This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Denial Of Justice Essay

2271 words - 10 pages

Discussion Question
Denial of Justice
In recent years, there have been a number of strong and sustained criticisms of the civil justice system in Australia.

“Justice delayed is justice denied”
In civil litigation, delay is linked to the perceptions of fairness and relevance of courts. The principal driving force for case management was the acceptance and recognition that there was too much delay in the civil justice system. Unacceptable delay is the time beyond that which is reasonably required for the fair and just determination of the case

Delay will impede the proper disposition of any case that does not come to trial promptly. The case takes longer to prepare and to try ...view middle of the document...

However, this is not always the case for all the litigants . Often, this results in two area of dispute: the extent of legal aid funding available and the complexity of the legal system. Unfortunately, no great increases in legal aid have been forthcoming from government, nor is greater funding likely in the foreseeable future. The more common result is attempts to simply court procedures and provide informal tribunals.
Causes of denial to Justice
(1)Cost Implications
The issue of cost permeates the whole of the administration of civil justice. It affects access to justice because costs can place the courts beyond the reach of those who cannot afford. There has been increasingly need for a simpler, cheaper and more accessible legal system. Cost of litigation has been a major problem for poor people to gain access to litigation. Litigation in courts is so expensive that most people cannot afford it. Potential applicants may be unable to commence an action or proceed with a claim. Respondents may be unable to defend a claim with legal representation or defend the claim at all.

Furthermore, the costs incurred in litigation can be disproportionate the the amount at stake or the complexity of the issues involved. The uncertainty arising from the amount of cost will result in the parties having difficulty in predicting their ultimate financial position resulting many litigants in not being able to meet the security for costs imposed by courts. This leads in dismissal or stay of proceeding whereby justice cannot be upheld for these litigants.

Witness Statements
The most common criticism of witness statements is their cost. While the court may save time and money, the additional cost of preparing witness statement falls on clients. The timing of costs is also altered because witness statements need to be drafted well before the trial. This front end loading of costs may have an impact on the willingness of litigants to pursue their cases in the civil litigation system.

Expert Witness
Expert witnesses are used to give evidence in cases where a specialist opinion is required on an issue before the court. Criticism of the use of expert witness focuses on the costs of experts and the difficult in ensuring that expert evidence is independent given the tendency for parties to “shop” for the expert that will best support their case. The need to consult and obtain evidence from experts may also be a component of delay in litigation which is translated into denial of justice.

Complexity of interlocutory proceedings
The various level of technicality, formality and complexity of the interlocutory proceedings have create barriers to access to justice. For many litigants, subjective factors associated with the way they perceive or experience the justice system are key barriers to access to justice.

(a)Discovery Process
The degree of complexity in the adversarial litigation can result in denial of justice. The discovery process is...

Other Papers Like Denial of Justice

Web Server Application Attacks Essay

1674 words - 7 pages load balancer. This will help against small attacks, but not against a DDoS started from several hundred hosts. Furthermore, increasing the number of servers is rather expensive. Attack on the Justice Department’s Web site An apparent denial of service attack, which overloads a site’s servers with requests for access, crippled portions of www.Justice.gov[->0]. Its site was experiencing “a significant increase in activity, resulting in

WHAT IS RELEVANT? Essay

742 words - 3 pages opinions to a criminal, especially on the topic of the relevance of justice. If one assumes that the question of 'what is relevant?' possesses a singular answer, which may also be considered true, that answer may be thought of as the truth, [not merely a truth]. (A truth is defined as the truth of an individual, while the truth is the truth of a corporate entity, or simply, the human race). However, most of man lives in denial of the truth, and

Riely V. California

573 words - 3 pages police had obtained from his cell phone. The court denied the motion, and Riley was convicted. Issue: Was the evidence admitted at trail from Riley’ s cell phone discovered through a search that violated Riley’s Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable search. Decision: Yes. The First Circuit reversed the denial of the motion to suppress and vacated the relevant convictions. Reason: The reason the First Circuit Court reversed

Law Case Brief

539 words - 3 pages Amendment. Ruling: The Supreme Court held that ruling VMI has violated the Equal Protection Clause pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment. The concurring opinion of Justice Ginsburg explained that Virginia was not able to show any persuasive justification to exclude women from entering the institution. The claim of VMI that allowing women to enter their institution will destroy the adversity system implemented by the school and cause the destruction

