Student Notes of observed dialog between Aristotle and Plato
Aristotle: So, let me get this straight, what you are saying is that this world we live in is not real?
Plato: You seem not to understand what I mean.
Aristotle: Because it is ridiculous.
Plato: No, listen. What I am saying is that the environment or form that we live in is full of unevenness, imperfection and impurity this because this form is merely a copy of the ideal world that one would understand once they rise above our physical environment and grasp it intellectually.
Aristotle: I understand you just fine but I disagree with you. I agree that our world is an imperfect world but I object to the notion that it is not ...view middle of the document...
Captives in a cavern, limited to the walls with no chance of tilting your heads. With the flame behind you, you can only see the walls of the cavern and the dark areas of the shadows placed between you and the flame. You are not able to comprehend that the dark areas you see and the echoes you listen to are a representation of actual things, behind you. This world that is available to our feelings and essence prevails only as a representation of the actual world.
Aristotle: Here is where I differ to you completely! !An individual is not formed from the perception of another’s mind but from a person who through germ or seeds was able to recreate another one hence, the seeds in the person would be in efficiency type because of its potential to become another person later on. Every person is a substance of matter and form, not a mirror or perception of another from another form.
Plato: That is just how easy it is to confuse overall deception for truth, just like the captives in the cavern experience, they easily make reference to the dark areas using the titles of the actual things that the dark areas indicate. This just reveals that knowledge is only a representation of the actual concepts in our thoughts. What is seen on the world is a replica of the genuine thing. The captives, by looking at the dark areas may understand what an item is but this does not allow them to declare that it represents an object, which...