This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Audit Quality Vs Audit Independence Essay

1590 words - 7 pages

Word count: 1471
What distinguishes auditing from consulting is the independence requirement in auditing, defined as “the absence of economic interest in the auditee” (Jeppesen 1998). However, he also concluded in this article that “auditors cannot be independent because audit is no longer independent”. This essay will explain and critically discuss the conception of audit independence in conjunction with audit quality by first defining audit independence, followed by definition of audit quality, leading to a discussion of the relationship between audit quality and audit independence. It is argued that however important the concept is, audit independence has potential threats and it is ...view middle of the document...

Mautz & Sharaf 1961 also confirmed this point by saying that the greatest threat to the individual auditor’s independence is “a slow, gradual, almost casual erosion of his honest disinterestedness”. On the other hand, operational independence is the immanent ability of auditing to be independent. It consists of informational independence, which concerns the problem with audting’s fundamental dependence on information supplied by the auditee; and epistemic independence, which defines that the knowledge upon which the auditor’s opinion is based on must be independent. In reality, such independence is difficult to achieve because the audit engagement is based all on data provided by the auditee, which violates informational independence. Another threat to independence lies in the relationship between auditors and auditees. The auditor is hired exclusively by the auditee with the aim of helping the auditee to reach its strategic objectives. For example, KPMG aims to provide services that “improve the reliability and relevance of information used for decision making”. The auditee is also directly involved in choosing the areas or processes to be audited, which on one hand helps the auditor focus his activities (Arthur Andersen); but on the other hand, the participation of auditees in the selection of areas to be audited increases the chances of auditors representing auditees’ self-interests, which means they are no longer independent. Moreover, Gibbins 2008 found that audit partner is the “relationship manager” responsible for keeping the client “happy” and the relationship in a “good” state, because even if he does not do so, the CFO may have several ways to move the auditor role towards what the CFO want in the relationships, namely auditors as “expert advisors” or “police officers”. Bazerman 1997 also found that auditors tend to be far less concerned about imposing harm on the anonymous public than on the known individuals of the auditee’s management, though theoretically, for an audit to be of value, the public perception of independence must be maintained. Having considered different aspects of audit independence using the definition of Jeppesen 1998, it can be argued that audit independence, crucial though it is, is not achievable in real life due to the relationship between auditors and clients.

According to DeAngelo 1981, audit independence is a component of audit quality. This paper defines quality of audit services as “the market-based joint probability that a given auditor will discover a breach in the client’s accounting system and report the breach”. In other words, audit quality consists of competence and independence. Competence depends on the auditor’s technological capabilities, auditing procedures and the extent of sampling. Independence in this manner is the auditor’s independence to report the breach without any interference. Nonetheless, this famous definition has not suggested how to measure audit quality. FRC 2006...

Other Papers Like Audit Quality vs Audit Independence

Should Schools Be Audited? Essay

3674 words - 15 pages _____________________________________________________ 16.2 Program-Specific Audits_____________________________________________ 16.2 Performance Audits ________________________________________________ 16.2 Auditor General Audits______________________________________________ 16.3 Management VS Auditor Responsibilities ____________________________________ 16.3 Selecting An Independent Auditor _________________________________________ 16.4 Preparing For Your Annual Audit

Doc, Docx, Pdf, Wps, Rtf, Odt

763 words - 4 pages 1 What does Internal Audit do? Internal audit is a department, independent of line management, whose prime responsibility is to review the quality and effectiveness of the controls within the banks to manage and mitigate risk and protect the assets of the bank. In performing this work Internal Audit provides recommendations and advice to management on matters requiring attention. Internal audit will normally produce an annual plan of

Auditing Standard

1871 words - 8 pages credibility of audit opinions depends on the integrity, objectivity and independence of the auditor. Accordingly, it requires the quality of audit more stringent, especially the independence of auditors’ assurance. ES2 illustrates the guidance on some particular circumstances, which may generate threats to the independence and objectivity of auditors. ES3 states that senior positions have collaborated with audit engagement for a continuous period should

Roles of Audit Committee

824 words - 4 pages ; reviewing compliance related matters and internal controls; overseeing the relationship, appointment and work of the external and internal auditors; and reviewing the annual financial statements and recommending them for governing body approval. As it relates to oversight of the internal audit function, the responsibilities of Committee’s include: ensuring that internal audit activity is structured to achieve organisational independence

Filipino Management Style Philippines: Management Style Tends Towards the Paternalistic as Is Often Found in Strongly Hierarchical Cultures. However, Managers Need to Be Aware of Certain Strong...

