Case Law Analysis

730 words - 3 pages

u01a1 – Case Law Analysis: Judicial Concepts
Student: Beatriz T. Halbert
Instructor: Professor Melvin Landry
Quarter: Fall 2013
Course: BUS3021

I selected U.S. Supreme Court (Court) case Commonwealth v. Continental Casualty, 393 U.S. 145 (1968) for my case law analysis on judicial concepts. The Court heard arguments on October 22, 1968. Mr. Justice Black delivered the opinion of the Court on November 18, 1968.
The petitioner, Commonwealth Coatings, sued Continental Casualty, on the prime contractor’s bond to recover money due for a painting job. The contract between the prime contractor and the subcontractor included an arbitration provision. The petitioner selected an ...view middle of the document...

Mr. Just Black’s opinion discusses at length the background of the third arbitrator, and their relationship with the prime contractor. The third arbitrator owned a large company in Puerto Rico, and conducted business with the prime contractor on a sporadic basis. However, Mr. Justice Black concluded that the prime contractor’s business with the third arbitrator was significant and repeated; and the relationship included services on the specific projects involved in the lawsuit. In addition, both the prime contractor and the third arbitrator failed to disclose their relationship to the plaintiff until after the award. It is clear that the opinion of the Court hinged on this fact (Commonwealth Coatings, 1968).
Mr. Justice Black referenced the United States Arbitration Act in his opinion. He stated that the provisions in the Act showed a desire of Congress to ensure that any arbitration is an impartial one. He also referenced Section 18 in the Rules of the Arbitration Association. Section 18 requires an arbitrator to disclose any circumstances or relationships that could create a presumption of bias. He also referenced part of the 33d Canon of Judicial Ethics that states that a judge should avoid any possibility of bias in their social or business relations. Mr. Justice White and Mr....

Other Papers Like Case Law Analysis

Business Law Essay

1508 words - 7 pages . misleading conduct), a company law issue (e.g. breach of director’s duty), negligence? Rules/Relevant Law Explain the legal principles (rules) relevant to the issues identified. Any relevant legislation and precedent cases should be used to support the explanation. Application/Analysis Use the law to argue for each party’s position or, in other words, apply the law to the hypothetical facts of the case study. This involves explaining

Law 421 Essay

455 words - 2 pages ) The Issue The legal business issue raised in the article is that of trademark infringement that would also be considered a theft of intellectual property. Being that Hyperphrase feels that Google has demonstrated deceptive business practice they feel resolving the matter in a court of law is the only to prevent further damages. “This intriguing case so far has two significant juridical teachings.  First, we learned that business

Kirchoff's Law

992 words - 4 pages action If you click on the picture to the right, you can advance to a second picture that depicts a loopabcd. If you begin at a and advance clockwise along the interior loop, the Voltage Law yields the equation: v1 + v2 + v3 + v4 = 0 In this case, the current will also be clockwise. Crossing the resistors will result in v1, v2, andv3 all being negative. Since you're crossing from negative to positive, v4 will be positive. If you consider the

Corporate Law

291 words - 2 pages Corporate Law SUB: CORPORATE LAW SECTION-A Q.1 Answer the following questions: (Any five) (40 Marks) 1. 'Corporate planning may be viewed as an organizational process that results in the development of the organization’s purposes, missions, objectives, goals, strategies, policies and detailed action plans to achieve the objectives.' Explain the statement. What benefits would ensure to an organization using corporate planning? 2

Business Law

928 words - 4 pages IRAC Method of Case Study Analysis Nsima Etok and Christopher Dunbar Business Law 531 March 31 2015 Gregory Martins Introduction In any type of business, whether it is partnership, Limited Liability Company (LLC) and or a Corporation, these are seen as different types of businesses that involves one, two or more People. The same is implied to businesses that are operated internationally between different

Business Law

3883 words - 16 pages and have the power to sue or be sued in its own name. A company is distinct from its director, shareholders, employees and creditors as recognised by the court in the case of Salomon v. A. Salomon Co Pty Ltd [1897] AC 22. The basic principle of corporate law regard an incorporated company as a separate legal entity for the purposes of legal analysis, separated from people who established them, who invest money in it, and who direct and manage its

