This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Broken Government Essay

2811 words - 12 pages

ES 213 Macroeconomics
Broken Government
John W. Dean’s book, Broken Government: How Republican Rule Destroyed the Legislative, Executive, and Judicial Branches, perfectly explains how today’s current state of government is in shambles. The blame cannot be harbored on the shoulders of one individual, rather the repeated actions of decades of GOP and ultra-conservative politicians. Their actions have questioned the relevance of the Constitution of the United States and the entire framework of the government system. Currently, the legislative branch is broken but under repair, the executive branch is broken and needs to be repaired, and judicial branch is nearing the breaking point. However, ...view middle of the document...

This was especially prevalent in the $2 billion mistake that the Republicans made and refused to fix. In short, the House and Senate passed different versions of the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005. The Act that was narrowly passed in the Senate gave patients thirty-six months payment for oxygen equipment and thirteen months payment for durable medical equipment like wheelchairs and hospital beds. The Act that was also passed, by the slightest of margins in the House where it was mistakenly written wrong, gave thirty-six months payment for all equipment to patients that needed it. When the mistake was recognized by the Senate pro tempore, he simply asked the Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert, a stout, super-conservative Republican, to ratify what was supposed to be the correct version of the bill at thirteen months of payment. He agreed on the thirteen month limit and the two sent it along to the President who quickly stamped the bill into law (Dean 52). These differences in benefit limits resulted in a difference of $2 billion for Medicare patients. So this “law”, if one would like to call it that, which is now in place, was not approved by the House, a clear violation of the Constitution. It is clearly stated in Article 1, Section 7 of the Constitution that both houses of Congress must agree on the same version of a bill for it to become law. This bill was not passed by the House of Representatives and many prominent law professors, from top of the line law schools, will verify that what is in place is most definitely not a law. No legal action was ever able to be taken against this because the decision would be upheld in conservative court rooms and higher conservative appellate courts.
Along with basic representation not being followed, the GOP controlled Congress was hardly ever in session. The Republicans favored a two day work week, allowing them to put a limit on the time bills were able to be debated. Representatives were only able to lobby for or against a bill for two minutes and that was it. After all of these short debate sessions were finished, they then allowed unlimited time to vote on the bills, instead of the mandated fifteen minutes. This allowed them to twist the arms and bribe people who were undecided or against their conservative policies into voting for them (Dean 37). This is not how bills are supposed to be proposed and approved in the legislative branch.
The legislative’s power to check and balance the President was also non-existent under Republican rule. They basically told the President that he was free to do whatever he wanted and Congress wouldn’t find any of his actions necessary for investigation. Prime instances of Presidential actions that should have warranted investigation were ignoring homeland security, allegations of torture, and the illegal surveillance of phone calls (Dean 41). Another instance would be when President Bush declared war on Iraq before going to Congress. Article 1 of the Constitution...

Other Papers Like Broken Government

Cvxbffbfs Essay

920 words - 4 pages families are also more likely to have difficulties in school. * Children from broken families are nearly five times more likely to suffer damaging mental troubles than those whose parents stay together, Government research has found. It also showed that two parents are much better than one if children are to avoid slipping into emotional distress and anti-social behavior. The findings say that children’s family backgrounds are as important

Lady Macbeth As The True Villain With Teacher Commentary

998 words - 4 pages At the end of the play Macbeth is a broken man”. Do you agree? How does the downfall of Macbeth maintain audience interest and how is the ending essential to the tragedy of Macbeth? At the end of the play Macbeth is a broken man because throughout the play he has continued to dig a hole of pity and self remorse, and his conscience comes to a point where there is no turning back. [[well put – in a sense you are defining “broken man” here

Broken Family

1934 words - 8 pages in the U.S. nearly doubled in the period from 1968-2003. ARTICLE 4 Politicians in opposition tend to denounce the "broken society" around them. When they get into government, however, they usually come round to the view that most of the society for which they are responsible functions well. They decide that problems are restricted to a defined number of thousands of troubled families – and draw up policies to deliver targeted help to them

American Democracy or Democratic Government

690 words - 3 pages ). People’s opinions on the word democracy vary from one to the next, others feel we are a silent republic instead of a democracy and some feel we are a democratic government only looking for world power. Democracy would be defined as a government ran by its people or elected representatives in a free nation without ruling from kings, and communist leaders. As you look at the word Democracy it is broken down into two parts “Demos” and “Kratiaâ