1185 words - 5 pages the continuance of the client relationship and the specific audit engagement 2. Evaluate compliance with ethical requirements, including independence. 3. Establish an understanding of the term of engagement. Benefits of Audit Planning 1. It helps ensure that appropriate attention is devoted to important areas of the audit. 2. It aids in identifying potential problems and resolving them on a timely basis. 3. It helps ensure

Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation

1608 words - 7 pages -term could cause the auditor to feel even more pressure to avoid losing the client. (Arel, Brody, & Pany, 2005) References Arel, B., Brody, R. G., & Pany, K. (2005, January). Audit Firm Rotation and Audit Quality. Retrieved November 21, 2011, from The CPA Journal: Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. (2011, August 16). Concept Release on Auditor Independence and Audit Firm Rotation. Washington, District of Colombia, United States of America.

He Relation Between Auditors’ Fees for Nonaudit Services and Earnings Management

3684 words - 15 pages questions raised by both FJN and the SEC. F II. FJN’s APPROACH The underlying proposition examined by FJN is that the strength of the audit firm’s economic dependence on the client, or economic bond, consciously or unconsciously reduces the auditor’s independence, or willingness to resist client-induced biases in the reporting process. The lack of auditor independence results in lower earnings quality. The underlying cause (the economic bond

Impact of Ict on Accounting Practice in Nigeria

1690 words - 7 pages contains the findings of an audit done on the financial records or accounts of a company. This report is a significant tool used in evaluating whether quality standards are met by the company. Most audit reports contain the analytical and systematic review, assessment, and recommendations made by the auditor on the business matter. An audit report is commonly performed on the financial aspect of the business as well as on the performance of the

Pase For Small Entities

3311 words - 14 pages explained in the Glossary. 2 THE AUDITING PRACTICES BOARD ES - Provisions Available for Small Entities (Revised) INTRODUCTION 1 The APB issues Ethical Standards which set out the standards that auditors are required to comply with in order to discharge their responsibilities in respect of their integrity, objectivity and independence. The Ethical Standards 1 to 5 address such matters as: • How audit firms set policies and procedures to


8674 words - 35 pages ); the FSA review of the UK Listing Rules (looking at auditor independence, 2001); a Treasury Select Committee (July 2002); the Coordinating Group on Audit and Accounting Issues, January 2003); and a government review of accountancy regulation (January 2003). 4 Office of Fair Trading 4 the profession itself). New regulatory initiatives aimed at enhancing audit quality (overseen by the FRC) include: • • audit partner rotation (a five

Latvia - Audit

1106 words - 5 pages of internal audit units and heads of institutions in the field of internal auditing and internal control system. To facilitate the independence of the internal audit, the Internal Auditing Council was established in accordance with the Cabinet of Ministers' regulations Nr. 346 "Statutes of the Internal Audit Council" approved on 5 October, 1999. The members of the Council were appointed on 9 August 2000 by the Cabinet of Ministers (Decree Nr

Related Essays

Audit Quality Essay

843 words - 4 pages the issues that most greatly affect audit quality such as the size of the audit firm, independence of the auditor, and the monetary considerations given. These factors also affect management’s decisions to select a particular audit firm. Audit quality is most heavily influenced by the size of the audit firm and the perceived reputation of that firm. The larger a firm, the more stress that is put on performing a quality audit due to reputation

Quality Audit Of Paper

2275 words - 10 pages Quality Audit Of Paper | INTRODUCTION PAPER Paper is a thin material mainly used for writing upon, printing upon or for packaging. It is produced by pressing together moist fibers, typically cellulose pulp derived from wood, rags or grasses, and drying them into flexible sheets. Paper is produced from its pulp either by paper machine (fourdrinier machine) ,or by handmade paper technique. The Fourdrinier Machine is the basis for

The Effects Of Longterm Auditor Client Relationship On Audit Quality

2445 words - 10 pages for instance audit quality, audit independence, audit learning, audit liability etc. Arguments related to auditor learning states that the audit tenure affects the audit quality in a positive way, because in the initial audit-client relationship the material errors are difficult to detect which poses a threat to the integrity of clients’ accounting reports, and thus audit quality improves with the increase in audit tenure (Johnson, Khurana

Documenting Independence And Objectivity: A Well Written Charter Provides The Framework And Purpose For Internal Audit Conduct

563 words - 3 pages Documenting independence and objectivity: a well-written charter provides the framework and purpose for internal audit conduct Many companies accept the thought of an internal audit charter to document when an internal audit is supposed to be independent and objective. An internal audit charter is a formal document that outlines the purpose, authority, and responsibility. It gives the internal audit department a place inside the company