David Hume And Determinism Essay

1107 words - 5 pages

The idea of Determinism is explored by many philosophers in the construction of arguments against free-will, morality, and liberty. Determinism is a philosophy that claims that all things are causally related to each other and there is a necessity behind every event that occurs and while Determinism as a term wasn’t coined as a term until the 19th century, David Hume explored these major concepts in his Enquiry, delving into the roots of humanity and questioning the truth of human freedom.1 In particular his exploration into human understanding leads him to conclude that there is no effect without a cause and liberty when opposed to necessity cannot universally exist.2 Hume’s discovery, the ...view middle of the document...

5 The other possible situation, which Hume clearly denies, follows the same causal chain but is the product of a dissimilar argument: God is imperfect.6 Hume argues that we cannot know this chain of events, and speculation on this subject leads us to ignore the world around us, which is the sole provider of knowledge. This ignorance of a world outside of the bounds of human experience does not allow us to understand the nature of God, making a discussion of his perfection outside of the bounds of reasonable philosophy. Determinism is the root of Hume’s method of discovery, and though it is clear that he is not willing to admit that God created human sin or is imperfect, Hume clearly acknowledges that such arguments have merit, though the answers lie outside of the subjective nature of empirical impressions.

One of the most influential human concepts is the idea of freedom with respect to individual and cultural identity.7 Hume, contrary to these overwhelmingly universal beliefs, claims that there is remarkable uniformity in human actions. He cites the predictability of the consequences of various human emotions relative to the motive, as with ambition leading to conquest or generosity leading to charity.8 Therefore, human action can be equally predicted by cause and effect, and it is absolutely necessary for a relatively stable society to exist. Hume argues that through observation we predict human behavior, and it is universally acknowledged that humans participate in this activity in contradiction to our belief that humans have the capacity to act freely.9 Hume speculates that morality may not be possible if this liberty does not exist because humans, under the will of an external force, could not accurately be blamed for their action because they are not the cause of them.10 However, an action can be performed causally within the bounds of a moral concept such as justice because, regardless of what force determined some form of injustice, there is an underlying feeling of wrongdoing that must resonate within the person who was causally determined to commit the act. Hume utilizes cause and effect to explain how human morality can exist through the constant effort of predicting certain consequences for various actions and emotions, further affirming his deterministic approach at...

Other Papers Like David Hume and Determinism

We Are Not Responsible for Our Actions, Discuss

1752 words - 8 pages that because of this we are then not responsible for the actions made because we have no choice over the outcome. This would then suggest that we do not have any responsibility, however Hume, Sarte and Heisenberg argued against hard determinism because as humans we feel that we have power over our own choices and decisions and that therefore this then suggests that we have the freedom to chose and decide. However Locke used the analogy of the

Media Determinism Essay

1779 words - 8 pages actions acts on us to influence us toward or away from such actions. Hunnex argued that, "those who invoke the naturalistic-fallacy argument assume (from Hume) that the 'ought' cannot be derived from the 'is'" (p. 28). * TECHNOLOGICAL DETERMINISM The phrase "technological determinism" may have been first coined by Thurstein Veblen in his The Engineers and the Price System (Ellul, 1964, p. xviii). The issues raised by technological determinism

Humes Ethics

1054 words - 5 pages Hume’s Ethics Contents 1. Introduction 2. Hume’s ethics as an emotive theory of ethics 3. Conclusion 4. Bibliography David Hume is an outstanding Scottish philosopher of the 18th century whose views has a significant impact on the following generations of thinkers throughout the world. His sceptical arguments concerning induction, causation and especially religion, including his famous thesis that human knowledge arises only from sense

Kant and Hume on Morality

1512 words - 7 pages church or watch football on a Sunday afternoon. When we encounter one of these more difficult decisions, we find that our actions are almost always coinciding with our morals. But from where do we as humans derive our morality? This question does not come with an easy answer. To find out the answer to this question, we must turn to two great philosophers, David Hume and Immanuel Kant, and examine each of their perspectives. Firstly we will

