Comparison Of Setting Essay

979 words - 4 pages

Fiction Essay: Comparison of Setting
ENGL 100
Jonathan Jones
February 2, 2015

Thesis – Can two completely different stories have similarities in their setting and how the setting was used to support the story?
I. Introduction – YGB and The Destructors took place during different time periods and in completely different locations. (Young Goodman Brown (YGB) – Nathanial Hawthorne published 1835, setting 17th century. The Destructors – Graham Greene published 1954 – setting mid 1950s)
a. Different time period
b. Different country
c. Different time of day
II. Why does the setting matter?
d. Include character impact.
e. The setting in both ...view middle of the document...

A short story tends to leave much interpretation to the reader, requiring analysis of the author, theme, setting, and possible morals embedded in the story.
The stories “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathanial Hawthorne and “The Destructors” by Graham Green are both popular short stories written by influential authors. “Young Goodman Brown” takes place during the seventeenth century in Salem Village, Massachusetts. Young Goodman Brown is a newly married young man that leaves his home at night to walk through the forest with devious intent. The entire story takes place over a few hour time span with the exception of the conclusion that summarizes the future. “The Destructors” takes place in England in the mid-1950s, after WWII and follows a gang of young boys over the course of several days. This story happens during the day, as many of the characters are young boys that are required to be home at a certain time.
The setting of a story can validate or create credibility. In the cases of “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Destructors” the setting makes both stories believable. “Young Goodman Brown” takes place in Salem Village during the time of the Salem Witch Trials. If the story took place in another time period or another location, it would take away from the credibility. The forest in the story symbolizes darkness and further develops the believability. “The Destructors” takes place in London after WWII. The location, Europe and London specifically, make this story believable. Without a post war zone setting, the story would only signify naughty children acting out. Due to the impact the war has on the area, the story introduces symbolism of society. The house survived 200 years of aging, and later bombings, while nothing else in the neighborhood survived. The history behind this house offers credibility to the story by offering an unstated explanation of the plot....

Other Papers Like Comparison of Setting

In Training, By Helen Lawson Essay

730 words - 3 pages Helen Lawson uses a number of sound and picture devices in the poem "In Training". How do they help us to enhance her description of the swimmer and the river?We have all seen a swimmer racing at all sports competition before, "In Training", by Helen Lawson brings back the thoughts in our memory but moves the background setting to a calm, smooth river in the morning. The poem uses a series of sound and picture devices to help us imagine the

The Use of Narratives and Its Effect on Stories

787 words - 4 pages The Use of Narratives and Its Effect on Stories The use of narrative view are important for an author. It determines how the reader interpret the story and ultimately understanding the theme. In the work of “Hills Like White Elephant” Ernest Hemingway uses third person objective point of view to present the conflict of a young couple over the difficult decision of whether to have an abortion. In comparison to Hemingway’s work, “Great Falls

A Nation Should Require All of Its Students to Study the Same National Curriculum Until They Go to College

546 words - 3 pages A nation should require all of its students to study the same national curriculum until they go to college Should a nation require all of its students to study the same national curriculum until they go to college? In my opinion, despite some shortcomings, the benefit of setting consistent curriculum across the country outweighs its drawbacks. Admittedly, requiring its students to study the same national curriculum is an important strategy to

Compare 3 Airlines

1236 words - 5 pages Task 1: Compare and analyze the products and services of these airlines are now offering for all classes in this route. Selected Flight Route: | Selected Airlines: | * Hong Kong * Shanghai | * Spring Airlines (春秋航空) * Juneyao Airlines (吉祥航空) * Dragonair (港龍航空) | Comparison Table: | Product or Services | Spring Airlines | Juneyao Airlines | Dragonair | Class Offering | Economy | Economy Business | Economy

Analysis of a Farewell to Arms Chapter One

636 words - 3 pages Elia Abou Rached Literature II Essay Professor Curtis Brown Chapter one of A Farewell to Arms opens with a descriptive overview of the setting the narrator is in, but the author doesn’t give away any information neither about the location of the battle nor about the identity of the narrator. Although the author is writing about war, he doesn’t focus on the gore or glory aspect of it. The description is detached and almost journalistic

