This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Do You Agree With The View That The Main Reason For Henry’s Failure To Obtain The Annulemnt Of His Marriage In The Years 1525 29 Was The Deremined Opposition Of Katherine Of Aragon?

930 words - 4 pages

There were many key factors attributing to the failed annulments plans, some were as result of Henry, such as the contrasting bible quotes presented and the diplomatic revolution caused by Henry’s thirst for European influence, other factors could be ofcourse contributed to the opposition of Catherine of Aragon who was continually persistent that her marriage to Henry was valid and the other main argument against the annulment was from the Catholic church. These combined factors essentially caused the break with Rome however one was predominantly more significant than the others.

Source 4 makes reference to one of the reasons Henry’s claims were so flawed, “Wolsey worried about Henrys' ...view middle of the document...

” Which contrasts directly with the suggestion that the failure of annulment was down to Catherine’s opposition and simultaneously the claims in Source 4 stating that Catherine was “by no means powerless.” This clear lack of opposition from the pope was further shown through Pope Campeggio’s suggestion mentioned in source 1 that Katherine “enter a convent, which would offer her an honorable retirement,” until she died, after which an annulment could be appointed. This attempt to please the king through offering suggestions to help him gain an annulment shows that the pope was not entirely against the annulment. On paper the power lay in the Pope’s hands as the Catholic church had shown they had the power to slow down proceedings by ensuring the case at Blackfriars was a failure after Pope Campeggio received orders against granting an annulment, along with using his power to adjourn court proceedings for a long period of time however there was a greater force acting over the pope restricting him and therefore Henry’s actions.

Despite the claims in Source 2 and 3 that the Pope fundamentally could have brought on an annulment if he were able to, without any worry for opposition from Catherine is contrasted in Source 1 through the fairly strong minded portrayal of Catherine that shows “Henry’s bullying only increased her determination.” And that she was “by no means powerless,” support the clam that she was the cause of the failed annulment. Catherine continually claimed that she had married Henry a virgin, despite Henry’s insistent claims otherwise which, had they have been proved true, would...

Other Papers Like Do You Agree with the View That the Main Reason for Henry’s Failure to Obtain the Annulemnt of His Marriage in the Years 1525-29 Was the Deremined Opposition of Katherine of Aragon?

Do You Agree with the View That the Main Reason for the Emergence of the Chartist Movement Was Disappointment Among the Working-Classes with the Outcome of the 1832 Reform Act?

854 words - 4 pages Use Sources 4, 5 and 6 and your own knowledge. Do you agree with the view that the main reason for the emergence of the Chartist movement was disappointment among the working-classes with the Outcome of the 1832 Reform Act? There are many factors for the emergence of the chartist movement and disappointment among the working classes is certainly the main factor; however Chartism as an issue is more complex than this and there has been

Do You Agree with the View That in the Years 1515-1525 Henry Viii Wholly Surrendered Power in Government to Cardinal Wolsey?

929 words - 4 pages Do you agree with the view that in the years 1515-1525 Henry VIII wholly surrendered power in government to Cardinal Wolsey? To a certain extent within 
Source 4 (by J.J. Scarisbrick 1968) supports the idea that possibly Henry VIII actually did surrender power over to Wolsey. The evidence within the source that suggests this possibly for being the truth is ‘a self-indulgent King had wholly surrendered the cares of the state into the Cardinals

Do You Agree with the View That the Main Factor Encouraging the Improvement of Public Health Provision in Britain in the Years 1833–75 Was the Fear of Further Outbreaks of Cholera?

1265 words - 6 pages Do you agree with the view that the main factor encouraging the improvement of public health provision in Britain in the years 1833–75 was the fear of further outbreaks of cholera? At first glance it’s easy to see that both sources 13 and 14 offer why the government should act on cholera and explain the fears of it returning again. Not only this but it states the important like it had to water and this was a major problem for public health

How Far Do You Agree That the Most Important Reason for Wolsey’s Fall from Power Was His Failure to Gain a Divorce for Henry Viii?

957 words - 4 pages The most important reason for Wolsey’s fall from power was his failure to gain a divorce for Henry VIII, how far do you agree? Wolsey’s dismissal from Henry’s court came in September 1529, though Wolsey had a plethora of failures before, his fall his failure to get a divorce for Henry VIII proved to be the most significant. This is because Wolsey’s strength of position depended on whether he got Henry what he wanted and the divorce was the

Opposition Was the Main Problem Facing Alexander3. How Far Do You Agree with the Statement?

1343 words - 6 pages modernising. Also educational reforms made a new class called “intelligencia” who shared western liberal views. As well as there were extremist groups that felt the only way for Russia to change was eradication of the monarch, they did not have clear aim what to do after. Alexander understood that and he launched strong repressions to preserve stability of monarchy, he believed that they were main threat and problem of Russia. Together with Pobedonoscev he

How Far Do You Agree That the Economy of Tsarist Russia Was Transformed in the Years Up to 1914?

