This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Assess A Utilitarian Response To Environmental Ethics

957 words - 4 pages

Critically assess a utilitarian response to environmental ethics.

Utilitarianism is teleological, concerned with the end or purpose of actions. It is also consequentialist, judging actions right or wrong according to their outcome. Many scientists, politicians and philosophers have expressed concern that the world is facing an environmental catastrophe. If this is to be believed, an ethical theory that focuses on the results of our actions seems most appropriate. Utilitarianism is able to take into account the risks to the environment of global warming, ozone depletion, pollution, deforestation etc.

Traditional utilitarianism would have done that using Bentham’s Hedonic Calculus. ...view middle of the document...

How can you decide how the pleasure of enjoying an unspoilt stretch of land compares with the convenience of being able to use a road?

There is also disagreement amongst utilitarians about whose interests would count in environmental calculations. Bentham talks of pleasure and pain, and would count any being that had the capacity to feel pleasure or experience pain. Even in the 21st Century, scientists cannot agree about this question. Mill favoured higher pleasures like reading and appreciating art, clearly putting human concerns above other sentient beings. This sort of thinking might agree with deforestation if cutting down trees provided homes for people. Even though many more animals may be displaced, humans count for more because they experience higher pleasures.

Hare talks of preferences, which makes it harder still to imagine completing any sort of calculation concerning the environment. As well as discussions about which animals have preferences, there is also the issue of how we can know what everyone’s preferences are, and how to weigh them up against each other. Take wind turbines, for example. Many people consider them an eye sore, and would rather not use them. However, many others see this sort of advancement as essential in protecting the world from global warming. It is impossible to balance one of these preferences against the other. It is also hard to see how seriously to take the threat of global warming – will it really affect generations to come? How many people and preferences will it affect? And how do you take account of the cumulative damage of the way we treat the environment?

This last point raises a very serious concern for utilitarians. Take the case of over-fishing. A fisherman goes out and catches a thousand cod. It is then revealed that the number of cod has become dangerously low, threatening the future of fishing in that area. Is this the result of...

Other Papers Like Critically Assess a Utilitarian Response to Environmental Ethics

A Response To Night Of The Scorpion And Sacrifice

776 words - 4 pages A Response to Night of the Scorpion and Sacrifice Both Nissim Ezekien and Taufiq Rafat are writing the poem from the point of view of a older person living in the western world looking back at the culture that hey were brought up in and the differences in ways of life and beliefs. "Sacrifice" tells the story of how a goat was slaughtered to bless a house about to be built and the struggle that a young onlooker is

A Response To Senge's Ideas About Learning Organizations And Leadership

2221 words - 9 pages A Response to Senge's Ideas about Learning Organizations and Leadership Extracted from the article "Peter Senge and the Learning Organization" Smith, M. K. (2001) 'Peter Senge and the learning organization', the encyclopedia of informal education, Issues and problems When making judgments about Peter Senge's work, and the ideas he promotes, we need to place his contribution in context. His is not meant to

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the Contribution of Religion to Social Change

934 words - 4 pages Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the contribution of religion to social change. (18 marks) Weber found that religion could cause social change, such as the Calvinism and capitalism. The Calvinists believed in predestination, so God had already chosen the elect to go to heaven and the individuals who hadn’t, could not do anything to change that. They believed that God was far

‘If a Business Wants to Maximise Profit, It Cannot Be Concerned with Corporate Social Responsibility’. Critically Discuss This Statement

1464 words - 6 pages ‘If a business wants to maximise profit, it cannot be concerned with corporate social responsibility’. Critically discuss this statement. This paper addresses the issue, if a business is to maximise profit, should it be concerned with corporate social responsibility. This is defined as the organisation’s duty to act ethically through the perspective of society and stakeholders and also known as CSR. Although it is a factor that should be

A Hybrid Approach to Ethics Is the Best Approach?

