Critically Evaluate The Comparative Transnational Effectiveness Of Benetton And Zara

2118 words - 9 pages

Critically evaluate the comparative transnational effectiveness of Benetton and Zara

Zara and Benetton are two of the most acknowledged clothing companies in the fast fashion industry. The different international business strategies they adopt result in different transnational effectiveness. To begin with, this essay will give a brief overview of the motivation, means and mentality of these two companies, and then compare how they sustain their competitive advantages through integration, responsiveness and flexibility. Next, it will highlight their evolving strategies and demonstrate the structures, worldwide learning and innovation models they adopt to support the strategies. Finally, ...view middle of the document...

Because Zara and Benetton competes in a fast fashion industry, they focus on producing some basics that can meet universal needs and sells aboard to achieve economies of scale.
Although Zara and Benetton carry the similar motivation to global expansion, they enter global market in different modes. Zara mainly uses wholly-owned subsidiary to achieve internationalization. By contrast, Benetton usually takes the form of
1
franchising and licensing. It is the first Italian fast fashion corporate that uses the quasi-franchising system to retailing (Crestanello and Tattara, 2009). Mentality refers to company’s strategy to go aboard. In general, Zara is evolving from global mentality to transnational mentality, while Benetton is witnessing the transformation from international mentality to global mentality.
Developing Transnational Strategies
Initially, ZARA and Benetton adopted Global Strategy and International Strategy respectively, for achieving the goals of global efficiency, flexibility and global learning.
Firstly, for achieving the global efficiency, both ZARA and Benetton take the advantage of national differences by centralizing the capital-intensive production, meanwhile, transferring partial labor-intensive activities in relatively low labor cost countries. For example, ZARA conducts about 64% of the production within the Spain radius area for protecting the production know-how, with 36% of the production of basic styles in Asia and Africa to reduce the production cost. Comparatively, Benetton mostly controls 80% of its production at home to enjoy the accession to superior domestic textile, with 20% of its basic products’ production in other regions (Decken, 2010). Additionally, the two companies pursue economies of scales in different ways. For example, ZARA triples other competitors’ annual sales by offering limited quantity but diversified choices to fashion-oriented customers to spread production costs. On the contrary, Benetton produces a considerable amount of garments dyeing with multiple colors but in limited styles, at the same time beats the competitors with the superior textile and dyeing quality, it enjoys higher margin from the standardized production with higher pricing (Fox, 2011).
Secondly, in terms of pursuing global flexibility, ZARA and Benetton adopt different entry modes to realize different levels of risk aversion. As mentioned above, ZARA expands mainly through wholly owned subsidiaries to guarantee tightly controlled and globally standardized operation. Benetton, by contrast, expands typically through franchising and licensing to avoid the macro risks of specific markets.
2
Thirdly, in regard to global learning, these two companies adopts different innovation models. ZARA aims to ‘discover’ and ‘reactively follow’ the fashion trends emerging globally, while Benetton proactively ‘create’ the fashion trends with exploring its own innovations. Details will be given later.
On balance, both ZARA and...

Other Papers Like Critically Evaluate the Comparative Transnational Effectiveness of Benetton and Zara

Critically Evaluate the Theory of Mind Hypothesis of Autism

1957 words - 8 pages Critically evaluate the theory of mind hypothesis of autism Childhood Autism is a rare and severe developmental disorder that affects about 4 in every 10,000 children (Baron-Cohen, Leslie & Frith, 1985). Autism affects how an individual communicates, socialises and even how they make sense of the world around them. Many theories have tried to explain what causes autism in an attempt to achieve greater understanding of the disorder and

Critically Evaluate the Law in the Areas of Murder and Voluntary Manslaughter and Include the Consideration of Possible Reforms

3369 words - 14 pages Critically Evaluate the Law in the areas of Murder and Voluntary Manslaughter and include the consideration of possible reforms. Homicide, in English criminal law is a generic term covering offences such as murder, manslaughter and death by dangerous driving. What they all have in common is the unlawful killing of a human being, and what distinguishes them is the state of mind of the defendant who has caused the death or the defences

Discuss the Need for World Order and Evaluate the Effectiveness of Responses in the Maintenance of World Order

1321 words - 6 pages Kimberley process was an effective response to the conflict diamonds as it requires governments to ensure shipments of rough diamonds are conflict free, discouraging the illegal trade of conflict diamonds. This notion of certified diamonds has improved the enforceability of laws revolving around conflict diamonds. However the lack of resources of Sierra Leone has limited the effectiveness of the responses such as the lack of X‐ray machines and

Describe and Evaluate the Effectiveness of Sociological Theories in Explaining the Role of the Public Services in Contemporary Society

2940 words - 12 pages Describe and evaluate the effectiveness of sociological theories in explaining the role of the public services in contemporary society. Since the beginning of time (Giddens, 2009), human kind has constantly striven to reflect and improve their past behaviour and conducts, with aspiration that their knowledge will help create a better society. Charles Wright Mills an American Sociologist refers to this as ‘Sociological imagination

