Critiques Of International Society Essay

2013 words - 9 pages

Critiques of International Society
Several major criticisms can be made of the lnternational Society approach to IR. First, there is the realist critique that the evidence of International norms as determinants of state policy and behavior is weak or non-existent. Second, there Is the liberal critique that the International Society tradition downplays domestic politics-e.g. democracy-and cannot account for progressive change in international politics. Third, there is the IPE critique that it fails to give an account of international economic relationships. Finally, there are several solidarist critiques that emerge from within the International Society tradition itself that focus on its ...view middle of the document...

When there is a conflict between international obligations and national interests the latter will always win, because the fundamental concern of states is always their own advantage and ultimately their security and survival. That is the concern that guides foreign policy. The International Society approach is not as soft a target as the realist critique claims. As pointed out, realism is built into the approach as one of its three basic elements. Wight (1966) characterizes IR as a “theory of survival” which is an acknowledgment of the primacy of states, their right to exist and the legitimacy of their interests. But the International society approach does not stop there. It emphasizes that states bind themselves to other states via treaties, and that justification for that can be more than merely self-interests (realism) or even enlightened self-interest (moderate realism). It emphasizes that states have legitimate interests that other states recognize and respect; it also emphasizes that states recognize the general advantages of observing a principle of reciprocity in international affairs (rationalism). Likewise, it notices that states do not observe treaties only when it is in their best interest to do so. Rather, they enter into treaty commitments with caution because they know that they are binding themselves to the terms of such treaties. If states really acted the way realists claim there would be no binding treaties, because no state could be expected to keep their promise when it was no longer in their interest to do so. Yet binding treaties are commonplace in world politics.
A more damaging criticism of the International Society approach is the theoretical incoherence that could result from trying to combine realism, rationalism and revolutionism within a single framework of interpretation, and from emphasizing not only international order but also international justice.
Liberals have directed most of their critical attention at realism, and the debate between liberals (or idealists) and realists was the most conspicuous IR debate in the twentieth century. However, one implied liberal critique is the lack of interest of International Society theorists in the role of domestic politics in international relations. Like realists, International Society theorists draw a firm line between international relations and the internal politics of states. They are not inclined to investigate the domestic aspects of foreign policy. A second implied liberal critique derives from the claim that liberal democracies are more peace-loving than non-democratic political systems. Here, republican liberals are criticizing not only realists but also-by implication-International Society theorists who tend to ignore the subject. A third implied liberal critique is the inability of the International Society approach to account for progressive change in international relations. Wight (1966: 33) claims that domestic politics is sphere of progressive change,...

Other Papers Like Critiques of International Society

Discuss How Castles Sees Mulitculturalism Essay

1656 words - 7 pages century emergence of modern-industrial states, where social theorists such as Durkheim, Weber and Marx, theorised that status based social differentiation was replaced by the social class as the driving force in society. Ethnicity and racial differences were viewed as surviving anachronisms, dating from pre-modern, traditional societies. This analysis was shared by social commentators and policy-makers who operated with an often implicit view that

Capitalism Essay

562 words - 3 pages -laden system characterized by persistent crises that have an inclination towards mounting severity. Critiques of capitalism argued that this tendency of the system to unravel combined with a socialization process that links people in an international market, produce the objective conditions for revolutionary change. The three Marxist critiques of capitalism were Karl Marx, Weber and Vladimir Ilyich Lenin. Marxists describe capital as "a social

Margret Atwood

603 words - 3 pages pattern of the colour red to illustrate the negative impact it has on women, especially the Handmaids.Atwood creates an oppressed society in which she critiques the role of oppression in everyday culture. Atwood's stylistic writing techniques help the reader define the oppression in each of the characters, and the internal thoughts of the narrator show the relationship between individual oppression and the oppression of a group. Atwood shows the

Gender and Development

1012 words - 5 pages economic change. It is now widely recognised that pervasive pre-existing gender inequalities mean that development processes have differential effects on women and men. Early feminist critiques emphasised the “marginal” position of women in development and advocated their “integration”. More recently, critiques have argued that women's “marginality” reflects the systematic gender bias in official statistics and development planning in general

