This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

By Definition, Miracles Can Never Happen. Discuss

1639 words - 7 pages

“By definition a miracle can never happen.” Discuss.
The known definition of a miracle is “an extraordinary and welcome event that is not explicable by natural or scientific laws and is therefore attributed to a divine agency.” However, Peter Vardy in The Puzzle of God gave four different definitions provided by many different scholars, including Aquinas and Hume, with Hume believing they are impossible but cannot be disproved compared to Aquinas believing they are completely possible even within the system of natural activity. What a miracle is can be debated forever due to the many different interpretations of who and why they come about, with psychologists such as Freud arguing they are ...view middle of the document...

Freud could be used to support this idea of a miracle not being able to happen due to the fact that the supernatural is non-existent. He argued that God is simply a father figure humans conjure from their minds in order to feel comfort and enable them to escape the realities of this world. This supports the statement as the general definition of a miracle is an event that is brought about by the action of a high being, which Freud states is just a figure of our imagination. Derren Brown agrees with Freud and says that humans use God as a way of moderating and controlling our behaviour when no one is around as we know that there is always someone watching our every move, this does not prove that God is an actual being that can cause real events such as miracles to occur. Therefore, defining miracles as events that God causes means that by definition miracles cannot happen, as there is no real God he is only in our minds.
Aquinas’ definition however, focuses more upon miracles being a result of God; “those things…which are done by divine power apart from the order generally followed in things”, despite this Aquinas also believes that miracles can be part of the order generally followed. The fact that he believes miracles can work within the laws of nature disagrees with the statement that by definition miracles can never happen, as he is not defining it just upon defying the laws of nature, he leaves the definition of miracles open to possibility from “those events in which something is done by God which nature could never do” to “when God does what is usually done by the working of nature, but without the operation of the principles of nature” or “not in that order.” Therefore, by Aquinas’ definition, miracles can happen without doing anything that is physically impossible such as defying laws of nature that everything else in the world seems to follow, as long as God conducts the event in a natural way.
Additionally, Aquinas argued that God’s activity in the world, such as miracles and religious experiences, are simply part of the normal order of things in the natural world, in my opinion, anything the creator of any world chooses to do within it is not abnormal or impossible, because that world already works to the creator’s choice of rules, which the creator can change or stop at any time. Richard Swinburne agrees with this, and argues that perhaps God can suspend the laws of nature and that Hume should not focus so much upon laws of nature as they are not just fixed truths, and said “one must distinguish between a formula being a law and a formula being universally true, being a law which holds without exception” meaning a law and a law which holds without exception are two different things, and that there are many ‘laws’ of nature that are not always universally true.
One could also argue that if by laws of nature we mean, for example, laws of thermodynamics and Newton’s laws of motion, then it is not clear that miracles are in direct...

Other Papers Like By Definition, Miracles Can Never Happen. Discuss

Life of Miracles Essay

1410 words - 6 pages , then scientists will never be able to understand how it arises. Atheists have the same way of thinking except that instead of looking for what had not been explained to find a place for God that they look for Miracles happen every day. They are always happening all around you. You may not notice it, but life’s smallest miracles are always happening. Our perfect universe is a miracle. It is in perfect balance so that Earth can sustain life. In

What Does Justice Mean to Jesus

891 words - 4 pages we know about Jesus he was born in Bethlehem Nazareth and it was around the time of King Herod. This particular king had a horrible plan to kill all of the Jews alive at that time. Of course knowing Jesus was one of them. When Jesus was killed on the cross by the Romans, he sacrificed his life to save all of ours which there you can see is a big example to how Jesus treated people in comparison to how the king did. To give you a better idea of

Notes On Hume & Poppers Different Philosophies

885 words - 4 pages ; make mistakes. It is much more likely that a person in question has lied and/or made a mistake than the person overturned the laws of nature.?Arguments against Hume?s ?miracle thesis?s?:-Do unexplainable, extraordinary events happen in real life? This must be true, despite Hume?s above arguments-Can we be certain that science will explain all such ?miracles? (extraordinary events)? No, we can never be sure; despite advances, scientists will never

Jesus Reflection Essay

791 words - 4 pages never come to discuss them. Christian Worldview really puts your knowledge and beliefs to a level of assessment and the ability to see into your morals and beliefs. First, we have miracles, the meaning of miracles were spoken throughout Mark 5, and John 11, verses that discover the power that Jesus is the Son of God who retains power over satan and his demons. He is a miracle worker when it comes to others, may they be strong or weak he guides