Law 200

3514 words - 15 pages illegal contract, and therefore transfer of tort liability for Ms Berkey’s personal injury was also illegal. Adams v Cape Industries plc [1990] It is the leading UK company law case on separate legal personality and limited liability of shareholders. The case also addressed long-standing issues under the English conflict of laws as to when a company would be resident in a foreign jurisdiction such that the English courts would recognize the

European Law

2928 words - 12 pages Stockholm University Department of law Master Programme in European Law Written assignment(BL4) Supervisor: Björn Lundqvist Author: Stockholm 2012 Introduction: Identifying the circumstances which would bring the mentioned agreement in the given case under the prohibition of Article 101 or 102 requires providing some relevant definitions of basic concepts in the competition law area and explanation of the

Wright's Law

1302 words - 6 pages . James was a student with superior intelligence and dyslexia. After James Brody case finalized, the Dare County LEA was required by federal and state law to make available special education and related services to James and offer him a free and appropriate public education as that term is defined under IDEA and state law. North Carolina’s public policy regarding special education declares that the policy of the State is to ensure every child a

Antitrust Law

5520 words - 23 pages Antitrust law is the law of competition, and it is perhaps the least understood law of all. This article provides an overview and explanation of the essential principals of antitrust law, along with comments on certain recurring themes and recent developments in the voluminous case law by which the courts have struggled to give meaning and practical effect to the principal antitrust statutes. What Is Antitrust Law? Broadly speaking, antitrust

Law Questions

860 words - 4 pages 1) Since the injured plaintiff was not wearing a seatbelt, why is Ford being sued for failing to test the seatbelt sleeve? In the case of Branham v. Ford Motor Co., the Plaintiff brought the case against Hale, the driver, and Ford because the company failed to test the seat-belt sleeve, even though he did not "seriously pursue the claim against Hale" (Reed, Pagnattaro, Cahoy, Shedd & Morehead, 2012). The case against Ford was based on "two

Related Essays

Taxation Law Case Analysis

1429 words - 6 pages CLAW3201 Case Analysis Introduction In Crown Insurance Services Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Crown), the issues raised are pertinent to the residence and source of the company under s6(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. As cases are determined on the basis of all relevant facts and circumstances of each case, this analysis will focus on how the court’s decision process determined whether Crown had carried on business in the years

Human Resources Law Trace The Historical Tradition Of Australian Labour Law Using Relevant Legislation And Case Law To Support Your Analysis. Do You Think The Current Direction Of Labour Law In...

2046 words - 9 pages March 2006 Howe, J. (2005) '"Deregulation" of Labour Relations in Australia: Towards Command and Control', Working Paper No. 34, Centre for Employment and Labour Relations Law, University of Melbourne. J. Isaac and R. D. Lansbury (eds), Labour Market Deregulation: Rewriting the Rules, The Federation Press, Leichhardt, 2005, pp. 1-14. Family Leave Test Case (2005) 143 IR 245. Metals Casual Award Case (2000) 110 IR 247. Redundancy Case (2004) 129 IR

Case Study Eu Competition Law

1703 words - 7 pages parties’ confirmation in the participation of the cartel. The Commission has granted K+N full immunity from fines Assignment: Competition in the European Union: The legal framework 5 under the Leniency Rules, since they have informed the Authority about this cartel firstly. 2. Analysis of the Case Building up a cartel is generally an infringement of European competition law. In this case the parties have

Law/531 Business Law Essay

1532 words - 7 pages Week 3 Individual Assignment Luis A. Campudoni LAW/531 Business Law Prof. Marlene Wilhite February 19, 2010 Legal Issues in Contract Fulfillment Agreements are a hot and critical topic in business agreements today. How do entities engaging in business contracts conclude in a consensus of the clauses, terms, and expectations of the project seem to fail at times due to expected and / or unexpected factors. This seems to be the case of the