This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Banking Ethics Essay

3850 words - 16 pages

JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ISSUES Vol. XLV No. 2 June 2011 DOI 10.2753/JEI0021-3624450213

Banking Ethics and the Goldman Rule
John P. Watkins

Abstract: Insulating people from the effects of the crisis has left intact the habits of thought and the basic institutional structure. The continued reign of pecuniary values leaves intact the Goldman Rule: pursue profitable opportunities regardless the effects on others. Within a culture dominated by pecuniary values, profitable opportunities present a coercive force. Laissez-faire policies allow profitable pursuits without restraint. Subprime mortgages offered an opportunity to tap a new source of profits, namely, the increase in housing prices. ...view middle of the document...

Banks pursued making subprime loans to tap a new source of income without regard to the effect such loans might have on debtors. Banks provided subprime loans

John P. Watkins is a professor of Economics at Westminster College in Salt Lake City, UT. This paper was presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Evolutionary Economics, January 7-9, 2011 in Denver, Colorado.

©2011, Journal of Economic Issues / Association for Evolutionary Economics


John P. Watkins

assuming a continual rise in home prices. The collapse in prices precipitated the collapse in banking profits, prompting a call for bailing out the banks. Government bailouts effectively rewarded financial institutions for “bad” behavior. Hence, meaningful institutional change required to reign in the financial sector remain wanting. The Banking of Ethics Banking is a peculiarly capitalist activity. The purpose is profit; the means is through the purchase and sale of debts: government securities, commercial paper, consumer loans, and so on. Banks purchase debts (assets from the bank’s point of view) with cash or spendable IOUs. Spendable IOUs represent a promise redeemable for cash or some other acceptable asset. To fulfill these IOUs, banks must obtain cash or the spendable IOUs of other banks either by liquidating assets or acquiring liabilities through deposits or borrowing. Profits stem from the income earned from interest and fees less the interest paid and operating expenses. During medieval times, the Scholastics considered banking unethical. They viewed charging interest a sin against God punishable by eternal damnation.1 The Scholastics could not reconcile charging interest with the idea that economic activity should serve a moral end. Charging interest appeared to take advantage of the needs of others, behavior contrary to the medieval notion of a functional society. In brief, interest placed the money lender above the social interest (Tawney 1926). Following Aristotle, the Scholastics considered money barren. They viewed money as a means to procure the goods and services necessary to live a virtuous life. They viewed the pursuit of money as an end in itself contrary to nature. For within nature, everything has a beginning and an end; the pursuit of money begins with money and ends with money in a neverending process.2 The Goldman Rule Laissez-faire policies foster a belief that individuals and organizations may pursue pecuniary values without restraint. For individuals lacking ethical considerations there is no tradeoff. There is only a single minded pursuit of profit. In Milton Friedman’s view, the only ethical issue is how an individual allocates his property.3 Ayn Rand, Alan Greenspan’s intellectual mentor, precisely summarized the ideology underlying the Goldman Rule. I work for nothing but my own profit — which I make by selling a product they need to men who are willing and able to buy it. I do not produce it for their benefit at the...

Other Papers Like Banking Ethics

Speech by Tun Dr. Mahathir Bin Mohamad

2122 words - 9 pages production of goods and services and to trade in these items. 26. Islamic banks must always obey the injunctions of Islam not only in rejecting riba but also in any form of gambling or profiteering. 4 27. By staying strictly ethical Islamic banks may lose business. But in the long run the ethics that Islamic bank adheres to will win it loyal clients. Already we are seeing the clients of the conventional system switching to Islamic banking for

Mr Musundi Essay

3982 words - 16 pages GLOBAL CORPORATE STRATEGY Name Course Instructor School Date Abstract. The report seeks to answer questions relating to Lloyd banking group, an internationally accredited bank that offers several services. Several issues are addressed in the report. The first issue being addressed is the merit and demerits of globalization in the global financial industry. Additionally, the threats and opportunities facing Lloyd Bank are looked at. The

Bnp Paribas: Analysis of Strategies

1446 words - 6 pages large corporations. In regards to the firm’s corporate level strategy, BNP Paribas has three highly diversified business units; Retail-banking, Corporate & Investment Banking and Investment Solutions. Retail-banking is the largest. It constitutes 45% of their revenues and employs 59% of their 200,000+ employees. It includes personal savings/checking accounts, online banking, etc. The main needs of clients satisfied by this division are

Citi Group

4196 words - 17 pages Citigroup: Restoring Ethics and Image Before Growth Charles Prince, CEO of Citigroup, is facing a daunting challenge as the head of the largest financial services organization in world. He has joined a company that has experienced significant regulatory scrutiny and that has been linked to the biggest scandals in corporate history. Unfortunately for Prince, the problems are pervasive throughout most of Citigroup’s diverse service offerings. In

