This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compensation V. Ethical Models Essay

1154 words - 5 pages

Compensation Versus Ethical Models

Background
When analyzing the executive compensation the way it should be justified, many aspects must be established. First, as Plato suggested for an ideal society these individuals were not receiving four times the number of their lowliest employee. With their high amounts of compensation that was received, it can now be understood as to why many of these companies drove our economy into what it has become today. Although I do not agree with the moral decision that agreed upon by the government with the bailout plan for these companies, it will be discussed different thought processes that could have taken place to recompense the leaders ...view middle of the document...

“According to the principle of utilitarianism, the right way to behave in a given situation is to choose the alternative that is likely to produce the greatest overall good” (Halbert & Ingulli, 2012). With such wording written, an individual can make a statement that to ascertain an executive’s compensation salary it would be best to see how profitable they are for the business. When this analysis were to be managed, the stakeholders would want to see both the short-term and the long-term benefits of the decision they would be making. If they were truly beneficial with the work that would be accomplished by the prospectus candidate, then they would receive a high salary than those that less proficient.

Deontology Ethics
When looking to use the deontology model of ethics for compensation then we need to ask the question if everyone in the world behaved the same way? “In contrast to utilitarian concern with consequences, and with maximizing social welfare, deontological ethics is marked by steadfastness to universal principles – for example, respect for life, fairness, telling the truth, keeping promises, - no matter the consequences” (Halbert & Ingulli, 2012). Unfortunately, this is not the case in today’s business world. Not all employees get paid the same amount of money for the same amount of work done in the office. With the design being used in compensation aspect every individual should get paid the same amount of money. There seems to be no ethical justification for this process to be used for compensation of executives.

Virtue Ethics
The use of the virtue ethics model gives us the basis of compensation of an individual’s character. This shifts focus from what a person should do to who the person is. “Virtue ethics, on the other hand, directs our attention to what human beings are capable of being on how the can cultivate the habits of good character that will naturally lead them to their fullest potential” (Halbert & Ingulli, 2012). If this were to be used with the compensation model for executive, then you have a potential problem for those that have character flaws. There can always be more that one right answer that can cause a moral dilemma when facing a business decision, and if the executive make the wrong choice should they be punished.

Ethic of Care
Using the model of ethic of care for making compensation decisions, we first have to look at the connections between the people making them. ...

Other Papers Like Compensation V. Ethical Models

Ethics in the Workplace Google Essay

2563 words - 11 pages reached in 1943. In the year 2000, Google AG joined the German government’s charitable foundation for the compensation of former forced laborers.[3] The organization’s firm stance in opposition to the Nazi’s practices was an early indication of Google’s high ethical standards relevant to human rights. The Google Group is part of the Chemicals Industry which, as an industry, has historically always been more highly regulated than others. Hence

Ceo Compensation Essay

5460 words - 22 pages percentage of that firm's total revenue; iii) policies and procedures of the advisor's firm to prevent conflicts of interest; iv) the advisor's business and personal relationships with compensation committee members; and v) whether the advisor owns stock in the company. The proposed rules also require disclosures from companies concerning their use of compensation consultants and conflicts of interest, which are intended to integrate the Dodd-Frank

Compensation Incentives

3610 words - 15 pages JOURNAL OF FINANCE .VOL. XLIII, NO. 3 .JULY 1988 people.exeter.ac.uk/maf206/baker_jensen_murphy_1988.pdf Compensation & Benefits, Compensation Systems: Design and Goals., (n.d); hrcouncil.ca › ... › HR Toolkit › Compensation & Benefits Fernandez-Araoz c., Rosmarin M., Compensation, Designing fair management reward system; THE FOCUS VOL. XIII/1(p. 62). www.egonzehnder.com/us/download/62-_Intern_II. Gerhart B. A, Minkoff H v B and Olsen R

Business Initiatives

2477 words - 10 pages , V (2013). 7 Management practices that can improve employee productivity. Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/victorlipman/2013/06/17/7-management- practices-that-can-improve-employee-productivity/ Martocchio, J.J. (2011) Strategic compensation: A human resource management approach (6th Edition).  McCord, S. (2011). City reorganization is approved. Augusta Chronicle. Retrieved from http://chronicle.augusta.com/latest-news/2011-03-30/augusta-reorganization-passes.

