Discuss Adam’s Criminal Liability, For Murder And Partial

1094 words - 5 pages

Discuss Adam’s criminal liability, for murder and partial
defences under the Homicide Ordinance which he may raise.

According to the Common Law, murder is an offence that established where there is an unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought.
However, this definition only appropriates under the Queen’s peace to prevent the killing during wartime being murder. The commission of murder can carry a penalty of twenty-five years or life imprisonment.

To commence with, the first question of this case is whether Adam’s act is voluntary and necessary or not. Since a killing in self-defence may not be regarded as a murder. In Hussey (1924) 18 Cr App ...view middle of the document...

Although Adam’s voluntary act lead to Leo’s death, he will only be liable for murder with relevant mens rea ” malice aforethought” at the time of acting. There is nothing to suggest that Adam really intended to kill Leo. Nevertheless, he had a strong intention to cause grievous bodily harm because he smashed Leo with glass immediately. It is enough malice if the intention is not to kill but to cause grievous bodily harm subject to the House of Lord in Moloney, 1985. Therefore, Adam is guilty of murder in terms of his actus reus and mens rea.

Actually there are some possible defences for Adam. He can use intoxication, provocation, diminished responsibility or others as defences though some of them may not be strong enough to raise.

For intoxication is quite difficult to rise as defences as Adam’s self – induced intoxication (drunk) was no defence. However, murder is a kind of specific intent crimes. In DPP v Majewski and R v Majewaki, the court held that intoxication cannot be a defence of basic intent crime while specific intent crimes can because these crimes require specific intent to kill or harm the victim that states at “Crimes Ordinance Sect.17- Compulsion in taking unlawful oaths “

Moreover, the fact Adam got drunk was reckless. Recklessness would seem to satisfy for this case to reduce as manslaughter through objective test. As a result, Adam is likely to convict with manslaughter if intoxication and recklessness are raised as defences.

If Adam cannot be helped by these two defences, he still can raise provocation as a defence. Under the Section 4 of Homicide Ordinance, the jury should also consider about the provocation incurred by charger. In this case, Adam was called as “ugly shorty” that insulted him very much because he only 5 feet tall. His situation is similar to the accused in R v Camplin (1978) 2 All E.R.168 whose charge of murder was reduced to manslaughter

In subjective test, he suffered a sudden and temporary loss control that showed from his negligent action. In objective test, he is a schizophrenic with 5 feet tall only and drunk when Leo poured ridicule on his height. It is...

Other Papers Like Discuss Adam’s Criminal Liability, for Murder and Partial

Discuss Economic Arguments For And Against Imposing Substantially

839 words - 4 pages Discuss economic arguments for and against imposing substantially higher taxes on sale of alcohol. Governments interfere in markets and their working with the primary purpose of provision of welfare to people and preventing market failure. There are many methods of intervention such as - taxes and subsidies - buffer stocks - applying maximum and minimum prices - provision of public goods and services - provision of education and

Euthanasia Is Legally, Morally And Ethically Unacceptable. Discuss. Foundation In Nursing Essay For Law/Ethics Module

2827 words - 12 pages control. Active euthanasia on the other hand involves a direct intervention to shorten the life of the patient, and the death of the patient was the intention. Also there exists the distinction between voluntary euthanasia, which is at the patients request, and involuntary euthanasia, in which the patient makes no specific request for euthanasia, and the judgement of others is used. The debate surrounding euthanasia evokes many impassioned feelings

Capital Punishment, The Road To A Corrupt Criminal Justice System, Must Be Abolished For The Sake Of Society. The Death Penalty Is Unfair Towards Society Members, Such As Tax Payers, Innocent People,...

2653 words - 11 pages innocent person who has been wrongfully executed. There are indeed many documented reversals of this sort, such as the case of Kirk Bloodsworth. "In 1984, I was wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death for the rape and murder of nine year-old Dawn Hamilton in Baltimore, Maryland. I spent eight years, eleven months, and nineteen days behind bars before DNA testing proved my innocence." (Kirk Bloodsworth, speaking at the USCCB Press Conference

Discuss the Need for World Order and Evaluate the Effectiveness of Responses in the Maintenance of World Order

1321 words - 6 pages World order is a term used to describe the balance of power among the nations of the world. It is linked with the political, economic and social framework in the world at a particular time and the effect that this situation has on the relationship between countries. There is an increasing need for world order in the global community due to growing conflict both within and between nations and regions. The increased trade between countries has

Taking Examples from Either the Housing Market or the Commercial Property Market, Outline and Discuss the Economic Factors Influencing Supply and Demand for Your Chosen Property Type

1004 words - 5 pages The housing market in UK has been effected in many different ways, from immigration to shortages of homes I am looking to discuss these factors in depth. The demand of houses depends on what the interest rates are, as this will decide whether the buyer will be able to get a mortgage at a cheaper rate. The lower the interest rate the more demand of houses and the more demand in houses the higher the price. The supply will depend on what the

