Carefully Read The Following Extract Several Times. Compare And Contrast The Ways In Which The Passage Below Attempts To Discredit Antony With The Ways This Is Done In The Speech Attributed To Octavian By Cassius Dio (

1318 words - 6 pages

Antony has been discredited in numerous way in both extracts. The key figure involved which led to the negative portrayal of Antony is the last ruler of the Ptolemaic dynasty, Cleopatra.

Contextually, Octavian already had a vendetta against Antony. Roman marriage was seen as a political coalition between families. Before the speech attributed to Octavian, Antony had abandoned his wife (the sister of Octavian) to pursue his life with Cleopatra.

Continuing with the theme of Cleopatra, both texts depict her as having complete control over Antony. Plutarch and Cassius Dio both illustrate a negative image of Antony due to Cleopatra’s influence. Cassius Dio claims Octavian said in a speech ...view middle of the document...

19) were passed to Antony during court proceedings.

Antony’s reputation continued to spiral due to Cleopatra as Egyptian’s ‘worship reptiles and beasts as gods, they embalm their bodies to make them appear immortal […] they are not ruled by a man, but are the slaves of a woman’ (Scott-Kilvert, 1987, Reputations, 2008, p. 27) which is unprecedented in Roman tradition. However, Plutarch does not mention Cleopatra’s culture within the extract from the Life of Antony.

This leads me to what I think is the main contrasting point: the difference in authenticity. Plutarch was a Roman citizen and classed himself as a Greek historian creating a number of character studies to illustrate great figures of Greek and Roman history. When necessary it was stated if there were any stipulations: ‘Calvisius was generally believed to have invented most of these accusations’ (Plutarch, AA100 Assignment Booklet, 2013, p. 19). Conversely, Cassius Dio made a dramatic and engaging piece of rhetoric causing suspicion of its validity. The speech was written around 200 years after the event took place. It is not an eye-witness account suggesting Cassius Dio may have invented it to create plausible fiction.

As explained above, both texts personify Antony as a changed man; no longer seen as a threat as a result of accepting an immoral way of life and becoming a disgrace to Roman tradition due to the bewitchment by Cleopatra.
Sub-total word count: 549

Bibliography
Plutarch, (trans.) (1965) abridged; quoted from ‘Plutarch: Markers of Rome’, (ed. Ian Scott-Kilvert), Penguin Books; reprinted in ‘AA100 Assignment Booklet’ (October 2013), Milton Keynes, The Open University, p. 19.
Scott-Kilvert, I. (trans.) (1987) ‘Cassius Dio: The Roman History: The Age of Augustus’, Harmondsworth, Penguin, pp. 52-55; reprinted in ‘AA100 The Arts Past and Present Book 1 Reputations’, Milton Keynes, The Open University, p. 27.
Fear, T. (2008), ‘Cleopatra’, in ‘AA100 The Arts Past and Present Book 1 Reputations’, Milton Keynes, The Open University, pp. 3-28.
‘Cleopatra’ (2008), AA100 DVD Video, Milton Keynes, The Open University.

Look carefully at Plate 1.3.32, Paul Cézanne’s painting Still Life with Plaster Cast, c.1894. How do the form and content of this painting contribute to our understanding of it as modern work?
Modern art is distinguishable from traditional art, however it is unclear as to who was the first artist to create a piece of modern art. It is said that Paul Cézanne could have been one of the first hence why he has contributed to the understanding of modern artwork today.

When looking at the composition of Cézanne’s Still Life with Plaster Cast (see Plate 1.3.32, Illustration Book, p.36) the viewer’s immediate attention is the mythological cupid in the centre of the picture which doesn’t support the idea of modern art as it tends to be made up of real things rather than...

Other Papers Like Carefully Read the Following Extract Several Times. Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which the Passage Below Attempts to Discredit Antony with the Ways This Is Done in the Speech Attributed to Octavian by Cassius Dio (

Examine the Ways in Which Feminist Sociologists Have Contributed to Our Understanding of Family

679 words - 3 pages Examine the ways in which feminist sociologists have contributed to our understanding of family Many of the contributions to this debate have come from radical feminists who have tended to focus on the following aspects of relationships: How domestic roles are divided between men and women, the nuclear family as an ideological construct and domestic violence.  Femenism is a sociologicalpersctive and political movement that focuses on womens

Examine the Ways in Which Childhood Can Be Said to Be Socially Constructed

1041 words - 5 pages To answer this question, one needs to define socially constructed then critically evaluate the different theories and studies investigating childhood on whether childhood is a social construct and hopefully come to some conclusion. Socially constructed is the idea that childhood is defined and driven by the norms and values of the society in which it is taking place. Sociologists would claim that childhood is socially constructed as it

Discuss the Ways in Which the Theme of Redemption Is Explored in a Christmas Carol

940 words - 4 pages Discuss the ways in which the theme of redemption is explored in A Christmas Carol In ACC, Charles Dickens explores the theme of redemption countless times throughout the novella. Through the salvation and alteration of the main character Scrooge, redemption is discovered. Transformed from a cold, miserly protagonist who seemed to live only for himself as he aged, to becoming as ‘as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the

Using Examples, Discuss the Ways in Which Any of the Following Can Be Analysed Either in Ideological Terms of the Construction of Gender or Race

1724 words - 7 pages taught him how to constructively direct his tendencies into good use, by killing those who have escaped the legal system and, as he says ‘deserve it’, such as child molesters , rapists and killers themselves. Similarly to Jack Bauer, Dexter is the main figure of authority, and has the same intention of safeguarding America from criminals. However they just do this in very different ways. Even though he breaks the rules, Jack Bauer tends to try and

Examine The Ways In Which Walker Uses The Symbolism Of Sewing In "The Color Purple" To Reflect Celie's Spiritual And Emotional Development

3252 words - 14 pages A major symbol that reoccurs throughout the novel 'The Color Purple' is the practice of sewing. This activity is one that several of the characters participate in, and for Celie it represents a way of channelling her energy and anger. It also allows her to bond with other females, creating strong relationships and giving her a sense of freedom and independence from the male dominance that has clouded a large section of her life. The quilt, an

Discuss the Ways in Which Brokeback Mountain by Annie Proulx and the Comfort of Strangers by Ian Mcewaneither Reinforce, or Seek to Disrupt, the Identification of Femininity and Passivity and/or...

