This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Of Streetcar Named Desire The Play And The Movie

1892 words - 8 pages

Janet Ng
Professor Faunce
WRT 102
7 March 2012
Textual Analysis of A Streetcar Named Desire

Based on Tennessee William’s A Streetcar Named Desire, Elia Kazan creates an award winning movie that helps readers visualize Stanley’s primal masculinity, the inner torments of the Kowalski women and the clash of the other characters’ problems which create a chaotic mess. Using stage directions in the play, William hints that Blanche is not who she appears to be while the movie subtly sheds light on Blanche’s strange little habits that suggests a bigger issue. The movie also censors many of the main themes in Williams’ play but makes up for it by having its actors flawlessly portray the ...view middle of the document...

The difference between the movie and the play is that in the play Stella doesn’t have to avidly seek a man and that she is still immersed in her fantasy world: one where she believes Stanley is loving and innocent of raping Blanche. By showing his readers the downfall of depending on men, Tennessee Williams is sending out a clear message to women to stand up for themselves and to be independent. In contrast, the movie supports independence by having Stella stand up for her newborn baby and herself by leaving Stanley. Why the stark difference you ask? Back in the 1950s, the rape scene was considered controversial and taboo so the director Elia Kazan was forced to punish Stanley by having his wife leave him at the end of the film. Even the slight suggestion of a rape scene necessitated Stanley’s punishment. Realistically, Stella would’ve stayed with Stanley because she had no support for herself or the baby.
Blanche’s and Stella’s reliance on men and inability to support themselves are used to illustrate the subliminal pressure for women to follow society’s norms. Women without men are seen as weak, and those who break away from their rigid social classes are looked down upon. Since these social norms have been instilled into Blanche, she believes that she has to have a man fawn over her feet at all times. She realizes that she is aging and thus by engaging in sexual trysts with men, she thinks that she is still wanted and that she still has a place in society despite her current status. “After the death of Allan - intimacies with strangers was all I seemed able to fill my empty heart with...panic, that drove me from one to another, hunting for some protection.” (Williams, pg 146).
William captures the problem of distressed women in our society through the portrayal of the rape scene between Stanley and Blanche. The scene exemplifies the power struggle between the two and is a representation of the society. No matter how hard she tries, she will always lose to men. Just like no matter how much women try, it will always be a male dominated world. In the movie, the rape scene is complemented with a dramatic soundtrack and dim lights that foreshadow what will happen. Blanche’s ruin is artistically depicted through the reflection of the mirror.
Stanley is characterized as a manly character with temper issues and is constantly shown to explode in anger at Stella and Blanche whenever they step out of line. Part of this anger stems from his desire to maintain his idea of masculinity. His wife had always been obedient and under his control, but the minute this new woman comes in, he loses control of his Stella. He obviously feels threatened by her higher social class, otherwise he wouldn’t have felt the need to rape Blanche and regain alpha status in his household. A symbol of Stanley’s brutishness is shown when he walks into the house with his sweat stained shirt and proceeds to change in front of Blanche despite the fact that she was a guest. Back in...

Other Papers Like Comparison of Streetcar Named Desire the Play and the Movie

The Relationship Between Stella And Stanley In Scene 4 Of 'A Streetcar Named Desire'

967 words - 4 pages she has just taken part in something holy.Blanche fails to see the magic in what to her seems an abusive and dangerous relationship, because she has never reconciled her identity with her own profound desire. The divide is too great between her aristocratic sense of self and the "animal" urges that have at times controlled her. Blanche herself invokes the streetcar named Desire as a metaphor of what she believes Stella feels. Stella throws the metaphor back at her: "Haven't you ever ridden on that streetcar?" Blanche's answer, "It brought me here," is truer than Stella knows.

A Streetcar Named Desire Essay

919 words - 4 pages Feminist Analysis of A Streetcar Named Desire Tennessee Williams is widely considered the greatest southern playwright and some of his works include Glass Menagerie, The Rose Tattoo, and A Streetcar Named Desire. A Streetcar Named Desire was greatly influenced by events in Williams’ life. Feminism is a collection of movements and ideologies aimed at defining, establishing, and defending equal political, economic, and social rights for women

Streetcar Named Desire

1163 words - 5 pages Streetcar Named Desire Tennessee Williams's play A Streetcar Named Desire contains more within it's characters, situations, and story than appears on its surface. Joseph Krutch, author of Twentieth Century Interpretations of A Streetcar Named Desire wrote, “The authors perceptions remain subtle and delicate… The final impression left is, surprisingly enough not of sensationalism but of subtlety” (38.) As in many of Williams's plays deeper

A Streetcar Named Desire

933 words - 4 pages In A Streetcar Named Desire, Tennessee Williams focuses on the past and present to explore the themes of desire, reality and illusion. He uses these themes effectively by reflecting on his genuine love for the Deep South in the USA. In Williams’ world of the 1940s the Old South was a broken and damaged place but it still had charm. Women in the Old South were expected to be both passive and chaste as reflected in the characters of Blanche and

