Do You Agree With The View That The Work Of William Howard Russell And Roger Fenton Presented The British Public With A Realistic Portrayal Of The Crimean War?

895 words - 4 pages

Do you agree with the view that the work of William Howard Russell and Roger Fenton presented the British public with a realistic portrayal of the Crimean War?
There are a number of different factors that collaborate to show that on one hand Russell and Fenton’s work may have offered an accurate image of the Crimean War and there are factors and sources that show that they possibly could have provided more realistic reports.
Firstly, Russell’s reliability is questioned in source 3 by Brandon High. High states: “Russell’s historical significance has to be entangled from the myth… because he obtained most of his information from friendly conversations with officers”. This implies that ...view middle of the document...

To further oppose the honesty of Russell’s reporting, the validity of the information in source 2 (by Russell) can be seriously questioned as Russell pronounces that he is “obliged to state what (he was) told occurred”. The fact that Russell was told this, by an unnamed source does not support source 2 as a legitimate account as there does not appear to be any solid truth and confirmation on where exactly the information came from. I know from my own knowledge that there was and still is a lot of confusion as to why exactly the Light Brigade was massacred in such a tragic fashion. The fact that Russell’s account is not significantly supported does not put his case in a good position compared to other reports or statements made by people such as George Paget who actually witnessed the charge and was a part of it.
Another factor to take into account is the fact that camera technology was not advanced enough for photographers such as Roger Fenton to take images of people or objects in motion. This therefore meant that all of Fenton’s images would have been set up and involved the individuals ‘posing’ in some form. He would not have been able to truly capture the soldier’s natural daily routines or actions. This can help to genuinely question the validity and credibility of the images taken by Roger Fenton.
There are however sources and factors that can vouch for Fenton and Russell portraying a genuine and authentic recollection of the conflict in the Crimea. For instance, source 1 describes the photography of Fenton as a “huge success” and “telling it how...

Other Papers Like Do You Agree with the View That the Work of William Howard Russell and Roger Fenton Presented the British Public with a Realistic Portrayal of the Crimean War?

How Far Do You Agree with the View That Stalin’s Foreign Policy Was a Major Contributing Factor to the Emergence of the Cold War in the Period 1945-50?

564 words - 3 pages the two conferences. The relationship and trust between the leaders that once stood close during the war had broken down. During this period Joseph Stalin, the leader of the Soviet Union and President Truman of the United States had conflicted with each other nations in a series of events in Europe such as the Czechoslovakian Crisis and the Berlin Blockade The leader of Czechoslovakia was defenestrated and communists ruled the country. The Czech

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Origins of the Cold War in the Period 1945-1950 Owed Much to Ideological Differences and Little to Personalities and Conflicting National Interests?

1136 words - 5 pages by introducing the Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan in 1947. Although this argument has its flaws, as at the Yalta conference the Soviets agreed to join the war against Japan for the southern half of Sakhalin Island and economic rights in Manchuria, which showed that the two superpowers were prepared to work together and did have some common goals. Overall it can be said that conflicting national interests were still a big factor in

Do You Agree with the View That the Main Factor Encouraging the Improvement of Public Health Provision in Britain in the Years 1833–75 Was the Fear of Further Outbreaks of Cholera?

1265 words - 6 pages Do you agree with the view that the main factor encouraging the improvement of public health provision in Britain in the years 1833–75 was the fear of further outbreaks of cholera? At first glance it’s easy to see that both sources 13 and 14 offer why the government should act on cholera and explain the fears of it returning again. Not only this but it states the important like it had to water and this was a major problem for public health

The Hazards Presented by Volcanic and Seismic Events Have the Greatest Impact on the World’s Poorest People'. to What Extent Do You Agree with This View?

1062 words - 5 pages 'The hazards presented by volcanic and seismic events have the greatest impact on the world’s poorest people'.  To what extent do you agree with this view? Hazards are anything that could cause damage to humans or buildings. Many volcanic and seismic events happen that cause hazards to humans. Often the world’s poorest people are hit the worst, however wealthier countries can also be adversely affected. The Kobe earthquake in Japan 1995

Do You Agree with the View That the Prime Cause of the Miners' Strike in 1984 Was the Conservative Government's Determination to Reduce Trade Union Power?

1444 words - 6 pages Do you agree with the view that the prime cause of the miners' strike in 1984 was the Conservative government's determination to reduce trade union power? - (40 - pg. 142 M. Lynch) On the 6th of March 1984, the National Coal Board announced that, in order to reduce government subsidies to the coal industry, twenty coal pits were to be closed. Six days later, Arthur Scargill, the leader of the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers) announced

How Far Do You Agree With The View That The Development Of The Cold War In The Years 1945-1948 Owed More Too Soviet Expansionism Than To The Usa’S Economic Interests?

