Assess The Positive And The Negative Aspects Of The United States Political Framework Based On The ‘Separation Of Powers’

2589 words - 11 pages

Assess the positive and the negative aspects of the United States political framework based on the ‘separation of powers’.
The United States is a presidential democracy; its political framework is based on the separation of powers between the executive, the legislative and the judicial branches of government. This is in contrast to a parliamentary democracy where there is a fusion of powers between branches of government 1. It is often argued that a parliamentary system of government based on a fusion of powers is a more effective form of government, particularly when legislating. Although this may be the case, the US political system has overcome issues faced by most parliamentary ...view middle of the document...

This division of power naturally created a system of checks and balances between the three branches of government. The separation of powers in the US has prevented the executive from becoming too powerful and over interventionist. For example, when a bill is passed through congress, it must be signed by the president in order for it to become law. The president can however, veto a piece of legislation by refusing to sign it. In a situation where the president refuses to sign a bill that has the approval of both the electorate and congress, congress has the power to override a presidential veto. This can only be achieved by a two thirds majority vote in both houses of congress. Although this is hard to achieve in practice, it is an effective restraint on a domineering president.

1 DALTON, R., J., STROM, K., POWELL, G., B., (2012). Comparative Politics. Custom book ed. Great Britain: Pearson Education Limited. Pg. 330.
2 Hillsdale College, (2003). Separation of Powers: Preventing Tyranny. [Online] Available at: [Last accessed: 13/01/2013].
3 MCKAY, D., (2001). American Politics & Society. 5th ed. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Limited. Pg. 45.
4 Hillsdale College, (2003). Separation of Powers: Preventing Tyranny. [Online] Available at: [Last accessed: 13/01/2013].
5DALTON, R., J., STROM, K., POWELL, G., B., (2012). Comparative Politics. Custom book ed. Great Britain: Pearson Education Limited. Pg. 330.

The Judicial branch of the government is argued to be the most effective restraint on the power of Congress. The Supreme Court in the United States has the power to strike down a law passed by the legislature by declaring it unconstitutional. This exclusive power given to Supreme Court means that Judicial Independence is extremely important. The US political framework, based on the separation of powers, has helped to ensure this vital element of Judicial Independence. The United States constitution states that there should be no overlap of power between the three branches of government, and most importantly no overlap in personnel. Article I, section 6 states ‘No person holding any Office under the United States, shall be a member of either House during his Continuation in Office’ 6. Each branch of government is operated by individuals entirely distinct from the other two branches of government. In the US political system members of the executive cannot have additional roles in the legislature also, unlike parliamentary systems of government where there is a fusion of powers and personnel. When Barack Obama campaigned for presidency in 2008, he resigned from his role as Senator of Illinois. It is extremely important that Supreme Court justices in the United States are completely free from influence from the other two branches of government. They hold a unique position in the US political system and are an...

Other Papers Like Assess the Positive and the Negative Aspects of the United States Political Framework Based on the ‘Separation of Powers’

What Are the Positive Aspects of the Stereotypes, If Any?

1282 words - 6 pages people/person without regard for individual differences. Even when stereotypes are positive, they always have a negative impact and can lead to discrimination. Prejudice is having a negative attitude toward a category of people. Stereotyping to me is the act of labeling a specific classification or trait to a person strictly based on a person's ethnic background, gender, age, or role. Generally speaking when people think about stereotypes they

Superiority Of The United States Essay

2258 words - 10 pages all other rebels to lay down their arms. The United States stayed in control of the Philippines until independence was granted on July 4, 1946" (Davidson).Thirteen years later, WWI began July 28, 1914. "President Wilson continuously tried to negotiate peace among the warring powers. While the United States debated entry into the war, the allies were coming close to losing the war. As momentum events propelled the United States forward war. On

History of the United States

1377 words - 6 pages The date of the start of the history of the United States is a subject of constant debate among historians. Older textbooks start with the arrival of Christopher Columbus in 1492 and emphasize the European background, or they start in 1600 and emphasize the American frontier. In recent decades American schools and universities typically have shifted back in time to include more on the colonial period and much more on the prehistory of the Native

The Creation Of The United States Constitution

991 words - 4 pages representation of the states was also one that was in a stalemate between the delegates (Constitution of the United States- A History). Larger states wanted a House of Representative with the number of congressman for each state based on the population of state. Smaller states saw this as unfair and wanted a Senate where each state had equal representation (Constitution of the United States- A History). In the Great Compromise the delegates finally came to