The Strategy of Zara

2144 words - 9 pages world. Threats First and foremost is competition from comparable competitors: H&M, Gap and Benetton. All three has narrower vertical scope than Zara, which owned much of its production and most of its stores. H&M is the most powerful competitor of Zara. H&M tended to have slightly lower price than Zara, engaged in extensive advertising like most other apparel retailers, employed less designers(60% fewer than Zara), and refurbished its stores

The Analysis of Zara

4708 words - 19 pages stores globally with politeness and frankness to charm the customers, treat them with excellent manners to get their loyalty. For the promotion of ZARA , they start focusing on website researches or smart phone application, either of them is the perfect way to display its production efficiently. 3.3.5 People Selling effectiveness might be critically affected by the behaviours of front-line employees who are interact with customers closely

Critically Evaluate the Potential Justification for Protectionism

1843 words - 8 pages Critically evaluate the potential justification for protectionism Introduction A number of governments are concerned with unemployment and recessionary impact following the financial crisis. The result of this has been for many to be being placed under political pressure to implement protectionist instruments such as tariffs. quotas and subsidies (Love et al, 2014). This essay will identify the five principal instruments used by governments

Compare and Contrast the Ideas and Positions of Booker T. Washington, Ida B. Wells-Barnett and W.E.B. Dubois. Critically Evaluate the Strength and Weaknesses of Each

1216 words - 5 pages 22/25 “Compare and contrast the ideas and positions of Booker T. Washington, Ida B. Wells-Barnett and W.E.B. DuBois. Critically evaluate the strength and weaknesses of each.” Black History 140B Professor Katungi 3-12-03 Booker Taliaferro Washington was born a slave on a plantation in Franklin Country, Virginia in 1856. One of our nations most powerful black educators; he illustrated his belief in the dignity of work. He was very

Critically Evaluate Whether the Main Features of Kant’s Deontological Approach Are Too Restrictive and Fail to Be Applicable to Modern Ethical Issues, Such as Euthanasia

1268 words - 6 pages Critically evaluate whether the main features of Kant’s deontological approach are too restrictive and fail to be applicable to modern ethical issues, such as Euthanasia. The main features of Kant’s deontological approach are in many ways restrictive and it can be argued that they fail to be applicable to modern ethical issues. However to say that they are exempt from providing any form of solution to modern ethical issues is a failing in

Critically Evaluate Some Aspects of Peron Centered Ciunselling

2627 words - 11 pages Emma Phillips Level four diploma in therapeutic counselling Essay : Critically evaluate some aspects of person centred therapy. This essay will critically evaluate some aspects of person centred counselling. I will provide a brief history of Carl Rodgers, who is considered by many to be a pioneer of the client centred approach, and his career. Attention will then be drawn to the model of person centred counselling which includes the

Many Experts Argue That People Do Their Best Work When They Are Motivated by a Sense of Purpose Rather Than the Pursuit of Money. Do You Agree? Critically Evaluate and Explain Your Position

1928 words - 8 pages 1. Many experts argue that people do their best work when they are motivated by a sense of purpose rather than the pursuit of money. Do you agree? Critically evaluate and explain your position. The study of what motivates people has fascinated researchers and academics over the years. Many renowned researchers have come up with their own model explaining the mechanisms of motivation. Though all these theories are unique in their own right, the

Related Essays

Comparative Analysis Of Zara And Topshop

544 words - 3 pages Study Proposal A comparative case analysis of Zara and Topshop Company I. Rationale As of the present, fashion industry market is growing and booming with the presence of low cost fashion companies such as Zara and Topshop. These kinds of companies have the possibility to dominate the industry of today and in the future and the situation for competition in the fashion industry can be set on high demand on such products and services

Explain And Critically Evaluate The Concept Of “Freedom Of Navigation”

2711 words - 11 pages Topic: Explain and critically evaluate the concept of “freedom of navigation” Prepared by: Nadir Gürpınar Table of Content: 1. INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................4 2. HISTORICAL ORIGIN OF THE FREEDOM OF NAVIGATION................................4 3. THE CONCEPT OF FREEDOM OF

Identify And Critically Evaluate Four Variables That Account For The Emergence Of International Business

2389 words - 10 pages Identify and critically evaluate four variables that account for the emergence of international business. International Business, which is the other way to seek an opportunity of brand new markets and a better driver of changing the recent environment (Ramirez-Aleson & Espitia-Escuer, 2001). It is thought as a business or industry that attracts and provides in international economic activities (Peng, 2011). From the views of domestic and

Critically Analyse The Effectiveness Of Leadership In The Nhs

1014 words - 5 pages HS 3001 LEADERSHIP AND CHANGE Critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership in the NHS Summary This essay will discuss and critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership role of senior nurses in the NHS. The essay will examine the definition of leadership, different theories of leaderships and how it can be implicated to nursing practice including changes that should be made to make nursing leaders more effective in NHS health