Compare Carbon Taxes With Emission Trading Schemes As Government Policy Tools

1594 words - 7 pages

Compare carbon taxes with emission trading schemes as government policy tools.

Introduction

Why do we need environmental control

Over the last century and a bit the world have added 40% more CO2 to the Earth’s atmosphere. Every year the World collectively add more again than we did the year before. The Earth is on an accelerating drive to change our planet’s atmosphere. The main source of this additional CO2 is the burning of fossil fuels.
There is a common consensus that global warming is an effect of increased carbon emission and only a few groups still hold on to the belief that there is no connection between emissions of greenhouse gases (Carbon) with the effect of global ...view middle of the document...

The only way to reduce carbon footprint and reduce the emission of CO2 is to put a price on emission of carbon and therefore ‘make the polluters pay’. This way the price to pollute will be included as a cost variable and considered the same way that expenses such as wages, rent, electricity, royalty etc are considered. When a price is put on carbon emission, it provides a clear disincentive to continue the current level of carbon emission but reduce carbon emission in a way that has the least impact on the current company production.

In addition, a price on carbon emission means extra costs to the company and this has the effect of the company to not just reduce emissions but to explore other alternative energy type such as renewable energy. The benefit is long term carbon emission reduction and potential development of low-emission technology for future use.

Carbon Tax

A carbon tax as the name suggests itself is a tax on pollution or carbon emission. The government set a price on the price of carbon with the resulting market force determining how much quantity of emission is reduced. Since there is a price on carbon emission, it becomes one of the factors of doing business and therefore a price that need to be paid by the business. Just like costs such as labour costs, rent and electricity- the price of carbon emission is another cost that the business needs to bear. There are no limits on how much emission a company can do, but any emission the business undertakes will need to be paid for in term of carbon tax.
Carbon taxes offer a potentially cost-effective means of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Carbon tax address the issue that the polluters are not taxed sufficiently for the extra pollution that these companies are emitting to the local atmosphere. The pricing of carbon will need to be specific and take into consideration factors such as
• The desirable emission level on a global scale
• The amount of revenue the government would like to generate from the scheme
• Likelihood of reduction in carbon emission on productivity
• Likelihood to alter carbon price in the future

Currently, Australia has a carbon pricing mechanisms where companies that emit over 25,000 tons per year of Carbon dioxide equivalent greenhouse gases and which are not in the agricultural or transport industry are required to surrender their permit and pay tax on the excess emissions. Government agencies report that in Australia, over 260 companies were liable to pay carbon tax in 2013(Department of Climate Change).

Advantages

Disadvantage
Emission Trading Scheme

The emission trading scheme on the other hand is a government initiative that set a limit on the total emission that is applicable and issue permits to emit a specific volume of pollutant. The permit can be traded and as a result, the market determines the price of carbon by the trading of permits – another word for emission trading. Therefore the government set a limit on the...

Other Papers Like Compare Carbon Taxes with Emission Trading Schemes as Government Policy Tools

Carbon Accounting Essay

5860 words - 24 pages , accounting is perhaps one of the least understood. After all, even Europe (a four-year veteran of carbon trading) still has not come to consensus on how to account for emission allowances. Carbon traders in the United States have only begun to grapple with the accounting issues of an already complex and unfamiliar market. Moreover, as carbon markets evolve and incorporate new elements, additional accounting challenges will continue to emerge. There is

Will Kyoto Work In A Federal System?

2596 words - 11 pages generation, forestry etc. Each individual sector will sit down and negotiate with the government realistic goals in a realistic time frame. Alberta has created a new policy in which industries producing over 100 kilotones annually have to report on the status of there green house emissions on a regular basis (Alberta's Climate Change Taking Action, October 2002 (March 15 2003).An offset trading system will be established which will allow industry to buy

Development and the Environment

1096 words - 5 pages deal at his summit with Mr. Obama as it does to an analysis of the pilot schemes’ track record.  But the carbon-trading scheme also chimes with China’s new desire to use market mechanisms in environmental policy. That wish was clearly on display in the country’s big new reform plan for environment policy, announced on September 21st by the government and Communist Party. The reform puts much greater stress on the role of markets to control

Climate Change: Energy Policy and Sustainability

572 words - 3 pages Climate Change: Energy Policy and Sustainability Introduction Global climate change due to human activity is a major concern to millions of informed citizens. The U.S. government and scientific community have acknowledged the threats posed by global warming are real and stem from the unprecedented emission of greenhouse gases such as C02 and methane in the last 75 years (U.S. EPA, 2013). The United States is a major source of world