Tainted Milk

2536 words - 11 pages . Organization can sometimes use the presence of a code as a badge of morality. Thus, they may practice corrupt acts and believe (and convince others) that since they possess a code of ethics, they must be morally sound: good companies, after all, do good things. d. Top management serves as ethical role models – Clearly, rationalization and socialization are facilitated if top management is perceived as being unethical. Rationalization tactics receive a

International Purchasing and Supply Chain Management

4020 words - 17 pages and Global Value Chain” and “CSR perspective” have been chosen with relevant theoretical models and has been analysed critically in the context of ethical purchasing view of global apparel brands who act as buyers in apparel industries of Bangladesh. Bibliography 1. Barney, J.B. (1991), Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage, Journal of Management, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 99-120. 2. Bannet, C. (2013), Have you been good? The

Marketing

1185 words - 5 pages dollars in revenues in 2004.The company has maintained a consistent growth and built a global company providing turnkey software development. There are many businesses that succeed-the unique factor about Infosys is in just over two decades it has built a brand known for ethical standards both inside and outside in the marketplace. The hypothesis of this paper is that corporate ethics promotes and inspires competitive advantage in a burgeoning

Ethical Issues for the Integration of Religion and Spirituality in Therapy

964 words - 4 pages Ethical Issues for the Integration of Religion and Spirituality in Therapy Ethics and Standards of Professional Psychology Patricia Elias Kaplan University   Abstract Over the past ten years, new developments in the psychological treatment and assessment of clients of diverse spirituality and religiosity has occurred. These changes have prompted the need for a broader understanding of therapeutic practices related to client spirituality

Strategic Management Ideas for Your Project

1750 words - 7 pages can a manager help develop organizational norms to increase productivity? Strategic Management International Business/ Management Knowledge Management Operations Management and Logistics Innovation Management Network and Relationship Management Corporate Social Responsibility Internationalization process Knowledge challenges faced by first time CEOs Developing competitive intelligence systems of specific company The models

Tesca Works

2260 words - 10 pages also mean the accepted guidelines of behavior for groups or institutions. Ethical leadership involves promoting normatively appropriate conduct through role modeling and interpersonal relationships; leaders with ethical leadership which must be legitimate and credible ethical role models can influence employee ethical conduct (Brown, Trevino, & Harrison, 2005). Ethical Leadership behavior has been proposed to be related to positive

Sylvia Gregorio

2651 words - 11 pages ethical changes. Cost is a concern moreso now that CERD is cutting on expenses. 1.c. On introduction of gender assessment and pay audit mechanism Advantages: Increase gender integration and awareness. Eliminate practice of gender bias in the workplace. Alignment of compensation vis a vis job responsibility. Promotion of equal opportunity regardless of gender. Encourage ambitions and career advancement regardless. Disadvantages

Related Essays

Business Ethic Essay

5500 words - 22 pages ) said that the followers’ perceptions towards ethical leader are related to the characteristics and situational influences of a leader. According to social learning theory, ethical leaders must be attractive and credible role models, so that the followers could see them as ethical leaders. To enhance their attractiveness, power and status are two characteristics of models. People are always pay attention to the behaviours of leaders or those who

Ethical Leadership Essay

1216 words - 5 pages , values and beliefs of something that we believe as the right behavior. The practice of ethical leadership is increasingly popular in every modern organizations nowadays even though its started gaining momentum in the early 20th century when leaders realized the relation of ethical practices and decision making contributes to efficiency and business profitability. This realization has lead to the development of 4-V model of ethical leadership by Dr

Compensation System Essay

3882 words - 16 pages . Vision-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------0811. Mission---------------------------------------------------------------------------------0812. Corporate Objective ----------------------------------------------------------------0813. Organizational Structure--------------------------------------------------------------0914. COMPENSATION FOR TOP MID AND OPERATING LEVEL-----------------1015. Compensation

Ethnic 2011 Index Essay

3807 words - 16 pages ? Influences on an individual's decision Fig 2.5 Table 2.7 2.70 2.73 Ethical decision - making models Langenderfer and Rockness(1990) - AAA model - SEVEN steps Which Model? Page 8 of 16 SEMESTER 2 2011 CPA 118 ETHICS AND GOVERNANCE MODULE 3 GOVERNANCE CONCEPTS 3.03 Preview Introduction Objectives Teaching Materials 3.05 3.05 Part A: Overview of corporate governance Why good corporate governance matters Global imperative FOUR factors