This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Dependable Dynamism: Lessons For Designing Scientific Assessment Processes In Consensus Negotiations

7096 words - 29 pages

Dependable dynamism: lessons for designing scientific
assessment processes in consensus negotiations
Noelle Eckley*
Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, 79 JFK Street (UR),
Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
Abstract
Negotiations that involve the use and interpretation of scientific information and assessment are often particularly difficult,
especially when the scientific input is uncertain or contested. Parties can exploit this uncertainty in order to stall progress, where they
might prefer a very different policy outcome. In addition, scientific input often changes as new research is done and disseminated. In
order to ...view middle of the document...

The ability to modify such conclusions at a later time facilitates decision-making processes by offering a new
dimension of compromise on both scientific assessment and policy decisions, and lowering the threshold of credibility necessary for
decision-making. r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Establishing consensus on regulatory actions, where
there are a large number of competing interests, is often
a difficult process. Where there are significant scientific
uncertainties and disagreements as well, controversies in
scientific assessment processes that inform policy
decisions can be a significant force in stalling policy
progress. For environmental issues in particular, recent
history has shown that making decisions informed by
scientific knowledge, and managing interactions between scientific assessment processes and policy discussions, has been a challenge for both scientists and
regulators. Compounding the problem of uncertainty
and dissent over scientific issues is the rapidly changing
state of the science in many relevant disciplines.
Those designing scientific assessment and negotiating
processes often look to other agreements in an effort to
learn lessons about how better to design such interactions. For example, ‘‘Modeled after the Montreal
Protocol’’ was a saying among delegates to the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee to develop a
global legally binding agreement on persistent organic
pollutants (POPs), in January 1999 (Earth Negotiations
Bulletin, 1999). One of the lessons often drawn from the
Montreal Protocol, as well as other existing agreements,
is that scientific assessment processes informing decision
makersFlike negotiations themselvesFshould be designed as adaptable or dynamic. That is, decisionmaking that is informed by scientific assessments should
be flexible enough to be modified based on future
assessment and review.
Richard Benedick, in his attempt to delineate
practical lessons from the Montreal Protocol experience,
mentions the idea of ‘‘adaptability’’ as a property of
decision-making and assessment processes that might
*Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-617-384-9244; fax: +1-617-496-
0606.
E-mail address: noelle eckley@harvard.edu (N. Eckley).
0959-3780/02/$ - see front matter r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 5 9 - 3 7 8 0 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 0 2 7 - 9help other agreements deal with the interactions of
science and policy, and the challenge of changing and
contentious science. In urging negotiators of other
agreements to pay attention to the process, not just
the outcome, of negotiations, he writes:
The developments following the 1987 signing [of the
Montreal Protocol] illustrated the wisdom of designing the treaty as a flexible instrument. By providing
for periodicintegrated assessmentsFthe first of
which was advanced . . . in response to the rapidly
changing scienceFthe negotiators made the accord
adaptable to evolving circumstances....

Other Papers Like Dependable Dynamism: Lessons For Designing Scientific Assessment Processes In Consensus Negotiations

Q1.Using the Assessment Tools We Have Discussed in Unit 6, (Mckinsey 7-S Framework, Balanced Scorecard, Swot Analysis Etc) Provide a Complete Assessment of the Company You Are Currently Working for....

2259 words - 10 pages , one per computer or connection to the internet. Switches can also be used as device for connecting computers in a network. If you had seven computers, and only one had a printer which you wanted to share, you would buy a switch to connect all the computers. There is also a combination of the two; a router with switching capabilities. This is the best of both devices. It may be more expensive, but it is definitely worth it. With this device, you

Job Analysis

1268 words - 6 pages into the human factor the main key to success. This has forced the heads of agencies to establish systems and adaptive processes to the new structures, requiring techniques that allow them to face and overcome the challenges that organizations are subjected. Therefore, in this research paper the reader will find a brief description and job analysis of the field of Human Resource Management (Spector, 2012). Job Analysis Method Job analysis

Managin Service Quality with the Balanced Scorecard

4722 words - 19 pages , users) and the internal perspective (processes, staff); 216 ROSWITHA POLL goals and measures taken; causes and results. The basic model of the Balanced Scorecard, adapted to the conditions of academic libraries, deviates from the original model in placing the user perspective rather than the financial perspective foremost, because libraries do not strive for maximum financial gain, but for best service. The following sections show the

Scientific Article

599 words - 3 pages decisionmaking took place wether to stop at the yellow light or try and make it through. Results showed that high risk-takers didn't hesitate for long before they made the decision. Low risk-takers found themselves hesitating and thinking about possible outcomes and the consequences of those decisions. Differences in the neural network or “white matter” were discovered in the two groups as well. High risk-takers were found to have more Scientific