Environmentally

2640 words - 11 pages UK are distinguished exclusions. In 1992 the UK 10 per cent Car Purchase Tax which later was traded by the UK government policy of levitation fuel duty, attested in The Green Fiscal Commission (2010). Respectively prevailing of car purchase taxes have been updated in a quantity of EU nations, to boost cleaner in addition to low-carbon automobile technologies. Skinner et al., (2006) proved from mid-2006, the Netherlands has familiarized a

Position Paper

975 words - 4 pages , do not significantly hinder economic activity, and work toward curbing Co2 emissions. Even with this strong evidence the US federal government remains reluctant to implement policy, and instead relies heavily on state governments to implement policies. Although some states have adopted emission reduction policies, they are highly inefficient and have not reduced national or per capita Co2 emissions. A 2013 C2ES brief found that a carbon tax of

Economic Policy Issues to Address Global Warming

1294 words - 6 pages Problem Global warming refers to the dramatic rise in the earth’s temperature due to the excess emission greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, water vapor and methane. This phenomenon of global warming has major implications for humanity and nature. With rising sea levels, hotter and drier weather and increases in uncertainty humanity is at risk and the natural environment. These turbulent conditions lead to rapid changes in economic

Car Feebate Program

2542 words - 11 pages because this policy is basically designed to impose taxes on those who buy high-carbon vehicles, and distribute these tax revenues to those who purchase low-carbon vehicles as subsidies. This is “Fiscal Neutrality”. However, if consumers’ preferences and purchasing behaviors towards vehicles change differently from what the government predicts previously, it could be possible to damage “Fiscal Neutrality”. Heo Kyoung-sun, Sung Myung-jae, and Kim

Carb Management an Insight

2061 words - 9 pages domestic, would be needed to encourage the use of higher-efficiency construction techniques and efficient cooling and heating systems, which often come at a higher initial cost with a long “pay-back” period. Carbon Capture and Sequestration In a carbon-constrained world, CCS would allow us to sustain many of the benefits of using hydrocarbons. Even where the CO2 generated by burning hydrocarbons cannot be captured easily, as with using oil

Business Envioernment

3678 words - 15 pages and EU Emission Trading Scheme (Control over industrial greenhouse gas emissions) etc. Aviation policy framework was developed to provide safety and security to the customers and give economic benefits to local communities for air travel. Independent commission was framed to fulfill the short, medium and long term needs of the customers. Civil Aviation Bill also impacts the business of the BA and it forces firm to manage air traffic services as

Climate Change

4622 words - 19 pages & ENVIRONMENTAL POLICIES. I n 2008-09, Portugal’s economy entered a recession as a consequence of the global economic downturn. The government responded with the adoption of a stimulus package, in which environment-related measures accounted for about 18%, equivalent to 0.15% of GDP. Support for energy efficiency, renewable energy technologies and investment in electricity and smart grids constituted the core of the “green” stimulus measures. This

Related Essays

Can Welfare State Reforms In Europe Be Explained By Government Attempts To Improve Economic Efficiency? Discuss With Respect To A Social Policy Reform In Two Countries

2706 words - 11 pages Can welfare-state reforms in Europe be explained by government attempts to improve economic efficiency? Discuss with respect to a social policy reform in two countries. 1. Introduction: Pension systems were first introduced in Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century. In the post-war ‘golden era’ of welfare they were subject to wide expansion and increases in the benefits offered. They became the largest source of state welfare

Carbon Trading Within Eu Essay

2504 words - 11 pages stated in the international carbon emissions trading schemes such as the Kyoto Protocol and EUETS, Antes et al. (2011) added that the suboptimal negotiation of the cap with respect to total pollution minimization leads us to critically examine the proposition that a generous allocation of grandfathered permits by the regulator based on recent emissions might pave the way for dominant positions. As a result, the carbon markets established by these

Australia Eco Essay

1171 words - 5 pages , traditional energy companies will suffer from government policy. As greenhouse emission price introduced, there is an extra cost for companies to consider. According to market rules, when cost rise, supply will decrease from this way, government reduced carbon emission. Meanwhile, traditional pollution energy companies’ interest damaged. There is a strong conflict between private benefits and social benefits. What is more, with a higher product cost

11 1 Essay

1224 words - 5 pages the financial strength of an organization. Therefore, correct entry of purchased emission allowances is essential for correct financial analysis of Polluter Corp. In 2002, the International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee developed an interpretation of how entities should apply cap and trade schemes such as mission allowances. According to FASB, emission allowances are intangible assets. This scope of this consideration is