This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Business Ethics And Hotel Injury Essay

1724 words - 7 pages

Business Ethics and Hotel Injury

Here are links to TWO cases. The first case, the Margreiter v. New Hotel Monteleone, Inc. case, is the decision to the case in your homework problem. Within that case, you will find mentioned the second case: Nordmann v. National Hotel Company, 425 F.2d. 1103 (5th Cir. 1970). That case establishes the basis by which the court in Margreiter determined the level of duty the New Hotel Monteleone owed to Mr. Margreiter. It may help you with the remainder of this homework.
Read both cases. Then, answer the questions below.
Here are the cases: Margreiter case       Nordmann case (I have attached the links below).

1. During an appeal, the appeals court ...view middle of the document...

The losing party emphasized the opinion of the police man that Margreiter was drunk, it pointed out the inconsistencies in the statement of Margreiter and the lack of memory of Margreiter. The losing party pointed out that Margreiter must have gone out of the Hotel on his own become intoxicated and fallen into wrong company. The losing part further claimed that the injuries suffered by Margreiter were not so great and that he had recovered.
The court relied on the fact that the loser's contention had already been rejected by the jury. The fact that the plaintiff had no history nor intention of straying out at midnight because he had plans with his associates. His associates corroborated his plans in court. The appeals court decided to uphold the verdict of the jurors. In other words the appeals court refused to decide the case on the argument of the plaintiff. In addition, the court relied on the fact that Margreiter had permanent brain damage, continuing headaches, traumatic neurosis, and epilepsy. So, apart from the verdict of the jury, the Appeals court also based its verdict on the medical report of Margreiter.

2. Now review the Nordmann case. The Margreiter court used this case to assist it with making its decision (see line two of paragraph #4 of the Margreiter opinion.) What did the Nordmann court say was the "duty of care" a hotel owes to a guest to protect him from injury by third persons?  Provide that here. Then, review the facts that the Nordmann court relied on to determine there had been a breach of the duty by the Nordmann court. Briefly recite those here as well. (Points: 10)

In Nordmann v. National Hotel Company, 425 F.2d 1103 (5th Cir. 1970), the Nordmann court said that the law imposes upon innkeepers at least ordinary or reasonable care to protect their guests against injury by third persons and some case call for the exercise of a higher degree of care. The court held the defendants to a standard of ordinary or reasonable care to protect the hotel's guest from injury by third person.
the facts that the court relied on in the Nordmann case to establish that there was a breach of duty are as follows. The verdict of the jury, the testimony of the occupant of the adjoining room David DuCharme who heard the robbery and assault taking place and who called the hotel operator and the room clerk asking for police but the police was not called immediately. The police were called in only 40 minutes after the assault because the room clerk claimed that he was very busy at that time. One examination of the facts, the court reached the conclusion that the defendants had failed to perform their general duty to protect their guest. The breach of duty was committed because criminals, sex deviates, and vagrants were allowed to wander indiscriminately about the hotel, there was failure to maintain competent staff of employee, failure to maintain adequate security personnel, failure to summon the police immediately and failure to...

Other Papers Like Business Ethics and Hotel Injury

Business Ethics and Dilemmas Essay

1040 words - 5 pages Business Ethics |Definition: Ethics are the moral principles that should underpin decision making. A decision made on ethics might reject the most | |profitable solution in favour of one of greater benefit to society as well as the firm. | It is important at this stage to distinguish between an ethical decision and a lawful decision. It may be legal for a public house to sell alcohol products to

Business and Ethics Essay

1342 words - 6 pages , there is a great and growing concern about the moral and ethical behavior of the people placed in leadership. Rule violations within intercollegiate athletics have risen, which has led to increased pressure on leadership to encourage positive ethical behavior. A result of the growing concern has been established by the codes of ethics made by intercollegiate conferences. Because we know that intercollegiate athletics has its share of ethical

Global Business and Ethics Paper

653 words - 3 pages Global Business and Ethics Paper As former third world countries like China and India continue to grow and become major players in the global marketplace ethical dilemmas also continue to grow. While our media focuses on the state of our economy and on the deteriorating jobs market here at home we have lost focus on the fact that we live in a global economy and that many of the jobs we have lost here have gone overseas. Many of these jobs

Social Media and Business Ethics

1355 words - 6 pages Social Media’s Impact on Business Ethics Introduction: The discussion of ethical problems associated with social media in the workplace is a relatively new occurrence. Approximately ten years ago technology entered a new phase evolving from the internet and email to an entirely different era (Ramos-Hernadez, 2007). Suddenly people who normally worked a 9 to 5 shift leaving work to transition into their personal lives. Facebook, Twitter

