This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Electoral Processes In Uk Essay

1038 words - 5 pages

Electoral Systems in the UK

There are two main types of electoral system in the UK:
First Past the Post (FPTP) & Proportional Representation (PR)

First Past the Post (FPTP);

FPTP is the voting system used for the election of MPs to 'seats' in the UK Parliament. It is a system in which the 'winner takes all' and usually gives a clear majority both at constituency and national level. This means that a candidate in a constituency only needs one more vote than the nearest rival to win the seat. Similarly, political parties only need to win one more seat in the House of Commons to have a majority.

Advantages of FPTP;

There is very little chance of extremist parties being ...view middle of the document...

This was shown in the 1983 general election when the Liberal/SDP Alliance won 25.4% of the vote and gained 23 seats while the Labour Party won 27.7% of the vote and gained 209 seats.

FPTP also encourages tactical (unfair) voting. This means voting for a party, other than your preferred party, to prevent another party from being elected. An example of this would be when a Labour supporter in a marginal Liberal/ Conservative seat votes Liberal Democrat in order to keep the Conservatives from winning.

Another disadvantage of FPTP can occur in marginal constituencies, where voters tend to change their party loyalty from election to election, and among 'floating' or 'swing' voters, who have no firm party loyalty. The outcome of an election can be decided on the voting patterns in these situations, even although the constituents may number only a tiny proportion of the electorate.

Proportional Representation (PR)
There is a number of systems that use PR such as the Single Transferable Vote (STV) (the Regional and National Lists) and the Alternative Vote. There is a third system that combines these two, known as the Additional Member System (AMS) or the hybrid or top-up system. The AMS system is presently used in elections for the Scottish Parliament, where voters can vote for single candidates in their constituencies but also for candidates from regional 'lists' put forward by each party. If there is a discrepancy between the percentage of seats the party has won and the percentage of votes cast, the seats are 'topped up' from the regional list.

Advantages of PR;
In PR systems there are no wasted votes in elections. Every vote is
counted and so there is no need for tactical voting. As a result,
there is a far greater degree of proportionality; the number of seats
more accurately reflects the number of votes cast for each party.

The number of constituency seats won under the First Past the Post-election and the number won under the Additional Member System in Scotland in 1999 were:
Party Constituency Seats Regional or ‘List’ Seats Total
...

Other Papers Like Comparing Electoral Processes in Uk

Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Has Not Gone Far Enough. Discuss

1093 words - 5 pages be removed in Parliament as Parliament remains sovereign. Although proportional representation electoral systems have been adopted for use in in the Scottish Parliament, devolved assemblies and Local Mayoral Elections, electoral reform has been argued to have not gone far enough in the UK. The sometimes-deemed ‘undemocratic’ First Past the Post system is still in use for general elections. A referendum on electoral reform in May 2011 was carried

Referendums Essay

655 words - 3 pages Firstly, referendums have been held to prevent the internal collapse of political parties. This refers to situations in which a political party is divided over a political issue, and the lack of consensus jeopardises the stability of the party. Failure to reach a consensus may cause revolts amongst back-bencher's, rendering party whips redundant. This can seriously danger the electoral prospects of the party, as publicly divided parties causes

To What Extent Is the Uk a Two Party System

772 words - 4 pages Scottish by-election were the Scottish National Party and Labour, so although it shows a two party system it is a massive achievement that SNP were main contenders in the election. Labour did however win the election so the UK as a whole remains a two party system. Since 1997 the use of proportional electoral systems for new bodies has helped to improve the representation of minor party’s. The two party systems is maintained by first-past-the

Uk Election Process

1651 words - 7 pages cross on a ballot slip next to the name of the candidate you wish to vote for. First Past the Post (FPTP) The British electoral system is based on the FPTP system. This system is very clear-cut and definitive, the candidate with the highest number of votes in a constituency wins. In order to vote in a FPTP system you simply mark a cross (X) next to the name of the candidate you are choosing. Alternative Vote (AV) Voters must rank the candidates

Politics Essay

2413 words - 10 pages the internet and social media | * Too many votes = voter fatigue – may hinder legitimacy and turnout | * May get people more involved in the political processes | * Tabloid may reduce the rational arguments and lead to emotional appeals | Stengths of UK democracy: Political institutions | Political processes | Political participation | * Strong representation of individuals and constituencies by MPs | * Elecetions are

Should Fptp Be Reformed?

