This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Describe The Similarities And Differences In The Way Identity Is Conceptualised By The Psychosocial Theory Of Identity And The Social Identity Theory

1723 words - 7 pages

Describe the similarities and differences in the way identity is conceptualised by the psychosocial theory of identity and the social identity theory.

This paper looks at two identity theories, Psychosocial theory and The Social Identity Theory. Beginning with an overview of each, then discussing similarities and differences including the background of the researchers, their research methods and the evidence they found.

Erik Erikson believed identity to be psychosocial – personal and social (Phoenix, 2007). Born in Germany, and raised by his Jewish mother and Jewish-German stepfather he took his stepfather’s surname of Homburger. His adolescence was fuelled by angst and he spent ...view middle of the document...

He argued that seeing someone as ‘different’ can threaten our own identity and therefore lead to aggression (Phoenix, 2007)

James Marcia found a method to measure Erikson’s theories on identity (Phoenix, 2007). He too focused on adolescents, and devised the semi-structured interview – a questionnaire that covered important aspects in an adolescent’s life. Marcia used the answers to collect quantitative data.

Marcia identified four identity statuses, depending on the amount of commitment and exploration the participant expressed. He discovered a status similar to Erikson’s ‘identity moratorium’. This status was used for participants who had low commitment and high exploration, meaning that they were still exploring experiences to enable them to grow and achieve identity.

The Social Identity Theory (SIT) was developed by Henri Tajfel (Phoenix, 2007). Tajfel, a European Jew, had escaped the Nazi regime. He believed that identity was gained from ones social groups, and either already having, or adopting characteristics that fit within those groups. He believed that a feeling of ‘belonging’ gave identity to the ‘ingroup’, and that other groups were classed as the ‘outgroup’ thus creating a feeling of hostility.

Tajfel and his colleagues used an experimental method to prove his theory. They divided groups of teenage boys into random groups, giving them untrue reasons as to why they were in a particular group. He then asked them to divide coins, allocating a certain amount for outgroup, ingroup, and individuals. The outgroup and ingroup coins were divided equally but the boys showed favour to the individuals within their group even though there was no gain to be won. Tajfel had proved that, in minimal conditions, the groups had ‘discriminated’ against one another (Phoenix, 2007)

The Social Identity Theory highlights that differences in power balance causes discrimination (Phoenix, 2007). It also discovered that ‘self categorisation’ can promote change. Those who feel of a lower status may strive to change their identity to improve their status, social creativity can be used to promote positive light on subordinate groups, and social competition can encourage social change by encouraging positive alternative views on social groups.

The first similarity we see between the psychosocial and Social Identity Theory is not between the two theories but between Erikson and Tajfel. Both used their own life experiences to base their hypotheses. Erikson on his troubled adolescence - perhaps Erikson’s belief that ‘a sense of continuity, uniqueness of worth’ (Phoenix, 2007) was important because those were missing in his life. Tajfel, on the persecution of the Nazi’s on the Jews, investigated why ‘ingroup’ and ‘outgroup’ discriminated against each other.

Both believed that identities are created through current historical events and are affected by where one is geographically. They also both supported that one must go through a...

Other Papers Like Describe the Similarities and Differences in the Way Identity Is Conceptualised by the Psychosocial Theory of Identity and the Social Identity Theory

Define The Concept Of Social Class Identity

1140 words - 5 pages Define the concept of social class identity Social class identity is the term used when referring to the differences social classes have, such as different cultures, norms and values. This is a very difficult term to be used in order to categorise an individual as social class can be subjective or objective. The government uses the objective view, based on the based on the economical status of the individual, to be able to identify them into a

The Concept of the Identity in Kim

682 words - 3 pages , Šumberová states “A similar instance can be discovered in Kim’s Britishness. It is marked by the constituents of soldier and ruler, and these people are exactly those whom Kim hates when he is imprisoned among the white British soldiers. At the same time, according to the prophecy delivered by his father, Kim believes that one day, he will become a military leader and is proud of it”(27-28). The question of belonging and identity hurts Kim

Black Identity In The Us

844 words - 4 pages BLACK IDENTITY IN THE US We continue to be obsessed with difference races but why? I am now going to give you three different perspectives on the issue. To start out with, I will give you an outline on the different attitudes to the situation of African Americans. Secondly, I will compare style by means of language and tone. And finally, I am going to argue my own view of the situation of African Americans today in text 2. Text 1 “Black

The Eruption Of Identity Theft

580 words - 3 pages ). One must remember that there will always be financial fraud, and that no payment system is perfect. However, when it comes to identity theft, the financial services industry must bear some of the blame for the crime. The credit granting system and electronic payment mechanisms are designed in such a way that committing fraud is easy. According to they believe identity theft is that the credit industry causes the crime by

