This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Claim: Critical Analysis Of Worker's Benefit Of Protection By Milton Friedman's Free To Choose

876 words - 4 pages

Book assignment: Paper # 2

10/29/10

Claim: Critical Analysis of Worker’s Benefits and Protection as Presented in Milton Friedman’s Free to Choose.

In Chapter eight of his popular Free to Choose, Milton Friedman takes on labor unions and government intervention in labor markets. He disputes the commonly held notion that labor unions and government spending are the cause of improvements in the living standards and wages of workers over the 19th and 20th centuries. He argues that because only “3 percent of workers” were members of unions as late as 1900, and because government regulation of the labor market was minimal prior to the New Deal, ...view middle of the document...

Second, unions lobby government for protections for labor unions, with much the same effect (229-243).
Keynesian economists dispute this analysis of their impacts on the labor market. First, Friedman’s conception that the impact of labor unions is determined solely by the concentration of unionized workers in the labor market is one that is open to dispute. This argument ignores the differential distribution of unionized workers—in some industries most workers are unionized, while in other industries there are almost no unionized workers. The impact of labor unions might be better analyzed on an industry-by-industry basis. Mischel and Walters argue that “strong unions set a pay standard that nonunion employers follow. For example, a high school graduate whose workplace is not unionized but whose industry is 25% unionized is paid 5% more than similar workers in less unionized industries.”
Friedman also argues that unions (and minimum wage laws) increase income inequality by increasing unemployment as well as racial disparities in income and employment. Using recent data, Mischel and Walters claim that unions decrease income inequality “because they raise wages more for low- and middle-wage workers than for higher-wage workers, more for blue-collar than for white-collar workers, and more for workers who do not have a college degree.” They also point out that the benefits of union wages accrue most dramatically to African American and women workers. Several studies conducted Free to Choose was published conclude that minimum wages have little, none or even a positive impact on employment, contrary to Friedman’s predictions (Bernstein and Schmidt 1998).
Finally, the state of the overall labor market today seriously calls into question Friedman’s argument that a reduction in the power of labor...

Other Papers Like Claim: Critical Analysis of Worker's Benefit of Protection by Milton Friedman's Free to Choose

Health & Safety Cost Benefit Analysis of a S

1756 words - 8 pages findings have been included. It will highlight any health & safety deficiencies discovered and the proposals for rectification of the deficiencies. The proposals will identify new work places, equipment, processes and activities that will reduce the hazards to employees and others who may be affected. The report will also include a cost benefit analysis and a recommended time scale for the actions based upon risk ranking. Findings 1. High

Critical Analysis Of Little Women

1428 words - 6 pages The Absence of Men in Little Women In her critical essay, “The House-Band”: The Education of Men in Little Women, Anne Dalke argues that the success of the women lies not in their independence, but in the remaking of the men on a female pattern. According to Dalke, the March women could not self-actualize without the men re-orienting their way of thinking. Male and female roles were clearly defined in the nineteenth century, but Dalke points

Beliefs of Benefit

846 words - 4 pages invested in. After all, if something has profoundly impacted the author’s life, it is likely that they have changed their life because of it. By writing the statement of faith, the author is sharing their knowledge that something has changed their life and that it is worth it. The third element of a statement of faith is that it is not something mundane. In the average person’s day-to-day life, it is not common for them to be familiar with the

The Benefit of Healthylifestyle

903 words - 4 pages in reducing our levels of stress, for instance, a good night's sleep can lower blood pressure and the elevated levels of stress hormones which are a natural result of today's fast paced lifestyle, there are physical effects of stress on your body, and an increase in the aging and degeneration of organs, cells and other body parts. By reducing high levels of stress, sleep helps to reverse these effects and encourages a state of relaxation. Pretty

Defending The Free Market: A Critical Analysis

634 words - 3 pages Defending the Free Market: Critical Analysis Defending the Free Market written by Rev. Robert Sirico is a book about how being a leftist seems like a very moral and right thing to do for people but in turn is not very economically sound. He talks about how back in his younger days he was a socialist and leftist but in turn with many talks with people and intense fact searching he figured out how the free-market system is the only way to