Jihad

607 words - 3 pages makes this clear when he says that “the ultimate goal of Islam is to unite mankind under a single banner of peace.” The only unity of mankind that Islam’s core texts envision is that of the rule of Islamic law and the concomitant denial of basic rights to non-Muslims. “In order to unite mankind,” Zafar continues, “Islam instructs to only use speech to be truthful, do good to others, and be fair and respectful. It attempts to pre-empt [sic

Racial Profiling in New Jersey

1044 words - 5 pages . Soto, it revealed that although African Americans comprised only 13.5% of drivers and 15% of the vehicles speeding along the stretch of the turnpike in South Jersey, they comprised 46.2% of the people stopped by the State Police. (Diamond) Furthermore, State vs. Soto was the case in which broke the ice when addressing the problem of racial profiling in New Jersey. After the case of State vs. Soto was ended in the courts, the U.S. Justice

Prostitution

1145 words - 5 pages that there are no absolutes in knowledge; morality is the denial of moral absolutes; and religious is the clam that there is no true religion . Greek philosopher Sextus Empericus believes in a position called moral relativism which says that moral values are strictly human inventions . 1.2 Psychological Issues in Metaethics Why be moral ? The psychological issue of metaethics deals with this question for which answers vary from ‘to avoid

Right to Counsel Paper

923 words - 4 pages ; this right has become an expectation through many court cases. One also may enjoy the right to represent themselves in a criminal proceeding. In the following it will be discussed about the developments of these rights and additionally the role of an attorney in the criminal justice system will be discussed as it applies to the right to counsel. Zalman (2008) “The twentieth-century growth of urban populations and bureaucratic, multi-judge courts

Capital Murder

849 words - 4 pages Capital Murder I think capital punishment has its ups and downs. I deem some instances you should use it and some you shouldn’t. I’m going to give you both sides and my opinions on capital punishment also facts on this controversial punishment. The first side I’m going to give you is that capital punishment is ultimate denial of human rights and that two wrongs don’t make a right. What this means is that by killing the person doesn’t change

Admin Law Essay

2879 words - 12 pages arise. Justice Moore concluded that although the applicant agreed to the transcript being used, her offer to clarify the existing oral evidence meant the Tribunal should have allowed her to testify again on the matters they were disinclined to believe. The use of the transcript alone and failure to request Ashmore to provide oral evidence to the reconstituted tribunal was deemed to be a denial of procedural fairness. The prevalence of procedural

Business

635 words - 3 pages what happened when Wikileaks released internal memos/emails that appeared criticized allies of the US. But, it also taught government officials how they should be communicating properly and effectively (an advantage). Basically, this act provides for accountability of elected and appointed officials to the public that they serve. This advantage far out-weighs the disadvantages. That the denial of access to the information and the attendant

Related Essays

Social Justice In India Essay

1172 words - 5 pages The term "social justice" implies several sound and eminently desirable concepts enunciated for the good of society in general, and of course it covers fair play for every section, especially the weaker groups in the popu¬lation. The reckless flouting of the concept of social justice, and the denial of equal opportunities in life which this postulates, all reflect a tendency that is anti-national and marks totally unfair and unjustified

Communal Justice In Igbo Land: An Appraisal

3951 words - 16 pages -to-think, not-to-be-constructive or not-to-improvise,” especially for the future: It tantamount to a child-like dependence on the parents. From this perspective, it seems that communal justice in Igbo land may be less favourable to individual’s creativity, and independent self-improvement. If that is the case, a certain denial of justice is implied, since it robs man of the resources and skills which his situations demand. By its very nature and

Crminal Justice System Essay

1320 words - 6 pages raise any more controversy on the subject but to open the eyes of people to see their is still discrimination against those of color than whites still in the 20th century. While working in this division, I noticed a lot of discrimination within this system such as the African Americans and Hispanics would receive a denial on their appeal and their property would be taken away from them whereas, if a Caucasian inmate appealed the same situation they

Ford Pinto Case Essay

3486 words - 14 pages of $67,000 under law (Aarts 4). The defendant, however, gained $137 million dollars. Clearly this is not a case of wrongdoing where what the defendant has gained is correlative to the plaintiff’s loss. It is clear that the Ford Pinto Case does not meet the criteria that Aristotle outlines as necessary for a case of corrective justice. COUNTER ARGUMENTS It could be argued that my denial that corporate ‘persons’ capture a single defendant who is at