This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assessment Of The Claim That The Family Has Become Increasingly Symmetrical

1228 words - 5 pages

Assessment of the Claim that the Family Has Become Increasingly Symmetrical

Many sociologists have different perspectives on whether or not the
family has become increasingly symmetrical. Some sociologists such as
Willmott and Young believe that the family does not consist of
conjugal roles where the couple have separate roles, such as the women
carrying out the expressive role and the male carrying out the
instrumental role.

Whereas there are other assumptions that have been made by other
sociologists, such as Ann Oakley, a feminist, who believes that
household roles are not joint, the cohabiting couple do not share
household tasks like childcare ...view middle of the document...

In light of Willmott
and Young’s inaccuracy she conducted her own research on 40 housewives
between the ages of 20 and 30, and found some evidence of husbands
helping around the home, but no evidence of a symmetry trend, being
that only 15% of husbands had a high level of participation in
housework and only 25% participated in a high level of childcare. Also
from her research she found that industrialisation lead to the
segregation of family roles around the home.

Mary Boulton also suggests that many surveys done exaggerate how much
childcare is actually done by husbands. Her argument is that while men
may ‘help’ with childcare, it is the wives who take main
responsibility for looking after the children, often resulting in them
having to restrict their own lives. A patriarchal ideology still sees
women’s work to be looking after the children and doing housework.
This argument backs up the evidence that Oakley has towards a non
symmetrical family.

Duncombe and Marsden are two sociologists that interviewed 40 couples
that have been married for 15years. They identified another area of
work that is usually carried out by the women called ‘emotion work’
which is defined as being the management of ones own and other people
emotional welfare. They see this as being work; therefore, women have
to do a ‘triple shift’. This proves the theory that the family is not
symmetrical as the women are still doing the work, with now more
evidence of that, which is the ‘triple shift’ theory.

Another feminist that would back up Oakley’s theory of the non
symmetrical family is Pahl (1993) who interviewed 102 couples with
children, she saw together and alone. She focused on how each
partner’s contribution to family income effects the decision making
within the family. The results of her research showed that the husband
controlled pooling was the most common, this means that the money is
shared but the husband has the most control and the wife had a lower
income. She also found that the situation where the wife had control
was the least common. Therefore in over a quarter of couples there is
some equality but in most cases had more power.

This proves the theory that industrialisation plays a major part in
the segregation, as the husbands are the main breadwinners therefore
giving them more power in financial issues, thus enforces women’s
economic dependence on men. In Oakley’s view, even though the 20th
century saw an increase in the increase in the number of married women
working, being a housewife is still seen as a women’s primary role.

Like Pahl another sociologist Stephan Edgell (1980) conducted research
on middle class and professional couples, he found that the...

Other Papers Like Assessment Of The Claim That The Family Has Become Increasingly Symmetrical

Assess the View That Debt Has Become the Main Obstacle to the Development of Less Developed Countries

1502 words - 7 pages Assess the view that debt has become the main obstacle to the development of less developed countries It can be argued that debt has become the main obstacle of less economically or in general terms less developed countries to actually develop. However, debt alone cannot be the reason why countries have not developed there many things that need to be taken into consideration such as aid being misspent by governments, war and natural disasters

1. It Has Been Claimed That Social Welfare Is Not About Promoting the Recipients’ Wellbeing but About Promoting Their Compliance with Particular Standards of Behaviour. Critically Discuss This Claim...

1731 words - 7 pages 1970s women were less respected if they chose to stay home. Many women felt at this time that they were considered second class citizens if they did not have paid work. Women increasingly were hesitant to stay home. This meshed in with the fact that it had become almost impossible for one income to suffice for a family’s needs. These two models of womanhood had implications for single mothers on welfare benefits. Part-time employment was now

Outline and Evaluate the View That the Family Diversity Has a Positive Impact on Society (33 Marks)

990 words - 4 pages family diversity is responsible for the marginalisation of men, as women are increasingly deviating from their ‘housewife role’. Furthermore, the ideology of familism views other family types and relationships as deviant and abnormal. For example, it disapproves of homosexual adoption, cohabitation, one parent families, working mothers & those who choose childlessness. Evaluation of Study 2 However, Melanie Phillips would argue that

Assessment Of The Bhamra Family

1118 words - 5 pages . Behind their backs, Jess joins a soccer team after one of the team members, a white English girl, introduces her to the coach. When she gets the opportunity to go to America and play soccer for an American college, she feels she has to choose between making herself happy and making her family happy. Assessment of Culture and Ethnic Traits Jess’ family is a lower-middle/middle-class family, living in a townhome that they own in a suburban-type area