Identity: the Constituents of Selfhood

1017 words - 5 pages that an individual identifies as belonging uniquely to them. Identity is a complex notion influenced by internal and external forces. It’s reified by both variable and invariable traits; further influenced by the combined efforts of those around. In short, individuality manifests itself from the convergence of important factors: genetics, adolescent development and cultural influences. All these elements and circumstances combine to form one

In Comparing The Identity Development Of Lgbt

583 words - 3 pages . According to Marszalek & Cashwell (1999) the Homosexual Identity Formation proposes six-stages within it model to describe the gay or lesbian identity development that leads to changes occurring in the person accepting their homosexual identity. The R/CID model “propose five stages of development that oppressed people experience as they struggle to understand themselves in terms of their own culture, the dominant culture, and the oppressive

Identity in the Color of Water

1192 words - 5 pages result, James, one of Ruth’s children and the author of the book, was deeply influenced by the process of the changing identity of his mother. Firstly, I wanted to explain the effect of changing the name. Usually, name was the first thing jumped into people’s mind when they were asked what identity is. The reason was a person’s name was a symbol and the most distinctive characteristic of an independent individual. Name explains the issue about who

The American Deam & Identity

578 words - 3 pages quickly they learned that black people are just as smart as white people. The American Dream is for me is a dying dream. You always hear about how bad the American society is. Crime is rising day by day. Now police are being called out to public schools at the drop of a hat.  All over America, very young school children are being arrested and marched out of their schools in handcuffs in front of all their friends.  For example, down in Georgia, the


1294 words - 6 pages identity and that I was becoming more like my friends. Therefore, for my sixteenth birthday I decided to go back to South America and get in touch with my heritage. Unlike Rodriguez, I did not join any social group. My parents had given me a trip to Cuzco to see the get there I took about two and half days because I took a bus rather than a plane. I thought it was more exciting and I was right. On the way there I met a lot of people and I made

Racism And Identity In Ralph Ellison’S The Invisible Man

2308 words - 10 pages deemed as the norm. Though the narrator ultimately establishes what his identity is, he undertakes a number of personas that, though may still pertain to the black stereotype, it still also display’s the questioning of not only race but identity as well. Lee simply notes this by stating that Ellison’s novel takes on the Emersonian theory by providing his speaker with a guiding light in his quest for independence by dehumanizing the social

Social Identity

1162 words - 5 pages I am a middle aged white man who is a son, a brother, a husband, a parent, a college student, and a paramedic. I am an American who is part of the lower middle class, but I came from a working class family. My social identities are many and to single one out may prove to be difficult because they all interact with one another in some fashion. I could not become a parent without being a man, or a brother without being a son. If I were to choose

Related Essays

Describe The Similarities And Differences In The Way Identity Is Conceptualised By The Psychosocial Theory Of Identity And Social Identity Theory

1896 words - 8 pages Part 1 Essay Describe the similarities and differences in the way identity is conceptualised by the psychosocial theory of identity and social identity theory. I will start this essay by explaining both theories, Psychosocial theory and Social Identity Theory mentioning what is understood by identity and answering my essay question describing their similarities and differences. Identity is a major area of study for

The Rubicon Of Sexual Identity: Capitalist Predialectic Theory And Debordist Image

625 words - 3 pages narrativity as a totality. However, the primary theme of the works of Madonna is the difference between language and class. A number of discourses concerning Debordist image exist. But the example of postmaterialist textual theory depicted in Madonna’s Sex is also evident in Material Girl. Derrida suggests the use of capitalist predialectic theory to read and modify sexual identity. 1. Tilton, U. H. A. ed. (1996) Capitalist predialectic

Multiculturalism And The Canadian Identity Essay

2590 words - 11 pages Multiculturalism and the Canadian identity. Introduction What is Canada? What is a Canadian? Canada, to employ Voltaire's analogy, is nothing but “a few acres of snow.”. Of course, the philosopher spoke of New France, when he made that analogy. More recently, a former Prime Minister, Joe Clark, said that the country was nothing but a “community of communities”. Both these images have helped us, in one way or another, try to interpret what

The Identity Of Women Essay

1178 words - 5 pages identity, simultaneously justifying this control by the state while potentially leaving women with the ultimate ability to shape images of nationhood through their agency. As a part of their popular resistance to colonialism, many national liberation movements expressed their (generally sincere) commitment to women's social and political causes. Though women contributed greatly to independence struggles throughout the formerly colonized world