This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Dissecting The Biases Present In The Political And Literary Perspectives Regarding Partition Of 1947

3720 words - 15 pages

Dissecting the biases present in the political and literary perspectives regarding partition of 1947: A holistic approach incorporating an analysis of the State account to understand the political agendas, and deconstruction of Manto’s writings to comprehend the biases present in the literary arena.
The history of the partition of India has been viewed, contemplated and constructed with a variety of perspectives, each differing according to a large number of variables. These variables include the time in which the perspective was formed and documented, the side of the border at which the writer resided, the views of the resultant states and how they portrayed these views, the personal ...view middle of the document...

Moreover, it will contextualize the literary writings of Saadat Hassan Manto, with the purpose of highlighting how works of fiction cover a different perspective, and are subjective according to the context of the writers.
Since 1947, Pakistan has struggled to form an identity. Immediately after the partition, it had to authenticate and legitimize the partition, and set itself apart from India. Pakistan felt the need to show the difference as they had to show that the differences were too much for Hindus and Muslims to reside together in a unified state. This was a tough task, considering the prolonged history of how they had lived together for so long, and keeping in mind how many cultures and norms of both the countries were similar due to the presence of a unified India for a long time. This led to the policy approaches that were to serve this purpose.
Firstly, legislation was passed in form of the Objectives Resolutions. This served the purpose of showing that this country was formed to provide freedom of religion and religious practices to Muslims, with the implications that such freedom was not provided in a unified India. Ishtiaq Ahmed talks about how it must have been an important consideration for the Prime Minister at that time, Liaquat Ali Khan, to distinguish Pakistan from Congress and secular India. It was declared in the constituent assembly that Islamic norms would be followed while practicing democracy, and hence a basis for an Islamic constitution was formed by the Objectives Resolutions (Ahmed 1).
Secondly, an educational structure was formed that highlighted India as a Hindu state, and where Muslims were highly marginalized and discriminated against. Furthermore, this education system has inculcated a sense of hatred towards India in Pakistanis. This has been a strategic move by the government to legitimize the creation of Pakistan further, by exaggerating the undesirable living conditions that existed in pre-partitioned India. The Two-Nation theory is accepted as a fact in Pakistan today, and it is widely believed that Muhammad Ali Jinnah based his political career on this Two-Nation theory. Many also believe Jinnah was a strong proponent of a Muslim state, and that his struggle throughout his political career and the emergence of Pakistan is a testament to that.
Within this education system, students associate Congress with Hindus, and Muslim League is considered the representative of Muslims in the pre-partition India. Even though Congress had many Muslim members within it ranks, some at the very top of the hierarchy, it is still considered to be a party that was working for the sole interest of the Hindus. Moreover, India is seen as a Hindu state, and is considered to be Hindu dominated. Even though India has more Muslims than Pakistan does, their treatment, or mistreatment, there is also grossly exaggerated. While studying partition, Muslims are painted as the helpless victims who were victimized at the hands of the...

Other Papers Like Dissecting the Biases Present in the Political and Literary Perspectives Regarding Partition of 1947

The Gaze Experiment: a Study of Gazing Habits and Biases with Respect to Different Facial Features

2257 words - 10 pages The Gaze Experiment: A study of gazing habits and biases with respect to different facial features. AbstractCan we tell which part of our face a person is gazing at when they are gazing at us? The experiment in question gives us an idea to where and why we think a person is looking at that location. There were 27 students split into pairs. Within the pair there was an experimenter and a participant. The experimenter would look at different

Newspaper Biases About the Woodstock Music and Art Fair

805 words - 4 pages November 18, 2010 Library Project II The Woodstock Music and Art Fair was an “Aquarian Exposition” that took place on a 600-acre farm in Bethel, New York from August 15 to August 18, 1969. The event was described to be “three days of peace and music” and drew a crowd of over 450,000 people[1]. Because this function drew such a large crowd, it also drew much media attention. The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Philadelphia

The New Israeli Nation Between 1947-1967

4286 words - 18 pages as well as 400,000 Arabs. The General Assembly (with support of both the USA and the USSR) approved the partition plan on November 29, 1947. The Jewish agency, eager to finally have a state approved the plan. The British agreed to depart from Palestine and turn over all authority to the UN by May 15, 1948. Israel had been successful at establishing a sovereign state due to its political pragmatism, in which they were willing to compromise by

Communications of the Past and the Present

1388 words - 6 pages Communication of the Past and the Present Lorelei Mau COM/170 09/26/11 Stephanie Ching Communication of the Past and the Present "Regardless of the changes in technology, the market for well-crafted messages will always have an audience."— Steve Burnett. How amazing is today’s advanced communication compared to communication of the past? From the beginning of time, as a species, we

