This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Differences In Lokpal Bill And Jan Lokpal Bills

2023 words - 9 pages

The Jan Lokpal Bill (Citizen's Ombudsman Bill): Is it flawless?
rate or flag this page
By premsingh

differences in lokpal & jan lokpal bill
Source: curtsy youtube video on lokpal bill

Since the beginning of Anna Hazare's protest at Jantar Mantar, I have been an ardent supporter of him and impressed with the way of handling an agitation with strong determination. Frankly speaking, it was enough to know that corruption was the major issue and provisions in Lokpal bill were to be incorporated to take care of it. I never tried to know about the different clauses of the bill whether it was drafted by Govt. committee or by the Civil Society. Hazare's protest at Jantar Mantar did not ...view middle of the document...

Version or Civil Society Version and then apply own mind to judge the plus points of each bill. I tried to analyze salient features of both bills (Civil Society and Govt.) and present these in simple way so that others also can make an in-depth analysis. There is no doubt that Anna Hazare has initiated crusade against corruption but some people may try to take advantage of the situation. An unbiased analysis may help common people to know the real intentions behind both the bills.
Corruption charges against NGOs
What does Govt. Version of Lokpal Bill says?
All the Non-Government Organizations,trusts, charities, movements, societies irrespective of funding sources should be covered under Lokpal.
What does Civil Society Version of Jan Lokpal Bill says?
Civil Society insists that Non-Government Organizations who receive government funds should be covered under Lokpal and self financed NGOs, trusts and movements should be kept out of Lokpal ambit. 
What does the logic demands?
Several private organizations are involved in different type of malpractices and receive funds from international organizations for charity purpose but these organizations uses these funds for purposes other than the social work. Such organizations need to be covered under Lokpal.
Citizen's Charter for grievance redressal
What does Govt. Version of Lokpal Bill says?
Government did not agree to have Citizen's Charter for each and every department for grievance redressal.
What does Civil Society Version of Jan Lokpal Bill says?
Civil Society insist for Citizen's Charter for grievance redressal for each department. It will be needed to show that a particular type of work will be done by a particular officer within a specified time period.
What does the logic demands?
This demand raised through Jan Lokpal bill is very important. Common people would not go to file complaints against local officials to Lokpal. If a grievance redressal cell is made in each office, it will hear the complaint of people related to department. If it fails to help people, complainant may approach Lokpal for help and justice.
Issue of Phone Tapping
What does the Govt. Version of Bill says: Permission to tap a phone may be granted only by the Home scretary.
What does the Civil Society Version of Bill says: Lokpal Bench will grant permission for phone tapping.
What the logic demands:Phone tapping is a very serious issue and it is encroachment in the privacy of a person. Permission should not be given for phone tapping to any one if it is to accumulate evidences against a person involved in corruption. There are several other means to collect evidences in corruption cases. Permission for tapping a phone must not be given in cases other than security threats.
Your opinion on Lokpal
Do you support making Lokpal just an forwarding authority or an advisory body?
Top of Form
*  Yes
*  No
Bottom of Form
See results without voting

Other Papers Like Differences in Lokpal Bill and Jan Lokpal Bills

Differences in Health Traditions and Cultures

1328 words - 6 pages Differences in Health Traditions and Cultures   Growing diversity in the United States is veracity in the 21st century. Undeniable proof on poor quality of health care provided to ethnic and racial minorities of all ages, compared to non-minorities, were provided by The Institute of Medicine. Attempts to remove health inequalities rising from differences in culture should concentrate on creating patient-clinician reliance relationships

Differences in Competencies Between Bsn and Adn

1161 words - 5 pages (Rossetter 2012). However, we will focus more on the differences in competencies between nurses prepared at the associate degree level versus baccalaureate degree level in nursing and identify a patient care situation in which nursing care or approaches to decision making may differ based upon educational preparation. The associate degree program (ADN) which was founded by Mildred Montag due to severe shortage of nurses was designed to

Gender Differences and Social Work Intervention in China

1591 words - 7 pages Yisi Zuo SOC 101 Gender Differences and Social Work Intervention in China Introduction Professional activity is one of the most important human activities in modern society; its effects permeate all areas of personal, family and social life. As China's market economy development and social transformation, and increasingly fierce competition in the labor market, unemployment and the rising threat of job flows down, various pressures caused by

Communicative Style and Gender Differences In Computer-Mediated Communications

4920 words - 20 pages KLAIPĖDA UNIVERSITY Faculty of Humanities Department of English and German Philology COMMUNICATIVE STYLE AND GENDER DIFFERENCES IN COMPUTER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATIONS Course Paper Author Tadas Dilnikas Academic Supervisor Liolita Bernotienė Klaipėda University, 2014 Contents Introduction 1. Aspects of Computer-mediated communication 1.1. Types of computer-mediated commmunication 2. face-to-face

