This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Can You Fight Poverty With A 5 Star Hotel?

4533 words - 19 pages

Can You Fight Poverty With a Five-Star Hotel?

(Photo courtesy of Mövenpick Hotels & Resorts)
by Cheryl Strauss Einhorn, Special to ProPublica, Jan. 2, 2013, 12 a.m.
* 0 Comments
* Republish
* Email
* Print
Connect with Facebook to share articles you read on ProPublica. Learn more »
*
*
*
* 1
inShare
This story was co-published with Foreign Policy.
Accra is a city of choking red dust where almost no rain falls for three months at a time and clothes hung out on a line dry in 15 minutes. So the new five-star Mövenpick hotel affords a haven of sorts in Ghana’s crowded capital, with manicured lawns, amply watered vegetation, and uniformed waiters ...view middle of the document...

Why, then, did the IFC give a Saudi prince’s company an attractively priced $26 million loan to help build the Mövenpick, a hotel the prince was fully capable of financing himself? The answer is that the IFC’s portfolio of billions of dollars in loans and investments is not in fact primarily targeted at helping the impoverished. At least as important is the goal of making a profit for the World Bank.
I reached this conclusion after traveling to Ghana—in many ways typical of the more than 100 countries where the IFC works—to see firsthand the kinds of problems the World Bank’s lenders are supposed to tackle and whether their efforts are really working on the ground. I pored through thousands of pages of the bank’s publicly available reports and financial statements and talked to dozens of experts familiar with its performance in Ghana and many other countries.
In case after case, the verdict was the same: The IFC likes to work with huge corporations, funding projects these companies could finance themselves. Its partners are billionaires and massive multinationals, from oil giants like ExxonMobil to Grupo Arcor, the huge Argentine candy-maker. Its projects include not only glitzy hotels and high-end shopping malls, but also gritty gold and copper mines and oil pipelines, some of which end up benefiting the very corrupt, authoritarian regimes that the rest of the World Bank is urging to change. Nearly a quarter of the IFC’s paid-in capital from member governments—now standing at $2.4 billion—came from U.S. taxpayers, and every president in the World Bank’s 69-year history has been an American. But the United States has had little complaint with these practices, even when they have become a subject of public controversy.
Not long ago, the World Bank’s internal watchdog sharply criticized the IFC’s approach, saying it gives little more than lip service to the bank’s poverty-fighting mission. The report, a major 2011 review by the bank’s Independent Evaluation Group, found that fewer than half the IFC investments it studied involved fighting poverty. “[M]ost IFC investment projects generate satisfactory returns but do not provide evidence of identifiable opportunities for the poor to participate in, contribute to, or benefit from the economic activities that the project supports,” the report concluded. In fact, it said, only 13 percent of 500 projects studied “had objectives with an explicit focus on poor people,” and even those that did, the report found, had a “limited” impact. The IFC did not dispute the conclusions.
There is certainly need in countries like Ghana, whose per capita GDP ranks in the bottom third of the world, with life expectancy in the bottom 15 percent and infant mortality in the bottom fourth. The IFC committed about $145 million in loans and equity in Ghana just in fiscal year 2012. Yet Takyiwaa Manuh, who advises the Ghanaian government on economic development as a member of the National Development Planning Commission,...

Other Papers Like Can You Fight Poverty with a 5-Star Hotel?

Young Women Can Look to a Better Quality of Life Than Before. Do You Agree?

1312 words - 6 pages Young women can look forward to a better quality of life than before. Do you agree? Introduction: Legally young women are equal to men and have similar right. In some modern society, women's plight have improve through years but in patriarchal society, men still keep this traditional image of women. Young women can look forward to a better quality of life than before: Women in modern society: Nowadays women play an important role in

Do You Think a Man and Woman Can Be True Friends?

893 words - 4 pages love, and adults over 70 are indifferent to this issue. In addition, homosexuals are also excluded since they are biologically against the human sexual nature. In sum, a man and woman in this text mean people from 10 to 70 who are mentally and physically healthy. To become friends with some people, we must “know” them. Do you think it is possible to be a friend with a stranger you’ve never met before? We can be a friend with someone when we know

‘Most Comedies Can Be Criticised for a Lack of Seriousness’. to What Extent Do You Believe This to Be the Case in the Play ‘Much Ado About Nothing’?

1713 words - 7 pages ‘Most comedies can be criticised for a lack of seriousness’. To what extent do you believe this to be the case in the play ‘Much Ado About Nothing’? ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ contains comedy throughout but it could be argued that seriousness is present in equal measure. They are portrayed simultaneously by Shakespeare in his play: where one scene is comedic to one part of the audience, seriousness could be interpreted by others. The writer uses

How far do you agree with the view that America was a land of opportunity during the 1920s?"

1732 words - 7 pages "How far do you agree with the view that America was a land of opportunity during the 1920s?" Explain your answer using sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and your own knowledge. (40 marks) The 1920s are widely known as the 'Boom Era', or the 'Roaring Twenties' and a "decade of lively economic growth" (Source 3), due to the sheer economic success and advancement, and the emergence of the motor car, Hollywood, consumerism and

Explain the Stages of a Symposium with Close and Detailed Reference to Vase Paintings You Have Studied

846 words - 4 pages Explain the stages of a Symposium with close and detailed reference to vase paintings you have studied. The symposium was an all male drinking party that was very popular during the Archaic and Classical periods. It was an aristocratic activity used to cement friendships, and each member in a group of friends would take it in turns to host this event. The participants would also take it in turns to supply the drink, although it was up to the

Do You Agree with the View That the Work of William Howard Russell and Roger Fenton Presented the British Public with a Realistic Portrayal of the Crimean War?

