This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Definition Of Tax Fairness Essay

1530 words - 7 pages

17 April 2010
Tax Fairness

In 1789, Benjamin Franklin wrote “In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes” (Martin 1). The fairness of death must be taken up with a deity but the fairness of taxes is very much a human issue. The idea of tax fairness is like motherhood or apple pie – everyone is supports it. Yet there is a wide disparity in what constitutes tax fairness. Investopedia offers little clarity with its circular definition: “[Tax fairness is] a tax platform based on an ideal that aims to create a system of taxation that is fair, clear and equivalent for all taxpayers” (Investopedia 1).

The folks at do not specifically define “fair ...view middle of the document...

This comparison will demonstrate how much tax fairness has eroded. I will conclude by endorsing a proposal that may not restore “fairness,” but can at least stabilize whatever fairness remains.

The Federal income tax came into being with the passage of the 16th Amendment in 1913. The U.S. Department of Treasury’s history of the income tax notes that Congress created this tax with a progressive scale, taxing less than 1% for those with the least incomes. The rates increased progressively up to a top rate of 7% for those with incomes over $500,000 (U.S. Treasury 1). We just stumbled upon the meaning of tax fairness in the minds of those who first created the tax – namely, that those with high incomes should pay a higher percentage of their income than those who earn less.

If we consider this as the baseline of tax fairness – with the highest earners paying seven times more than those earning the least – then the proposed Fair Tax Act, with its single rate sales tax, is in direct opposition to the 16th amendment’s sense of fairness. Describing the Fair Tax Act as nonpartisan is laughable.

In the ninety-seven years since the 16th amendment was passed, the tax rates have changed frequently. Within five years, the top rate was increased to 77% and it reached a peak of 87% in 1954. The top rate was chopped down to 50% under Ronald Reagan, and when the Bush tax cuts are fully implemented, it will be 33% (U.S. Treasury 1). Those with the lowest incomes who pay taxes currently pay 10%. Compared to the baseline of the wealthy paying at a rate seven times greater than the poor, the wealthy now pay only three and one-third times more. Expressed another way, the system is now less than half as fair as when it started.

In 1942, the tax law began recognizing “capital gains” differently. As opposed to wages for work performed, capital gains are “unearned income.” They are “pay back” from owning investments. Currently, the top tax rate on capital gains is 15%, less than half of the top tax rate on wages. Since capital gain income is heavily concentrated among the wealthiest Americans, the result is that the wealthy are paying most of their taxes at the same tax rate (15%) as earners with wages in the 35,000-45,000 range. How’s that for fairness?

With the creation of the Social Security system, a new tax was levied against wages. These taxes are not progressive – everyone pays the same rate, 7.65% of wages. (Note: since capital gains are not wages, they pay 0% of this tax). One more thing: a wage cap was placed on Social Security taxes. The tax stops when one’s wages exceed $106,800. Curiously, the National Taxpayers Union identifies $113,000 as the threshold to enter the 10% of income earners (National Taxpayers Union). So, let me correct what I wrote earlier: not everyone pays the same Social Security tax rate; the richest pay less. How does this compare with the sense of fairness established in the16th amendment?

While the Federal...

Other Papers Like Definition of Tax Fairness

Basic Principles of a Sound Tax System

1225 words - 5 pages , and neutrality. Equity: Two Kinds of Tax Fairness When people discuss tax “fairness,” they’re talking about equity. Tax equity can be looked at in two important ways: vertical equity and horizontal equity. Vertical equity addresses how a tax affects different families from the bottom of the income spectrum to the top—from poor to rich. Three terms are used in measuring vertical equity: ■ Regressive tax systems require that low- and middle

Tax Compliance Essay

4486 words - 18 pages and Ho, 2005). Kirchler and Maciejovsky (2001) also found that when people could understand the tax laws, they are more willing to respect the tax system, thus they are more compliant to pay tax instead of evading it. Having adequate knowledge of tax laws and regulations may change the perception of the taxpayers about the fairness of the tax system and consequently encourage them to comply with tax obligations (Alabede, Zainal Ariffin, and Md

Current Event.Docx

592 words - 3 pages need to proved by the government or an agency, which tend to finance themselves through taxes. Also, there are several kinds of taxes in the category, including income tax, negative income tax, capital gains tax, corporate tax, property tax, inheritance tax, expatriation tax, etc. Both of my articles are talking about President Obama’s new idea about making the wealthy people to pay a higher tax in order to restore fairness, and the articles also

Review Of Aicpa Review Of Good Tax Policy

1881 words - 8 pages are commonly used as indicators of desirable tax policy. Incorporating those principles into the analysis and debate on tax law changes ensures an effective tax system based on good tax policy. This paper explains the framework's 10 guiding principles of good tax policy.   Equity and Fairness This concept states that similarly situated taxpayers be taxed similarly. "Equity" refers to-both horizontal and vertical equity. Vertical equity means

