This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Creating Meaningful Work Essay

1865 words - 8 pages

In a discussion case about Great Jobs and Meaningful Jobs, Desjardins (2009, p 92) suggests that despite the common assumption that people work in order to earn money to survive, people have many reasons for pursuing the types of work and specific jobs they choose. Meaningfulness is defined as ‘the value of a work goal or purpose, judged to the individual’s own ideals or standards’ (May et al., 2004). Based on this position, individuals do not necessarily place the same weighting on different aspects of their employment. In this essay, I will argue that the claim that some work is more meaningful than other work is relative to the fulfilment an individual derives from their work, and ...view middle of the document...

This view of work does not consider the psychic benefits one can gain from work.
The liberal view of work is based on the individual being able to choose their work based on their own requirements and on how the work will affect them. This is more in line with Bowie’s definition of meaningful work in A Kantian Theory of Meaningful Work (1998), where meaningful work is defined as work that is freely entered into, allows the worker to exercise their autonomy and independence, enables workers to develop their rational capacities, provides a wage sufficient for physical welfare, supports the moral development of workers, and does not interfere with the workers’ conception of how they wish to obtain their happiness.
John Stuart Mill (1859) validates work as an opportunity for self-fulfillment, and encouraged individuals to choose their work consciously. ‘The ability to choose one’s work is important not only because one is more likely to choose a work role that fits one’s preferences and competencies, but because choice itself is a good, an activity “in which man perfects himself.”’(Mills, cf Clayton, p. 130).
Work must support the development of rational capacities, and enable workers to balance work and other commitments, given that work is by no means the only or most prominent avenue to meaningful living (Rifkin, 1996).

Clayton highlights that wages allocated by the market might fall below some minimally acceptable level, because the market is driven by economic criteria rather than by considerations of individual welfare. The wage must therefore be determined by how much it will take to maintain physical welfare, as opposed to a wage determined by the market.

As far as moral development is concerned, activities that incorporate virtues such as honesty, compassion and loyalty create meaning in work. This puts workers in situations where they are consciously aware of their actions and the effects of their actions on others as well as on their working environment. ‘When one experiences their [job] as meaningful, this is a subjective experience of the existential significance or purpose of [work]’ (Lips-Wiersma and Morris, 2009, p 492).

Michaelson (2008) uncovered that meaningful work is discussed in relation to subjective concerns such as self-esteem as well as objective concerns such as the social contribution of one’s work.
This tells that people don’t just work for monetary compensation. Work has the potential to contribute some instrumental value in people’s lives that they might otherwise not have obtained. Thus states Desjardins, ‘what work you did and how you did it will play a significant role in deciding how worthwhile your life has been’ (p 124).
Job satisfaction also contributes towards commitment to an organisation. According to Clayton, internal goods, the intrinsic benefits that derive from a practice, can also be said to include their products, which accrue to the public’s benefit. If these intrinsic benefits...

Other Papers Like Creating Meaningful Work

Existentialism Essay

3494 words - 14 pages people do not live meaningful lives, and demonstrate how that statement relates to the story of Sisyphus, and expand upon Taylor’s belief that it is essentially impossible for the majority of people to live a truly meaningful life. Thirdly, I will introduce Susan Wolf and her views on what features are needed in order to live a meaningful life in contrast to the views of Taylor and Nagel, and determine whether or not her criticism of Taylor and

A Positive Physical Working Environment Essay

710 words - 3 pages A positive physical working environment is as important as anything when it comes to creating a positive overall work environment. It can have a large bearing on the attitude and productivity of employees, and hence on their ability to work well. Things such as ambient temperature, the quality of lighting, personal space, noise levels, the quality of the air, the furniture and fittings, and so on can influence the overall work environment in a

Good Study Habits for Academic Success

544 words - 3 pages impression on the brain. So, don’t grind on the same subject all night. Change it up, take breaks and re-visit the material in intervals - even spacing over a period of days if possible, which has been proven to enhance retention even further. 3. Make Information Meaningful Whether it's creating rhymes or patterns, or even relating material to something else perhaps through word or scenario associations, such tactics can make information more


537 words - 3 pages satisfaction, and performance become limited, and more often than not result in employee turnover. Continued levels of stress and conflict at work eventually result in absenteeism clue to stress-related medical problems” (Deems, 2005). Motivating employees When it comes to motivating employees it takes dedication and consistency to help convey positive outcomes. “Action plans help to clarify expectations and accountability, align and coordinate

