This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Defense For The Electoral College Essay

1633 words - 7 pages

Chapter 6 Electoral College Assignment

Explain the electoral college and its purpose as presented in the videos posted in the "Lecture and Video" tab. Do you think the electoral college is effective? Why?

Yes I do believe the Electoral College is effective.

I think the Electoral College is one of the most elegant systems in our republic. The key word here is republic and not democracy. We are not a true democracy in the sense that we are ruled by the will of the majority, but rather we are a constitutional republic that employs democratic methods. We have systems that check and balance power between the 3 branches of government, between states and the federal government and ...view middle of the document...

But it wouldn’t and is illegal for that to happen in our country because the constitution, our highest authority in our land has outlawed slavery in the 13th amendment. It would take more than the simple will of the majority of people to overturn that law. It would take congress, including those aforementioned senators, who do not equally represent the people, and a super majority of the states to overturn that.

The videos explaining the Electoral College and the problems with the Electoral College were a cynical attempt with very specious arguments. For one, he states that the electoral congress doesn’t make candidates spend time in small states before the election as people defending the college say it does. Well he’s right, but it has nothing to do with small or large states, but states that are purple or swing states. With or without an electoral college, a candidate would have to spend time right before an election that will give them the most votes in closely contested areas. He has no proof or data that without an electoral college those patterns would not change. Candidates do visit small states earlier in the election, because it does behoove them to. It just so happens that in recent elections, the pivotal swing states have been larger states and most of the smaller states are solid to semi solid in the camp of one campaign or the other. You can bet, that if an election swung on the 3 electoral votes of Wyoming, the two candidates would campaign ferociously
there. If we were to go with equal proportionment of electoral votes, Wyoming’s one vote is less important. If the Electoral College were abolished, there would be no need to directly campaign there. It’s not Wyoming’s fault that they are a small state. They have duly been given statehood and all the rights that go with it. Including a small extra 2 votes to check larger states for the election of president and equal senate representatives as California has.

The other argument he and others who oppose the college, say is that we the people do not directly vote for president. While technically true, it’s an argument based only on semantics to scare people who are ignorant of the process that their vote doesn’t count. Ask the voters in Florida if their vote counted in 2000, or Ohio voters in 2004 or voters in Illinois or West Virginia in 1960. It wasn’t delegates in the college that turned the election, IT WAS THE VOTERS!!!! The people themselves made those elections in key areas of the country very close, sometime a difference of 200 votes.

Rogue Delegates who on rare occasions vote against the will of the people in the states is so rare that it is a non-issue. It has never overturned the outcome of an election. It’s basically a ceremony to make party loyalist feel important. It’s nothing but pomp and circumstance that very few people pay attention too. It’s analogous of the Queen’s opening of parliament every year in England. She has no power...

Other Papers Like Defense for the Electoral College

Should The Electoral College Be Reformed?

2453 words - 10 pages believe that the Electoral College should be reformed for a more proportionally representative system or abolished in favor of direct elections. 3. History and Background In order to understand why the American presidential election process is as it is now, it is essential to understand the historical context. The Founding Fathers had to solve a lot of difficulties. At the time of the creation of the Electoral College, the United States

To What Extent Were Opposition Weaknesses the Main Reason for Conservative Electoral Victories Under Thatcher

1698 words - 7 pages “popular” Thatcherism. It could certainly be argued that while the Conservatives’ great success in building a substantial electoral base was more to do with their policies and the strengths of the leader than it was to do with the weakness of Labour. However, it could certainly be argued that it was the weakness of the Labour Party in its inability to appeal to what was a consistent and growing anti-Conservative majority from 1979-1987, which was a very significant reason for Thatcher’s three victories.

