Beyond Friendship And Eros Essay

2757 words - 12 pages


this book is the culmination of our over-twenty-year attempt to
articulate the meaning of a dialogical love relationship between a
man and a woman who are married, but not to each other. We will articulate
the meaning of dialogical love throughout this book by reflecting
on concrete examples, seeking the meaning of this relationship in light
of the thought of scholars, and by dialogue between the authors. For
now, we will merely identify dialogical love as love that grows out of
personal interaction that is initiated by the presence of the other and
responds directly to that presence. It contrasts with “love” in which persons
use each other ...view middle of the document...

Macmurray developed an interpretation
of personal love that called for change in the way we think of
the relationship between men and women. Martin Buber and Alfred
Schutz interpret ways of being between persons that imply new understandings
of the relationship between men and women. C. S. Lewis and
Rollo May treat love as a personal relationship and distinguish love
from friendship. Caroline Simon and Robert Solomon treat intergender
friendship directly and explore its relationship to love. In this book we
will share the thought of philosophers who have enlightened our understanding
of the relationship between men and women and will explore
possibilities they suggest.
We will explore possible nontraditional personal relationships
between men and women and give concrete examples of how some of
these possibilities have found fulfillment. We will ask our readers to
entertain the possibility of developing new relationships with persons of
the opposite sex rather than the traditional ones based on sex and romance.
The primary question this new direction raises is not, “Are they friends
or lovers?” but “Is their relationship personal or impersonal?” Relationships
that focus on fitting the designated ways of society are often
impersonal—even when they are called personal relationships such as
friends or lovers. In personal relationships, as we will show, persons
respond to each other as they are present to each other and in ways that
presence calls forth, rather than by following the dictates of societal
roles. When people attempt to relate to each other personally within the
confines of societal structures, they often find their personal relationships
restricted and truncated by these structures. Even those who initially
do not feel their relationship restricted by traditional structures
often look to their personal relationship as it matures, rather than to
society, to define the meaning of that relationship.
Our goals in trying to articulate the way of being that we have
called dialogical love are twofold. Academically, we want to issue a call
for further exploration of what we designate as dialogical love so that it
can be better understood and more clearly articulated. Personally, we
want to help others venture out and explore new personal relationships
that go beyond traditional structures in their quest for abundant being
and deep personal fulfillment.
We can speak of relationships that foster abundant being and deep
personal fulfillment because we have been in such a relationship for over
twenty years. We have encountered other couples who have experienced
similar relationships, some of whom participated in the interviews used
in this book. Those we interviewed shared the common experience of
developing deep fulfilling relationships that do not fit into the accepted
categories of our society—courtship, marriage, affairs, or “just” friend
relationships. We did not...

Other Papers Like Beyond Friendship and Eros

Prostitution Essay

1145 words - 5 pages term eros (Greek erasthai) is used to refer to that part of love constituting a passionate, intense desire for something , For example in the beginning of a man and woman’s relationship. It is a selfish kind of love in which the person only looks for things that can benefit him or her . Philia entails a fondness and appreciation of the other. For the Greeks, the term philia incorporated not just friendship, but also loyalties to family andpolis

Poetry Anthology Essay

5552 words - 23 pages Reflections Of Love Table of Contents Prologue Storge (Affection in families)-Definition The Little Black Boy- William Blake Winter Trees- Sylvia Plath Mother to Son- Langston Hughes Philia (Friendship)- Definition Love and Friendship- Emily Bronte Time to Talk- Robert Frost Eros (Romance)- Definition Somewhere Never Traveled- E.E. Cummings Wind and Window- Robert Frost She Walks in Beauty- Lord George Byron Agape

The Use Of Deconstruction In Public Policy Formation

4072 words - 17 pages aporia as a possible impossibility. It is at once expected and rejected, a coming that no one wants, that is always untimely when it arrives (thus manifesting the nature of event as such). The ultimate border for thinking the tension of "no way" is that between life and death, here and beyond. In the West this relationship has been thought for the most part from the position of "here." Death joins friendship in this problematic since Philosophy

Attitudes Towards Romantic Relationships in Men and Women

1541 words - 7 pages multifaceted and consists of six different styles. The three primary styles were found to be the following. Eros was found to be a portrayal of passionate romance where a strong physical and emotional bond is evidently present. Ludus is more based on the idea of conquest, where the individual attempts to win over as many partners as possible while taking pleasure in transient relationships and remaining uncommitted. Storge stems out of friendship, a slow