Characterizing Revenge In The Past And Present

792 words - 4 pages operas. The idea was also evident during Shakespeare's time and was included in many of his plays, one of the most notable being the tragedy Othello. Throughout the past and present it is clear the extensive feeling and consequences of experiencing revenge.The characteristic of revenge is also evident in my own experiences. Many times I will shove my brother, or I will refuse to answer his questions for homework to get revenge for his bothering me

Perspectives On Liberation In Kate Chopin's The Story Of An Hour, And The Storm

884 words - 4 pages Sometimes the most liberating experiences are those not sought. In Chopin’s stories: “The Story of an Hour”, and “The Storm”, we are exposed to different views of liberation. The opportunity to venture with or without someone will be further elaborated. Furthermore, the act of gaining something is not necessarily always accomplished by addition. In Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour”, Mrs. Mallard was a woman trapped in a marriage. You

The Present and Future of Employee Engagement

1248 words - 5 pages The present and future of Employee Engagement We live in a world where businesses are becoming increasingly complex. The epochal shift from the industrial to the information age is providing a very important challenge for humanity and the organisations that represent it. Furthermore, with the complexity of today’s business comes the complexity of efficiently managing the people that, united, represent the organisations humans depend on. In

Historical Perspectives of the Diagnosis of Asthma in Children

1819 words - 8 pages Historical Perspectives of the Diagnosis of Asthma in Children 1. Introduction: The causes of Asthma: Looking at some recent reports of asthma disease, most of the acute exacerbation because cold and phlegm caused by dysfunction of the lungs which occurred in sputum of asthma. Chronic repeatedly patients mostly offset organs function. Its complex etiology occurs due to some reasons of genetic, physical fitness, diet, environment, age, and

Critically Compare the Psychodynamic and Behaviourist Perspectives in Psychology Assignment

1301 words - 6 pages Critically Compare the Psychodynamic and Behaviourist Perspectives in Psychology Assignment. Research suggests a popular definition of psychology is ‘the science of the mind and behaviour`. Psychology is considered to be a science and take`s the role of many perspectives. Psychologist’s draw upon a range of approaches ‘different ways of thinking`, each of which views the person and the study of the person in very

The Life and Literary Career of Oscar

2769 words - 12 pages HUE COLLEGE OF FOREIGN LANGUAGES ASSIGNMENT British Literature [pic] Name: Dang Thi Quynh Lan Class: B2K5F Hue, 8/2011 I. The life and literary career of Oscar Oscar Fingal O' Flahertie Wills Wilde, or more succinctly Oscar Wilde, was born on October 16, 1854 in Dublin, the second of three children born to Sir William Wilde and Jane Francesca Wilde. He had his first encounters

Columbus and the Native Americans: Two Perspectives of History

956 words - 4 pages Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492. This is a well-known memory device learned in grade school that does not begin to tell the whole story. Columbus’ discovery of the New World led to both triumph and devastation. These two words best describe the situation even though they completely contradict one another. There are always two sides to a story, and in this instance the perspectives are that of the humble Native Americans of America and

Related Essays

In The Context Of The Years Of 1847 1947, How Far Was The Partition Of India In 1947 Inevitable?

3913 words - 16 pages Unit 4 Historical Enquiry “In the context of the years of 1847- 1947, how far was the Partition of India in 1947 inevitable? “ Pawanpreet Dhaliwal Candidate Number-3049 In the context of the years of 1847- 1947, to what extent was the Partition of India in 1947 inevitable? ------------------------------------------------- The countries India, Pakistan and Bangladesh were once united as a whole Sub-Continent mixed with Muslims, Hindus

1947 Partition Of India Essay

1266 words - 6 pages Analyse the reasons for the 1947 partition of the South Asian sub-continent into India and Pakistan. The partition of the South Asian sub-continent into India and Pakistan was one of the most crucial events in both countries histories. There was exceeding tensions in India between the two main political parties; the Indian National Congress, with predominantly Hindu based support and members and the Muslim League formed later as protest

Biases Present In Blackfish Essay

1220 words - 5 pages Blackfish is a documentary that tells the story of Tilikum, a "notoriously aggressive" orca who has been linked to the deaths of three individuals while being kept in captivity. The film, told largely by five former SeaWorld trainers, uses highly emotional footage to portray Tilikum as an animal that has been negatively impacted by his life at SeaWorld. Blackfish is advertised as a documentary but, in reality, is little more than propaganda, and

An Account Of The First Indo Pak War (1947 1948)

702 words - 3 pages started (1947-48). The military was called upon to defend the borders of the state of Jammu and Kashmir when tribals--principally Pathans--attacked from the northwest reaches of Kashmir on October 22, 1947. India's 161st Infantry Brigade was deployed and thwarted the advance of the tribal forces. In early November 1947, the 161st counterattacked and successfully broke through the enemy defenses. Despite early successes, the Indian army suffered a