Causes and Prevention of Burnout in Human Services Staff Paper

1030 words - 5 pages manager, being aware of the signs and symptoms of burnout is essential to prevention. Organizational strategies for the prevention of burnout and remediation are key responsibilities of management. Most importantly, managers are to help ensure that workers are doing work that is meaningful and employees are not overloaded with demands that are impossible to meet, and have the decision-making autonomy appropriate for professionals (Lewis, 2007

“Jakob Wywialowski And The Angels” Analytical Essay

456 words - 2 pages of thinking. The exterminators are big burly men with stogies in their mouths and lots of tools and weapons in their big black truck. This gives the exterminators a sort of mean and tough kind of feel, creating a feeling that the process of extermination will be a fairly loud and messy one. When the exterminators begin their work, Niffenegger tells us that angel extermination is not easy by writing that smoke and fire billowed from the attic

Foundations Paper

845 words - 4 pages Foundations Paper Olive Garden, Red Lobster, and Longhorn Steakhouse are places many have had the pleasure of visiting. These restaurants focus on providing exceptional customer service and creating a positive work environment for their employees. Along with the focus on exceptional service, these restaurants share another commonality; they are all a part of the Darden Restaurant Group. In 1938, a 19 year old by the name of Bill Darden

The Next Nigga

583 words - 3 pages SIGNIFICANCE OF BUSINESS ETHICS AND REFORM Creating meaningful ethical reform in business requires teaching students practical, concrete, psychological tools for how to work with their inner conflicts and emotional patterns, teaching them how to embrace the challenges that directly come up as we seek to build businesses that create both money and meaning, renouncing the fundamentalist dogmas of the cult reasons of the single bottom line. And

Perception and Leisure Time

666 words - 3 pages week's hard work, can get a fresh idea to their life and work because a person need to have some enjoyment in life. A person can perform activities well in their lives since it helps re-energize and relax people. It is imperative that youth be given a wide range of opportunities for meaningful participation within the community, provided or facilitated by a multitude of organizations, institutions and programmes in all sectors. On the other hand

Infosys Case

1470 words - 6 pages as though they were losing the ability to do meaningful work and weren’t clear as to how they fit into the changing policies and practices that were being implemented at the company. Another possible solution would be to try to make moves to bring the original small and collegial feel of the company back because it seems as though that is another one of the biggest complaints from the employees over time. While it usually doesn’t

Vision and Change Process

916 words - 4 pages , or larger group of people. 3. The process must include effective teamwork. 4. Include analytical information but also dream big. 5. Recognize that creating a vision is challenging work. 6. Acknowledge this process takes time. 7. The end product sets future direction, yet is flexible, feasible, desirable, and can be conveyed in five minutes or less. Collins supports the idea of flexibility, conveying that the brutal facts must help shape the

Related Essays

Meaninfull Use Essay

1086 words - 5 pages . Because, in their EMR training they learned that if a nurse leaves the system without login out, anyone else can work with the nurse password jeopardizing the safety of the patient as well as the nurse. REFERENCES CMS releases long-awaited definition of 'meaningful use' of ... (n.d.). Retrieved from Gambell, M. (2012). Industry leaders’ address today’s biggest challenges. legal and regulatory issues.

Decision Point 2 Essay

726 words - 3 pages Principle 1 focuses on Content Pedagogy. As stated by the Ball State University website, “The teacher understands the central concepts, tools of inquiry, and structures of the discipline(s) he or she teachers and can create learning experiences that make these aspects of subject matter meaningful for students.  FL Version - Language teachers are proficient in the language they teach. They understand language as a system, how students learn a

What Is Love Essay

592 words - 3 pages not divulge the content of this assignment or any of my work, generally or specifically, to any current or future James Madison High School students. DATE:3/31/15 You must first create an Grammarly account if you have not already done so. Please click on the link below for instructions on creating an account and how to submit the report with your assignment. What is love? Love is a very special and meaningful word to each human being. Each

Advance Information Tecnology Essay

2381 words - 10 pages the criteria for the stages of Meaningful Use. The IT Specialist is chosen for his knowledge of computer hardware and software and will be instrumental in the purchasing and setting up of the required hardware and computer trouble shooting. The IT specialist and his staff will be responsible for setting up passwords and access for all users. The Medical Director is chosen for his knowledge of the physician work flow and his experience with