Assessment Ideas Essay

4303 words - 18 pages

At the coal face: critical reflections on two tutors’ formative assessment practices under pressure.

Billy Meyer and Penny Niven

INTRODUCTION
The context for this research was an Academic Literacy course at the UKZN. The course is part of a broader Access (Foundation) Programme, which is designed to help 1st year, mostly Zulu First language students from impoverished educational backgrounds adjust to the reading and writing requirements of a Humanities or Social Sciences degree in English. We (the writers) are both tutors on this course, sharing the teaching of some 75 ‘Access’ students. During the first semester of 2006 the outcomes of this course were, initially, that the students ...view middle of the document...

Besides being an“activist” research model, action research is also “critical” (p 205) because it aims to expose and identify the self-interests and ideological incoherence of educators. By reflecting on why they act in particular ways, the educators can then resolve to act in theoretically stronger ways. In this instance, we as tutors on the course critically interrogated the ideologies informing our formative feedback. Having noted incoherence within our practices, we wanted to revisit the theoretical frameworks for a better practice, and to develop a stronger, more accountable “praxis” (p 190). Action research is also ‘critical’ is because it aims to be “emancipatory” (p 202), that is to generate real change, bringing “transformations of consciousness” into “transformations of social realities” (p 181).

Furthermore, action research is “participatory” and “inclusive” in character (p 191). Therefore this project aims, over time, to work collaboratively with a larger group of tutors, involving them in them in the research process. At its best, this type of research develops “self-reflective communities” (p 201). In a context where there are usually seven Academic Literacy teachers, including some inexperienced Masters and PHD students, across the two UKZN campuses on which this course is offered, a project such as this one has the potential to be mutually developmental, building capacity within the community of practitioners.

Action research involves “spirals” or “cycles” of planning, acting, observing and reflecting (p 186). This “self-reflective spiral” (p 184) gives evidence of the “dialectical quality of action research: the dialectic of retrospective analysis and prospective action”, (p 185). This paper describes one cycle within the broader framework of an ongoing series of interactions between reflection, theory and practice.

METHODOLOGY
The first stage in the essay writing process was the starting point for this research cycle. Between the first and final drafts of the essay, we swapped our students’ scripts, initially with a view to standardising our marking criteria for the summative assessment at the end of the semester. This gave us unexpected opportunities for observing, in detail, each other’s styles of formative feedback, because the students were required to submit their first drafts alongside their final versions. In fact, one of our criteria for the summative assessment at the end of the process, was making a decision about the depth and quality of the changes which the students had made between their first essay and their final draft in response to our formative feedback. Engaging with this process we started to note the surprisingly different ways in which we gave formative feedback. We began to consider and discuss these differences and wonder whether they mattered – whether our comments were really aligned with the courses’ outcomes. We also wondered if our responses truly conformed to any of the substantial...

Other Papers Like Assessment Ideas

Assessment Task and Planning Essay

3059 words - 13 pages 1. TO BE ASSESSED: 1.1 Subject or Learning area: Languages - English 1.2 Lesson topic: Essay writing 1.3 Grade: 10 2. NCS LEARNING OUTCOME Learning outcome 3 (LO3) will be assessed in this lesson, namely writing and presenting 3. ASSESSMENT STANDARDS Identify the target audience and the specific purpose such as arguing or narrating; develop coherent ideas; decide on and apply the appropriate style, point of view and format of texts 4

Planning and Enabling Learning Essay

1294 words - 6 pages underpin co-operative learning and the Peer review toolkit includes many ideas to help learners build confidence in use of feedback both with each other and in the context of progress reviews. Quite clearly initial assessment is only the first stage of the learning process, if continuous assessment and positive feedback is fluent throughout the learning process then motivational levels will be kept at a premium. This kind of initial and continuous

Taqa Unit 1

1640 words - 7 pages , tests or observations 1:2 Define the key concepts and principles of assessment Concepts relate to ideas of assessment and principles are how ideas are put into practice. To effectively ensure consistency and fairness of decisions it is imperative to follow the assessment cycle, which consists of an initial assessment, assessment planning, assessment activity, assessment decision and feedback and review of progress. These will be broken

Hbr Do Organization Prefer Conformists

518 words - 3 pages relations may also effect performance as in innovations and innovative ideas always not a good practice.it requires promoting an idea through accepted channels ,risk taking and most importantly mistakes tolerance. Q2: Discuss the external factors that can affect the process of performance assessment within an organization. Do they help or hinder that process? Performance assessment is actually evaluating the achievements ,succeses and on the