Annotated Bibliography

1406 words - 6 pages and loss in stock some few years back and even as one filed for bankruptcy (GM) the other hard not to, and succeeded. Both companies needed to make some changes in an effort to recover. In an article by Terry Corbell, as he points out the 7 lessons that other businesses could learn from the Ford motor Company, he infers that If a business is performing in a mediocre fashion, chances are the company needs an overhaul. A culture change, if you will

Compare the Business Culture of the Uk with That of Japan

3217 words - 13 pages Theory of the Japanese”, has been of fascination for both Japanese and foreigners alike, and the industrialised world seems acutely aware that the Japanese are very different to Westerners, in ideology, religion, and business strategies. There are countless books, articles and websites which attempt to teach people how to communicate with the Japanese in business negotiations. However, these sources can cause further alienation, where the numerous

Assignment 5: Multiparty Negotiations, Trust/Reputation

1584 words - 7 pages willingness to act on the words, actions and decisions of another”. Trust also reduces uncertainty over future outcomes, simplifies decision processes, and provides us with peace of mind. Trust during negotiations can easily be damaged if care is not taken as in the scenario painted below. A homeowner entered into negotiation with a gardening and landscaping contractor to do lawn care for him bi-weekly every month for $80 and will only accept a

How Does The Development Of Core Competencies Provide Both Advantages And Disadvantages For An Organisation?

1651 words - 7 pages combination of existing ones in new ways; or a complete renewing of the resource base,depending on how dynamic the environment is, in order to sustain competitive advantage and address external changes. What is important here is the managers’ perception of the environmental dynamism that providesthe basis for their ability to identify the need for changes and extend those changes when necessary. According to Amrosini et al (2009), managers who fail to

Psy Paper

937 words - 4 pages these was that they pretty close to if not almost on the nail when it can to my personality , the big five assessment I thought about the answers and agree with the finding. I’m very much an extroverted person because I enjoy interact with people I happen to be around at that time. I tend to be a little critical of myself when concerning doing certain things for myself, I believe I could or should do things better. When, it comes to dependable I

Continuous Assessment

2395 words - 10 pages other students may need additional lessons or activities to keep them engaged in learning. IV-TECHNIQUES AND TOOLS FOR CONTINUOUS ASSESSMENT IV-1-TECHNIQUES FOR CONTINUOUS ASSESSMENT  Sitting and Listening Closely. Teachers watch the behavior of the students at work and listen closely to their conversations. At times, they may ask questions during conversations to clarify details about what students are doing and what they are finding

Personal Development Plan and Essay

3995 words - 16 pages intelligence assessment and 360-degree managerial competency assessment that were conducted over the past 18 months. The Myers-Brigg Type Inventory (MBTI) is a validated tool to assess preferences in relation to basic mental processes and orientation of energy. The psychological typing is based on the theory that people have a natural hierarchy of preference in the way they behave. Katherine Briggs and Isabel Briggs Myers identified sixteen possible

Related Essays

Samuel Da Groass And Others Were Planning To Open A Restaurant. At Some Point Prior To August 1985, Da Groass Orally Agreed With Philippe La Jaunnie That La Jaunnie, In Exchange For His Contribution In...

644 words - 3 pages exchange for his contribution in designing, renovating, and managing the restaurant. When they had made the oral promise, it does count as a unilateral contract, which is a promise for an act and it is accepted when the performance of the contract is completed by the offeree. There was a valid contract made between the two parties, however it became an executory contract because it was not fully performed when LaJaunnie was terminated from the

Review A Range Of Different Assessment Methods Available And Explain The Ones You Would Use For Your Subject Area. Evaluate The Use Of Assessment Methods In Different Contexts Including Reference To...

868 words - 4 pages Review a range of different assessment methods available and explain the ones you would use for your subject area. Evaluate the use of assessment methods in different contexts including reference to initial assessment. Justify the types of assessment records you would complete and why.There are many methods of assessment in teaching and they all fall into one or more of the following three categories: initial, formative and summative

Review A Range Of Different Assessment Methods Available And Explain The Ones You Would Use For Your Subject Area. Evaluate The Use Of Assessment Methods In Different Contexts, Including Reference To...

1357 words - 6 pages Review a range of different assessment methods available and explain the ones you would use for your subject area. Evaluate the use of assessment methods in different contexts, including reference to initial assessment Quotation. Continuous effort - not strength or intelligence - is the key to unlocking our potential. Winston Spencer Churchill Introduction. This assignment has been prepared in order to review a range of different

Disability Assessment Autism Disabilities Were Looked At In Relation To Nutrition, In Which I Was Given The Topic Of Autism To Research And Prepare An Essay For That Looks At The Disability And...

4043 words - 17 pages behaviour and the ability to concentrate and learn. Some autistic patients have also reported mild to dramatic improvements in speech. Some have also reported fewer bouts of diarrhoea and loose stools. Removing from diet Vitamin Therapy Increasing certain vitamins has are very effective for many autistics. Increasing vitamin 6 (pyridoxine) and magnesium help improve behaviour as well as improvements in brain wave activity and metabolic processes