spaces from the left margin. II. PACKAGING 1. The final paper of each chapter per quarter will be