This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Boeing Case Study

2585 words - 11 pages

Corporate Finance
Boeing 777 Case Study

Question 1 - What is the appropriate required rate of return against which to evaluate perspective IRR from Boeing 777?

To evaluate the IRR of Boeing 777, need to compare it against the WACC of Boeing’s commercial business. The first step is to estimate a value for WACC:
1. Cost of Debt

As provided in the case, the tax is 34%, and the cost of debt is 9.73% - derived from the yield to maturity of Boeing-issued debt with a 5-year maturity. As such, the after tax Boeing cost of debt is estimated to be 6.42%.

2. Cost of Equity

To calculate the cost of equity, we ...view middle of the document...

As the S&P 500 is an index representative of the large cap universe, we chose to look at the 58-months S&P 500 beta figures.

To calculate the beta of Boeing’s commercial business, we took out the defence beta by looking at unlevered beta (beta asset) of companies with high defence contribution (or defence pure plays) which are Grumman, Northop and Lockheed.

First, we calculated the beta of debt (assumed equal for all companies, given they have the same risk, and hence it is safe to assume they have similar cost of debt):

βdebt = (9.73% - 8.82%) / 5.4% = 0.169
The table below summarizes the calculations, assuming beta debt of 0.169:

  | Boeing | Grumman | Northop | Lockheed | McDonnell | Average |
% US Space | 26% | 87% | 89% | 85% | 66% |   |
Beta Equity | 0.81 | 0.8 | 0.74 | 0.87 | 0.6 | 0.803 |
Beta Debt | 0.169 | 0.169 | 0.169 | 0.169 | 0.169 | |
Debt/Equity | 0.018 | 1.756 | 1.288 | 1.182 | 2.714 |   |
Beta Asset | 0.799 | 0.398 | 0.418 | 0.490 | 0.285 | 0.435 |

  | Defence Pure Players |   | Commercial/Defence Players |

We can now assume that Boeing Defence unlevered beta is 0.435. We need to take out the Boeing Defence beta from the total Boeing Beta to get the commercial beta.

We are provided with both revenue and asset splits. Because assets provide a historic view of the company, and the commercial sector has been growing fast within Boeing, it makes more sense to look at the revenues split. This split is also a good approximation of Boeing’s target divisional split, which is important in valuing different divisions of a business.

  | Total Boeing | Defence |   | Commercial |
Revenue Split | 100% | 26% | | 74% |
Unlevered Beta | 0.799 | 0.435 | | 0.93 |

The last step is to re-lever the beta and calculate Boeing’s commercial equity beta. Using the same debt-to-equity ratio of 0.018, the equity beta of Boeing commercial is 0.94.

3. Weight of Debt and Equity

We used the market value capital structure of Boeing – 1.8% debt and 98.2% equity (rationale provided in Question 3). We use gross debt instead of net debt, both of which are possible, as long as it is applied consistently in the model.


We now established all the components of the WACC and can apply the initial formula with which results in a WACC of 13.76%.

Question 2 – What is the value of the market risk premium that you have used? To what extent would you use historical excess returns? Explain also the choice of the risk free rate.

Geometric means are more useful for long-term investments. Serial correlation between returns of a specific period will push the arithmetic mean upward which is not an accurate indication of future performance. However, the preference of one over another is a source of academic debate; both have flaws, a blend of the two is optimal, but not available.

Given that we selected a long-term risk-free rate we need to use a measure of long-term market risk to be...

Other Papers Like Boeing Case Study

Boeing 787 Essay

1668 words - 7 pages The Pennsylvania State University Department of Industrial & Manufacturing Engineering IE466: Concurrent Engineering Individual Homework #1 – Boeing 787: The Dreamliner Boeing 787: The Dreamliner Case Study (download from Angel) During the past decade, Boeing watched as their competitor, Airbus, launched several new and very successful aircraft. In 2004, Airbus surpassed Boeing in commercial airplanes

Boeing 7e7 Essay

2384 words - 10 pages Boeing 7E7 It is our understanding that there is a new and better jet to be made. However, with times they way they are, it is extremely risky to embark on an endeavor of this magnitude and not be successful. We have put together a study and recommendation that should assist you in your decision in whether or not to grant final approval to proceed with the project. Although significant investments are required to develop the Boeing 7E7, a

Boeing E-Enabled Advantages

1788 words - 8 pages functionality. This is to recommend that Boeing should look for more promising companies (as a failover backup) that could support e-Enabled if the current supporting bodies fail to deliver through its standards. Other recommendation that can be described in this study case is to offer certain features or software on a free trial or discounted fee to allow airline operator to understand the advantages and scope of e-Enabled services. The awareness and widespread of understanding may need to be improved through not only websites but also other sources of medias.