Comparison Between Different Types of Education

924 words - 4 pages their own time. Classroom courses boast face-to face-interactions, which is hard to replicate in the online classroom setting. Although online learning can be a great enhancement to in-class learning, it should not replace the classroom experience due to the interaction between the professor and the student, development of peer relationships, and the effectiveness of the in-class learning setting. Before the two types of courses can be compared


5172 words - 21 pages differentiation. B) barriers to entry. C) no barriers to entry. D) downward-sloping demand curves facing the firm. Answer: B Diff: 1 Topic: Market Structures 4) Regardless of market structure, all firms A) consider the actions of rivals. B) maximize profit by setting marginal revenue equal to marginal cost. C) produce a differentiated product. D) have the ability to set price. Answer: B Diff: 1

Esstinal Litraray Terms

661 words - 3 pages character in a literary work Rhyme – repetition of similar or identical sounds: “look and crook” Rhyme Scheme – pattern of rhyme among lines of poetry [denoted using letters, as in ABAB CDCD EE] Setting- The time and place of a literary work Simile – a direct comparison of dissimilar objects, usually using like or as: “I wandered lonely as a cloud” Soliloquy - a dramatic device in which a character is alone and speaks his or

Rhetorical Analysis

908 words - 4 pages that support anti-violence and gun control, Michael Moore did everything he could to fuel the fire of those that already supported him. In many instances he went too far over the top. For example, the most touching part of the film I referred to earlier of the father speaking against guns to an anti- gun and violence rally. This was overshadowed by the direct comparison to a similar setting of Charleton Heston, an avid gun supporter and

Fiction Essay

1051 words - 5 pages unjust. These stories bring a lot of comparisons such as the setting of the stories, but mostly there are contrasts such as the symbolism within the stories and the meaning each author put behind their stories. Outline I. Introduction - A. Relates to real life situations B. Can be a lesson learner II. Comparison - Setting A. Takes place within a community B. Lovely scenery C. Expresses warm feelings

Memory Management Comparison

696 words - 3 pages Memory Management Comparison Christopher Liebenrood POS/355 March 24, 2014 Chris Miserendino Memory Management Comparison While researching the differences between the memory management systems of Windows and Linux operating systems there was not many differences except a small few. To start the memory management system is one of the most vital parts of the system. It manages and organizes the structure of (RAM) Random Access Memory as

Related Essays

The Lottery Versus Destructors Essay

981 words - 4 pages Fiction Essay Thesis and Outline ENGL 102-B06 LUO 201340 Fall 2013 Kevin Prohaska ID# 25391876 Writing style used: MLA Kevin Prohaska Dr. Suzanne Penner 201340 Fall 2013 ENGL 102-B06 LUO 20 August 2013 Comparison of the Lottery and the Destructors: Settings * Compare the settings of each story to each other. * Could the settings have been changed and the punch of the story still be there? * The symbolism of the

Allstate Goal Process Essay

618 words - 3 pages Allstate’s Goal Setting Process Effective Or Not? Michael Young Strayer University Discuss the following related to Allstate Insurance company using the goal setting process, evaluate Allstate’s goal setting process, and determine whether it is effective or not. Allstate is one of the largest insurance companies in the country, and has a dominant share of the insurance market. A great

The Harsh Realities Of Life Essay

1223 words - 5 pages day that sets a very serene and peaceful tone. Flowers are blooming and the excitement of summer is in the air. It makes us want to jump right into the village and make it our home. The last comparison is to whether the setting creates different expectations to what actually occurs. In the Most Dangerous Game, we can only wonder what lies ahead with the background that the author gives us to work with. He kind of sets us into a mind frame of

Contrast Between Two Stories Essay

668 words - 3 pages understand.Taking place in 17th century Puritan New England, "Young Goodman Brown's" setting is sapless in comparison to the mystical and enthralling island of "The Most Dangerous Game." In "The Most Dangerous Game" author Richard Connell takes time to describe the island on which Rainsford becomes trapped. "A large island…rather a mystery…the old charts call it "Ship-Trap Island"…rocky shore… dense jungle came down to the