Streetcar Named Desire

823 words - 4 pages truth and shadows representing the lies and dreams. Light and shadows could also represent the present and the past. Many characters, such as Stanley, Mitch and Stella all in the light as they are living in the present, whereas Blanche hides in the shadows as she yearns to be young again. Music and sound effects are of great importance in adding to the main ideas of a Streetcar Named Desire. Music is used as dramatic irony to establish the mood

"A Streetcar Named Desire" By Tennessee Williams. A Reaction, Assessment Of Literary Value, Biography Of The Author, And Literary Critism

3102 words - 13 pages Tennessee Williams's play A Streetcar Named Desire contains more within it's characters, situations, and story than appears on its surface. As in many of Williams's plays, there is much use of symbolism and interesting characters in order to draw in and involve the audience. The plot of A Streetcar Named Desire alone does not captivate the audience. It is Williams's brilliant and intriguing characters that make the reader truly understand the

Secrets and Lies- a Streetcar Named Desire

1208 words - 5 pages an appearance of dependence on men using secrets and lies. In ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’, Tennessee Williams reveals that the world has become a place in which the ruthless reigns and the estranged suffer. Stanley symbolizes aspect of Brutality in the play, as being described in Blanche’s brutes speech, ‘maybe he will strike you or maybe grunt and kiss you… there has been some progress… such things as poetry and music… don't hang back

Compare Family Grudges and Violence in 'the Homecoming' and 'a Streetcar Named Desire'

998 words - 4 pages “diseased”. This is not what the audience would have expected, which adds to the shock impact of the violence. ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’ is a work of social realism. It is set in the American Deep South in the 1940’s. The play uses expressionism and plastic theatre. It follows the story of the protagonist Blanche, who is a fallen woman in society’s eyes. Blanche seeks protection and security in New Orleans with her sister Stella and her husband

Streetcar Named Desire - Character Analysis

2822 words - 12 pages Colin Ma Candace Waid English 10 28 May 2013 Character Analysis in A Streetcar Named Desire: Tennessee William's Comparison of American Societies Tennessee Williams' play A Streetcar Named Desire is a play concerning Stanley and Stella Kowalski, and Stella's sister Blanche Dubois. Stella and Stanley are a happily married couple who live in New Orleans. However, once Stella's sister Blanche comes to stay with them she “spoils the routine

Streetcar Named Desire Adaption Analysis

1515 words - 7 pages "In A Streetcar Named Desire, Williams seeks to portray the nature and effects of sexuality." How effectively does the film capture this central concern? Elia Kazan’s 1951 film adaptation of Tennessee William’s 1947 play, A Streetcar Named Desire was forced to dilute the primary concern of sexuality to make it more suitable for a broader American audience. Due to anticipated and unanticipated interjections of the conservative Production

Soundeffects in a Streetcar Named Desire

1265 words - 6 pages eetcar Eilis Mc Colgan 27/11/2011 A Streetcar Named Desire Music and Sound Effects A Streetcar Named Desire is hugely dependant on the effects of music; the melody is interlinked with the stage directions, character speeches and the most dramatic scenes. i.e. music plays the role of a mood setter and as a source of characterization. There is two recurring pieces of music during the play, The Blue piano and the Varsouviana polka. The

Related Essays

Streetcar Named Desire And Presence Of Superego

1251 words - 6 pages . Unfortunately for her, Stanley, who lives by the more powerful element of the id, dominates over her and destroys her by the end. The predominating conflict of flesh and spirit modifies and includes all the other conflicts - sociological, psychological, moral, cultural - which A Streetcar Named Desire presents… By pitting… the weakness of Blanche against the insensitive stolidity of Stanley, her cultural pretensions against his penis-status

Symbolisms In The Streetcar Named Desire

980 words - 4 pages Symbolisms in “A Streetcar Named Desire” Sometimes, people are consumed by what they once accomplished and what they once called their own. What a person did in their past greatly affects who they are today. In the play “A Streetcar Named Desire”, Tenessee Williams uses different symbols to reveal different meanings of lines and passages. Williams intentionally hid the real meaning of these lines and passages using symbols to intrigue the

A Streetcar Named Desire The Conflict Between Stanley And Blanche

1872 words - 8 pages and the desire to remove her influence over Stella drives him to form a cruel plan to get rid of her. When he enters and Stella rushes over to greet him, he knows he has won part of the battle, Stella trusts him over Blanche and this proves to him that he is loved more. This scene enhances the understanding of the play as a whole as it shows us what drives Stanley to bring Blanche’s downfall in a cruel manner whereas previously, in Scene two, it

Comparison And Contrast Of The Ways Of Characterization Used By The Two Playwrights In Arthur Miller's "The Crucible" And Tennessee Williams' "Streetcar Named Desire"

535 words - 3 pages Both Arthur Miller's "The Crucible" and Tennessee Williams' "Streetcar Named Desire" extract has two characters in each scene. One of them is usually one of the main characters of the stories: Mr. Proctor in the Crucible extract and Blanche DuBois from the scene of Streetcar Named Desire. Both of them had a serious conversation with their partner. There are lot of stage directions in both therefore far more indirect characterization can be found