This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Appraisal Guidelines Part 2 Essay

669 words - 3 pages

Critical Appraisal Guidelines: Qualitative - Part 2
Amanda T. Creel
Grand Canyon University: NRS – 433V
June 9, 2013

The research article reviewed was “Ultrasound – Guided Peripheral Venous Access vs. the External Jugular Vein as the Initial Approach to the Patient with Difficult Vascular Access” by T.G. Costantino MD, J. F. Kirtz MD, and W. A. Satz MD. Intravenous (IV) access is commonly performed in the Emergency Department (ED). In patients with difficult access, physicians are frequently called upon to perform these procedures. Physicians should be familiar with both the external jugular (EJ) IV technique and the ultrasound – guided IV (USIV) peripheral access techniques. Some hospitals have specialized team of nurses that have been educated and trained on the proper way to establish an EJ IV and/or USIV. This study examined both techniques and collected data to establish which techniques was better for the patient.
Protection of Human ...view middle of the document...

The subjects entered the study voluntarily after being education on the research. After the education process, a written consent was obtained. The patient was then placed in a randomized tract of the study.
Data Collection
The study has 2 variables in which data was collected. The 2 variables included USIV and EJ IV. The study had 2 inclusion criteria: age must be greater than 18 years of age and 3 failed IV attempts. The need for a central line and the inability to give consent were the exclusions. The data was collected through a non – blinded randomized study of ED patients in need of IV access and how much time it took to establish access. The study included 32 patients that received an USIV and 28 patients that an EJ IV was obtained. The EJ IVs and the USIVs were established by 2nd and 3rd year medical residents that were trained in USIV. The study was conducted in the ED only from June 2007 to December 2007. The data collection began with the first IV attempt and ended with the successful cannulation of either the USIV or EJ IV. The rationale of the study was to show which technique is more commonly successful as the first approach to the patient with difficult intravenous access.
Data Management and Analysis
Methods Used in Study
The data analysis used in the study was based on outcome measures. The author based the success of cannulation on the presence of 5 mL blood and a patent IV line that infuses easily. Data collected was grouped into 6 different areas. The areas included the number of successfully placed IVs, number of successful IVs obtain in each technique, amount of time it took to place the IV, length of stay in the ED, average number or total sticks, and any complication observed while in the ED.

Process of Study
The development of the study was validated by the successful cannulation of a peripheral by using either USIV or EJ IV techniques. The data is collected and analyzed through memos, notes, tables and diagrams. The study included 3 tables and 1 diagram including the data obtained. The author did not state if statistical software was used during the study. The results were displayed in the hypothesis testing form while using a p – value

Other Papers Like Critical Appraisal Guidelines Part 2

Management Appraisal Essay

632 words - 3 pages that the report that is written will deliver factual results and improve their performance. (MacMillan, 2015). Part of the process in the performance appraisal evaluation review should include the following: 1. Regular feedback relevant to the manager’s job. 2. Clear performance expectation communication and setting. 3. Performance link to clearly compensate. 4. Organization

Performance Appraisal Essay

5885 words - 24 pages rating to the 10 employees. 7. Discuss the feedback with the employees. 8. Conduct post-appraisal Interview. 9. Initiate corrective action if required.METHOS:(A) TRADITIONAL METHOD (1) Ranking Method (2) Paired Comparison (3) Forced Distribution (4) Forced Choice Method (5) Check List Method (6) Critical Incident Method (7) Essay Method (8) Field Review Method (9) Confidential Report(B) MODERN METHOD (1) MBO (2) BARS

Human Resources

1296 words - 6 pages Human Resources The French writer Antoine de Saint-Exupery once said “a goal without a plan is just a wish”. Today’s presentation summarizes Health System’s plan for implementing a formal performance appraisal system for each employee, both individually and as part of a team, as well as outlines our strategy for implementing an organization-wide succession plan to fully maximize our use of human resources. As you were briefed at the last

Hr Management

3350 words - 14 pages manager is expected to provide feedback. The appraisal process would be incomplete if this critical phase was not to occur. Feedback should be provided in such a way to motivate and guide employees (Cooper, T. L., 2000). Appraisals should be used to improve skills by establishing training and coaching Maximizing HR Relationship opportunities. In order to be more effective, managers should possess interpersonal communications skills to foster

Human Resourse Management

2263 words - 10 pages TEGA INDUSTRIES LTD. Human Resource Management Performance Management – Appraisal System Parthapratim Chakraborty 11/1/2011 PART – 1 : Performance Appraisal System Introduction : Performance Appraisal is an objective system to judge the ability of an individual employee to perform his tasks. A good performance appraisal system should focus on the individual and his development, besides helping him to achieve the desired performance