Cert Ed Mod 2

2600 words - 11 pages Introduction What is assessment? Gravells (2008) suggests that assessment is a process of ascertaining if learning has taken place. Gravells adds that assessment enables the assessor to find out if a learner has gained the required skills and knowledge needed at a given point towards a course or qualification.   The assessment process in a teaching environment is a necessary requirement in order to measure a pupil’s knowledge and understanding

Edahod5 Assignment 1

4947 words - 20 pages English FAL Book review: book choice as agreed upon with educator Grade 11 Learning outcome (NCS): Reading: The learner is able to read and view for understanding and to evaluate critically and respond to a wide range of texts. 3. Assessment standards (NCS) applied We know this when the learner is able to: a) demonstrate various reading and i) summarise main and supporting ideas in point form, sentences and/or viewing strategies for paragraphs

Bus520

485 words - 2 pages Self-Assessment Score Sheet Directions: Complete the following self-assessments: A Twenty-First-Century Manager, “TT” Leadership Style, Intuitive Ability, Conflict Management Strategies, Time Management Profile, Organizational Design Preference, and Which Culture Fits You?” These self-assessments are located in Week 1 of your course shell. Read the scoring narrative provided at the end each self-assessment and record your score in the

Self Evaluation

1245 words - 5 pages :       | | | | | | | |Self-Assessment: Exceptional Exceeds Expectations Meets Expectations Improvement Needed Unsatisfactory | |Evaluator’s Assessment: Exceptional Exceeds Expectations Meets Expectations Improvement Needed Unsatisfactory

Authentic Assessment: Evaluating Reading And Writing Education

1166 words - 5 pages (1996), authentic assessment was developed due to criticism directed towards multiple-choice tests which in most cases provide superficial ideas of a student’s knowledge and understanding in a particular subject area and the application of the knowledge acquired by the students A critical look at the developed authentic assessment strategy shows that this assessment strategy is reliable and valid mainly because it provides a genuine

Tda 3.7 Assessment for Learning

1235 words - 5 pages TDA 3.7 UNDERSTAND THE PURPOSE AND CHARACTERISTICS OF ASSESSMENT FOR LEARNING 1.1 Compare and contrast the roles of the teacher and the learning support practitioner in assessment of learners' achievements. Although the teacher and the learning support practitioner work together to provide all pupils with the best possible knowledge, their roles in that process differ. It is the teacher who has the duty to plan the lessons

Bsbwor501 Manage Personal Work Priorities

2926 words - 12 pages (BSBWOR501) MANAGE PERSONAL WORK PRIORITIES AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT DOCUMENT (Please print your name) ____________________________________ (BSB50215) DIPLOMA OF BUSINES ------------------------------------------------- ASSESSMENT COVER SHEET CANDIDATES - Please submit this entire document (do not separate or remove pages) – with this page completed as required – and place at the top of your assessment

Related Essays

10 Principles On Assessment For Learning

1213 words - 5 pages the skills of self-assessment. Assessment for learning should be part of effective planning of teaching and learning A teacher’s planning should provide opportunities for both learner and teacher to obtain and use information about progress towards learning goals. It also has to be flexible to respond to initial and emerging ideas and skills. Planning should include strategies to ensure that learners understand the goals they are pursuing

Understand How To Involve Learners And Others In Assessment

542 words - 3 pages . They will collect and be aware of evidence that will be required for the assessor. • Peer pressure is created by your fellow workmates, they will create different ideas and thoughts • The collection of evidence for assessment is self driven and will need input from others • The portfolio will need to be structured and evidence collated - this gives a sense of ownership by the candidate 4.4 Explain how assessment arrangements can be adapted

Continuous Assessment Essay

2395 words - 10 pages throughout an investigation encourages students to expand their thinking, modify their investigation, and revise their ideas while the investigation is still going on. Continuous assessment also enhances student learning in an inquiry based classroom when the students and teacher work together to articulate a vision of “good science.” 3)-ENABLES TEACHERS’ PROFESSIONAL GROWTH By striving to better understand and guide students’ thinking

Curriculum And Asses Essay

1228 words - 5 pages one’s writing skills and ideas in ones essay were given. This, for me personally, improved my performance in my English subject. Creative writing was one of the things I enjoyed because of the way in which it was taught. In conclusion I believe that the best form of assessment to serve the purpose of promoting pupils learning in the best way possible is that of assessment for learning. It is a form of formative assessment which gives feedback to pupils over a period of time and allows for improvement during the course of the year. All in all it caters for all pupils and their individual needs when it comes to assessment and learning.