Belonging Essay Emily Dickinson And Anna Karenina

951 words - 4 pages

Good Morning Year 12 and teachers. Within Emily Dickinson’s Romantic poems ‘I had been hungry all the years’ and ‘I gave myself to him’ and Leo Tolstoy’s novel Anna Karenina, the authors recognize differing sides of social isolation and the social and personal contexts of the authors and characters, which shape the character’s isolation. In both texts the characters’ happiness is contingent on whether the choice is conscious or not. This in turn has shaped my understanding of the perplexing concept of belonging.

Both authors present isolated female protagonists. They show how society has strong expectations of women, which ultimately in these texts lead to their isolation. Emily ...view middle of the document...

She does not conform to her Puritan society and remains content unlike the persona who yields to society, which results only in isolation. In essence, she trades personal happiness and self-identity for social isolation.

In ‘I had been hungry all the years’; Dickinson uses the metaphor of hunger to describe the depth of her initial desire to belong to society. Her hunger is analogous to her desire for emotional and mental belonging. The syntax of phrases such as “ I trembling, drew the table near” suggests her unfamiliarity in sharing a social connection in the word “ trembling”. This is further reinforced through the use of the transferred epithet of the wine as “curious” used to suggest alienation of this experience. As the persona experiences her desire, she soon feels like ‘ a berry of a mountain bush/transplanted to the road’. The initial bewitchment of the laden table repulses her in its artificiality, reflected in her distinct preference for the ‘crumb’. Now in a position to sate her hunger, Dickinson finds that her hunger has disappeared. In other words, having achieved her goal she continued to feel a sense of social isolation. Hence both the persona and Dickinson isolate themselves from society, which can be seen as self-imposed. Their happiness is contingent with their conscious choice of not wanting to belong.

Dickinson and Tolstoy differ in their portrayal of female protagonists; Dickinson epitomizes a woman of strong inner strength, able to withstand social isolation. Her choice to remain a spinster illustrates a moral high ground, unwilling to let social convention warp her perspectives. In contrast, Anna Karenina initially conforms to social expectations. Eventually, however, she defies societal norms by committing adultery flagrantly and living with Vronsky. Anna’s choice to commit adultery is not frowned upon; rather it is her inability to not to keep a...

Other Papers Like Belonging Essay Emily Dickinson and Anna Karenina

Belonging Essay

832 words - 4 pages An individual’s experiences with their society shape their views on belonging, influencing the decisions they make regarding their association with their world and identity. These notions of belonging are explored by the poet Emily Dickinson through her anthology The Selected Poetry of Emily Dickinson, specifically the semi – autobiographical poems “This is my letter to the world”, “I died for beauty but was scarce”, “I had been hungry all the

Emily Dickinson Essay

3679 words - 15 pages another. Adrienne Rich’s reading of Emily Dickinson and her later published essay point out that Emily Dickinson seems to regard herself as “an imperious energy and her poetic creation as a form of aggression.” Rich transfigured understanding of Dickinson and of poetic power in women. Rich also focused attention on the enraged Dickinson of the first feminist conceptions, and turned attention to the little read poem “My Life had stood- a Loaded Gun

The Ending Of Anna Karenina

612 words - 3 pages The Ending of Anna Karenina As we saw at the end of the novel Anna Karenina, Anna ends her tragic life by throwing herself onto the tracks underneath an oncoming train, while begging God for forgiveness during that time. The way Anna's life ended symbolized the rise and fall of her life put together into one incident that took place on the subway. Anna, who at one point was a very prominent woman in the Russian Society, now lived a sad and

Understanding Emily Dickinson

3262 words - 14 pages order to make the reader aware of Emily Dickinson’s poetry diversity. The critic says that this poem, as well as a few of her others, displays the thoughts and feelings a person may be having or even thinking right before they say goodbye for the final time (Bussey, Page 9). Chanthana Chaichit is the author of another critical essay on the poem “Success Is Counted Sweetest.” The name of Chaichit’s essay specifically explains “Emily Dickinson

Coming Full Circle In Anna Karenina

2306 words - 10 pages What happens when you cut yourself off from society, or are cut off by it? This is the main question that Leo Tolstoy explores in Anna Karenina. Isolated from society, Anna is destroyed by a conflict of wills. The desire of the individual is forced to give way to society’s restrictions and requirements, represented in the image of the railroad. Those who do not conform to society will ultimately face death, a fate, that