Business Ethics and Ethical Reasoning

1083 words - 5 pages Business Ethics and Ethical Reasoning Managers are faced with daily decisions to ensure that they are leading by example in their managerial position. Managers must make sure their actions are fair, honorable, and reasonable to employees and customers is the groundwork of good ethical decision making. In today’s society ethical issues are becoming extremely complicated because of global and diversification in corporations. A broad explanation

Business Ethics and Moral Philosophy

1297 words - 6 pages Applying Moral Philosophies to Business Ethics Moral philosophies - present guidelines for determining how conflicts in human interests are to be settled and for optimizing mutual benefit of people living together in groups. --There is no one correct way to resolve ethical issues in business. -- Each type of philosophy has a distinct basis for deciding whether a particular action is right or wrong. -- Ethics issues analyzed using different

Business Organization and Management Ethics

1506 words - 7 pages Abstract The assignment/paper is an ethics exercise with two different cases to analyze and determines what direction/decision I would take in each case. The first case is to justify my decision to allow a top performing staff member, Kay, to apply for a different position within the company. Kay and I both are aware that I would not be allowed to replace her due to budget cut and a friend of the boss is also applying for the position. The

Germany and South Africa Business Ethics

1492 words - 6 pages Business ethics can be described as different things everyone has their own thoughts on what business ethics are or should be, different parts of the world are also looking at things the same way Germany, South Africa, and the United States of America can be described as three totally different countries with different languages and totally different ways of life, so of course their business ethics are going to be different. Germany and

Cultural Issues and Ethics in International Business

1498 words - 6 pages Cultural Issues and Ethics in International Business Introduction The expansive and unstoppable process of globalization has forced employers to form their ability to trade and negotiate with the outside world. However, it is important not only they are immersed in this subject, your staff, or one who is qualified to do so, you should also have access to the most significant aspects of foreign trade, logistics, and the impact. Companies

Ethics and Moral Issues in Business

674 words - 3 pages accomplishments and discover parts where advancement is required. Business ethics can be defined as written and unwritten codes of beliefs and values that manage choices and actions within a company. In the business world, the company’s value sets standards for defining the difference between good and bad choices and behavior. In the most basic terms, a definition for business ethics boils down to knowing the difference between right and wrong and

Shangri-La Hotel Public Company Limited Business Analysis, Company Profile and Financial Analysis - Jsb Market Research

954 words - 4 pages Shangri-La Hotel Public Company Limited Business Analysis, Company Profile and Financial Analysis Released On 9th July 2015 Summary "Shangri-La Hotel Public Company Limited Business Analysis, Company Profile and Financial Analysis" contains in depth information and data about the company and its operations. The profile contains a company overview, key facts, major products and services, financial ratios, financial analysis, key

Related Essays

Ethics And Business Essay

903 words - 4 pages 1. What does the term ethics mean to you? Do you see a difference between ethics and morality? Explain your answer. When it comes to ethics in business, many companies are famous for their downfall due to poor ethics. A recent example of this is Enron and the accounting fraud that took place. The term ethics can have multiple meanings, and can often be thought of as morality. To me, the definition of ethics is the ability to judge what is

Business Ethics And Deontology Essay

1541 words - 7 pages corporate standards of conduct in a business organization. Whether intended or not, these ethics/standards can have a major impact on an organization bottom-line – it can add value to an organization by showing that it can be trustworthy across all spectrums of business dealing. Adversely, cracks exposed in an organization’s ethical veneer can send investors and consumers fleeing and drive the company to bankruptcy. The objective of this paper is to

Business Values And Ethics Essay

880 words - 4 pages Define Values and Ethics GEN 200 May 26, 2010 Define Values and Ethics Values and ethics are very important to any firm or corporate business. First of all, what do we mean by values and ethics. In 1986 the theme for the Army was values. The listed four organizational values are loyalty, duty, and selfless of services. The four individual values are commitment, candor, and courage. (2008, April 19). Values provide the basis

Ethics And Business Essay

813 words - 4 pages Ethics and Business In this paper we will review how ethics plays a role in business by examining a memo that was written between two Enron executives. Enron was an energies and commodities corporation who is most known for their insider trading scandal in the early 2000’s that resulted in bankruptcy. They were one of the five largest audit and accounting partnerships in the world and their financial fraud caused clients and shareholders to