1485 words - 6 pages Should the Electoral system used in general elections in the UK be reformed? The election system that we currently have in the UK is a lot like marmite, you either love it or you hate it… There are many different arguments for and against this system, however people forget that within getting rid of the First Past the Post system, you will then need to then replace it. This then poses the vital question of which is the best fitting system and

Management Control

1164 words - 5 pages performance of the total organization, including its employees, production and other processes and sub systems like departments and projects. Performance appraisal gives opportunity to both employer and employee to communicate their common goals and to assess how well these are achieved. Operations management Operation management is the process of specifying a performance standard by comparing to a familiar standard, monitoring and measuring

Has Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Gone Too Far?

1577 words - 7 pages Has constitutional reform in the UK gone too far since 1997? Due to the uncodified nature of the UK constitution it is organic and the lack of higher law enables constitutional reforms to occur far quicker and with greater ease than seen in other countries, such as the USA. A constitutional reform is a political change in the constitution. There are varying bodies of opinion on the extent of constitutional reforms that are currently required

Benchmarking

1723 words - 7 pages understand your own processes and establish perform levels. 2. Identify Comparative Companies. This can be undertaken through organisations such as the American Productivity and Quality Centre (www.apqc.org) who offer a brokerage service or for the public sector organisations could contact the Public Sector Benchmarking Service (www.benchmarking.gov.uk) run by Customs and Excise in the UK. Also various award winning companies can be approached

Study of Goverment Systems

1004 words - 5 pages appoint or recommend for appointment one of its members to be the chief executive. 3. What are the major characteristics of a democratic state? In the US, these are separate. Congress is the Legislative Branch passes legislation and the Executive Branch (consisting of the President and the Departments) will oversee its implementation. In the UK, the Departments are under direct control of the MPs (Members of Parliament). The difference is

Elections

722 words - 3 pages commons and influencing bills. In conclusion First Past The Post has a lot of advantages that outweigh its disadvantages as although it doesn't always give a proportional outcome, but it is the easiest method and is the easiest and most efficient to understand also the public seem to like as the referendum was defeated by a large majority showing the UK is happy with the current electoral system and it also provides a clear and strong constituency link which is an important feature for a democracy.

Related Essays

An Essay I Did In Year 8 (Uk) Comparing "Glasgow Sonnet" And "Westminster Bridge"

593 words - 3 pages to collect the rubbish. The poet describes Glasgow as having puddles with "hackles" on them. It says in the poem "hackles on puddles rise". The meaning suggested is that the wind (again) is making the puddles ripple. This means that there is a bitter wind blowing around Glasgow. A powerful image is created when the poet describes how the mattresses puff up. "Old mattresses puff up briefly and subside". This suggests again that the wind is blowing

International Relationals Essay

2994 words - 12 pages European Government and Politics GV 2218 Continuous Assessment 2 Name: Shane O Callaghan Student Number: 109819851 Course: BCOM2 Assess the merits of the political reform process underway in the UK. You should examine the proposed changes under a number of headings including but not limited to the electoral system, the House of Lords, and open government. You must discuss why potential reform should take place, its observable implications and

Comparing The Political Systems Of Uk And Morocco

1203 words - 5 pages Comparing UK’s and Morocco’s Politics I. Introduction The United Kingdom is one of the most developed countries in the world. Many historical reasons are behind the success of this latter country; but the reason that has a special importance in my opinion is the industrial revolution. Leading the global movement of industrialization made the UK today a prosperous country. Citizens enjoy their civil liberties according to the Human Rights

‘Despite Several Attempts To Regulate Campaign Finance, Money Increasingly Dominates The U.S. Electoral Process And Is The Main Factor Contributing To A Candidates Success’ Discuss

1304 words - 6 pages candidate runs but rather the expenditure limits. This suggests that money increasingly dominates the US electoral process and is the main factor in contributing to a candidate’s success because Congress trying to limit indicates its influence and dominance. In the UK, there is a strict campaign finance rule, which also compliments the idea that it is a dominant factor. Another argument agrees that money increasingly dominates the US