The Basis Of The United States Government

1433 words - 6 pages The Basis of the United States Government The United States government was formed based on one thing—the science of man. Many different psychological and political theories are founded on the basis that there is an actual science of human beings. The ideas and theories of Hobbes, Locke, Roseau, and Montesque all contributed to the formation and compellation of our governmental structure, among others. In fact, they all agreed on one

The President of the United States

1234 words - 5 pages racial identity which was required of them, but they had what they called reference books. If anyone was caught without the reference book they would be fined or put in prison. This book contained their fingerprints, photo and information on access to non-black areas Based on this information I believed that’s why the Public Safety Act and the Criminal Law Amendments Act were passed in the year of nineteen hundred fifty three. They added penalties

Alexander Hamilton and the First Bank of the United States

1738 words - 7 pages Encyclopedia of American History. 1st. Ed. 1998. Print. Hamilton, Alexander. “On the Constitutionality of an Act to Establish a Bank.” EbscoHost Database. 3.16 (2009) Web. Lane, Carl. “For a Positive Profit: The Federal Investment in the First Bank of the United States, 1792-1802.” The William And Mary Quarterly. 54.3 (1997): 601-6012. JSTOR. Database. 10 Oct. 2009. Morgan, Wayne H. “The Origins and Establishment of the First Bank of the United States.” The Business History Review. 30.4 (1956): 472-492. JSTOR. Database. 10 Oct. 2009. “Thomas Willing.” UPenn Archives. “The University of Pennsylvania.” 28 Nov. 2003. Web. 16 Oct. 2009.

The Progressive President of United States

3879 words - 16 pages The significant factor that leads the United State becomes the most powerful country actually depend on its presidency and the policy to control their society. In fact, the United States has survived from several situations that should have brought them down to the crisis, but, the national political leaders such as Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson, who intense to the social and political changes in America, have successfully raised a

Analysis of the United States Army

2960 words - 12 pages and represented other aspects of the Army’s organizational life. This analysis will examine the organizational structures of the United States Army and look at how these metaphors have influenced the Army’s performance both in the actions it has taken to help maintain America’s freedom and the freedom of citizens around the world. Analysis of the United States Army The United States Army, the land-based component of the American Armed

The Growing Gap of Wealth in China and United States

4084 words - 17 pages time in history. But the current debate spotlights the challenges of addressing poverty in middle-income countries such as China, India and Brazil, where economic growth is strong but wealth is unequally spread. And what is true in the developing countries of the unequal distribution of wealth, and of the consequences of that unequal distribution, is true again on a world scale. On the other hand, in some developed countries such as United States

Role Of The United States Constitution

831 words - 4 pages Constitution PAGE 2 Constitution PAGE 4 The United States Constitution has been governing our way of life for over 200 years. Throughout its time, it has been viewed in many ways to make our lives easier. It has been the legal structure of our political system, establishing governmental bodies, determining how their members are selected, and prescribing the rules by which they make their decisions. From the start, the United States has

Related Essays

The Positive Aspects Of The Cold War: 1946 1991 Describes The Positive Aspects And Outcomes Of The Cold War, And How It Helped To Create A Stable World Economy And Political Structure

1518 words - 7 pages many other countries as possible in order to weaken the enemy's political strength on the world stage. In order to do this, both the United States and the Soviet Union provided large amounts of financial aid and weapons, and signed bi-lateral trade agreements with countries and/or ethnic groups with whom which they wanted to be allied. They also provided funding to revolutionaries in other countries that were not in their sphere of influence

The Positive And Negative Effects Of Dna Profiling

2879 words - 12 pages Genetic engineering has developed and blossomed at a frightening rate in the last decade. Originating as merely an area of interest for scientists, genetic engineering has now become an area of which all people should be somewhat knowledgeable.DNA profiling has many uses, both positive and negative, in our society. Aside from its usefulness in many legal investigations, DNA profiling can be used in the workplace to discriminate against employees

The Absence Of A Separation Of Powers In Britain Gives The Government Too Much Power

885 words - 4 pages ‘The absence of a separation of powers in Britain gives the government too much power.’ Discuss. 1c) Britain's govt. is too powerful due to its absence of a separation of powers. Britain’s executive, legislative and judiciary are fundamentally connected. Many are part of two or more these powers, such as the PM who is in both the executive and the legislature. Therefore a large majority can do as it pleases. The Govt. controls itself and can

Principles And Articles Of The United States

2697 words - 11 pages branches to work together and to compromise with each other on the issues affecting the citizens of the United States. But disagreement in the making of public policy happens often in the United States as well in may other countries. Because of the way that our political system is set up there is bound to be some disagreements between the political parties. We all know that no political system is perfect whether federal or state but the Constitution