Concepts of Health & Health Promotion

3087 words - 13 pages physical, emotional and psychological aspects of well being within one’s self. Social issues surround the concept of health making it difficult to limit it to only one definition and perspective, as health is affected by the society and culture we live within. Dahlgren & Whitehead’s model (citied by Adams et al 2001) demonstrates this clearly by illustrating the main determinants of health as socioeconomic conditions, living and working

History Paper

1112 words - 5 pages role. However she loses all of her moral values once she gets married to the wealth merchant as the author critiques “On one side she shouts to her servants, on the other, yells at her maids.” Both “shouts” and “yells” link into the idea of loss of moral values. According to Confucianism, she is supposed to have a friendly relationship with her servants and maids instead of yelling at them and bossing them around. Her moral values are totally lost

Postmodern Feminism

1676 words - 7 pages around man gained more importance in terms of power than the female discourse. Foucault in his genealogy clearly explains how subjects emerge in history through practices of power relations. Feminist writers claim that mainly man theorist discourse influences the ongoing anarchic situation in international relation. They also claim that a woman view of the world would change most of the interpretations of the world and specifically international

Business Ethics

1712 words - 7 pages The success of modern business is apparent, but recently there is much concern in the business-and-society literature and in the general press on whether business fulfils its social role responsibly. Business ethics, corporate social responsibility and corporate governance movements have been developed in recent decades as responses to a growing sense of corporate wrongdoing. This paper attempts to explain why the three movements seem yet to

It is a paper about anarchism. describeing what it is and what anarchy is,

533 words - 3 pages the US, to libertarian socialism, a social system which believes in freedom of action and thought and free will, in which, the producers possess both political power and the means of producing and distributing goods,), there have always been two common positions at the core of all of them, opposition to government and opposition to capitalism. Anarchism is both positive and negative, it analyses and critiques current society while at the same time

The Great Gatsby

1232 words - 5 pages success, has driven many lower-middle class individuals succumb to the gateway of deviance in order to achieve financial success. Fitzgerald also critiques the ideals of his society through a warped view of hedonism. A hedonist is one who reflects conviction to the motivation of a desire for happiness and the experience of pleasure, through the mindset that does not suffice the capacity for considering long-term needs, much less the needs of

The Benefits and Disadvantages of the Imf and the World Bank

1215 words - 5 pages The Benefits and Disadvantages of the IMF and the World Bank International Economic Course FN5203 Short Paper Assignment 1 Week 2 This essay discusses the benefits and disadvantages of the International Monetary Funds and the World Bank - the Bretton Woods Institutions. The first part of the discussion will be a short history of these institutions and will also try to explain why they were formed. This will be followed by the

Related Essays

Critiques Of Society Through Technology In Thx 1138 And Blade Runner

1797 words - 8 pages Allison Margolis Authors and Genres Professor Griffith 3/13/2013 Critiques of Society Through Technology in THX 1138 and Blade Runner The threat of overdeveloping technology has been portrayed in film throughout time as a negative influence on society. As shown in THX 1138 and Blade Runner, made by George Lucas and Ridley Scott respectively, society is overturned by the use of technology and these films can therefore be seen as a warning

Functionlism Essay

1074 words - 5 pages international agreement will serve to benefit the least advantaged. * Other critiques of Functionalism relate to its failure to take into account the effects of intergovernmental organizations (a critique countered by neo-functionalism), it’s failure to consider the origins of conflict (which go far beyond simple lack of co-operation or understanding), and its failure to explain situations of divergence in international relations. In summary

Juvenile Justice Essay

1439 words - 6 pages jurisdictions – national and international, academic, non-government associations and the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOCSAR). The confirmation base for all new legislation, policy and agenda is focus on rigorous assessment within Government. As well, the Legislative Appraisal Committee examines all Bills initiated to Parliament and all systems theme to disallowance conditions in the Legislation Review Act 1987 Youth Justice Youthful

Resource Based View Essay

2647 words - 11 pages advantage. Therefore, resources and competencies approach first appeared as a theory of competitive advantage or a theory of “performance of the firm” (Argyres & Zenger, 2007). It is only recently, in the last 20 years that organizations have started using the resource based view approach on strategy. Nowadays, they view it as the most important key development in international business research and strategic management, an approach that