Tax Evasion In Canada

5622 words - 23 pages fairness of Revenue Canada towards the citizens regarding the tax policy, and what it should do to decrease or totally finish this type of crime.Tax evaders and forms of tax evasionJust like every criminal, tax evaders don't have a certain type. They can be anyone around us, but there are some researches that put the tax evaders in categories. Small businesses, self employed individuals, accountants, ones who commit illegal activities, and big

What Are Challenges in Designing an Effective Personal Income Tax Systems

573 words - 3 pages | 35.9 | 48.1 | 49.5 | 35.6 | 32.1 | Among the taxes of all kinds, personal income tax is one of the most effective monetized tools targeting at individual residents and corresponding income source. Hereby, this essay illustrates the challenges in designing an effective income tax system on a basis of social fairness to achieve purposes of distributing and redistributing wealth, promoting social security, and reducing income disparity


1847 words - 8 pages As we know, Congress devised a very broad definition of income and codified this definition in Section 61 of the Internal Revenue Code. Explain the Code's definition of income and how it is generally applied to taxpayers. In particular, explain how the Code's definition of income is different than other potential definitions of income, such as the economic concept of income, and use an example to illustrate the difference between the two systems

Tax Environment and Personal Tax Liabilities

4847 words - 20 pages at: investopedia, nd. DEFINITION OF 'INHERITANCE TAX'. [Online] Available at:, nd. DEFINITION OF 'CAPITAL GAINS TAX'. [Online] Available at:, nd. DEFINITION OF 'TAX AVOIDANCE'. [Online] Available at:, nd. DEFINITION OF 'TAX EVASION. [Online] Available at:

Intermediate Acct Test Bankch19

5499 words - 22 pages deferred tax asset. d 43. Definition of uncertain tax positions. c 44. Recognition of tax benefit with uncertain tax position. d 45. Reasons for disclosure of deferred income tax information. c 46. Classification of deferred income tax on the balance sheet. b 47. Classification of deferred income tax on the balance sheet. d 48. Basis for classification as current or noncurrent. d 49. Income statement presentation of a tax benefit

Auditing & Taxation

1063 words - 5 pages manufacturer transfers the burden of this duty to the buyer of the car in form of a higher price. Thus, an indirect tax is such which can be shifted or passed on. The degree to which the burden of a tax is shifted determines whether a tax is primarily direct or primarily indirect. This is a function of the relative elasticity of the supply and demand of the goods or services being taxed. Under this definition, even income taxes may be indirect

A Legal and Ethical Examination of Corporate Tax Shelters

3369 words - 14 pages on gains held longer than a year is 15%” (O’Neill, 2012, p. 230). By strategically placing assets, or by designing partnerships as partnership pass-through or profits only partnerships, income will be taxed at the capital gains rate, not the typical corporate tax rate (O’Neill, 2012). Deductions and investments are both legal methods of reducing tax liability, available to individuals and corporations. While they qualify under the definition of

Related Essays

Tax Avoidance And Tax Evasion In Bangladesh

5263 words - 22 pages development and social welfare of the country. What is tax evasion & tax avoidance? Definition of Tax Evasion: Tax evasion may be defined either as the understatement or concealment of taxable object or as the failure to pay tax in time either by the assessee or his agent. So it is illegal. In case of tax evasion, tax liability is reduced or tax is not paid at all. Tax evasion means illegally hiding income or concealing the particulars

Tax Reform Paper

1725 words - 7 pages and to report. The flat tax remains a popular idea in part because it eliminates double taxation. It eliminates the death tax, capital gains tax and taxation of savings and dividends. Fairness remains a popular feature of the flat tax. A taxpayer who makes $5000 pays the same tax rate as someone who earns $500,000. The taxpayer who makes more pays more taxes simply because their income is greater. It does not discriminate based on income; everyone

Public Sector Economics Essay

4463 words - 18 pages Public Sector Economics Exercises 1. Florida Taxation a. The 5.5% corporate flat tax levied in Florida is a PROPORTIONAL tax because it is based on gross income of corporations. This tax is levied at the identical 5.5% rate across all levels of gross income on corporations registered or doing business in Florida, so by definition, the tax is proportional. b. Florida’s 6% sales tax is REGRESSIVE since all consumers, regardless of earnings

Smiths Canons Essay

1331 words - 6 pages slight differences. This is because Smiths canons make sense and are difficult to disagree with. In my opinion there should be 5 core attributes of a good tax system which are; Equality /Fairness, Certainty, Simplicity, Stability and Competitiveness. I agree with smiths canons however I feel that more ‘canons’ should be added in order to have a modern, fair, and efficient tax system, therefor my proposals also include the views of other