This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Briefly Explain The Role Of Autonomy In Kantian Ethics. Then Argue Either That Kant Is Correct Or Incorrect In Claiming That Morality Requires Autonomy

983 words - 4 pages

Autonomy provides self-identification and placement in a person culture. Immanuel Kant believes that autonomy plays a big role in making ethical decisions. I believe that is correct and this is because morals vary from culture to culture and universalizability does not exist. Morals are supposed to bring good but there are circumstances where a moral action might bring damage. Due to this premise I feel as though it is not always right to do the duty that is expected. I also believe that if a duty is imposed on us, the fulfillment of that duty will not make us any more ethical.
To explain my universalizability statement, Immanuel Kant believes that acting immorally is unreasonable because ...view middle of the document...

Kant proved the relationship of morality and rationality in his Argument for the Irrationality of Immorality. Also referring back to the quote about categorical imperatives, it displays that our morality does not depend on our desires, because if it did people would avoid their moral duty to do what they want or enjoy. This point is important because it shows that acting out of our desires would be immoral and therefore irrational because in order to be a moral act, it would have to require the action to have a good reason by all people.
My stance on Kant’s thinking is two-sided, in the thought that I agree with him on most of his thoughts and philosophical knowledge but also I disagree with him on some of his ideas. I agree with about all of Kant’s ideas, except that the morality of an action depends on it to be universalizable. I can see where Kant gets his idea, but a believe that many rational actions that can fulfill our moral duty cannot be universalizable because of the difference of cultures in the world. I believe as Kant said that morality relies on the intentions of the actions, but what if your good intentions cause you harm? Martin Luther King Jr died with good intentions and although he had good intentions, his killer was opposed to what MLK stood for as well as a good portion of people back then. There were other people who also disagreed with his methods such as Malcom X, but just because some culture or group of people may not agree with your actions, should that stop you from doing them? I believe it should not stop you from acting out in what you believe is morally right only because it is not accepted in other places or even in your culture. Kant would disagree on this point and say those acts are irrationally...

Other Papers Like Briefly Explain the Role of Autonomy in Kantian Ethics. Then Argue Either That Kant Is Correct or Incorrect in Claiming That Morality Requires Autonomy

What Are the Four Legal Means That Affect Employment Practices in Canada? Identify and Briefly Describe Each One

599 words - 3 pages What are the four legal means that affect employment practices in Canada? Identify and briefly describe each one. (20 marks) The four legal means that affect employment practices in Canada are: 1. Constitutional law. 2. Human rights legislation. 3. Employment equity legislation. 4. Labour law, employment standard and related legislation. Constitutional law: Constitutional law is the core of supreme law of Canada that incorporates all

Many Experts Argue That People Do Their Best Work When They Are Motivated by a Sense of Purpose Rather Than the Pursuit of Money. Do You Agree? Critically Evaluate and Explain Your Position

1928 words - 8 pages hierarchy of needs theory (Wood, 2010). Another possible explanation for the weakness of intrinsic motivation is that manual workers are often relatively uneducated and hold blue collar jobs. The nature of work that they perform is often repetitive and unchallenging to the mind. As such, blue collar workers might be more inclined to seek a sense of purpose out of the workplace, either in their hobbies or family (Gruenber, 1980). Work becomes

7. Are There Procedures And Processes That Are Common To The Use Of Sdlc, Prototyping, And Agile Methodologies? Explain Any That You Can Identify And Then Indicate Why The Methodologies Are Considered...

4533 words - 19 pages their own developments. As the Chinese individuals get to be trend-setters themselves, they would understand the significance of IPR insurances; in this manner would regard and consent to IPR laws. At the point when the Chinese pioneers see that their benefit is lost on the grounds that other individuals duplicate and offer their items without their authorizations or assents; then they would under standing the disdain that other remote

Some People Think That a University Professor Should Focus Time in Doing Research; While Other Think That the Main Role of a Professor Is to Educate Students in a University

552 words - 3 pages Some people think that a university professor should focus time in doing research; while other think that the main role of a professor is to educate students in a university. Nowadays, when taking about the issue on whether university professors should focus time on doing research or educating students, someone claims that the latter should be the main role for a university professor. Nevertheless, as far as I am concerned, university

Identify The Goal Of The Company And Describe The Strategy That Was Adopted To Achieve It. Explain With Full Reference To Available Information And Data How Successful, Or Otherwise, This Strategy...

1408 words - 6 pages Identify the goal of the company and describe the strategy that was adopted to achieve it. Explain with full reference to available information and data how successful, or otherwise, this strategy turned out to be in practice. Company overview Bunge Company was found in 1818 by a German merchant, Johann Peter Bunge in Amsterdam, Holland. It was to merchandise grains and imports from the Dutch colonies. The company has since grown to become one

Identify the Argument for and Against the View That Morality Is Dependent on Religion

2033 words - 9 pages AO1) Identify the argument for and against the view that morality is dependent on Religion. The relation of morality to religion has been an issue of intense debate during the past century; it is a very diverse and controversial topic and many philosophers have attempted to explore and explain it, but still there remains the question of whether or not morality is dependant on religion or not. To begin my argument, I will first explore in

Is It Correct to Say That India Has Attained Fulfledged Freedom?

