Case Study On Negligence

2187 words - 9 pages

Case Study on Negligence - Stella v Christine

Stella can take an action of Negligence against Christine for her careless conduct regarding the slippery floor as well as the heating urn and steamer. She will be the plaintiff, and Christine, the defendant. Stella bears the burden of proof that Christine owed her a duty of care, but omitted to perform it, which caused her personal injuries and economic loss. The elements, including duty of care, breach of duty of care, and damage, must be proven on the balance of probabilities. If proven, Stella will probably be able to claim monetary compensation for her medical costs, loss of earnings, and suffering and pain. At the meanwhile, however, ...view middle of the document...

In our case, any reasonable person could have foreseen a real risk of injury to the students incurred by Christine’s careless conduct about the slippery floor as well as the heating urn and steamer on a table inside the over-crowded classroom. Therefore, Christine owed Stella a duty of care. Particularly, Christine was fully aware of the risk from the oversize of class, as she “found that she was not able to effectively supervise the students” and some students suffered from physical injuries when she had 35 students in one class.
b. The relationship of the defendant to that risk
Whether the defendant is in a controlling position through resources, knowledge, legal duty or right or not is taken into account. Christine, as Stella’s yoga instructor who hired the classroom and arranged the place, was in a controlling position.
c. The nature of the damage that the plaintiff suffered
The context in which the damage occurred is considered. In Nagle v Rottnest Island Authority [1993], the plaintiff "dived from a partially submerged rock ledge into the water. Almost immediately, his head struck a fully submerged rock and he became a quadriplegic". The trial judge concluded that the Board was under a general duty of care at common law to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable risks of injury to visitors lawfully visiting the Reserve.
In our case, Stella was seriously injured while performing some yoga posture in Christine’s class. The urn and steamer that fell onto Stella’s body from table had been used by Christine. Hence it can be established that Christine is liable for the damage.

In summary, the relevant elements can be proven that Christine owed a duty of care to Stella.

Breach of the duty of care
Section 9(1) Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld) gives three tests for breach of the duty of care.
a. A foreseeable risk.
There was such a risk that a reasonable person would have foreseen if they were in the position of the defendant. and
b. Non-insignificant risk.
There was at least a probability of harm. And
c. Reasonable precautions would have been taken.
In the circumstances a reasonable person in the position of the defendant would have taken precautions.

Correspondingly, the court shall take into account the following four elements when deciding whether the duty of care has been breached, according to s 9(2) CLA:
a. The probability of risk or injury
In Bolton v Stone [1951], the court held that the cricket club was not negligent because the likelihood of harm was low, that is, the probability of a person being struck by a cricket ball which was hit out of the ground was low.
By contrast, in of Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan [2002], the Full Court of the Federal Court dismissed Barclay Oysters’ appeal that they had not breach the duty of care to consumers and the final decision was that the Barclay Company was negligent.
In our case, the combination of slippery floor and heating urn and steamer on a table...

Other Papers Like Case Study on Negligence

Case Study on Intuit

632 words - 3 pages Case study Week 4 Intuit company is an American software company that develops financial and tax preparation software and related services for small business, accountants and individuals. And this essay will use poter’s five forces to analysis the Intuit company and understand its strength of your current competitive position, and the strength of a position you are consider moving into. First of all, the porter’s five forces analysis

Case Study on Crossroads

3590 words - 15 pages A Case Study on Crossroads: A Story of Forgiveness1 Prepared to Support the Central Learning Activities In PACO 500 Introduction to Pastoral Counseling Liberty University/Seminary 1John K. Harrison, 2007. Crossroads: A Story of Forgiveness (Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions, Inc.). The previous case study of Dr. Gary Stewart was revised by this course’s subject matter expert. Further insights have been added to facilitate the preparation

Case Study On Mary

897 words - 4 pages Case Study on Mary Client is a middle-aged female, currently unemployed. She states she is a dropout, a divorcee and has no children, (further into her recovery, we find out that she is a mother of a deceased child). Mary is in the hospital as a result of getting into a fight with a local at the bar. Mary has been in the hospital three times in the last year, she appears to be suffering from hallucinations and possible seizures in the

Case Study on Marketing

1177 words - 5 pages Starbucks and City Café: Friend or Foe? (pg 265-267) Case Objectives To understand how to define different market segments based on the variables used to divide the market To be able to identify and explain the marketing actions used to reach the target markets To draw a perceptual map and explain the positioning strategy of the different brands Case Synopsis President Chain Store Corporation (PCSC) was established in Taiwan in 1987 and

