This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Consider Whether Obedience Research Is Unethical

676 words - 3 pages

Consider whether obedience research is unethical

The aim of the Milgram’s experiment was to measure the willingness of study participants to obey an authority figure who instructed them to perform acts that conflicted with their personal conscience.

40 males aged between 20 and 50 years of age. They were obtained by responding to a newspaper advertisement which asked for volunteers to participate in a study of learning at Yale University. They were paid $4.50 to take part in the experiment.

Two people would be introduced (one would be a confederate) and would draw lots to see who went where, they were told one person would sit in front of a device that could shock the other person, and the other would sit in a separate room being shocked. The only form of contact was a microphone system, there was no visual contact.

The “Subject” who was sat in front of a box that would supposedly give the other person an electric shock and could shock the learner at ...view middle of the document...

The findings where shocking. All 40 of the participants obeyed up to 300 volts at which point 5 refused to continue. Four more gave one more shock before refusing; two stopped at the 330 volts level and one each at 345, 360 and 375 volts. Therefore, a total of 14 participants defied the experimenter, and 26 obeyed. Overall, 65% of the participants gave shocks up to 450 volts (obeyed) and 35% stopped sometime before 450 volts.

Orne and Holland claimed that the research lacked experimental realism, meaning that the experimental set up was not believable. They thought the participants were aware that the electric shocks were not real, thus, the research lacked internal validity. However, the participants’ stress reactions contradict this. (Orne & Holland claimed the participants were just playing along to please the experimenter - demand characteristics.) Orne & Holland also claimed that the research lacked ecological validity.

A variation of this experiment has also been carried out by Hofling. The aim was to investigate whether or not nurses would obey an order from a doctor that went against hospital regulation and was contrary to safe practice.

The study was carried out in a real hospital with real staff. An unaware nurse was phoned by an unknown doctor and asked to administer 20mg if Astrofen (non-lethal sugary drug) so that it would take affect before the doctor arrive. If the nurse obeyed she would be breaking hospital rules, she would be giving twice the maximum dose and the drug it’s self was not on the ward list for that day.

Hofling found that 21 out of 22 nurses obeyed the doctor until they were stopped by a confederate nurse. When they were asked why they obeyed, they said that a similar scenario has occurred before and that when they disobeyed doctors can get angry. This experiment has realism as it is a field experiment.

The overall findings from both experiments is that people are much more inclined to go against their moral or ethical beliefs if they are given orders by respected authority figures (Legitimate authority). They also believed that if something did go wrong they would be able to blame the authority figure in question as it was that person who gave them the order (Agentic Shift).

Other Papers Like Consider Whether Obedience Research Is Unethical

Frl 408 Term Paper

2523 words - 11 pages relationship, the agreement between these two entities, is agreed upon a mutual trust. The agent agrees to performance, accounting, loyalty obedience, and lastly notification. When it comes to obedience, agents must abide to the principal’s instructions, as long as it is legal. Obedience and loyalty can be the most difficult thing when one is dealing with an unethical person. For example, (Parkinson, 2006) puts a situation like this, “A producer of

Unethical Business Research Paper

777 words - 4 pages Unethical Business Research Conduct There are several reasons a company can be found guilty of an unethical/illegal crime. Whether they were asking inappropriate questions; skewing research results; failing to maintain participants’ confidential information; using participant information for unintended purposes such as selling goods or services. The list could continue through a long dissertation. On Monday, July 2, 2012 an unprecedented

Ethical Decision Making and Ethical Leadership

3810 words - 16 pages behavior for organizational members, the ethical culture reflects whether the firm also has an ethical conscience. Ethical is a function of many factors, including corporate policies on ethics, top managements leadership on ethical issues, the influence of coworkers, and the opportunity for unethical behavior. Obedience to authority is another aspect of the influence that significant others can exercise. Obedience to authority helps to explain

Unethicial Behaviors

642 words - 3 pages Unethical Research Research is a powerful tool because what it reveals. The gathering and storing research in most cases may not have dire consequences in our personal lives other than making a bad decision and who among us haven’t made one of those before, but in the business word gathering data or research information may have dire consequences like peoples livelihood. As in the article from Cheryl Lozano-Whitten, regarding Eron and