541 words - 3 pages Is it correct to say that INDIA HAS ATTAINED FULFLEDGED FREEDOM? On the basis of the right to express opinions constitutionally a basic right assured for the citizen of India, I would like to draw your kind attention to ponder over it before the celebration of India’s Independence on the above cited topic. One may have the freedom to express his or her opinion without affecting the feeling of any individual but when the same tries to act

‘Behaviourists Explain Maladaptive Behaviour in Terms of the Learning Principles That Sustain and Maintain It. Discuss This Statement and Show How a Behaviourists Approach to Therapy Is in Stark...

2495 words - 10 pages conditioning and habit forming. Innately, unconditioned stimuli produce response for example looking away from bright light. Outcomes are dependent on how a response has been conditioned for example a young child may learn to be fearful of a dog or have interest in one. Behaviourist state that learned behaviour is a result of training or conditioning and nothing instinctual. Main Essay There are two main types of conditioning in the behavioural

Which Approach Under the Classical Management Had Ups Practiced That Made Ups Successful in the Past? Explain the Advantages of the Approach

745 words - 3 pages In United States, there is a largest transportation company called united parcel service (UPS). It provides the services on deliver the parcels for the market of domestic by air-express or ground delivery. UPS is a popular company that able to provide a stable and low-cost delivery of small parcels in united state or even the other country. The rule, regulation, policies and procedures have been given to the UPS worker so that they can work well

Research The Four Symbols That Are Traditional For The Four Evangelists. Explain In Written Form Why You Think Each Symbol Reflects The Work Of The Corresponding Evangelist

1420 words - 6 pages right side; and they four had the face of an ox on the left side; they four had also the face of an eagle. (ASV)The root of man is H120אדם'âdâmaw-dawm'From H119; ruddy, that is, a human being (an individual or the species, mankind, etc.): - X another, + hypocrite, + common sort, X low, man (mean, of low degree), person.The root of lion is H738אריה ארי'ărîy 'aryê

Discuss the Role of One or More Factors That Influence Attitudes to Food (4 Marks + 8 Marks)

1113 words - 5 pages Discuss the role of one or more factors that influence attitudes to food (4 marks + 8 marks) Social learning theory emphasises the impact that observing other people has on our own attitudes and behaviour. One way children acquire their attitudes to food is observing and imitating their peers. Birch et al. carried out an experiment finding that children would try a vegetable they disliked if their peers were eating said vegetable. This

Related Essays

Describe How The Principles Of Collaboration And Autonomy Relate To The Principles Of Working In Partnership With Women. Then Critically Analyse How Midwives Apply These Principles To Provide...

1745 words - 7 pages The ANMC Competency Standards for the Midwife (2008) value woman-centred midwifery practice and state that midwives must work in partnership with women and their families. Using the available evidence, describe how the principles of collaboration and autonomy relate to the principles of working in partnership with women. Then critically analyse how midwives apply these principles to provide woman-centred midwifery practice. As stated by

1.State The Administrative Agency That Controls The Regulation. Explain Why This Agency And Your Proposed Regulation Interests You (Briefly). Will This Proposed Regulation Affect You, Or The Business...

538 words - 3 pages instead) and write the following regarding it: 1.State the administrative agency that controls the regulation. Explain why this agency and your proposed regulation interests you (briefly). Will this proposed regulation affect you, or the business in which you are working? If so, how? Submit a copy of the proposed regulation along with your responses to these five questions. The proposed regulation can be submitted as either a separate Word

Describe What Is Meant By The Process Of Nursing And Explain The Role Of The Nurse Within That Process

2121 words - 9 pages team,” (Oxford Dictionary of Nursing, 2003, p. 241.) The significance of this stage of the process is that role of the nurse, in conjunction with other members of the multidisciplinary team, is to provide assistance to patients to manage the plan of care set out for them (Peate, 2012.) Then the patient with the support of the nurse can enhance or stabilise their health, if possible, and recognise signs of deteriorating health (Timby, 2009

Was Polanyi Right To Argue That "Work Is A Vital Human Institution And An End In Itself, Not Just A Means To Aggregate Social Wealth?" How Do Labor Rights Relate To The Five Goals Of Development?

544 words - 3 pages not aim to work for aggregate social wealth, they won't make any money, and also it cannot help the growth of economy. Apparently, people need to work hard and more to gain more money, and have a better living standard, at this point, Polanyi is not that right because only work with effort can produce profit.How do labor rights relate to the five goals of development?The five goals of development are democracy, order, equality, autonomy and