This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Business Law Essay

1312 words - 6 pages

Scenario Summary |
Virginia Pollard worked as a cashier and clerk for Teddy’s Supplies, a family-owned chain of film production equipment supply stores in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.  During a routine performance evaluation, Virginia's supervisor at Teddy's complained that she made too many personal phone calls when she worked in the West Orange store.  The supervisor noted this on Virginia's annual review, and warned her to keep personal calls to a bare minimum while at work.  Soon thereafter, Teddy transferred Pollard to guard film equipment in the main warehouse behind the storefront; Virginia couldn't make personal calls there, and her work became exemplary. Her performance evaluation ...view middle of the document...

In that case, the employee should report using the company website form which will submit the incident to Human Resources."
Pollard never filed a complaint with Steve King, her supervisor; she also did not file a complaint at the website, although she claimed she told King in July 2008 that she felt she was being "picked on" by the guys she worked with. She claims Steve King told her to "grow some balls" and to "get over herself." She testified during the NJ Human Rights Commission hearing that she tried to file an anonymous complaint but the website wasn't working the day she tried to do so.
In August of 2008, King and the other warehouse workers put a sign on a truck that read "HARDHAT REQUIRED/BRA OPTIONAL." King and another employee called Pollard over to look at the sign and encouraged her to do as it said. She refused and tried to walk away. King promised not to report her to management, whereupon she lifted one side of her shirt in the back and exposed part of her bra on her backside. Upper management learned of the incident that October by a co-worker who filed an anonymous complaint online.  After a brief investigation, Pollard was fired for exposing her bra. None of the men were disciplined. A man replaced Pollard in the guard shack.
That November, Pollard filed a charge of sex discrimination with the New Jersey Commission on Human Rights. The Commission found that Pollard had been the victim of sex discrimination and that Teddy's reasons for firing her were pretext, and awarded her back wages and damages. Teddy's appealed to the circuit court, including in their case that Pollard had committed several infractions, including participating in the spanking incident. They reported that Pollard had failed to report any sexual harassment and included a copy of their sexual harassment policy as part of their defense case. The Circuit Court found that Teddy did have good reason to discipline Pollard but that firing her was in fact disparate treatment when compared with the utter lack of discipline given to King. The circuit court reversed the Commission's award of damages because it believed that Teddy had been right to discipline Pollard, but they ordered Teddy's to reinstate Pollard to her old position. Pollard appealed to the New Jersey Court of Appeals and refused to accept her job back.
Your Role/Assignment |
You are an independent Human Resources Consultant that was hired by Teddy’s Supplies to consult on this case during the appeal.

1. Teddy's Supplies' CEO has asked you to advise him on the facts of the case and your opinion of their potential liability. Write a memo to him that states your view of whether the company is exposed to liability on all issues you feel are in play. Include in your memo any laws that apply and any precedent cases either for or against...

Other Papers Like Business Law

Business Law Essay

935 words - 4 pages punishment for violation of the crimes. It also helps to resolves disputes by providing a basis for deciding the legal interest and rights to every party involved in the dispute. Modern law in the United States regulate businesses and individuals in a combination of constitutional law, statutory law, common law and administrative law on a federal, state, or local level. (Melvin, 2011) The function and role of law in business can help with the

Business Law Essay

1230 words - 5 pages BUSINESS LAW IN CROSSBORDER TRANSACTIONS Question 1 Common Law and Civil Law are two of the world’s legal systems. Common Law, which is also called Anglo-American law, has its roots in England and implicit in former English colonies like USA, Australia, most of Canada and Malaysia. On the other hand, Civil Law, which is also known as Continental European, is originated from Western Europe and divided into four groups. The first one is

Business Law

1361 words - 6 pages , patents and copyrights, and ordinary contract rights, has only conceptual existence and thus does not come under Article 2. A moveable item can be carried from place to place. Tangible property is property that has physical existence and can be distinguished by the senses of touch and sight. A car is a tangible property; a patent right is intangible property. (Miller, Jentz. Business Law Today: Comprehensive. 9. VitalSource Bookshelf. South Western

Business Law - 4137 words

4137 words - 17 pages Chapter 43 Law for Small Business ------------------------------------------------- Section 1: The Importance of Legal Counsel ------------------------------------------------- Section 1: The Importance of Legal Counsel This chapter will cover the specific laws for small business owners and requirements needed for someone to start their own small business. The legal principles in this chapter are applied in the context of a small