Borges Blue Tigers

821 words - 4 pages and they are also seen as predictive elements. The blue tigers have been present in Alexander dreams for a long time and it is no coincidence then, that the pebbles he finds when he is at the top of the hills are exactly the same colour for which he could never find a word or definition nor another sample of it on earth. This reminds us to the Greek and the importance they conveyed to the meaning of dreams. The illogical process of

Criminal Sentencing

1259 words - 6 pages SentencingThe third goal is "Deterrence" which Catherine discusses, The definition of deterrence is example or threat of punishment to convince people that criminal activity is not worthwhile. Basically crime prevention. The threat of what "may" happen if you commit this crime. By trying to convince someone that if they committed a crime there would be a punishment for those actions. Many feel this is working and the one of the most effective roles in

Youth of India

1254 words - 6 pages benefit society or even the world at large. Miracles start to happen when we give as much energy as to our dreams as we do to our fears. By which we as the youth of our nation, the future of our nation can achieve great and change our developing country to a developed country and fulfil our Kalam’s vision of India 2020.

Religion in the Old Testament

1416 words - 6 pages The Exodus of the Israelites is the equivalent to our present day Fourth of July or Bastille Day to the French. Israelite writers discuss the Exodus the most out of any other event in history. The story of the Exodus is one of the most famous stories of the Old Testament. Three of the most significant aspects of the story of Exodus are the call of Moses, the use of plagues as miracles, and the Passover. Moses was a Hebrew who was raised with

Nt 1310 Final Review

1022 words - 5 pages cables | | | Term Electromagnetic interference can be prevented by what? | | Definition don’t install cables in same panels as electric cables, right angles, run through separate holes, proper separation from electrical devices | | | Term What is the main difference between fiber-optic and copper media? | | Definition FO is immune to EMI, higher data rates, longer distances, more secure | | | Term What is the main

Argument From Religious Experience

1318 words - 6 pages that there are many people who testify to having had such experiences constitutes indirect evidence of God’s existence even to those who have not had such experiences themselves. The Argument from Miracles When and where do religious experiences occur? Religious experiences can happen to anyone, anywhere and at any time. Although religious experiences are somewhat unique, it is not uncommon for them to occur in some very ordinary places. In the


2075 words - 9 pages records as true, even if it is a one second hesitation? This is simply because in the day and age of which is currently being lived, mankind is more open to proper and scientific logic. “Miracles by definition are violations of laws of nature that can only be explained by God's intervention” (Martin, The Transcendental Argument for the Nonexistence of God). If a hot dog were to appear in front of a human right now because he was so hungry and

Related Essays

Can Welfare State Reforms In Europe Be Explained By Government Attempts To Improve Economic Efficiency? Discuss With Respect To A Social Policy Reform In Two Countries

2706 words - 11 pages Can welfare-state reforms in Europe be explained by government attempts to improve economic efficiency? Discuss with respect to a social policy reform in two countries. 1. Introduction: Pension systems were first introduced in Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century. In the post-war ‘golden era’ of welfare they were subject to wide expansion and increases in the benefits offered. They became the largest source of state welfare

The Reason For Increase In Divorce In The Uk Can Be Explained By The Changes In The Law. Discuss This Statement

652 words - 3 pages shows that changing in divorce laws has lead to higher divorce rates. As people now have more choice to divorce for different reasons and men and women are equal. People can divorce because their unhappy or simply fallen out of love. However in more recent years divorce has actually decreased. This could be because it is more common for people to stay in marriages but to be separated. Many couples often find themselves in relationships where the

Paper On Philosophy

573 words - 3 pages ‘A belief in miracles leads to the concept of a God who favours some but not all of his creation’. Discuss. A miracle is either a “violation of the laws of nature,” or “divinely caused,” and Christians argued with the latter definition, further suggesting that miracles are revelations. Both approaches leads us to believe that God favors some but not others because miracles are “infrequent,” and seemingly arbitrary, which questions his

Assess Hume’s Reasons For Rejecting Miracles. (35 Marks)

810 words - 4 pages sources are written in a bias view, many different accounts of the same event by different people would be needed before a record could be trusted, as many miracles only happen to one individual this is not the case and thus, Hume rejected historical miracles. In conclusion Hume’s reasons for rejecting miracles hold some ground as they are logical arguments, the nature of some humans leads to the exaggeration of many stories creating fantastical events that probably never occurred to the extent claimed. The lack of empirical evidence would solidify some of his claims as well as the scientific explanations behind healing ‘miracles’, such as a migraine suddenly healing.