Case Study On Epilepsy

771 words - 4 pages INTRODUCTION The purpose of Case Study: Epilepsy is to provide an understanding of the basic principles involved in the drug treatment of epilepsy, including factors to consider in the initiation and assessment of AED therapy. On 29th January 2014 around 2.15 am, there is a patient admitted in ward 7 (Medical) from A&E Department due to epilepsy. Basically, epilepsy is group of related disorders characterized by a tendency for recurrent

Case Study on Karsakoff Syndrom

972 words - 4 pages Abstract: This is a case study regarding the effects of chronic alcohol abuse in Patient F43, F referring to the patient’s gender as Female; 43 referring to the age of the patient. Patient F43’s problems with alcohol are further complicated by anorexia nervosa, depression, and bipolar disorder, all of which were known to exist before any problems associated with drinking had developed. As a result of chronic alcohol abuse, Patient F43 is

Case Study on Ping Sweeps

720 words - 3 pages In today’s technology there are many different fast growing terms and ideas. I will discuss what ping sweeps are and how do they work as well as port scans. To begin with, according to a case study by Gregory M (Chip) Pyles Jr, Ping sweeps and port scans are computer activities that unethical people could use to gain access to personal or company networks. Ping sweeps and port scans can be dangerous, but can also be prevented. Ping sweeps is

Case Study Snap On Tools

649 words - 3 pages Snap on Tools Case Study 1. Selling strategy is a major component of Snap-on’s marketing strategy. They developed certain strategies that attracted customers and expanded their market, their original selling strategy did not work and once they went to a more direct approach, customers started buying the product. The second component is that their basic commitment to direct selling has remained pretty much unchanged, even though the

Hostess Case Study on Hr

795 words - 4 pages Hostess Case Study The story of what happened to Hostess is quite long, winding and multi-faceted. Hostess ultimately fell into bankruptcy and finally liquidation as a result of several key issues that the owners and management failed to address on throughout the history of this company. Merger after merger resulted in a web of collective bargaining agreements with over 12 unions, 40 pension plans including participation in multi-employer

Case Study on Gropu Behavior

1905 words - 8 pages CASE STUDY ON GROUP BEHAVIOUR Hindustan Lever Research Centre (HLRC) was set up in the year 1967 at Mumbai. At that time the primary challenge was to find suitable alternatives to the edible oils and fats that were being used as raw materials for soaps. Later, import substitution and export obligations directed the focus towards non-edible oil seeds, infant foods, perfumery chemicals, fine chemicals, polymers and nickel catalyst. This

A Case Study on Starbucks

792 words - 4 pages Exploration of Successfully Managed Innovation of A Company: A Case Study on Starbucks   Introduction In an acutely vying business environment, innovation has been highly regarded by enterprises. It is vital for companies to effectively apply innovation strategies into practice. In this essay, Starbucks, as a world famous cafe brand, will be taken as an example to demonstrate how a company has successfully managed innovation. Body

Related Essays

Legal Case Study Negligence

2943 words - 12 pages Jeckyll used, breach would be satisfied. Vicarious liability For the purposes of recovering damages, Duncan may wish to have the local surgery at which Dr Jeckyll practices held vicariously liable for his injury. In this case, vicarious liability will depend on whether the relationship between Dr Jeckyll and the surgery was that of employer-employee and whether the negligence was conducted in the course of his employment. As it is obvious

Case Study On Adhd

1044 words - 5 pages with ADHD have a problem with inattentiveness, over activity, impulsivity, and or a combination of these. Some symptoms of ADHD would be the inability to stay focused, difficulty controlling their behavior and hyperactivity. The two development theories that I think are most closely affiliated with Jeremiah are the behaviorism theory and Piaget’s cognitive development theory. These theories are most applicable to this case study. Behaviorism is

Case Study On Malaysia

1030 words - 5 pages Case Study on Malaysia Malaysia is a multicultural society. Malaysia consists of three main ethnic groups, 50.4% being Malays, 23.7% Chinese, 11% indigenous people, 7.1% Indians and 7.8% other races. Due to its colonial past under the British rule, ethnicity has been an issue in Malaysia even up till this day. (Noor, 2013) Social identity is based on the assumption that society is structured into different social groups that that will lead to

Case Study On Napan

1313 words - 6 pages Introduction to Organisational Behaviour Group Project Case Study Nupath Foods Ltd Word Count 1000 Written by: Background Denise Roberge is the brand manager of Nupath Foods Ltd. Under her helm, the company sales is hiking a healthy growth of 20 percent in the past quarter. These have brought attention to various higher management , like James