Critical Review

1546 words - 7 pages they are, the more attracted by each other they will be. Next, Joseph listed four different types of love. They are lusdus, storge, mania, pragma and eros. The author shows that ludic lover considers love entertainment and excitement while the storgic one think love means peaceful and slow. Another kind of lover is called "manic", elation and depression are what the people belong to this group illustrate about love. The two last types of love

The Language Of Antony And Cleopatra

1742 words - 7 pages seem to make pictures, but just as quickly dissolve into vapours: "My good knave Eros, now thy captain is Even such a body: here I am Antony, Yet cannot hold this visible shape . . ." Empire and honour were lost first. Then Antony believes his lover has been lost, and feels as if his whole identity is evaporating. We have seen Antony as a general, a lover, a noble friend and leader. This speech touches on

Can You Be Friends with Your Boss?

914 words - 4 pages Can you be friends with your boss? Introduction: This journal is written by Karen Dillon, a former editor of Harvard Business Review. In this journal the author states the perks and the fallouts of being friends with one’s boss. Here, Karen have shared her views about how one should identify whether friendship with one’s boss is a good thing or not depending on five factors. To justify her views, she have included the thoughts, sayings and

Situation Ethics

896 words - 4 pages treated equally in business/cost benefit analysis - Ford Pinto) Six Fundamental Principles: 1. "Only one thing is intrinsically good; namely agape" (e.g. telling the truth isn't always good, sometimes lying is better - murderer at the door). Only absolute is agape love. Not eros (sexual), philia (friendship) or storge (family) love. 2. "The ruling norm of Christian decision is love: nothing else". Love replaces the law; law obeyed only in

The Love Songs of the Beatles

1424 words - 6 pages something as that can be composed of different interpretations by different people. LEE is a researcher that came into conclusion and categorized the Different types of love songs: 1. EROS - Romantic love based on physical attraction 2. LUDUS - fun and not serious love 3. STORGE - Love of men about friendship and caring 4. PRAGMA - Love the practical and logical part of the relationship 5. MANIA - Obsessive and jealous 6. AGAPE

The Friendship Between Gene And Finny In A Seperate Peace

1653 words - 7 pages Separate Peace, even friendships born out of conflict can be life altering. A friendship creates so many life changing memories whether it lasts a few days or a lifetime. Someone stated that "Friendship happens on its own accord and consequently the quality and frequency of friendship experiences are beyond our direct control" (Block 1).Gene and Finny's friendship was certainly an example of how unpredictable and transforming relationships can

A Comparison of the Christian and Ancient Greek Cultures

1722 words - 7 pages Christian creation story, Genesis, and in many accounts of the Ancient Greek creation story, the earth began with darkness and nothingness- a void, or Chaos, as known to the Greeks (Genesis 1:2; Tripp 159). This Chaos was the bearer (meaning that he gave birth to) of Ge/Gaia (Earth), Tartarus (underworld), Eros (love and sex), Erebus (darkness), and Nyx (night) (Tripp 159). In the Christian creation story, God is the parallel to the Greek

Related Essays

Eros And Agape Essay

880 words - 4 pages that there are actually four types of love which I suppose we’ve all experienced sometime in our lives. First there is Philos, which means friendship or brotherly love, the word is derived from Philadelphia, known as the “City of Brotherly Love”, second is Storge, which is a family love, referring to the close bond among mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers, third is Eros, which refers to natural or sexual love that can exist between a man and

Essay Three Types Of Love

1103 words - 5 pages , it could look a lot like eros when a man and a woman become that close, but as long as those in the friendship know and don’t exceed their own limits, philos love can continue to unite them as platonic brother and sister for far longer than others expect. For instance, there is a book in the Bible that refers to this kind of love and says: “Whoever finds one friend has found a treasure” (Sirach 5:14). Some people prefer to say that the first love

My Definition Of Love Essay

959 words - 4 pages . Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, and always perseveres.” (1st Corinthians 13:5-7). In order for me to give you my best definition of love, I would have to use the four types of love given by the ancient Greek philosophers. They are phileo, the love of friendship; storge, the love of family and relatives; eros, the love of affection and obsession; and agape, the

Love Attitudes Essay

2673 words - 11 pages two individual’. Although conceptions of love vary widely, the most prominent and influential approach to psychology is Lee’s (1973) love styles and Lee (1988) quoted ‘it is the relationship that is styled, not the lover’ (p. 49). These love styles consist of Eros, Ludus, Storge, Pragma, Mania and Agape, divided into primary and secondary styles (Lee, 1973). According to Lee (1973), ‘Eros’ represents powerful physical and emotional attraction