Comparing Austrian And Post Keynesian Criticisms Of The Neoclassical View Of Competition

2336 words - 10 pages

The competitive process is fundamental in economics, although it is extremely difficult to define under a universal definition due to the various views laid down by different theories. While the standard theory concentrates on market structure and strategic behaviour, the Austrian School focuses on market dynamics and entrepreneurship whilst the post- Keynesian school directs its attention to the areas surrounding dominant firms and administered prices. This essay will attempt to compare and contrast Austrian and post-Keynesian criticism of the standard neoclassical view of the competitive process.
‘The neoclassical theory of the firm considers four main theoretical market structures: ...view middle of the document...

Monopoly is a market structure with a single firm, producing a unique product, which is protected from competition by entry barriers. Monopolistic competition is another market structure where a large number of firms produce similar products with free entry to the market, falling between perfect competition and monopoly. Oligopoly is a market structure with a small number of firms, with products either identical or differentiated, with barriers to entry with firms recognising their interdependence.
In Addition to the Austrian and neoclassical schools, another critic of the standard theory is post-Keynesian theory, interpreted from the work of John Maynard Keynes, becoming prominent in the 1960’s. Post- Keynesianism is related with uncertainty to macroeconomic problems. In the post-Keynesian theory, oligopoly is seen as the regular state of affairs in the majority of markets, where firms compete on dominance.
In neoclassical theory, the key notion of competitive markets involving price-taking firms is the basic conception of competitiveness, basing competition on the idea that consumers are able to maximize utility and firms can maximize their profits. There is full and relevant information, allowing people to act independently. In the market process firms produce as efficiently as the current state of technology allows at the equilibrium point where price equals marginal cost, allowing for normal profit in the long run. (Sawyer, 1990)
The Austrian school of thought has strong criticisms against the neoclassical price theory. Kirzner (1973) argued that ‘the focus of attention, on the task of price theory, is thus on the values of the price and quantity variables, and in particular on the set of values consistent with equilibrium conditions.’ (Kirzner, 1973, p. 5.) Price theory is fundamental in standard theory, involving, ‘a market system the activities of market participants insist of choosing the quantities and qualities of commodities and factors to be bought and sold and the prices at which these transactions are to be carried out.’ (Kirzner, 1973, p. 4.) This describes the approach of the neoclassical school with examines the associated pattern of equilibrium price, cost and output.
The Austrian school of thought bases its ideology on entrepreneurial rivalry. The Austrian school criticises the neoclassical view on price theory and argues that ‘price theory helps understand how the decisions of individual participants in the market interact to generate the market forces which compete changes in prices, in output, and in methods of production and the allocation of resources.’ (Kirzner, 1973, p. 6.) Kirzner (1973, p. 6.) goes on to say that ‘the efficiency of the price system, does not depend upon the optimality of the resource allocation pattern at equilibrium; rather, it depends on the degree of success with which market forces can be relied upon to generate spontaneous corrections in the allocation patterns prevailing at times of...

Other Papers Like Comparing Austrian And Post-Keynesian Criticisms Of The Neoclassical View Of Competition

What Were the Criticisms That the Humanists Made of the Catholic Church?

965 words - 4 pages What were the criticisms that the humanists made of the Catholic Church? The Catholic Church faced many criticisms from the humanists; the humanists were a group of intellectuals who supported the reform of the church, but did not propose new policies but rather a change to improve he intellectual and moral standards of the clergy. Despite affecting the church and the faith in the church there was not much impact on the ordinary people they

The Election of President Obama and Post Racialism

865 words - 4 pages to what African Americans had to offer largely in part to the post civil war era whereby African Americans were progressive and they were interested in educating themselves after the end of slavery. Another event that moved us closer to the election of an African American President was the initiatives of Reverend Jesse Jackson who saw that opportunity to galvanize African American voters with the election of Harold Washington who was Chicago’s

The View Of Self

1507 words - 7 pages The View of Self The view of the 'self' and the theory of personal identity are one of the most interesting topics in the world of philosophy. It attempts to answer the question as to what makes the person now the same person that existed a year (or any period of time) ago. The world is constantly evolving and becoming more

Dynamics of Platform Competition: Exploring the Role of Installed Base, Platform Quality and Consumer Expectations

1754 words - 8 pages externalities, and explains the role of installed base and consumer expectations for products in the network market. The section then goes on to apply these concepts to platform markets to understand platform competition and how using the concept of critical mass a platform rises to dominance. Section 3 discusses some key business strategies applicable to platform markets. Section 4 concludes the analysis by extending a few strategy proposals as to

'Evaluating Utilitarianism' - What Are The Main Features Of Utilitarianism As An Ethical Theory? Examine And Consider Criticisms That Have Been Made Against Utilitarianism

2266 words - 10 pages What are the main features of Utilitarianism as an ethical theory? (10 marks)Examine and consider criticisms that have been made against Utilitarianism. (10 marks)Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that pivots around the belief that morality should be judged by consequence and the way in which an action can be deemed moral or immoral, depends upon the number to which it brings the greatest happiness. A decision can be defined as ethically

Which Of The Two Major Approaches To Economic Policy (Keynesian Or Classical) Will Lead The Usa Out Of The Economic Crisis Faster?