Bureau Of Fire Protection

4190 words - 17 pages UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES National College of Public Administration and Governance Diliman, Quezon City PERFORMANCE OF THE BUREAU OF FIRE PROTECTION (BFP): CONTRIBUTIONS TO FIRE MANAGEMENT A proposal submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for PA 199.2 By: Nheo Cervantes Geofel Soriano Adviser: Vicente Mariano September 27, 2011 I. Introduction Fires are one of the few calamities of which we can

Essentials of Executive Protection

1741 words - 7 pages being a drunkard and involved in a scuffle. Brown in turn does not want the Queen to know what truly happened and believes he should resign in the best interest of protecting the Queen's reputation. Although he is rough and not as refined by today's Protection standards, he still holds his obligations to protecting the Queen physically and reputational. As time progresses Queen Victoria's virtual recluse, especially at Balmoral Castle in

From Protection To Competition – The Deregulation Of The Airline Industry

1963 words - 8 pages 1.The importance of airlines to their home countries as a reason for their protection (flag carriers, military considerations)For a long time the airline industry was treated as a special case in the international business. The aviation sector was subjected to different rules and held to different standards.One reason for this special status was the national defense. Under programs such as the U.S. Civil Reserve Air Fleet (CARF) plan, civilian

Biography Of Milton Friedman: Famous American Economist

1727 words - 7 pages education in New Jersey. Friedman specialized in mathematics as he intended to become an actuary. Friedman was influenced by Arthur F. Burns and Homer Jones, two economics professors who persuade Friedman that modern economics could help the depression at Rutgers University. In year 1933, Friedman choose the scholarship in economics that was offered by University of Chicago and he earn an M.A. At here, Friedman met his future wife, Rose Director, an

A Critical Analysis Of The Concept Of Addiction With Reference To Drug Misuse

1705 words - 7 pages , expression and treatment, it is useful to include these problems in addiction practice."From a sociological point of view Abercrombie (1988) defines 'addiction' as"..the devotion to or enslavement by a substance, typically a drug, which is regarded as physically or socially harmful."This definition indicates towards the traditional perception of this subject where the substance is only seen as being addictive and the one doing the enslaving. But this

In "Twenty-One Stories" Graham Greene Is Concerned With A Number Of Themes. Choose Any One Of These Themes And Discuss By Making Close Reference To His Collection

710 words - 3 pages , the cause of Francis' death is "fear, fear of the party, fear of being made to hide by himself in the dark." Moreover, for the adult in "The Second Death" fear is about the afterlife. He fears judgement because of the immoral life which he led. He believes that suffering is eternal and says, "when one's dead there's no unconsciousness any more for ever," it is not like sleep "or rest in peace."In "Proof Positive" and "A Little Place off the

Related Essays

An Analysis Of Blake's Milton

4739 words - 19 pages sufferings had reached the dwellers in eternity, with the result that the poet Milton received a heavenly command to return to earth to deliver him from the tyranny of his oppressors. This was the fulfilment of an ancient prophecy "in Eden recorded that Milton of the land of Albion should up ascend, forwards from Ulro, from the Vale of Felpham, and set free Orc from his chain of jealousy." The person of Orc is used by Blake to represent "the fires of

Cost Benefit Analysis Of Three Gorges Project

1684 words - 7 pages Cost-Benefit Analysis of Three Gorges Project Shen Bojiu China is working on the controversial Three Gorges project. Are such projects economically justified? 1. Introduction The Three Gorges Project (TGP) in China is the largest hydro project in the world. The project was first proposed by Sun Yat-sen in 1919, and 84 years later, in 1993, the project has started its construction. The TGP has three phases. The first phase is from

Critical Analysis Of The Story Theft By Katherine Annporter

1444 words - 6 pages on his play. By taking the purse, the janitress is demanding that the protagonist had failed to claim or declaim what is rightfully hers. A part of her discovery is that her apathy has contributed to her losses, the moral and spiritual implications of which are illuminated in the religious structure and imagery throughout the story (Unrue, 1993). III. THE FUNCTIONS OF THE CONVERSATIONS AND CONVERSATIONAL IMPLICATURES To the surprise of most

To Autumn By John Keates Critical Analysis

663 words - 3 pages worth of death. The poem achieves this by using descriptive and vivid expressions to describe the essence of autumn. The poem uses powerful language to achieve effect. It often makes use of imagery, exaggerated language and onomatopoeia to create an atmosphere of the English autumn, for the reader. Language such as this excerpt from the first stanza, And fill all fruits with ripeness to the core, To swell the gourd, and plump the