Business Research Process

802 words - 4 pages is not a new idea. As the countries economy grows the population begins to see more unethical results. The way this is done is my taking the information that is given about certain product or service and misrepresenting it make it look like a great choice. As the economies begin to boom these practices are often seen more often. I would like to do my paper on the medical research practices. The organization I would like to talk about or evaluate

Paper

640 words - 3 pages art history and has in depth knowledge in different fields. In this article, Xaxx identifies four reasons why accountants engage in unethical behavior. The first reason is greed for money. The fact that accountants deal with huge sums of money may easily tempt people of a greedy nature. Accounting crimes do not involve guns and breaking into houses, and greedy people may consider it a friendly form of theft. Money is the only item that

The Impact of Ethical Leadership to Employee Performance

1772 words - 8 pages problems, which affected employee performance. Yet, ethics cannot be shaped without ethical leadership. As the result, many scholars have been doing extensive research about the impact of ethical leadership to employee performance, which become a crucial aspect of maintaining business continuity of a company. Ethics & Leadership Overview Ethics is a tool that used by society to define whether an act is acceptable or not (Malloy et al, 2003

Social Media and the Effects on Health in Adolescents Ages 10-18

541 words - 3 pages The historical cases of Humphrey’s “Tea Room” study (Sieber, 1977), Milgram’s “Obedience” study (Blass, 2007), Zimbardo’s “Prison Study” (Zimbardo, 2015) and Tuskegee study (Tuskegee University, 2015) showed the unethical research on human subjects. The studies were never reviewed by the Institutional Review Board (IRB, 2014) because it was not around at that time. Today, the consideration of ethics needs to be a critical part of the

Obedience to Authority

1583 words - 7 pages authority figures and that he/she would never actually follow through with unethical orders (Blass, 2002). Influential Research on Obedience to Authority Intrigued by the current situation at the time and also seeking answers, Milgram decided to investigate just how far a person would be willing to go if they were given orders by an individual in an authoritative role (Slater, 2004). According to Slater (2004), Milgram speculated that people

Bers

2106 words - 9 pages organizations. This shows, workplace bullying always happened in organizations whether organizations is for-profit, non-profit, not-for-profit, and even in government. Currently, workplace bullying becomes unidentified because of circumstances as perspective of managerial attributes, (Namie & Namie 2003). 1.2 Research Questions The research questions for this article stated as below: * How unethical behavior and workplace bullying related

Ethics in Psychological

1100 words - 5 pages account ethical situations a researcher should take into consideration the risk/benefit ratio.”The risk/benefit ratio is a subjective evaluation of the risk to a research participant relative to the benefit both to the individual and to society of the results of the proposed research” (Shaughnessy, Zechmeister,& Zechmeister,pg. 514, 2009). Psychologists use the APA guide of ethics to help them decide whether an experiment is ethical, this

Related Essays

Business Research Ethics Essay

794 words - 4 pages Business Research Ethics RES 351 September 8th, 2014 Business Research Ethics Occasionally, ethics may fall between the cracks. When ethics are not considered with the utmost importance, there are a variety of consequences an organization may suffer. Organizations must make sure that they adhere to the most paramount level of ethics in every aspect of business. It is important to consider how important ethics are to business research

Ethics Essay

4350 words - 18 pages Zimbardo Prison Experiment B. Roles at Work C. Conflicting Roles can Lead to Unethical Behavior D. Roles Can Also Support Ethical Behavior E. Practical Advice for Managers: Roles VII. People Do What They are Told A. The Milgram Experiments B. Obedience to Authority at Work C. Practical Advice for Managers: Obedience to Authority VIII. Responsibility Is Diffused in Organizations A

Milgram Study Essay

808 words - 4 pages beings. This is what Stanley Milgram, a psychologist in the 1960s, wanted to find out through experiments. As a trainee police officer, no doubt you would never consider performing ‘nefarious actions’. However, you could be in a position where members of staff in authority, give you an order, the content of which, you believe to be unethical and wrong. This correlates to the Nazi question; did they murder six million Jews because they chose to

Conformity And Obiedence In Public Services

2155 words - 9 pages Uniformed Public services respect for people of higher ranks is expected all the time whether or not there is a feeling of personal respect. Commanders and those who are team leaders can show respect to sub-ordinates by congratulating people for the work they have done, by listening to their concerns, by appraising them accordingly, or by doing what is right in order to advance their careers. Obedience is an essential part of employment in the public