933 words - 4 pages unemployed labor in the United States. The unemployment rate as of September 19, 2011 exceeds the 10% mark. The other sides of the critical economic situation include high levels of inflation and household debt and the following decrease in purchasing power of the population. The governmental bodies usually exploit one of the two major approaches to Economic policy. These include the Classical and the Keynesian approaches. The Classical

From Protection To Competition – The Deregulation Of The Airline Industry

1963 words - 8 pages started and failed. Another financial crisis in the early 1990s led the industry to develop complex holding structures, race to create global seamless service through a network of strategic alliances and expand non airline and/or discrete services.Serveral studies suggested that real prices fell faster under regulation than they did in the post-deregulation period. Moreover, the deregulation did not benefit all consumers in terms of level and

Effects Of Quality Management On Domestic And Global Competition

1669 words - 7 pages release with the view of selling or competing internationally. Global marketing is important for products and services of those companies, which have worldwide demand, like food, automobile, or cosmetic companies. In such market the company will have competitiveness in the local market but also in the international market and to ensure longer competition the company needs to maintain quality of product or service by working on totally quality

A Farewell to Arms Within the Critical Framework of Feminism and the Principles of Post Structuralism

3292 words - 14 pages This essay is an attempt to examine A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway, within the critical theoretical framework of Chris Weedon’s essay, ‘Feminism and the Principles of Post Structuralism’. At the heart of feminist post structuralism lies the theory of post structuralism itself. The theory offers a way to study the conditions of how knowledge is produced. To understand an object it is necessary to study both the object and the systems

Effects of Quality Management on Domestic and Global Competition Paper

829 words - 4 pages Total Quality Pioneers Luz Maria Maysonet-Román University of Phoenix MGT/449 Quality Management and Productivty Rebeca Rodríguez-Canales 6 de febrero de 2012 Total Quality Pioneers La calidad es importante, independientemente del producto o servicio. Muchas veces las empresas se centran en los beneficios en lugar de calidad para satisfacer a las partes interesadas. La calidad es tan importante como las ganancias cuando se trata

Christian View of the World

1551 words - 7 pages "The purpose of developing a Christian view of the world is not merely to evaluate and judge the world, but to change it," (Boa, 2004). Having a Christian worldview is hard enough in American but add in the entire world and it can be a little trickier. Thinking Christianly has a major impact on how someone would do business overseas, in a global economy. When it comes to a Christian worldview in a global economy there are numerous issues that

Related Essays

Abuse Of Keynesian Economics Essay

5589 words - 23 pages to increasingly ignore those guidelines over the years, and governments now are boosting economies through government expenditure, even when they are not stuck in a downward spiral, and there are no authorities to stop them from continuing their exploits. Robert Skidelsky is famous for his understanding of Keynesian economics, and, in an interview, he was asked if he believed Keynes would support how his policies are being used in the post

The Cost Of Competition Essay

1618 words - 7 pages Microeconomic Assignment | The cost of Competition | Case Analysis | Justine Liu MBA Candidate at TiasNimbas Business School | * Explain how between January and September 1997 the game changed compared to that which had existed prior to January 1997. Prior to January 1997, there were only two big players in the market of flights between Turin in Italy and Innsbruck in Austria. These two players are Air Turin and Innsbruck

A Study Of The Life And Career Of Lord Alfred Tennyson And Selected Criticisms Of His Works

1904 words - 8 pages A Study Of The Life And Career Of Lord Alfred Tennyson And Selected Criticism Of His Works       Whether a person likes or dislikes the works of Lord Alfred Tennyson, most would agree that he was one of the most influential writers of his time period. Tennyson grew up in a wealthy family never wanting for anything. English author often regarded as the chief representative of the Victorian age in poetry. Tennyson

Discuss The View That Monopoly Power Is The Natural Result For Firms Who ‘Win The Game’ Of Competition?

2761 words - 12 pages Discuss the view that monopoly power is the natural result for firms who ‘win the game’ of competition? Monopoly power or market power is the ability for a business to earn high levels of profit by being able to choose their pricing strategies in their market and being able to raise to what they want in the same market and don’t have to worry about to losing costumers if they have true monopoly power then price still shouldn’t effect