Debate On Gay Marriage Essay

889 words - 4 pages

English Composition I 161
16 September 2012
A Critique of “A Debate on Gay Marriage” by Andrew Sullivan
Same-sex marriages or “homosexuality” has become one of the most highly controversial topics in today’s society. One half of our population is in favor of “homosexuality”, while the other half strongly disagrees with the sexual orientation that others prefer. A debate titled “A Debate on Gay Marriage” had circulated. It states the supporting beliefs of the writer Andrew Sullivan from his book, “Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality” and rebutting arguments from William J. Bennett, a prominent cultural conservative, which appeared as an op-ed column in the Washington ...view middle of the document...

Recognizing the legal union of gay and lesbian couples would represent a profound change in the meaning and definition of marriage” (Bennett, 409). By broadening the definition of marriage and consenting same-sex marriages, Bennett questions the controversy that will form by our society. Bennett disputes about homosexuals having the same right as heterosexuals in adopting children having knowing that a child being raised by mother and father is socially acceptable. Bennett indicated that “among worldwide cultures, where there are so few common threads, it is not a coincidence that marriage is almost universally recognized as an act meant to unite a man and a woman (Bennett, 410).
I feel that the debate from both writers, Andrew Sullivan and William J. Bennett, provided appropriate arguments as to why same-sex marriages should and should not be made legal. In Sullivan’s article, he portrayed passion for stating his case on the equality and dignity for all citizens, mainly homosexuals. He fully committed himself to seek out that homosexuals have equal rights in marriage as to heterosexuals, having the same right in raising children, and being a role model for young gay individuals. He could have made a stronger point of view by citing creditable studies and sources. For example, Sullivan’s point of view of children being raised by “homosexual” partners, he could have conducted or cite several well-conducted study bearing his point of view. Sullivan’s point for the concern about the importance of legalizing gay marriages, he failed to cite a liable source. He indicated that “gay marriages were legalized, 90 percent of the political work necessary to achieve gay and lesbian equality would have been achieved” (Sullivan, 407). He never...

Other Papers Like Debate on Gay Marriage

Same Sex Marriage Essay

866 words - 4 pages gotten from a different state (Rauch, 2013). Some legal means that can be used to bring the gay marriage debate to a standstill include the majority rule. Since the constitution points out nothing about marriage, it is left to the people to decide. From a different perspective, this may not be the best to do, the majorities are not always correct. There are no children expected from gay marriages, and this has a negative impact on the population

Gay Marriage Essay

1473 words - 6 pages Gay Marriage: The Complicated Moral Debate The debate on gay marriage is a complicated one. Many different emotions, ideas, and opinions are formed from the subject. There are some who believe that gay marriage is morally wrong, and damages the foundation of the traditional marriage. Andrew Sullivan, a gay rights activist, stated in his article Here Comes the Groom (New Republic, 2015): The argument that gay marriage would subtly undermine

Gay Marriage

946 words - 4 pages Gay Marriage debate Recently, gay marriage has become an issue of great concern all over the world. The question whether this marriage should be legalized has continued to raise heated-up debates in all social, religious and political arenas. The matter was has come into fresh discussion after the president of The United states of America passed a motion that allows gay marriage in the country. The following is an analysis of a debate that was

Gay & Lesbian Marriage

1302 words - 6 pages incorrect form of prejudice. Recently, a high end Atlanta law firm, King & Spalding, would not represent the House of Representatives against a Gay Rights Advocacy group on the constitutionality of homosexual marriage due to opinion pressure. For many gay rights advocates, the decision amounted to a turning point in the debate — the moment at which opposition to same-sex marriage came to look like bigotry, similar to racial discrimination and

Gay Marriage

653 words - 3 pages Name: Tutor: Course title: Date of submission: Gay Marriage Overview The issue of same-sex marriage has generated heated debate over the leeway of legalizing this kind of marriage in the globe. The first law enabling this type of marriage was enacted in the twenty-first century. This marriage has varied the jurisdiction to state laws. Equality, sense of belonging and dignity are all contained as compared to the typical marriage of different sex