768 words - 4 pages A Hybrid approach to ethics is the best approach? Virtue ethics is an agent-centred theory thus focuses on the person performing the action themselves rather than then the action they perform. Virtue Ethics was developed by Aristotle, however, is originally based on Plato’s four cardinal virtues; courage, temperance, prudence and justice. A follower of virtue ethics would believe that the goodness of something should not be decided on by an

A Guide to Formal Ethics: Developing Ethics Programs for Today's Workforce

2132 words - 9 pages Running head: A GUIDE TO FORMAL ETHICS A Guide to Formal Ethics Developing Ethics Programs for Today’s Workforce Jessica L. Krauter Western Governor’s University A GUIDE TO FORMAL ETHICS Abstract This paper is an ethics program that was developed as a part of a new employee handbook. This was written under the scenario that a new ethics officer for Company X has

How Do We Assess Whether A City Is Global? What Other Criteria Could Be Used? This Essay Seeks To Identify Criteria’S And Different Aspects To Assess What Makes A City Global. Firstly, It Will Outline...

336 words - 2 pages How do we assess whether a city is global? What other criteria could be used? This essay seeks to identify criteria’s and different aspects to assess what makes a city global. Firstly, it will outline and explain the concept of globalisation and a global city, showing evidence from the use of academic sources and giving examples if necessary. It shall then continue to examine and focus on a specific global destination, discussing different

“a Study to Assess the Knowledge and Attitude of Social Phobia Among the Adolescent in Selected College at Tumkur with a View to Develop a Health Education Module .”


Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the Contribution of Functionalism to Understanding of the Role of Education

568 words - 3 pages Brenna McRandal Using material from item A and elsewhere, assess the contribution of Functionalism to understanding of the role of education When studying education, Functionalists seek to discover what functions it performs to meet society’s needs. Durkheim identified two main functions of education: creating social solidarity and specialist skills. Durkheim argues that society needs a sense of solidarity, and that without solidarity, social

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere Assess the Contribution of Religion to Social Change (18 Marks)

1030 words - 5 pages Using material from Item A and elsewhere assess the contribution of religion to social change (18 marks) Religion can be powerful under the right certain circumstances for social change. However it can be argued that religion can be a conservative force. Weber argues that religious beliefs contributed to major social change- specifically the emergence of modern capitalism in Northern Europe in the 16th and 17th centuries. Modern capitalism

Society Has Entered a New Postmodern Age and We Need New Theories to Understand It. Assess This View

949 words - 4 pages ------------------------------------------------- Society has entered a new, postmodern age and we need new theories to understand it. Assess this view. Postmodernism is a movement that has emerged since the 1970’s. Postmodernists argue that we are now living in a new era of postmodernity where image and reality are indistinguishable and we define ourselves by what we consume. They believe that this new kind of society needs a new

Related Essays

Critically Assess The Contribution Of Positivist Approaches To Criminological Thinking

4439 words - 18 pages why the differences are so vast. The main criticism of twin studies is that it takes no consideration of possible environmental influences (Hollin, 1989). One possible factor that could lead to higher concordance rates for MZ twins is that the social environments they share are more similar than the DZ twins. MZ twins often have a closer relationship than DZ twins, meaning that they behave similarly, and participate in the same activities

Response To A Novel Essay

954 words - 4 pages Response to a novel. By Luke De Munari. Watch out for Jamie Joel by Mike Dumbleton. Add Another Chapter Deputy Jamie turned up today; she had a brief meeting with Angela. Angela said Jamie seemed very positive and keen to make a go of school this term. I am very pleased Jamie seems to have the right mindset towards her schooling, after all she’s been through. Cathy Lee saw me about some funding issues regarding the Breakfast Club

Response To A South African Response

1384 words - 6 pages Response to a South Africa Investment Leon Grier Personal & Organizational Ethics Dr. Tina Engle March 19, 2012 Response to a South Africa Investment In my judgment one of the benefits to continue with the expansion project of the Caltex plant is it would continue to keep Caltex black employees employed. Caltex has improved the life of its current minority employees even though the country itself hasn’t tried to improve the welfare

Response To Like A Winding Sheet

633 words - 3 pages Response to “Like a Winding Sheet” by Ann Petry The short story “Like a Winding Sheet” by Ann Petry opens with a young African American man reluctant to get out of bed for his night shift. We are introduced to his lovely wife, who is portrayed as affectionate and silly. The impression is that the two, Johnson and Mae, have a healthy marriage and a good friendship. Though Mae doesn’t want to leave the house because it is Friday the 13th