Business Law - 1508 words

1508 words - 7 pages principles and cases and thus reliance on what others have written is necessary. This guide attempts to provide you with some assistance in writing and referencing law academic papers. Some basic resource materials are also noted. [NB: This guide is a starting point only.] There are two types of Law Academic Papers Students who take the Business Law Major will inevitably be expected, at some stage, to answer at least two different

Business Law - 928 words

928 words - 4 pages IRAC Method of Case Study Analysis Nsima Etok and Christopher Dunbar Business Law 531 March 31 2015 Gregory Martins Introduction In any type of business, whether it is partnership, Limited Liability Company (LLC) and or a Corporation, these are seen as different types of businesses that involves one, two or more People. The same is implied to businesses that are operated internationally between different

Business Law - 369 words

369 words - 2 pages Problem 1 ISSUE Is the terms of Ash’s contract with Davis Car Rental Pty Ltd unfair under the ACL? LAW ACL s.23 states that a consumer’s contract is unfair if: * It causes a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations, * It is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the business; and * It would cause detriment to the consumer. APPLICATION The car hire contract is considered as a

Business Law - 1696 words

1696 words - 7 pages are the flexibility and inexpensive way you can organize and control the company. The owner can create their own policy and procedures as long as they are with the parameters of the law. They receive all income generated by their business and can reinvest as they see fit. Disadvantages There are a few disadvantages sole owners can experience such as raising funds, use their own personal savings and acquiring debt through business loans

Business Law - 1666 words

1666 words - 7 pages Duress to act like a defence in contract law. Tort of Conspiracy happens when two or more commits and agrees on a course of conduct to harm another, involves lawful acts, performed in furtherance of the agreement and the plaintiff to suffer damages. In the case of Wu Yang Construction Group Ltd v Zhejiang Jinyi Group Co Ltd (2006), employees who conspire to resign from their jobs at once and negatively affecting the employer’s business and

Business Law - 3883 words

3883 words - 16 pages AbstractInternational trade has existed since times immemorial and can be dated as long back as 2000 B. C. With the increasing complexities and volumes in international trade, an urgent need for a uniform code for regulating these transactions was keenly felt in present day economy where domestic and foreign politics play their influencing role in conducting transnational business. International Law for business aims at providing the regulations

Business Law - 692 words

692 words - 3 pages Business Law Q.1. What is meant by discharge of contract? Discharge of contract relates to the circumstances in which the contract is brought to an end. Where a contract is discharged, each party is freed from their continuing obligations under the contract. A contract may be discharged in one of the following ways: * Discharge by Performance * Discharge by Breach * Discharge by Agreement * Discharge by Frustration

Related Essays

Business Law Essay 629 Words

629 words - 3 pages employer or a doctor or even a public place where one can make phone calls. Statutory Law Most new law is statutory law. It affects each of us in business, professional and personal lives. This is more a people-made law or a law made as a result of people electing local legislators who pass state statutes; people vote for senators and representatives who create federal statutes. Example: Criminal Law. Bills Bill is a proposed statute

Business Law Essay 908 Words

908 words - 4 pages Business Law 315 - Chapter 1 Review Questions 1. In the common law system of the United States, a crime is defined as: a. a private wrong that necessitates litigation between the victim and the perpetrator b. any act prohibited by the government and made punishable through imprisonment or fines c. litigation where the injured party sues to recover compensation for the damages and injury sustained as a result of the defendant’s

Business Law Essay 854 Words

854 words - 4 pages between or among independent nations. * Executive Orders laws issued by the President or by the governor of a State.Administrative Law body of law created by administrative agencies to carry out their regulatory powers and duties. | Chapter 2 Definitions | Ethics study of what is right or good for human beings.Business Ethics study of what is right and good in a business setting. | Ethical Theories | Ethical Fundamentalism individuals look

Business Law Essay 982 Words

982 words - 4 pages procedures. The rules are so complex and they can affect other entities of the business this law is very crucial. Administrative law is the rules that have been established by the company. These rules help guide orderly conduct and established goals for the company. The Case and Common Law Doctrines, which has been discussed earlier about. Furthermore, when you think about common law and all the Sources of American law what is it so