Discuss the Drawbacks and Benefits of Using the Internet as a Resource for Researching Academic Assignments Rather Than Using a Traditional Library

867 words - 4 pages Discuss the drawbacks and benefits of using the Internet as a resource for researching academic assignments rather than using a traditional library Nowadays, more and more college students are in favor of utilizing web information to complete their assignments rather than traditional libraries. However, there are still a series of problems in the web resources. This essay aims to discuss the benefits and drawbacks of web information. It

“Pfeffer (2005) Argues for Wage Compression and Symbolic Egalitarianism. Discuss the Validity of His Arguments

1813 words - 8 pages and lowest paid jobs. Wage compression can create a sense of teamwork, collaboration and cooperation. Symbolic egalitarianism can signal to insiders and outsiders that there is a comparative equality within the organisation. This is done by diminishing status distinctions, for example eliminating executive dining rooms and not having reserved parking spaces for certain employees (Standford University, 1994). Pfeffer’s arguments can be valid

Select A Community Support Network In Your Area And Discuss What Services It Provides For The Community, How Accessible It Is, And Who Accesses It. Uniting Care Burnside

923 words - 4 pages Uniting Care BurnsideUniting Care Burnside is a non-government agency of the Uniting Church, which aims to "provide a just and safe society for all young people and their families-because children matter."(Uniting Care Burnside brochure, pg 4)The Dubbo department opened over twenty years ago following the merger of several similar services. Eventually the original residential homes of Badalla House and Dalmar were closed, and the Government

College Entrance Essay. The topic of this essay was "Discuss your motivation for pursuing college-level study, addressing your personal interests and career goals"

560 words - 3 pages Over the past few years I have increasingly become confident that a career in psychology is the right path for me. I am by nature a very caring, helping person, a good listener and someone who enjoys being able to connect with others.My friends and family see me as the kind of person they can go to when they need to talk about their problems, and they know that I am someone that they can trust. To me, there is nothing more fulfilling than the

Every Organisation Has To Prepare For The Abandonment Of Everything It Does"( Peter Drucker). Discuss This Statement In The Context Of Change Management And Strategy

2993 words - 12 pages so as to effectively develop a new sigmoid curve , that is a new future. It should be noted that changes can be subject to adequate extra finance and resources. This is the reason behind why an organisation should always be prepared to embrace change. It should always have a continual focus on improvement , and must not rest on it's laurels and should thus not wait for the wolf to be knocking on it's door.Drivers for change.An organisation

From 1810 to 1815, New England Was the Hotbed of Sectionalism and Nullification, While the South and Southwest Were Strongly Nationalistic. What Accounts for the Switch in Positions in the 1820’s? in...

1121 words - 5 pages for the basis of their economy. Even though one of the major causes of the War of 1812 was because of British interference with American trade, the New Englanders were still extremely opposed to the war. The Southerners wanted the war and overwhelmingly supported it. They showed their support through feelings of intense nationalism. The trading policies put into effect during the war completely destroyed New England’s economy. New England

Related Essays

Professional Regulations And Criminal Liability Essay

1561 words - 7 pages  Professional Regulations and Criminal Liability Loretta Rosario-Ellison HCS 430 April 21, 2014 C. Darnell Stroble, Esq. Professional Regulations and Criminal Liability In every state, there are medical professionals on a regulation or committee board. This paper will discuss some vital issues that are pretentious by regulation of the health professional in the State of Kentucky. The issues of discussions are to identify the

Criminal Liability And The Use Of Force

1109 words - 5 pages AL LIABILITY AND THE USE OF FORCE Margaret Barnes LEG-320 Criminal Law Professor Muhammad Strayer University Date: 01 February, 2013 Criminal liability and Use of Force 1. The crime of solicitation takes place when a person invites, commands, requests, and hires or urges another person to commit a specific offense (LexisNexis, n.d.). For a solicitation to take place

Theme Of Murder In A Rose For Emily And Killings

861 words - 4 pages      In the short story 'A Rose For Emily'; and the short story 'Killings'; people have been murdered and the motivations for the killings are understandable but never the less still murders. The reason for murder in 'A Rose For Emily'; is not as clearly shown as with 'Killings';, that story is a classic 'eye for an eye'; type story. The main character in 'A Rose for Emily'; (Emily) and the main character in 'Killings'; (Matt) both kill out of

Discuss How The Interaction Of Class, Gender, Race And Age Affects Criminal Opportunities

312 words - 2 pages 1. Discuss How the Interaction of Class, Gender, Race and Age Affects Criminal Opportunities Many criminologists have looked for the answers on the effects of crime with only a few who agree on common grounds on why some choose to commit crimes and others choose to defy it even though there are given opportunities. Criminologists have found four sociological variables class, gender, race, and age are now viewed as a direct contributor to