1051 words - 5 pages national reorganization and government control on a scale not seen before. Franklin Delano Roosevelt was born into a wealthy aristocratic family. He grew up on a large estate in the New York area. He greatly admired his 5th cousin, President Theodore ‘Teddy’ Roosevelt and early on had aspirations of following in his footsteps. Given the economic conditions at the time, Roosevelt won the 1932 presidential race “by a landslide”. His platform was

To What Extent Was the Canadian Government Treatment of the First Nation of the Prairies Justified

923 words - 4 pages . The soil was also very barren on the prairies, which could not compare to the fertile lands around the Great Lakes. The land had not been fully cleared and broken. Due to the fugitive weather in prairies, the farmers also struggled with the drought and insects. The Cree chief Poundmaker also tried to farm, but his crops died in drought one year. It was quiet clear that the Canadian government was not ready to deal with the life that they promised

Accounting Repsonabity

542 words - 3 pages are enforced. 2. Bank of America Corporation Other Release No.: 34-73243 I am going to use this article to show laws that were broken relating to keeping books and records in reasonable detail. 3. Beatty, J. F., Samuelson, S. S., & Bredeson, D. M. (2013). Introduction to Business Law. Mason, OH: Cengage Learning. I am going to use this source to discuss the responsibly of each client. 4. Chaffee, E. C. (2014). LEAD ARTICLES

Iraq Facing Problems

605 words - 3 pages Mohammed Sabir Essay 1 Writing 3 Iraq has many problems over the past decade. As today, Iraqi government is trying to develop and enhance their country. The environment of Iraq becomes more polluted every day. Because of the toxic gases which produced by the factories. However, this is just one the problems that Iraq is facing today. Iraq is facing three important challenges or problems which are political, religious, and educational

Gone With The Wind

875 words - 4 pages acres far more than they could ever belong to her. Her roots went deep into the blood-colored soil and sucked up life, as did the cotton...Tomorrow there would be so many things to do." (413-4) Her self-imposed desire for progress and the future overrides the faults of Reconstruction, perhaps indicating Mitchell's laissez-faire approach to government. Among those faults are the Northern soldiers, one of whom enters Tara with Scarlett the only able

Btec Health and Social Unit 11

4827 words - 20 pages is due to the government cuts and the government may not perceive this risk as something a substantial amount of money has to be spent on. Broken Swing: There are several potential risks of having a broken swing within a children’s play area. These risks can be eliminated in different ways. The first way to minimize this risk is to have the council to put up a sign up which clearly states that’’ this equipment is cannot be used due to the

Privatization of Government

645 words - 3 pages Privatization of Government We have all heard politicians talk about the benefits of privatizing government can save money. In actuality, the savings are not always there. Obscured fees for items such as contract monitoring and sub-par administration can end up costing more than the cost to perform the same tasks in-house. The Government Finance Officers Association estimates that hidden and indirect fees add up to 25% of the actual contract

Related Essays

The Effect Of Broken Homes On Academic Peformance Among Secondary School Students In Akamkpa Local Government Area Of Cross River State

849 words - 4 pages . The concept of broken homes contributed to the falling standard of education in the country. It is based on this premise that this research work dealt with the impact of broken homes and students` academic performance in secondary schools in Akamkpa Local Government Area, Cross River state. According to Collins Advanced Dictionary of English, define home as a family unit. It’s composed of the father, mother, children, and sometimes with any other

Impacts Of Broken Home On Academic Performance

3749 words - 15 pages ABSTRACT This survey research conducted to find out the effect of broken homes on primary school pupils academic achievement in Jere Local Government Area. Two objectives and three research questions where formulated to guide the study. The population of the study consist of all the senior pupils in four selected school in Jere Local Area. Through the process of simple random sampling a total number of 100 pupils where selected to participate

Effect Of Broken Homes Essay

6959 words - 28 pages primary goals of education. Teacher’s welfare in terms of better condition of service and encouraging pay package with lots of incentives to make teachers more dutiful and dedicated. Government should also provide welfare for children from broken homes so as to alleviate the obvious predicament and put in place legislative and judiciary policy so that provision for taking care of the educational responsibility and needs of

The Broken Window Fallacy Essay

909 words - 4 pages or necessary, the government shortfall in other budgets is a direct result of them. The government is making the tradeoff that base operations can suffer in order to continue to fight these wars. REFERENCE PAGE WIKIPEDIA.ORG, PARABLE OF THE BROKEN WINDOW, ACCESSED FEB 4, 2010 THAT WHICH IS SEEN, AND THAT WHICH IS NOT SEEN, FREDERIC BASTIAT, 1850 ECONOMICS IN ONE LESSON, HENRY HAZLITT, 1946