Boeing And Capitalism

7319 words - 30 pages Boeing and Capitalism in the United States of America Abstract This study investigates American capitalism in a historic perspective. The paper then proceeds to examine the issue on a meso-level with its relation to the company Boeing. Finally it discusses the various entrepreneurial decisions and their impact on the success and failures of the corporation. The approach has been reading relevant historical books, finding articles on the


663 words - 3 pages Week 2 Case; Warren Buffet, 2005 Introduction This case is about Berkshire Hathaway’s bid, through MidAmerican Energy Holdings Company, to acquire PacifiCorp, which is an energy- utilty based company, in order to diversify the activities of Berkshire Hathaway. The ideas of enterprise valuation are portrayed in two methods. These methods are multiple valuation and discount factor. These methods help evaluate the impact that a single

Boeing 777 Case Solution

4524 words - 19 pages share prices appear to have tracked closely with the S&P 500 until about January 1990. The graph of Boeing’s share prices on page 200 of the case looks more closely at the period January 1990 through October 29, 1990. Is the market telling us something about Boeing and the Boeing 777 project? According to the graph of Boeing’s share price on page 200, it is indicated that Boeing had a significant increase in stock price in 1990 when Boeing

Boeing Paper

1112 words - 5 pages Running Head: Week 3Paper Week 3 Paper Rodney Buras MANAGEMENT: THEORY, PRACTICE AND APPLICATION MGT/330 29 December, 2009 – 1 February, 2010 ROBERT BLOOMFIELD Boeing’s Management Social responsibility is an individual or a group’s actions benefiting the society more than oneself or more than one group. Research and development is another avenue the airline companies have. Boeing benefits use of

Boeing Industry

740 words - 3 pages II. Industry Level Boeing Company’s main purpose of business is the production of Airplanes for commercial use and cargo delivery. Boeing Company also engages in different sectors of defense, space, engineering and security industry. They are more known for their work in the earlier. They produce aircrafts for numerous commercial airline companies of numerous countries. The Commercial Aircraft Manufacturing Industry is an extremely

Boeing Al

1421 words - 6 pages BAL may acquire because of the time consuming process. BAL is also geographically disconnected from TBC which could mean inconsistencies in communication. 4)Core business is fairly narrow because it is mostly specialized for ADF so new opportunities with other businesses are very limited. 5)No great relationships with suppliers 6)Top-down management approach and vision from parent The Boeing Company (TBC) is hard to visualize and put into

Boeing Management Planningpaper

688 words - 3 pages {draw:frame} {draw:frame} Boeing Management Planning Legal issues, ethics and corporate social responsibility Like all other companies, Boeing has had its fair share of legal issues. A few of these legal issues include: Lockheed Martin sued Boeing in June, 2003 by claiming that a former employee passed 25,000 documents to McDonnell Douglas that allowed Boeing to win a majority of military satellite launches. According to Boeing (2010

Boeing and Aircraft Management

912 words - 4 pages Programme Description   Duration / Mode of Programme Students may enrol on a full-time or part-time basis. Full-time students must enrol for a minimum of 9-12 credit hours per semester. Part-time students may register for 6 credit hours each semester. The duration of studies for both full-time and part-time students is as follows: Status | Minimum | Normal | Maximum | Part time | 2 academic years | 4 academic years | 5 academic years

Related Essays

Boeing Case Study For Marketing Services

1141 words - 5 pages I.Introduction"Boeing has long talked about expanding into the services area...." Does it make sense? This is the question that we will try to answer in this paper by analyzing the market conditions, the customer needs, and Boeing's core capabilities.Within the commercial aircraft industry, Boeing's focus for value-added service relates primarily to the transport airplane segment, which is expected to grow in the following years.The most

Boeing Essay

1159 words - 5 pages Case Study: Boeing 42 The long list of Boeing's woes seems to have reached its pinnacle in late 2003 with the scandal surrounding the Pentagon deal that alleged inappropriate behavior and the loss of documents by Boeing officials. After his seven-year reign at the head of the organization, December 2003 saw the eventual resignation of Phil Condit. Many breathed a sigh of relief at the news. The problems at Boeing were reportedly endless. From a

Boeing Case Essay

625 words - 3 pages producing Buick sedans in 1998. The third major reason for subcontracting of jobs is also driven by the desire to lower total production costs. Many countries will contribute to a company's development costs in order to gain production plants and develop industries. In the case of The Boeing Company and Japan, the development costs for the 777 jet airliner were $5 billion. …

Case Boeing X Airbus Essay

546 words - 3 pages . $ 1,614 million with the sale of 48 aircraft, the estimated price of 225 million per aircraft and 20% operating margin. Conclusion Analyzing the case study, there is no dominant strategy, since the Boeing develop a super jumbo size of the A3XX or even a larger version of 747, the launch will be prevented, due to strong competition. If Boeing ignore the threat, or do a price war, it would be interesting to launch the Airbus A3XX therefore