Business Organization And Management Ethics Essay

1506 words - 7 pages


The assignment/paper is an ethics exercise with two different cases to analyze and determines what direction/decision I would take in each case. The first case is to justify my decision to allow a top performing staff member, Kay, to apply for a different position within the company. Kay and I both are aware that I would not be allowed to replace her due to budget cut and a friend of the boss is also applying for the position. The second case is Marty has miss applied an expense for a local community development committee dinner meeting.

Case 1: Stephanie Lyncheski, after careful consideration and working through the Checklist for Making ...view middle of the document...

The individualism view advances long-term self-interests. The moral rights view respects and protects the fundamental rights of people. And the justice view treats people impartially and fairly.
The utilitarian, moral rights and justice views would require I approve Kay’s request to apply for the new position because she is deemed to be a long term employee for the company and is a high performer which in the long term is best for Kay’s growth within the company. On the other hand, the individualism view would require I do not let Kay apply for the position because I need Kay for two main reasons. 1. Kay is a high performer, which helps me look good to my management and 2. I cannot replace anyone who leaves for quite some time due to the budget cuts, which will put additional stress on the my team and myself if she leaves the team.
Step 2: Get the facts: 1. Kay knows my situation that I cannot replace her and she is the top performer within my team. 2. By asking my permission to submit an application for the new position in a different division of the company, tells me she wants to stay with the company but is looking for advancement and more challenging work.
Step 3: Identify your options: Option 1: I can tell her no with an explanation of how much she is needed in my team. Option 2: I can give her permission to apply for the position. Option 3: I can give her permission and request the hiring manager not to consider her due to my team’s needs. Option 4: I could tell the hiring manager about the boss’s friend’s son, to make sure the son gets extra consideration which should keep Kay from being hired for the new position.
Step 4: Test each option: Is it legal? Is it right? Is it beneficial?: Option 1 is legal and beneficial but I do not believe it is right because Kay has worked hard to have the qualification required for the new position and she is a high performer. Option 2 is legal, right and beneficial. Kay is a high performer and has the potential to rise within the company which could help me later because she would appreciate me letting her apply for the position. Option 3 is not legal or right but is beneficial. The benefit is it allows Kay to go through the application process and she will think I am a good manager so when she does not receive the position she will stay with my team. Option 4 is not legal or right but could be beneficial. The possible benefit is Kay would not receive the position and stay with the team.
Step 5: Decide which option to follow: I chose option 2, to give her permission to apply for the position. I know from personal experience, when a manager holds an employee back for their own team’s benefit. it can back fire on the manager. The employee usually will leave the company so the manager is still short an employee and the company did not retain a good employee. It is better to take the high road and help people progress and not hold them back.
Step 6: Double-check your decision by...

Other Papers Like Business Organization and Management Ethics

Organization and Management Analysis

1483 words - 6 pages Organization and Management Analysis By Bianca Andrews Course: HCS/514 March 23, 2014 Professor Samantha Bame Introduction Most, if not all, companies are made up of organizations. As an organization, it consists of people who are structured and managed with a specific purpose. That purpose is to create and achieve one or more specific goals as a whole. The people within the organization all play a different role that helps to

Business Models, Systems and Organization Essay

647 words - 3 pages Business Models, Systems and Organization BUS/211 9-8-2014 Business Models, Systems and Organization Introduction I like to drink coffee; it wakes me up and gives me the boost, although limited, of energy that I need to get my day started. My favorite local business is "The Human Bean" a small drive through building setup to service coffee on both sides. They can get your selection of coffee ready in a flash so that you can drive off

Business Ethics and Deontology

1541 words - 7 pages corporate standards of conduct in a business organization. Whether intended or not, these ethics/standards can have a major impact on an organization bottom-line – it can add value to an organization by showing that it can be trustworthy across all spectrums of business dealing. Adversely, cracks exposed in an organization’s ethical veneer can send investors and consumers fleeing and drive the company to bankruptcy. The objective of this paper is to

Ethics and Business

903 words - 4 pages 1. What does the term ethics mean to you? Do you see a difference between ethics and morality? Explain your answer. When it comes to ethics in business, many companies are famous for their downfall due to poor ethics. A recent example of this is Enron and the accounting fraud that took place. The term ethics can have multiple meanings, and can often be thought of as morality. To me, the definition of ethics is the ability to judge what is