Explore the Claim That Consumer Society Is Characterised by Freedom of Choice

2017 words - 9 pages through such concepts as zero sum gain. Their increasing share of the UK grocery market and their expanding into alternative lines of product, correspond to an increase in their market power to suppress rival supermarkets (Allen, 2010 p.66), which in turn has led to closure of small family businesses, such as: greengrocers, butchers, corner shops etc. Helen Rimmer – a member of Tescopoly, argues that approximately 50 small independent shops close

Wood floor or will become the trend of low carbon situation has a better development space

754 words - 4 pages granulation equipment made of wood plastic composite materials, and then extrusion production group made of wood flooring. Wood floor or will become the trend With the increase of people's attention to environmental resources, recycling based economic development model, which is the core of recycling and comprehensive utilization of waste materials, has become the trend of world economic development. Vigorously develop the recycling of

Ultra-Fine Mill Has Become the Landmark in Industrial Field

587 words - 3 pages , building garbage piled up in the open air or simple landfill and transport most of the non closed transport vehicles, inevitably cause the transport process of garbage left off, dust and rock stone dust problems, serious influence the city's appearance and landscape. Let the rock stone to become available in building materials, research shows that the use of construction waste, recycling of metal ultra-fine mills in swaziland image is

Access the Claim That ‘the Main Function of Education Is to Maintain a Value Consensus in Society’ (20 Marks)

619 words - 3 pages Functionalist believe that the main function of education is to maintain a value consensus in society. The term value consensus means that the majority of society agree. For example in the United Kingdom people believe going to school and getting a education is a norm: this is a value consensus. The education system has many purposes such as secondary socialisation of children and allocation of roles, due to the meritocratic that lays within

Dd101 Tma06 Evalulate the Claim That When Talking of British Culture, It Is Better to Talk of Cultures

1270 words - 6 pages conflict with arguments that Britain has become a multi-ethnic and multicultural society and must develop a more multiple and complex national identity. When looking at national identities, it is important to look at the effect that migration has. From the point of view of the British Isles, we can examine the difference that the influx of migrants had to the culture of the country, in particular the arrival of migrants from the West Indies and Asia

Is the Uks Constituition Becoming Increasingly Codified

862 words - 4 pages The British constitution has become increasingly codified, discuss. A constitution is a set of rules that defines the manner a country is run. The British constitution is said to be an unwritten constitution, more accurately it is uncodified as much more of the British constitution is written down, however, they are not all written down in a single document like a codified constitution would require as how the US is, however draws from

Evaluate the Claim That the Souk Is Distinct from the Body

2095 words - 9 pages causes the tantrum is driven by irrationality, as is the human body. Plato uses the argument from knowledge to substantiate the claim that the body and soul are distinct. He describes learning as remembering what the soul has known previously in the world of Forms. Our grasp of concepts such as beauty despite not encountering the Form of beauty is used to prove the eternal nature of the soul. However, this argument relies on the assumption that

Related Essays

The Family Unit Is A Truly Symmetrical Unit Of Socialisation That Ensures Harmony And Cohesiveness

837 words - 4 pages irrelevant in today’s society. Many feminists argue that despite women having the opportunity to work as men to, there is little evidence that the average family is symmetrical. It is claimed that women have simply acquired a dual burden of paid work and housework. This leads to claims that the family remains patriarchal as men benefit from both women’s earnings and their domestic labour. Elsa Ferri and Kate smith (1996) found that the increased

Assessment Of The View That Conjugal Roles Have Become Equal

1301 words - 6 pages . Willmott and Young agree with the statement that conjugal roles have become equal. During the 1970’s they announced the arrival of the symmetrical family, a family in which the roles of husband and wife were similar. In the home the couple ‘shared their work and shared their time’. Husbands were seen to be increasingly helping with domestic chores, child rearing and decision making about family life. Willmott and Young found that

Assess The View That The Growth Of Family Diversity Has Led To The Decline Of The Traditional Nuclear Family

1278 words - 6 pages Assess the view that the growth of family diversity has led to the decline of the traditional nuclear family. The traditional nuclear family consists of a spouse and a husband with children. Firstly, a reason for the decline in the nuclear family is because of divorce. As divorce has increased there has been a rise in cohabitations. Cohabitations involve an unmarried couple in a sexual relationships living together. Whilst the number of

Assess The View That The Family Has Lost Its Functions

987 words - 4 pages Assess the view that the family has lost its functions Functionalism is the theory that all parts of a society serve a function which contributes to the survival of the society. Many sociologists argue that modern day nuclear families are becoming less common. Instead of just a couple and their independent children, extended, reconstituted and lone parent families are becoming increasingly more common. Leading, to the loss of traditional family