Gender And Cross-Cultural Differences In Identifying Prototypes

1919 words - 8 pages AbstractThe concept formations of prototypes are typically thought to be associated with previously explored subjects. This experiment was designed to test whether gender and ethnicity differences influence the choice of a prototypical object. Twenty-four students from Capilano College enrolled in Cognitive Psychology were surveyed. Of this group, five were males and nineteen were females. Objects included in this experiment were birds

Differences In Competencies Between Associate Degree And Bacculaurate Degree

806 words - 4 pages Differences in competencies between nurses with associate degree verses baccalaureate degree level Is there a difference in the thinking and processing of a nurse with baccalaureate degree and associate degree? According to the researches that were done in the past, there are difference in competencies between Baccalaureate nursing and associate nursing. Performance in nursing care by well educated nursing is higher than one with lesser

Differences In Communication Strategies Of Men And Women

704 words - 3 pages Differences in Communication Strategies of Men and Women Robert Bly and Deborah Tannen say there is a large difference in the way men and women communicate. In the article, "Where are Men and Women Today?" Bly and Tannen describe women as rapport-talkers. Rapport-talk is using language as a way of establishing connections and relationships with others. They continue by stating that men use report-talk to

How International Differences in the Ownership and Financing of Companies Could Lead to Differences in Financial Reporting

1888 words - 8 pages How International Differences in the Ownership and Financing of Companies Could Lead to Differences in Financial Reporting   Introduction The major objective behind the development of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) has been to achieve financial reporting across different countries, which could be easily compared. In order to achieve this kind of comparability, it is very crucial that the IFRS be used by all the

Describe and Explain the Differences in Energy Production and Consumption in Sweden and India

632 words - 3 pages Describe and explain the differences in energy production and consumption in Sweden+ India India has a much higher productivity rate in terms of producing energy than Sweden. Although Sweden has more money and technology to produce, India’s industrialising has led to a very high rate of productivity when producing coal. It is the world’s third biggest producer. Due to such large quantities of coal in India it is their abundant source for energy

Differences in Competencies Between an Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing

1004 words - 5 pages Fund research which was mentioned earlier on, BSN nurses tend to make less errors as opposed to AND nurses. All the differences mentioned arises from the one year difference that exist between both degrees. It may sound small, but the amount of knowledge compacted in this year can make the difference in saving a life. Reference Rosseter, R. (2014, January 21). The Impact of Education on Nursing Practice. . Retrieved July 13, 2014, from http

M1 – Discuss Similarities and Differences in the Nutritional and Energy Requirements of Two Groups of Individuals

554 words - 3 pages M1 – Discuss similarities and differences in the nutritional and energy requirements of two groups of individuals I chose to look at two different social groups, which is a pregnant women and a teenage girl that is 16 years old. The differences between the pregnant woman and the 16 year old teenage girl, is when it comes to their energy and nutritional requirements, for example: the teenage girl who is 16years of age needs to have 1800

Related Essays

Lokpal And Jan Lokpal Bill Essay

1101 words - 5 pages at the Centre, and Lokayukta(s) in the states. What is Lok pal Bill and how many times it was presented in parliament? The Lokpal Bill provides for filing complaints of corruption against the prime minister, other ministers, and MPs with the ombudsman. The Administrative Reforms Commission (ARC) while recommending the constitution of Lokpal was convinced that such an institution was justified not only for removing the sense of injustice from

Lokpal Bill Essay

1018 words - 5 pages This is a summary of a paper presented at the 28th Annual Conference of the Association for Research on Nonprofit Organizations and Voluntary Action in November 1999. This paper was submitted to the peer-reviewed academic journal Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly for consideration. ¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬_______________________ Nonprofits’ Use of the Media in the Influence of Public Policy: Is there a correlation between exposure in

Differences In Adn And Bsn Essay

1203 words - 5 pages Competency Differences in ADN and BSN Nurses Jim Bob Grand Canyon University NRS-430V: Professional Dynamics June 8, 2014 In today’s health care field, most registered nurses are prepared at two different levels. There are ADN or associate degree level nurses and there are BSN or bachelor degree level nurses. Both of these levels of nursing require knowledge of human anatomy and physiology, medications, disease process and appropriate

Similarities And Differences In 2 Stories

655 words - 3 pages English 21 Topic #1 The adult and child relationship between the story “A Mother in Mannville” and the story “Thank You Ma’am” is that both characters in both stories have build an unexpected relationship that brings two strangers close. Both stories have their differences and similarities that will make both stories very interesting. Overall I think “A Mother in Mannville” ended in a sad way, therefore I don’t think it has a