1608 words - 7 pages War even further as these were introduced to battle the USSR. The conflict brought about by the US economic interests is best described in Source 8 from Terry Morris’s Europe 1870-1991. The author suggests that to keep the American economy in a boom period, there would be a need for “high levels of military and government expenditure” and for this to happen “the USSR was portrayed as aggressive and threatening”. They would carry on with this

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Years 1945 – 48 Owed More to Soviet Expansionism Than to the Usa’s Economic Interests?

1126 words - 5 pages hand, in line with evidence from sources 8 and 9, USA’s economic interests could have been seen as having the most impact on the development of the Cold War. A further argument could be to suggest that it was in fact due to ideological differences, which is backed by evidence from all three sources. Overall, the development of the Cold War from 1945 – 48 owed more to the USA’s economic interests than any other factor. There is evidence in all

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Years 1945-8 Owed More to Soviet Expansionism Than to Usas Economic Interests?

1044 words - 5 pages How far do you agree with the view that the development of the Cold War in the years 1945-8 owed more to Soviet expansionism than to USA’s economic interests? My opinion is that the development of the Cold War was due to Soviet expansionism rather than the USA’s economic interests in the years 1945-48. The Sources all present to some extent the idea that Soviet expansionism was to blame. Source 7 argues Soviet expansionism as the most

“the Fact That Girls Do Better Than Boys Is More to Do with Factors Outside of the School Rather Than Factors Inside of the School.” to What Extent Do You Agree with This View?

976 words - 4 pages “The fact that girls do better than boys is more to do with factors outside of the school rather than factors inside of the school.” To what extent do you agree with this view? If we look at exam results such as GCSEs and A levels there is a clear picture of girls outperforming boys. Girls are also more likely to pass their A levels and go on to university. These gender and differential educational achievement have been explained by the

Do You Agree with the View That the Main Reason for the Emergence of the Chartist Movement Was Disappointment Among the Working-Classes with the Outcome of the 1832 Reform Act?

854 words - 4 pages Use Sources 4, 5 and 6 and your own knowledge. Do you agree with the view that the main reason for the emergence of the Chartist movement was disappointment among the working-classes with the Outcome of the 1832 Reform Act? There are many factors for the emergence of the chartist movement and disappointment among the working classes is certainly the main factor; however Chartism as an issue is more complex than this and there has been

Compare and Contrast Wilde’s Presentation of the Fallen Woman in a Woman of No Importance with Hardy’s Presentation of the Same Issue in Tess of the D’urbervilles. Say How Far You Agree with the View...

1244 words - 5 pages in the novel being “what can I do for you my beauty?” this flirtatious quote mirrors Alec's sexual description as Hardy tries to build his character on lust and sexual desire towards women. Throughout the novel, Alec is very well spoken which also suggest that he is well educated “Very kind of your mother, I’m sure. And I for one don’t regret her step”. His dialogue and sentence length is also lengthy and being presented as well educated means

Related Essays

How Far Do You Agree With The View That America Was A Land Of Opportunity During The 1920s?"

1732 words - 7 pages "How far do you agree with the view that America was a land of opportunity during the 1920s?" Explain your answer using sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and your own knowledge. (40 marks) The 1920s are widely known as the 'Boom Era', or the 'Roaring Twenties' and a "decade of lively economic growth" (Source 3), due to the sheer economic success and advancement, and the emergence of the motor car, Hollywood, consumerism and

.How Far Do You Agree With The View That The Development Of The Cold War In The Period 1945 50 Was The Result Of Stalin’s Foreign Policy?

3210 words - 13 pages .How far do you agree with the view that the development of the Cold War in the period 1945-50 was the result of Stalin’s foreign policy? Development of the Cold War, in the five years between 1945 and 1950, could be argued as taking place for a number of reasons and due to various individuals. It could be easy to simply site Stalin as the main reason responsible for it’s outbreak and growth, clear through his approach on communist expansion

How Far Do You Agree With The View That The Development Of The Cold War In The Period 1945 50 Was The Result Of Stalin’s Foreign Policy?

3182 words - 13 pages Germany and Berlin were split into Western and Eastern zones; recognised that this could not be a long term solution, the West wanted to rebuild Germany and create a stable democracy and economy – Stalin on the other hand was more concerned with making Germany pay to the full extent. Source S, an extract of Geoffrey Roberts’ ‘Stalin Wars’, reinforces the fact that Stalin’s view and inability to agree with the West over the German question, “was

Do You Agree With The View That The Sino Soviet Split Was Caused Primarily By The Political Rivalry Of Khrushchev And Mao?

1744 words - 7 pages Do you agree with the view that the Sino Soviet Split was caused primarily by the political rivalry of Khrushchev and Mao? The Sino Soviet split occurred largely due to the ideological issues that Mao and Khrushchev had, having vastly opposite ideas on the nature of Revolutions. However, through this you largely see the clash of their personalities and how they differed vastly seen through the Soviet speech in which Khrushchev seriously