895 words - 4 pages Do you agree with the view that the work of William Howard Russell and Roger Fenton presented the British public with a realistic portrayal of the Crimean War? There are a number of different factors that collaborate to show that on one hand Russell and Fenton’s work may have offered an accurate image of the Crimean War and there are factors and sources that show that they possibly could have provided more realistic reports. Firstly, Russell’s

Tma03 Part a Discuss Why It Is Important to Support People to Have a Voice and Express Their Views with Confidence. How Can Care Workers Facilitate This?

1885 words - 8 pages signals. It is body language, it’s the certain inflection we put on words to create emphasis, it’s the way we are recognised as ourselves, and it’s a signature if you like. How many times have we all recognised someone on the radio for example, by just hearing them talk or express views and opinions? It is what makes us unique and sets apart from everybody else. It is communication, whether we can speak or not, we have a voice. Having a voice

Can Welfare-State Reforms in Europe Be Explained by Government Attempts to Improve Economic Efficiency? Discuss with Respect to a Social Policy Reform in Two Countries

2706 words - 11 pages Can welfare-state reforms in Europe be explained by government attempts to improve economic efficiency? Discuss with respect to a social policy reform in two countries. 1. Introduction: Pension systems were first introduced in Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century. In the post-war ‘golden era’ of welfare they were subject to wide expansion and increases in the benefits offered. They became the largest source of state welfare

Do You Agree or Disagree with the Following Statement? in Order to Attract Good Students, a University Should Spend a Lot of Money Funding Social Activities

528 words - 3 pages them with innovative courses, excellent teacher resources and accountable partners. Basically, it is the creative and sometimes even demanding majors and courses that good learners hope to experience in universities the most, but not exciting clubs and bars. It is pretty obvious that lots of top universities have already noticed the demand for good students, and here is an example of a successful experiment by introducing innovative classes

From Your Perspective As A User Of Such Products, You Should Examine How Your Chosen Marketer Has ‘Serviced’ & Interacted With You As A Customer Using Your Understanding & Appreciation Of Marketing,...

784 words - 4 pages doesn't like school despite having a 4.0 grade point average -he has a little sister,Jazmine and baby brother, Jaxon  -can solve a completely scrambled Rubic's Cube in less than 2 minutes -stated that he originally wanted to become a hockey player, incorporating his number (#6) in his signature.   -When he got into the singing business he kept his old signature with the #6 in it. -wore huge black glasses on KissFM, but they were only used as a

Why Can It Be Difficult to Decide Whether or Not a Person Is a Carer and Does It Matter? Base Your Answer on the Case of Someone You Know

820 words - 4 pages Name: Asha Renah 23 February 2011 Part A: Essay Title: Why can it be difficult to decide whether or not a person is a carer, and does it matter? Base your answer on the case of someone you know. In this short piece of writing I will talk about the reason why it’s a great significance to be able to say who is and who isn’t a carer. The value of being recognised for the work being done helps lift the feeling of isolation and

Related Essays

Can You Be Friends With Your Boss?

914 words - 4 pages Can you be friends with your boss? Introduction: This journal is written by Karen Dillon, a former editor of Harvard Business Review. In this journal the author states the perks and the fallouts of being friends with one’s boss. Here, Karen have shared her views about how one should identify whether friendship with one’s boss is a good thing or not depending on five factors. To justify her views, she have included the thoughts, sayings and

Do You Think That Efficiency Can Conflict With Effectiveness?

589 words - 3 pages Do you think that efficiency can conflict with effectiveness? Explain and provide many real live examples as you can. Basically Efficiency and Effectiveness are two sides of a coin. Efficiency is competency in performance or ability to accomplish a job with a minimum expenditure of time and effort while effectiveness to achieve the intended or expected result. Ex. 1 In an advertising campaign. A company could spend millions of

Can A Cusumer Have A Relationship With A Brand

1405 words - 6 pages . Finally, I am going to discuss if customers can have relationships with brands. Goods and Services Sprint Nextel is a communications service organization that offers a wide range of communications services, the most popular being their telephone and cell phone service. The company began as Brown Telephone Company in 1899. Over the next seventy years it continued to prosper, and by the 1970’s, it was considered the nation’s largest independent

Given The Hotel's Stated Employee Preferences, What Recruitment Sources Would You Suggest They Use And ... What Would A Hotel Paris Help Wanted Ad Look Like?

563 words - 3 pages HR Over a typical weekend, literally dozens of want ads for experienced pressers or cleaner-spotters can be ... What would a Hotel Paris help wanted ad look like?Given the hotel's stated employee preferences, what recruitment sources would you suggest they use and ... What would a Hotel Paris help wanted ad look like?Given the hotel's stated employee preferences, what recruitment sources would you suggest they use and ... What would a Hotel