This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Crimes And Verdicts Essay

1567 words - 7 pages

CRIMES AND VERDICTS
PROFESSOR TIMOTHY KELLY
INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE
MAY 29, 2014

I have chosen the State of Florida vs. George Zimmerman as the first part of this paper. Why was Zimmerman charged and tried at the state level, and then face the possibility of Federal charges? Is this not “double jeopardy”? The court that will try a case is decided by jurisdiction, jurisdiction being defined as “(1) the legal authority of a court to hear and decide a certain type of case; (2) the geographic area over which the court has authority to decide cases “ (Definitions, n.d.). Also we must clarify state and federal jurisdiction. Federal court jurisdiction is limited to the types of ...view middle of the document...

With that said, it is a far reach to charge him with a hate crime when there was no evidence in the state trial that his actions against Martin were “because of the actual or perceived race, color, religion, or national origin”. In addition, the Federal Bureau of Investigation concluded that there is no evidence of Zimmerman acting based on racial motivation. I believe the Federal investigation was a direct act to appease certain groups outraged over the result of the state trial. In my research, it was the majority opinion that there is insufficient evidence to charge Zimmerman with any Federal crime. My final thought is this, if Zimmerman is charged with a federal crime, is not the federal government saying in a way, the jury in the state trial got it wrong?
Robert H. Richards IV, the wealthy heir to the du Pont family fortune, was convicted of raping his infant daughter, yet will spend no time in prison. Although convicted in 2009 in Delaware, the case was kept quiet until Richards former wife filed a lawsuit in Delaware Superior Court in 2014 on behalf of their children alleging "personal injuries arising from the childhood sexual abuse." She alleges that Richards not only abused their daughter, but also admitted to abusing their infant son (Conlon & Gallman, 2014). Despite being sentenced to eight years, the judge suspended the sentence stating "defendant will not fare well" in prison. Richards instead received eight years’ probation, ordered to receive treatment, and was registered as a sex offender. Richards was originally indicted on two counts of second-degree rape of a child, punishable by ten years in prison for each count. But as part of a plea agreement days before his 2008 trial, Richards pleaded guilty to fourth-degree rape -- reportedly a Class C violent felony that can bring up to 15 years in prison, though guidelines suggest zero to 2 1/2 years (Crimesider, 2014). uperior Court Judge Jan Jurden suggested that she considered unique circumstances, and that Richards needed treatment vice prison time. This sounds like a something that would be said for a drug abuser, not a child molester. At Richards' 2009 sentencing, prosecutor Renee Hrivnak recommended probation, but the Attorney General’s chief deputy Ian R. McConnel said that in retrospect, he wished she would have sought prison time (Crimesider, 2014). One Delaware Public Defender stated the results of this case may cause the public to be skeptical about "how a person with great wealth may be treated by the system." You think? How does a judge state the “defendant will not fare well in prison”, and not expect public backlash? I’m sure no one “fares” well in prison, especially child molesters, much less wealthy ones. One of the terms of his probation was to attend a specific intensive treatment facility located in Massachusetts, which he did not (Barrish, 2014). The hearing transcript shows that the prosecutor and the judge cited the intensive therapy offered by the...

Other Papers Like Crimes and Verdicts

Restorative Justice Essay

918 words - 4 pages another. Restorative Justice is not as mutual as contemporary criminal justice. The two procedures are alike in aiding the criminal justice system, but differ in the elegances on how it distributions its resolutions and verdicts. It’s best described as,” In old-fashioned justice, we have a habit of asking the questions-what corruption transpired, who done it, and how are we going to discipline the individual? In Restorative Justice, we

Juveniles Must Accept Responsibility Essay

2096 words - 9 pages criminal courts are instead dealt with in the misdemeanor court (Snyder 3). Howard Snyder, Director of the National Juvenile Court Data Archive, in his report, demands that the courts must not continue letting minors leave the courtroom with minimal sentences for dangerous crimes. Most importantly, juvenile crime forces the courts to neglect time from the adult criminal courts. Juvenile crime has done nothing but increase in the past, and

Juveniles Trial

1076 words - 5 pages (Michel, n.d.). For this reason they will remain with their story even when it was misconstruing (Michel, n.d.). They will thus keep repeating the story to other people, ignoring the facts. Besides that, intentional deception might also be because the witnesses could have been involved in the crime and have the intention to conceal the truth (Colb, 2011). It’s either for personal gain or just simply to protect the crimes committed by their loved

Legal System in France

1811 words - 8 pages religious beliefs as a motivation for the enactment of prohibitions. As a consequence, France has long had neither blasphemy laws nor sodomy laws (the latter being abolished in 1789). It’s regularly updated (e.g. in 1994 a new criminal code was introduced, including clauses on sexual harassment, ecological terrorism, crimes against humanity and maximum jail sentences, which are 30 years). France has two judicial systems: administrative and judiciary