1089 words - 5 pages How far do you agree that the economy of Tsarist Russia was transformed in the years up to 1914? During Alexander III reign, the Country of Russia and its economy was in a very backward state. We saw the Country suffer with extremely low industrialisation, as many of their workforce focused on agriculture. They struggled to sell enough grain at export, in order to fund large scale industrialisation as the serfs were forced by lack of freedom to

Do You Agree with the View That the Prime Cause of the Miners' Strike in 1984 Was the Conservative Government's Determination to Reduce Trade Union Power?

1444 words - 6 pages Do you agree with the view that the prime cause of the miners' strike in 1984 was the Conservative government's determination to reduce trade union power? - (40 - pg. 142 M. Lynch) On the 6th of March 1984, the National Coal Board announced that, in order to reduce government subsidies to the coal industry, twenty coal pits were to be closed. Six days later, Arthur Scargill, the leader of the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers) announced

How Far Do You Agree That Lenin’s Leadership Was the Main Reason for Why the Bolsheviks Were Able to Seize Power in 1917

1350 words - 6 pages How far do you agree that Lenin’s leadership was the main reason for why the Bolsheviks were able to seize power in 1917. Lenin was a very significant figure during the Russian revolution, under his strong leadership and the advice of some of his advisors, Lenin helped the Bolsheviks come to power. However I would not agree that his leadership was the main reason to why the Bolsheviks were able to seize power as factors such as the weakness

.How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Period 1945-50 Was the Result of Stalin’s Foreign Policy?

3210 words - 13 pages .How far do you agree with the view that the development of the Cold War in the period 1945-50 was the result of Stalin’s foreign policy? Development of the Cold War, in the five years between 1945 and 1950, could be argued as taking place for a number of reasons and due to various individuals. It could be easy to simply site Stalin as the main reason responsible for it’s outbreak and growth, clear through his approach on communist expansion

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Period 1945-50 Was the Result of Stalin’s Foreign Policy?

3182 words - 13 pages Development of the Cold War, in the five years between 1945 and 1950, could be argued as taking place for a number of reasons and due to various individuals. It could be easy to simply site Stalin as the main reason responsible for it’s outbreak and growth, clear through his approach on communist expansion, use of Red Army and inability to uphold agreements. However for a war of any kind to develop there is always more than one party involved

How far do you agree with the view that America was a land of opportunity during the 1920s?"

1732 words - 7 pages "How far do you agree with the view that America was a land of opportunity during the 1920s?" Explain your answer using sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and your own knowledge. (40 marks) The 1920s are widely known as the 'Boom Era', or the 'Roaring Twenties' and a "decade of lively economic growth" (Source 3), due to the sheer economic success and advancement, and the emergence of the motor car, Hollywood, consumerism and

Related Essays

Do You Agree With The View That The Main Reasons For Henry's Failure To Obtain The Annulment Of His Marriage In The Years 1525 29 Was The Determined Opposition Of Katherine Of Aragon?

1071 words - 5 pages Do you agree with the view that the main reasons for Henry's failure to obtain the annulment of his marriage in the years 1525-29 was the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon? Within the years of 1525-29 Henry failed to obtain an annulment of his marriage, it was suggested that the main reason for this failure was because of the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon however it is also argued that other factors such as the pope

Do You Agree With The View Expressed In Source Three That The Diplomatic Situation Was The Main Reason For Henry’s Failure To Obtain An Annulment Of His Marriage To Catherine By 1529?

1402 words - 6 pages Do you agree with the view expressed in source three that the diplomatic situation was the main reason for Henry’s failure to obtain an annulment of his marriage to Catherine by 1529? It is obvious that there is more than one reason behind Henry’s failure to obtain an annulment of his marriage to Catherine by 1529. It is however possible to identify that the diplomatic situation did not help his case in getting an annulment and was most

How Far Do You Agree That The Limited Appeal Of Mazzini's Ideas Was The Main Reason For The Slow Progress Of National Unity In The Years 1815 48?

1530 words - 7 pages , Mazzini would ensure the formation of a democratic Italy that gave equal rights to everyone. However, Mazzini was absent or in exile from Italy for over 40 years of his life, causing him to become disconnected with the people of Italy. This led to his ideas failing to gain the support from the majority of people, as he overestimated their willingness to revolt and change their circumstances. Quite simply, the governing of Italy was of little

How Far Do You Agree That The Impact Of The Second World War Was The Main Reason Why The Position Of African Americans Improved In The Years 1945

1461 words - 6 pages How far do you agree that the impact of the Second World War was the main reason why the position of African Americans improved in the years 1945–55? The impact of the Second World War was, without a doubt, crucial in improving the lives of black Americans over the years 1945-55, as it led to federal support of the cause. However, it wasn’t as important as the use of direct action which, for the first time, was able to convert de jure into de