Ethics and Business

813 words - 4 pages than she is with the questionable business practices that her corporation is involved in. In the memo Sherron does not raise question on the social ethics of the situation. Social ethics would be the responsibility Enron has to the greater society and to the employees of the organization itself. Sherron seems more concerned about how it would hurt her saying “eight years of Enron work history will be nothing on my resume.” The situation raises

Business Values and Ethics

880 words - 4 pages for judgment about what is important for the organization in its business. Values are embodiment of what an organization stands for, and should be the basis for behavior of its members. How do value relate to ethics? Values are what we, as a profession. Judge to be right “individually or organizationally”, values determine what is right and what is wrong, and doing what is right or wrong is what we mean by ethics. To behave ethically is to

Business and Ethics

1342 words - 6 pages that we had the opportunity to hear speak in class. He is a very well known and accomplished non-profit executive with an extensive record in helping children grow into what they aspire to be. He provides leadership, management and direction to boys and girls club organizations in completing its tasks of developing children into positive, productive, open-minded, and responsible adult citizens. Ron Greene’s overall goal if nothing else is to impact

Business Ethics and Professional

1649 words - 7 pages Chapter 9 Self-Assessment: Followership Styles Kelley proposes critical attributes that recognize exemplary and incapable followers. One of the traits is that followers focus on objectives within a large framework and decide on the role to perform at a specific time to expedite the accomplishment of organizational goals. An adherents' demonstration of commitment and duty to the organization beyond the individual level, separates them from

Business Ethics and Dilemmas

1040 words - 5 pages Business Ethics |Definition: Ethics are the moral principles that should underpin decision making. A decision made on ethics might reject the most | |profitable solution in favour of one of greater benefit to society as well as the firm. | It is important at this stage to distinguish between an ethical decision and a lawful decision. It may be legal for a public house to sell alcohol products to

Business Law and Ethics

2529 words - 11 pages pub and the future strategy and plan of the pub with which Tom agreed. So it unwise to claim that he was unaware about the prospect and future actions of the pub and therefore there is no question of discrimination on the ground of sexual orientation. “This is not a gay pub” vs. “Under new management…friendly staff.” “It is also against the law for someone you work for to have rules, policies or practices, which though not aimed at you

Management Planning And Ethics

931 words - 4 pages administration no matter the size of organization except for the self-employed. Keeping the morality at workplace is truly important. Filling out the form according to the Employee Handbook is the written proof of communication between the management and the employees.ConclusionSince CEO plan on hiring more staffs in the near future, his action of organizational restructuring seems to be good and the organization is getting ready for expansion. He also encourages employees to gain more knowledge by training.This organization starts to earn more revenues comparing to the last year.References:

Related Essays

Business Ethics In Organization Essay

1901 words - 8 pages PRACTICE OF BUSINESS ETHICS MMUI J131 • Rotua Veronika Ariester • Sarah Afifah • Samuel Krissandi • Ronald • Eldhie Sya'banni • Reffit Gustaroska ORGANIZATIONAL ETHICS DEFINITIONS  Organizational Culture: The values, beliefs, and norms that all the employees of that organization share  Value Chain: The key functional inputs that an organization provides in the transformation of raw materials into a delivered product or service

Business Ethics In An Organization With Theories

4367 words - 18 pages Organizational Communication' Management Communication Quaterly Vol-20 No-1, pp.39-62Trevino, L. K., & Nelson, K. A. (2004) Managing business ethics Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.Vargo, S.L. and R.F. Lusch. 2004. "Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing." Journal of Marketing, Vol. 68 (January 2004): 1-17William, L (1971) An Introduction to Ethics. London: MethuenWolf, N (1991) The Beauty Myth: How Images of Beauty are Used against Women. New York: Harper Collins Publisher IncYukl, G (2006). Leadership in Organisations. 6th ed. New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Ethics In Business And Management Essay

2126 words - 9 pages , they are the investors and they have the right to make the most profit out of the mine because it is their investment. If however, assuming life is the most important element, then clearly, the residents have every right to invade the mine to make the living. Barrick’s right to profit is outweighed by the villagers’ right of living. On the other hand, based on ethical egoism, an individual or a business should only act according to their own

Business Organization And Adr Essay

1418 words - 6 pages Running head: BUSINESS ORGANIZATION AND ADR Business Organization and ADR Celestine Moore Business Law 575 November 18, 2013 Professor Thomas Kershaw Business Organization and ADR When starting a business as an entrepreneur involves the process of decision-making of several or one specific entity to assist with determining which type to form “such as,” general, limited, cooperative, joint partnership, a franchise, or sole proprietorship. However