Emily Dickinson

1636 words - 7 pages Emily Dickinson Emily Dickinson was a brilliant American poet, and an obsessively private writer. During her lifetime, only seven of her eighteen hundred poems were published. Dickinson withdrew from social contact at the age of twenty three and devoted herself to her secret poetry writing. Dickinson was born in Amherst, Massachusetts on December 10, 1830. There she spent most of her life living in the house built in 1813 by her

Because I Could Not Stop for Death

1058 words - 5 pages Emily Dickinson’s “Because I could not stop for Death” is a remarkable masterpiece that exercises thought between the known and the unknown. Critics call Emily Dickinson’s poem a masterpiece with strange “haunting power.” In Dickinson’s poem, “Because I could not stop for Death,” there is much impression in the tone, in symbols, and in the use of imagery that exudes creativity. One might

A Well-Known and World Renowned Famous Poet

780 words - 4 pages successful, which did not bother Dickinson, who in fact, did not want her work to be seen or published due to her fear of being misunderstood. It took over 50years for almost all of her works were published. In fact, when her works she became a well-known and world renowned famous poet, which would have been impossible in her time. Emily Dickinson was a talented and intelligent poet, that never lived to see her work published (Pickard,103). Emily

Ender's Game

582 words - 3 pages LIST OF ESSAYS ON CHARLES DICKENS!!! - 15k - Cached - Similar pages Emily Dickinson - essays on Emily Dickinson Essays on Emily Dickinson's Poetry. Students writing essays on the poetry of Emily Dickinson ...Description: Information on buying essays on the life, works, & poetry of Emily Dickinson.Category: Arts > Literature > Poetry > Poets > D > Dickinson, Emily - 14k

The Tormented Soul Of Emily Dickinson

1368 words - 6 pages Emily Dickinson, the self-secluded poet from Amherst, is now considered one of the greatest American Poets. She, in breaking conventional grammar rules, created a new form of poetry, her own, to attain this title. Through the use of unconventional grammar styles Dickinson was able to create a poem, when read in the mind appears to be incomprehensible, but when read aloud is made clear to the reader. Dickinson also made use of common objects and

Tension Felt in Emily Dickinsons Poems

943 words - 4 pages their beliefs, all in order to escape the alienation and rejection of not belonging. Emily Dickinson explores the stress between wanting to belong and staying firm in your beliefs which she conveys through her poetry, especially in poem 82, ‘I had been hungry all these years’ and poem 67 ‘I died for beauty. Poem 82 explores the personas desire to belong yet urge to remain confortable within herself whilst poem 67 looks at the consequence the

Related Essays

Hsc Belonging Emily Dickinson, Ugly Duckiling

1286 words - 6 pages selected poems by Emily Dickinson, most notably I Had Been Hungry All the Years, What Mystery Pervades a Well, and I Gave Myself to Him, the story The Ugly Duckling by Hans Christian Andersen, and the song Invisible Kid by Metallica. I Had Been Hungry All the Years is Dickinson’s expression of how she views herself in relation to belonging – or more correctly, not belonging. She uses the metaphor of “windows” representing barriers to belonging

Walt Whitman And Emily Dickinson Quotes Explained

1613 words - 7 pages Kathryn GalbraithAmerican Lit.Emily Dickinson was a brilliant writer and is often considered the "mother" of poetry. For this reason I choose a passage from her writing to start this paper.Some keep the Sabbath going to churchI keep it staying homeWith a bobolink for a choiristerAnd an orchard for a dome (Emily Dickinson)This is a strong passage about religious faith and how one chooses to worship. In the eyes of Dickinson worship was in her

Emily Dickinson Review And Interpretation Of Poems #449, #465, And #712

1800 words - 8 pages obviously see the theme of death and the ABCB rhyme scheme."I died for beauty, but was scarceAdjusted in the tomb,When one who died for truth was lainIn an adjoining room.He questioned softly why I failed?"For beauty," I replied."And I for truth,-- the two are one;We brethren are," he said.And so, as kinsmen met a night,We talked between the rooms,Until the moss had reached our lips,And covered up our names."-Emily Dickinson poem #449The speaker claims

Belonging Essay Using ‘Strictly Ballroom’ And Two Related Texts

1174 words - 5 pages Belonging Essay using ‘Strictly Ballroom’ and two related texts Belonging is important in Baz Luhrmann’s Strictly Ballroom, Looking for Alibrandi by Melina Marchetta and Minh Bui Jones’ feature article, On Home and Haven. These texts show how belonging or to fit into a group and be part of something is essential to human existence and brings more meaning to one’s life. Belonging is about being comfortable with the people you interact with and