John Locke's Concept Of A Persistant Self

1079 words - 5 pages persistent beings, and that we mistake the ideas of identity and diversity when defining the self as persistent. David Hume proposes in his argument that the concept of a persistent self lacks sufficient justification for its premise. Hume suggests that in order for there to exist a persistent self, “[i]t must be some one impression that gives rise to every real idea. But self or person is not any one impression, but that to which our several

Experience Of Truth

633 words - 3 pages Experience of Truth While both Philosophers, Rene Descartes a rationalist and David Hume an empiricist had vastly different views on where the bulk of individual knowledge is gained. Both had the power of persuasiveness of opinion that could become conceivably believable if while reading their writings, a reader does not keep in perspective that it is their (the writer) belief. Descartes believed in a priori knowledge and that ration and

Examine the Arguements Against the Teleological Arguement

786 words - 4 pages Examine the arguments against the teleological argument for the existence of God? (30) The design argument is also known as The teleological argument; it is an argument for the existence of God or for a higher more intelligent creator. The earliest version of the argument is associated with Socrates in ancient Greece. One argument which disagrees with the teleological is an argument from the famous philosopher David Hume, who said that even

Two Philosophies And Their Bel

719 words - 3 pages Two Philosophers and Their Theories of Belief When reading Rene Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy and David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, one notices that both philosophers focus a large part of their writings on the subject of human belief. Both authors have different theories on what makes a person form those beliefs that are important in life. Through an analysis of their theories, it is possible to understand the

Philosophy and Religion

2529 words - 11 pages Bible shouldn’t there view be black and white? There is no gray with God. As stated I struggle with this and could see how one would challenge this idea. Are there times when it is right to do what’s wrong? My worldview says no but I would say yes. Does this mean I do not have a Christian worldview? I would say no. Now that I have shared and critique my worldview lets look at the worldview of David Hume and Thomas Aquinas. David Hume is one

‘We See Examples Of Design Throughout The Natural World And Conclude That An Intelligent Designer Is Clearly Demonstrated.’ Assess Whether This Argument Succeeds

903 words - 4 pages by natural selection otherwise we would still all be cave worms. This is known as the fine tuning argument. These are all arguments that can be taken from design, however you can look at it from a different perspective and start from the other end. David Hume express an argument from this point of view. He says that human inventions display purpose, binoculars allow us to see into the distance, cars allow us to get from A to B quicker and

Do We Have Free Will?

913 words - 4 pages could most likely explain why this decision was made. First off, there are three main viewpoints on the idea of free will: compatibilism, determinism, and indeterminism. Compatibilists state that it is possible for both free will and determinism to exist at the same time. Given an instance, a compatibilist will say that even though you are only really presented with one option in all situations, if this option is in accordance with the your

Related Essays

Classical Metaphisics Essay

1183 words - 5 pages Name Professor Course Date Philosophy Free will can be termed as the ability of agents to make choices with no constrains of different dynamic factors. This principle of free will has implications on religion, legal and ethical factors among others. Philosophers since time immemorial have debated extensively on the existence or the nonexistence of free will in nature.one of this philosophical figure is David Hume, he maintains that humans are

People Are Morally Free To Do What They Want. Discuss

631 words - 3 pages determination of free will. Soft determinism basically argues that our actions are determined but we are still morally responsible for our actions. Doesn’t rule out free will. It also says that some of our actions are conditional whilst others are caused by external influences. A very famous philosopher David Hume describes liberty as only mean a power of acting or not acting according to the determination of will that is we chose to remain at rest, we

Ethical Issues In Accounting Essay

740 words - 3 pages Ethical Issues in Business and Accounting Barbi Hammond October 31, 2010 Ethical Issues in Business and Accounting The business and accounting worlds are full of ethical dilemmas and scandals. The works of great philosophers of the past can be directly applied to current situations in today’s business and accounting ethical situations. David Hume is one of the philosophers whose works could be applied to the business world today. David

Kant Versus Hume Essay

985 words - 4 pages Kant VS Hume David Hume works from world to mind, Immanuel Kant from mind to world. Hume, how we experience the world is conditioned by the world. Kant, how we experience the world is conditioned by the mind. Most contemporary philosophers believe that Hume refuted the views of the rationalists before him (Descartes, Hobbes Spinoza, and Leibniz), who all held that there is an element of genuine a priori reasoning in causal inference