Gay Marriage - 945 words

945 words - 4 pages to gain the tax benefits or tax cuts that a married couple can obtain. In the articles, “Let Gays Marry,” by Andrew Sullivan and “Leave Marriage Alone,” by William Bennett, they both talk about the subject of same sex marriages. They both believe that marriage is based off of tradition. However, they debate on if these marriages should be allowed and if they are proper. Sullivan goes on to prove he believes same sex marriages are proper

Homosexual Marriages Should Have the Same Rights as Heterosexual

4076 words - 17 pages All States, but Naming it “Civil Unions” · Legalizing Gay Marriage/Civil Unions Against Some States, Recognizing it in All · Recommendation · References INTRODUCTION: Same Sex Marriages Having Same Rights as Heterosexual Marriages Gay marriage has been an active debate amongst politicians, religious figures, and the public. The debate has spanned over a decade with little change for either side. The issue of gay

For and Against Gay Marriage

605 words - 3 pages Marriage” William J. Bennett expresses himself against same-sex marriage. Andrew Sullivan thinks that homosexuals cannot have equal rights until the same-sex marriage is legalized, but William J. Bennett says that talking on this topic is totally pointless. Bennett says that legalizing gay marriage would be destroying that word “marriage.” He calls it an “honorable estate,” because of the differences between men and women balance it out and

Gay Marriage, Absolutely Not!

604 words - 3 pages In recent years gay marriage also referred to as same-sex marriage has grown into an extremely controversial nationwide debate. This topic is seemingly appearing progressively on the voting ballots and voters have rejected the proposed changes every time. Marriage properly understood is an essential prerequisite for stable, healthy families. Societies throughout history and across the world have learned this from experience, and modern

Gay Marriage Essay

1251 words - 6 pages Egypt as shown in artifacts found. The Western world was known for being very accepting of same-sex relationships and unions, which is revealed in Greek paintings. People who are against gay marriage primarily focus on the moral aspect of gay marriage. Supporters of gay marriage think about same-sex couples and the positive effects it can have on them and our society. Gay marriage should be legalized in all states because it is their civil right

Same Sex Marriages

3998 words - 16 pages the United States. It has been a competing legislation, lawsuits, and ballot initiatives in attempting either to legalize or ban the practice. Nearly seventy percent of people in the U.S. oppose gay marriage, almost the same proportion as are otherwise supportive of gay rights. Same sex marriage has really showed how our rights as humans can easily be violated based on someone else’s decisions, feelings, or religion. It is our rights as humans

Related Essays

The Gay Marriage Debate Essay

2750 words - 11 pages building upon ideas that we rose in the debate as well as incorporating some new material. Throughout this essay, the ‘for and against’ positions will distinguish between both sides of the argument. Inclusion of scholarly articles will become evident throughout this essay to support the main points that will be made within this argument on gay marriage as well incorporating case studies that support both ‘for and against’ gay marriage. Overall, this

Gay Marriage This Is An Essay On Why Gay Marriage Should Be Allowed In The United States. It Covers Several Reasons Why Gay Marriage Should Be Allowed Including Constitutional Reasons

555 words - 3 pages An issue that is of both national and international concern is the right of homosexuals to marry. The issue of gay marriage is a highly controversial and important issue in the 2004 Presidential Election. One could list a host of religious reasons why gay marriages should be banned, but none would have any relevancy because the constitution establishes a separation of state and church. Therefore, any religious reason to ban gay marriages would

Article About Gay Marriage Essay

1008 words - 5 pages Gay Marriage Gay marriage has provided one of the biggest debates in this decade. Now in 2015, after about 10 years of discussion of whether gay marriage should be legal or illegal, gay marriage is now legal in every state of America. Though there are still many different opinions about whether gay marriage should be legal or illegal. A debate on the website ProCon.org shows different quotes for and against gay marriage. The newest quotes

Gay Marriage Essay 970 Words

970 words - 4 pages their civil liberties. Soon in the future this status will be achieved and gays will be treated just as other human beings. Gay marriage is a controversial issue that attracts numerous reactions from those advocating and those opposing the vise. The issue regarding whether lesbian and gay marriages attracts heated debate. In the societal setting, certain individuals believe that homosexuality is immoral while gay advocates believe that putting