Criminal Justice

4145 words - 17 pages Criminal Justice Intro Exam 3 Study Guide Capital Punishment- The Ultimate Sentence: * Capital punishment- the use of the death penalty to punish wrongdoers for certain crimes * Only 23 countries still employ the death penalty and the US is the only western democracy that continues the practice Methods of Execution: * In the early years they adopted drawing, quartering, and boiling the convict alive but by the 19th century these

Crime And Deviance

3404 words - 14 pages -represent violent and sexual crime, portray criminals and victims as older and more middle class than they actually are, exaggerate police success, exaggerate the risk of victimisation. Cohen and Young – the news is manufactured. Notion of news values. * Media as a cause of crime – horror films (Childs Play and James Bulger killing), violent video games, concerns over lyrics in rap, imitation (copycat crimes), etc. Effects of TV on children

The Insanity Defense

3174 words - 13 pages eighties in an attempt to reform the insanity defense and decrease the amount of NGI verdicts. The NGI verdict is the more dangerous verdict and the one which I believe has the strongest argument against the insanity defense. The objection here is that it allows dangerous men to return to the streets where they commit heinous crimes. Of the 300 persons committed on NGI verdicts 80 percent were released from mental hospitals by psychiatrists, and

Death Penalty

1858 words - 8 pages ). It is often argued that threatening to put an individual to death using the death penalty is a good teaching technique to would-be murderers that “killing is wrong,” and that this technique would deter people from committing such crimes. Philosophically the debate on death penalty concerns whether putting criminals to death is a defensible form of punishing them and passing a strong message to others that killing is wrong. Ethically

Canadian Morality And The Law

3078 words - 13 pages discriminatory, but considered this discrimination acceptable, since none of the couples excluded are capable of meeting the "fundamental social objectives" intended by the act.  In this way, La Forest felt he was upholding both the letter and the democratic spirit behind the law.     An analysis of the verdicts in Mossap and Egan reveal two common themes.  On a technical level, both cases dealt with the same issue:  How does the law understand

The Traitorous Tyco Scandal: Sentencing of L. Dennis Kozlowski and Mark Swartz

3512 words - 15 pages The Traitorous Tyco Scandal: Sentencing of L. Dennis Kozlowski and Mark Swartz Business Law 447-A Written By: Lindsey Proffitt White collar crime is not a victimless crime, and affects many people. These crimes can devastate a company, force investors to lose billions of dollars, and destroy people’s life savings. Through L. Dennis Kozlowski’s and Mark Swartz’s scandal reported in 2002, the Tyco Company lost over $28 billion dollars in

??+

2936 words - 12 pages injection and hanging. In those jurisdictions that practice capital punishment, its use is usually restricted to a small number of criminal offences; principally, murder, that is, the deliberate premeditated killing of another person. History of Capital Punishment in Australia In the nineteenth century 1 520 people were hanged for crimes including burglary, sheep stealing, forgery, sexual assault, murder and manslaughter. Since Federation (1901

Related Essays

I'll Upload One Later Essay

2012 words - 9 pages punch’ or ‘king hit’ incidence within NSW it gives rise to alcohol related violence and having a major effect upon societies safety. Usually during incidence like the ‘king hits’ seem to be not a heavy sentencing incident under the Law enforcement [powers and responsibilities act 2002 and the Crimes [sentencing procedure] act 1999. The effect of these act have not stopped the incident reason being fair sentencing is not provided. Due to the law

Crimes Againist Humanity Essay

1486 words - 6 pages Crimes against Persons Student’s Name University’s Name Abstract In the United States of America, the law pertaining to crime against persons is complex; due to the principle of dual sovereignty that is a component of federalism. This essay entails analysis of murder as crime against persons. Murder cases are classified by the hierarchy of acts which entails: homicide, murder, manslaughter, and lastly justifiable homicide. English courts

Justice Delayed Is Justice Denied Essay

959 words - 4 pages or justice.” A prompt trial is guaranteed by the sixth amendment of the United States Constitution. A defendant who is held in jail for a lengthy period of time prior to his day in court could ultimately be found not guilty and then will have been in a sense wrongfully imprisoned. Trials that are pushed back for years may mean that witnesses may be lost or their memories may fade and a guilty man could walk. Victims of crimes and their families

Saudi Arabia Is A Medium Political Risk

1034 words - 5 pages clashes took place elsewhere, such as at Narayanganj, south of the capital, where 20 people were reported killed. The coming months look turbulent. A war-crimes tribunal will continue issuing verdicts on trials of Islamist hardliners, nearly all of them leaders of Jamaat, over atrocities committed during the 1971 war of independence from Pakistan. One guilty verdict in February led to violent protests and the deaths of at least 67. On May 9th the