Personal Responsibility Is the Fuel for College Success

1158 words - 5 pages Personal Responsibility is the fuel for college success XXXX GEN/200 XXXX Instructor: XXXX Personal Responsibility is the Fuel for College Success Although many people attend

The Government Should Help Students Pay For College

2524 words - 11 pages Being able to attend and graduate college is a dream and the next step in life for many students. However, going to college and finishing school are two completely different things. There has been a decrease in students who completed college. Researchers are wondering, what is causing students to not finish schooling? There are many reasons and questions to why it could be affecting the completion of college rates. One of the main issue is the

The Beginning of My Start: It’s Never Too Late for College

853 words - 4 pages The Beginning of My Start: It’s Never Too Late for College As a youth I have always wanted to attend college. My family did not encourage going to college and I wanted to be different. After graduating from high school my plans to go to college were delayed. I became a parent at the age of 19 and my life began a new journey. I was still determine to go to college and continue my education. After becoming a mother my plans for going to

College Entrance Essay. The topic of this essay was "Discuss your motivation for pursuing college-level study, addressing your personal interests and career goals"

560 words - 3 pages Over the past few years I have increasingly become confident that a career in psychology is the right path for me. I am by nature a very caring, helping person, a good listener and someone who enjoys being able to connect with others.My friends and family see me as the kind of person they can go to when they need to talk about their problems, and they know that I am someone that they can trust. To me, there is nothing more fulfilling than the

Government

644 words - 3 pages I choose to agree with the Electoral College. I don’t want a direct popular election because I want the smaller states to still have a voice, but, if America switches to direct popular election, the way things are, might just go worse. There are some good reasons for a direct popular election, and there are not good reasons for one too. I like the Electoral College a lot, and I would like the voting system to keep it that way. However, our

Electoral College

742 words - 3 pages The electoral college of the United States of America should be kept in the way that it has been functioning for at least 200 years. Democracy in the United States nor its equal representation principle has never been affected by the Electoral College. The check and balance principle created by the founding fathers is represented in this electoral system. When voters cast their ballots in a U.S. presidential election, they arent electing

Electoral College Paper

2029 words - 9 pages president (National Atlas, 2011). In addition, it is important to understand not only how the Electoral College works, but how why it was even created. The Electoral College was created by the founding fathers in March of 1784 when it was included in Article II, Section I of the U.S. Constitution. The Electoral College was created for two reasons: First, the founding fathers were afraid of direct election (by the people) to the presidency because

Electoral College

580 words - 3 pages Should the Electoral College be abolished? This complicated question has been debated for years and will probably continue into the future. Initially, I felt that the Electoral College was no longer necessary now that times have changed. My opinion began to shift upon further contemplation. Now, I believe that the Electoral College is an important part of American history that needs to remain in the government. In the past, it has proven

Electoral College

1721 words - 7 pages The Electoral College Andie Downs ENG 105 Research Paper Final Every four years on the Tuesday after the first Monday of November, the election for the next President and Vice President of the United States takes place. Although thousands of individuals cast their vote for their candidate of choice on this day, it is really Electors that they are voting for. The electors that are selected will go on to choose the next President and Vice

Related Essays

The Electoral College Essay

1056 words - 5 pages this by discussing its strengths, weaknesses and attempts to reform it. The Electoral College system has been criticised many times since its establishment. It is seen to contain weaknesses for not fully serving American democracy. The main problem is that the system clearly has the potential to frustrate the electorate. Because of the aggregation of the electoral votes by state, it is

The Electoral College System Essay

550 words - 3 pages president. The compromise was to set up an Electoral College system that allowed voters to vote for electors, who would then cast their votes for candidates, a system described in Article II, section 1 of the Constitution (Bonsor, K. 2000). Opponents of the Electoral College point to Bush as a reason to get rid of the current system — he was president even though he lost the popular vote. Since the distribution of electoral votes tends to over

Electoral College Time For Change Essay

2219 words - 9 pages Electoral College, Time for Change? By Chris Brady May 21, 2014 Introduction: The history of the Electoral College was born by the founding fathers during the Constitutional Convention. There were roughly four ideas of how to elect a president to the United States. First was the idea of giving the power to Congress to choose the president, but detractors worried that giving the authority to Congress could create corruption, political

How The Electoral College Works Essay

2607 words - 11 pages themselves on how the Electoral College works in order to make good decisions when voting for the president. Electoral College delegates elect the President. Voters elect Electoral College delegates. The Electoral College was created as a compromise between election by Congress or popular vote for the presidential election process. At the time, some politicians believed an election by popular vote was not good for the country, and others did