3571 words - 15 pages which Jack died he feels and not by some tyre which is supposed to of exploded in Jacks face. Ennis denies his sexuality and states, “I’m no queer” along with Jack whom says “Me neither. A one shot thing. Nobody’s business but ours” Jack states this even though he has been having relationships with men away from Ennis, something which is probably the cause of his death later on. Both Ennis and Jack reinforce and disrupt the identification of

Outline Some Of The Ways In Which Cultural Deprivation May Lead To Educational Under Achievement For Working Class Pupils

290 words - 2 pages There are many ways in which cultural deprivation may lead to educational under-achievement in working-class pupils. The term ‘Culture’ refers to all the norms, values, beliefs, skills and knowledge that a society or group regards as important. This culture is transmitted to the next generation through socialisation. According to cultural deprivation theories, some working class parents fail to transmit the appropriate norms, values, attitudes

The New York Times and Boston Scientific: Two Different Ways of Innovating with Information Technology

1918 words - 8 pages Saint Mary's University Chapter 1 / Foundations of Information Systems in Business CASE 2 27 The New York Times and Boston Scientific: Two Different Ways of Innovating with Information Technology A and the resources to turn their ideas into reality. Typical projects are measured against criteria like revenue potential or journalistic value. R&D projects aren’t. “Since we build software, there’s no huge capital investment up front,” Frons

According to the Author of This Extract, What Aspects of Faraday’s Life and Work Contributed to His Reputation? How Does the Picture Presented Here Compare to the Picture of Faraday’s Reputation in...

718 words - 3 pages Part 1 According to the author of this extract, what aspects of Faraday’s life and work contributed to his reputation? How does the picture presented here compare to the picture of Faraday’s reputation in his own lifetime presented in Book 1, Chapter 4? The extract from The Times written some 100 years after the birth of Faraday portrays the image of a great man of science, a pioneer to be emulated ‘…how his successors have followed him

Examine the Ways in Which Social Policies and Laws May Influence Families and Households

953 words - 4 pages Examine the ways in which social policies and laws may influence families and households. Some sociologists have suggested that social policy has caused families to become more diverse while others disagree. Social policies are the laws and practices put in place by the government that effect social issues, in this case the family. For example, in the 1930’s the Nazi government in Germany wanted to encourage Aryan families and put in place

Examine the Ways in Which Social Policies and Laws May Influence Families and Households

893 words - 4 pages heterosexual and homosexual, had the right to adopt on a basis equivalent to that of a married couple. This has made adopting easier for unmarried couples with fertility issues, but the biggest change to have resulted from it is that homosexual couples can now, fairly easily, adopt children, leading to a much more diverse range of families. This change has been heavily criticised by New Right thinkers, who claim that it further undermines

Related Essays

Compare And Contrast The Ways In Which Csi And The X Factor Attract Audiences?

674 words - 3 pages Experts have different views about how to deal with recidivism. Some believe that custodial sentencing is the best way of reducing re-offending, others think that prison may not be the solution and that there are better alternatives. There is also much debate about whether treatment programmes reduce re-offending. Discuss ways of dealing with the problem of recidivism, refer to the views outlined above in your answer. (12) Custodial sentencing

Read The Following Poems By Thomas Hardy (‘The Oxen’) And Seamus Heaney (‘Cow In Calf’) In The Faber Book Of Beasts (Pp.195 And 62). In No More Than 600 Words, Compare The Ways In Which The Two Poets...

766 words - 4 pages Read the following poems by Thomas Hardy (‘The Oxen’) and Seamus Heaney (‘Cow in Calf’) in The Faber Book of Beasts (pp.195 and 62). In no more than 600 words, compare the ways in which the two poets represent cattle. New forms of poetry, however radical they appear, almost always show traces of tradition. (Danson Brown, 2008, p.63) ‘The Oxen’ written by Thomas Hardy and ‘Cow in Calf’ by Seamus Heaney show significant differences but also

With The Help Of Examples Drawn From The Surveillance Film, Outline The Ways In Which Surveillance Is Used To Deliver Crime Control And Social Welfare

714 words - 3 pages Cochrane, Commentator, The Open University, 2008a). The use of CCTV as a surveillance tool in The Open University (2008a) shows how criminal activity can be monitored and controlled when a man enters the White Rose Shopping Centre in Leeds, from which he is banned for previous deviant behaviour. CCTV is used by the security staff to visually track his movements through the centre. This information is passed onto other security staff and a police

Compare The Ways In Which Shakespeare And Marvell Have Used Poetic Form, Structure And Language To Present Their Thoughts And Feelings Of Love

2204 words - 9 pages hear/ Times winged chariot hurrying near;/ And yonder all before us lie/ Deserts of vast eternity’ The lamenting tone is indicative of the fact that time will bring death, an awareness of which is always with the speaker. The rhythm and rhyme scheme is lyrical and carefully crafted to summarise the choices his lover must make, highlighting that waiting and resisting is pointless. This is reinforced with ‘Deserts of vast eternity’ as it shows