Performance Management

7702 words - 31 pages that the characteristics of performance management systems for managing organisational performance are that they are corporate systems which include the following processes as part of an integrated cycle of management: * Setting corporate policy and resource aims and guidelines, * Specifying within the above framework, a detailed set of plans, budgets, objectives, targets and standards of performance, and * Regularly and

Evaluation and Morale

1009 words - 5 pages communicated her strengths and other accomplishments that maybe had not been reviewed by the nurse manager during the planning phase. The results of the appraisal interview should be used as guidelines for continuing positive behaviors as well as a plan for improvement of the course of the next year. In this case study with the staff nurse feeling she received an inadequate evaluation this process has been under minded as he/she is unable to take away any


1062 words - 5 pages relations to increased profits. 1.4.0 The main objective of the study was to assess the effectiveness of the Performance Appraisal (SPA) system in Ghana Health Service at Manhyia District Hospital. 1.4.1 Specific objectives for the study were to find out: 1. To measure employees’ understanding of the objectives of the appraisal system, its processes and procedures at Manhyia Hospital. 2. To find out whether the appraisal system at Manhyia

Restructuring Appraisal Systems

6342 words - 26 pages . (2013) Issues and Challenges in the Practice of Performance Appraisal Activities in the 21st Century. International Journal of Education and Research. [Online] 1 (4). Available from [Accessed: 17th October 2013] CEDERBLOM, D. and PEMERL, D. (2002) From Performance Appraisal to Performance Management: One Agency's Experience. Public Personnel Management. [Online]31(2). Available from: [Accessed


2049 words - 9 pages . Employees can develop a plan for correcting the deficiencies and reinforce the weaknesses through performance appraisals. Performance Appraisal can use by supervisors to identify training and development needs. (Dessler, 2013) An effective Appraisals always involves the 3-step performance appraisal process: (1) setting work standards; (2) assessing the employee’s actual performance relative to those standards (this usually involves some rating form

Career Development Plan Part 2

771 words - 4 pages Career Development Plan Part III Dana Hagood University of Phoenix Human Capital Management 531 Laurene Collins April 26, 2010 Career Development Plan Part III Management is a word that encompasses many tasks. The particular tasks this paper is addressing will be the role of managers using a tool such as a performance appraisal to help shape the careers of future managers. Whether the manager likes it or not at least once a

Related Essays

Interclean – Performance And Career Management

1322 words - 6 pages from the World Wide Web on October 3, 2008 from Appendix - A Performance Appraisal Form Template Part -1- EMPLOYEE INFORMATION Name Of Employee: Manager Name (Optional): Date Position: Period: to REVIEW GUIDELINES Complete this peer review, using the following scale: NA = Not Applicable 1 = Unsatisfactory 2 = Marginal 3 = Meets Requirements 4

Performance Management Essay

891 words - 4 pages . For example, a person who receives below 100% appraisal rating should not be rated a High Potential (HP). Rule 2: Minimum Appraisal Requirement to be Rated CR An employee must be rated at least 95% in 2 consecutive appraisal cycles to be rated a Critical Resource (CR). Rule 3: Minimum Appraisal Requirement to be Rated CC An employee must be rated at least 90% in 2 consecutive appraisal cycles to be rated a Core Contributor (CC). Rule 4: Appraisal Rating for UA and UP UAs and UPs would typically have an average of < 90% and > 80% in 2 consecutive appraisal cycles. Rule 5: Appraisal Rating for ELPP ELPPs would typically have an average of

Analysis Of The Employees Performance System Individual

2875 words - 12 pages AN ANALYSIS OF THE EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL SYSTEM By AHMAD MASOOMZADEH MR101158 LECTURER: Dr. Hooi Lai Wan TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS 2 INTRODUCTION 3 LITERATURE REVIEW 3 What is Performance Appraisal 4 Purpose of Performance Appraisal 4 History of Performance Evaluation 4 Performance Appraisal Techniques 4 Conclusions 4 REFERENCES 4 INTRODUCTION Throughout history, companies and

Study Guide Chapter 3 Essay

1261 words - 6 pages 2) This term refers to a difference between the output of a human judgment processes and that of an objective, accurate assessment. This difference could be due to bias, prejudice, or other subjective, extraneous influences. 2) _______ A) content validity B) a first-impression effect C) rating error D) the performance appraisal process 3) In 2009, employees were expected to earn average merit