Example Of Proposal

9563 words - 39 pages banking apparatus compounded with other related aspects included ethics, professionalism, duties and responsibilities towards customers and company will improve efficiency and running smoothly in Islamic banking. The bank reputation and image is also an important factors that affect the customer satisfaction. For instant, the customer may only switch to another banks if the new bank is able to provide more better products and services than the

Branding Strategies in Banking Sector in India

2391 words - 10 pages BRANDING STRATEGY IN BANKING SECTOR IN INDIA A REVISED SYNOPSIS SUBMITTED FOR Ph.D. IN MANAGEMENT Table of Contents 1. TITLE OF THE THESIS 3 2. INTRODUCTION 3 3. A BRIEF REVIEW OF THE WORK ALREADY DONE IN THE FIELD 4 Branding 4 Branding Strategies 4 Branding strategies in banking sector 5 4. NOTEWORTHY CONTRIBUTIONS IN THE FIELD OF PROPOSED WORK 6 Rationale of the research 6 Objectives of the study 7 5. PROPOSED RESEARCH

Aig Bailout

812 words - 4 pages government in 2008 in effect stepped in and halted the dynamics of a free market with the assumption that AIG was too big to fail. What will the Government do when other big companies face such risks? Without hindsight, as the question says, AIG should have been allowed to sink and while the world economy and our banking system may have been adversely affected at the time, it would have sent a message of responsibility and strong corporate governance

The Hawthorne Experiment

1543 words - 7 pages and boost company profits or negative and cause the company to go out of business as we have seen with the banking industry. Organization that have good ethics and are transparent with information will tend to have better employee interaction, which will lead to increase profits. Reference Page What Caused Mortgage Meltdown . (2008, November 06). Retrieved July 29, 2011, from Hearlad News :

Free Trade vs Protectionism

3055 words - 13 pages reform (2011) available at: accessed on [5/12/2011] * Wikipedia, social responsibility (2010) available at: accessed on [4/12/2011] Book ref * Crane, A. Matten (2010) business ethics, third edition, Oxford University press. * Fisher, C. Lovell, A. Business ethics and values: individual, corporate and international perspective, second edition. Pearson Education * Mellahi, K. Wood, G. The ethical business: challenges and controversies. First ed. Palgrave Macmillan Ltd

Corporate Governance

4897 words - 20 pages Governance is aimed at ensuring proper governance of business as well as complying with all the governance norms prescribed by regulatory board for the benefit of all interested parties including society. The basic objective is the maximization of long-term shareholders value within the parameter of public law and social ethics to give an impression to customers and employees about the transparency and fairness of business. Particularly in banking sector

Ethics Paper

897 words - 4 pages manipulation of information or just right out stealing of company’s assets or even its stakeholders money. Recent developments in the financial services industry, especially those directly connected with the global banking industry have prompted many shareholders and other financial stakeholders to question the moral obligations of corporations. Moral obligations and business ethics are an integral and important part of the strategic management

Related Essays

Unethical Practice Essay

5078 words - 21 pages . Those in favor of Islamic banking believe the Islamic banking system is superior to the capitalistic model of the West, because it is structured around a "strict code of ethics" (based on the Quran) and is prohibited from "exploitative practices" (including the charging of interest). According to Islamic banking proponents, this allows banking to be an integral part of a moral society (governed by the Quran). In contrast, they believe capitalism

Islamic Finance Essay

607 words - 3 pages This essay will provide a comparison between Islamic Finance and conventional Finance principles. In order to do this, firstly it is necessary to determine the scope and establish some of the fundemental concepts that define Islamic Finance, or "Sharia compliant banking" as it is often referred to. After this, it will be possible to discuss some of the advantages that Islamic Finance institutions have over the typical conventional banks. As

Business Research Ethics Essay

627 words - 3 pages Week 2 Business Research Ethics RES351/Quantitative Analysis for Business February 9, 2014 Citigroup, Inc. is a well diverse financial services company, which provides various financial needs to corporate customers, as well as individual consumers. Citigroup divides the services offered into three business segments, which are Corporate and Investment Banking, Global Wealth Management, and Global Consumer. They also have

Cyber Ethic Essay

3078 words - 13 pages ISSUES AND CHALLENGES IN CYBER ETHICS INTRODUCTION According to Barquin (1992), cyber ethic guidelines consist of Ten Commandments which are: (1) Thou shall not use a computer to harm others, (2) Thou shall not interfere with others computer work (3) Thou shall not snoop around in others computers files, (4) Thou shall not use computer to steal, (5) Thou shall not to bare fall witness, (6) Thou shall not copy or use proprietary software