This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assess Hume’s Reasons For Rejecting Miracles. (35 Marks)

810 words - 4 pages

Hume was a verificationist and approached miracles from an empirical view, relying on probability as a basis for his reasons for rejecting miracles.

Hume defined miracles as a ‘violation of the laws of nature’, he believed that the laws of nature were set in stone, through the use of a posteriori knowledge Hume identified them as being universal and unchanging. Hume observed that some Biblical miracles, such as Jesus walking on water, violated those laws of nature. He then went on to identify the probability that a violation of these laws could occur, Hume argued that if the probability of an event occurring was low then there was little chance that the miracle had actually occurred. ...view middle of the document...

Thus, he concluded that reports of miracles such as these could not be trusted due to a lack of empirical evidence to support such claims. Secondly, Hume also noted that miracles occur within the ‘barbarous’ periods of history as well in the ‘less civilised societies’; he believed that they occurred in these societies as the lack of education would lead the people to be awed by such events that would possibly be known as natural events in civilised societies. Events such as the Aurora Borealis may have been believed by the uneducated as miracles caused by God as a demonstration of His power and presence within the universe, when the scientific explanation is simply a refraction of particles within the atmosphere. These two practical arguments are reasonable reasons for rejecting miracles, the tendency to lie for personal gain occurs commonly in the world, one example would be of a woman who claimed to have survived 9/11 but was actually in another country during the event. The lack of education is also a valid reason as many miraculous reports come from the medieval period or in the less educated nations across the world, there is a lack of knowledge that prevents people from understanding some natural phenomenon, instead believing them to be a miracle.

Another observation by Hume was...

Other Papers Like Assess Hume’s Reasons for Rejecting Miracles. (35 Marks)

Assess the Sociological Reasons for the Change in the Social Position of Children and the Consequences of These Changes for the Family and Society

967 words - 4 pages Assess the sociological reasons for the change in the social position of children and the consequences of these changes for the family and society (24 marks) The social position of children over time has greatly changed, this evident through the work Philippe Aries. During the Middle Ages (10th-13th Century) Aries (1960) argued that ‘the idea of childhood did not exist.’ He used works of art as evidence to show that children of that time

Assess Sociological Explanations for the Relationship Between Gender and Religious Practice and Participation. 33 Marks

828 words - 4 pages , for example orthodox Jews forbid women priests. However Wright argues that Judaism has allowed women to become Rabbis since 1972. Armstrong also argues that women weren’t always depicted as lower than men in sacred texts. Although in Islam women will often pray behind a screen, separate to men and will not be allowed to touch the Qur’an if they’re menstruating. Holm’s argues this is devaluating women within religion. Similarly, Radical Feminists

Assess the Arguments and Evidence for and Against the View That Foreign Aid Is an Obstacle to the Development of the Majority World. (33 Marks)

644 words - 3 pages Aid for developing countries always comes in different forms with different objectives that it is trying to achieve. Different perspectives have their views on whether aid is actually helping or if it is making the situation in the developing countries even worse. Theories such as modernisation believe that aid is a rather positive thing for the development of the majority world. Rostow argues that thses countries have economic barriers that

‘In His Defence Speech, Euphiletus Presents Himself As Both A Good Husband And A Good Citizen.’ To What Extent Do You Agree? Give The Reasons For Your Views And Support Them With Details From The...

546 words - 3 pages show he was administering the law. He expected the Athenians to view him as a good citizen carrying out the laws of the city: “For I am now risking the loss of life, property and all else that I have, because I obeyed the city’s laws.” As a man with some influence among his neighbours, Euphiletus felt he could make such a claim. However, Euphiletus did allow his wife too much freedom which lead to him killing his wife’s lover In conclusion


5071 words - 21 pages , changes in family size over the past 100 years or so. (24 marks) 1 0 Using material from Item 2B and elsewhere, assess sociological views of the impact of government policies and laws on family life. Item 2A Over the past 40 years or so, there has been a decline in the number of first marriages in the United Kingdom. One of the reasons for this decline is the change in the role of women in society. In order to develop their careers, women

By Definition, Miracles Can Never Happen. Discuss

1639 words - 7 pages the laws of nature cannot be defied, (if they could be broken they would not be laws), by Hume’s definition, miracles can never happen, as laws of nature are fixed. Hume also does not believe in the supernatural, so to state that miracles can only be brought about by the will of a higher being is again saying that miracles can never happen because that higher being does not exist, and therefore cannot make an event, such as a miracle, happen


843 words - 4 pages ) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Assess the usefulness of functionalist theories in understanding religion today.(33 marks) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the view that most people today choose not to be lifelong members of religious organisations. (18 marks) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Jun ’11: | Assess the view religion is a force for social change (18 marks

Business Research

2530 words - 11 pages steps. 1. Come up with a definition of the construct. 2. Develop a response format. 3. Assess t he validity and reliability of the measurement scale. 4. Develop an instrument (one or more items or questions) that actually measures the concept that one wants to measure. What is the correct order? Choose one answer. | a. 1-4-2-3. | | | b. 1-2-3-4. | | | c. 1-2-4-3. | | | d. 1-4-3-2. | | Incorrect Marks for this

Paper on Philosophy

573 words - 3 pages motivation for Wiles’ rejection of God’s providence is that if God did cause miracles, they would seem arbitrary and biased for the above reasons. It also removes the idea that God is not omnibenevolent (because he chooses not to intervene consistently) or that he is not omnipotent (because he cannot intervene consistently). He instead argues that while Biblical miracles should not be dismissed, they should instead be considered as symbols and demythologized, as Bultmann proclaims. This helps to reveal God as worthy of worship without involving biased miracles. In conclusion… (Left this out because it’s just a summary).

Beyond Th Poyr

269 words - 2 pages e of the reasons for ethnic differences in educational achievement. [12 marks] • Using material from Item A, and elsewhere, assess the contribution of functionalist sociologists to our understanding of the role of the education system in society. [20 marks] Research Methods The research methods section of this paper is one of the more straightforward sections that you will have. It consists of four questions that with the

Kant Versus Hume

985 words - 4 pages he argued the aspect of constant conjunction. In this aspect, the cause and effect must be spatially and constantly existent. Secondly, he asserted that it must have temporal priority, in that; the cause had to precede the effect. Lastly, the event must have a necessary connection we must develop an understanding of why a cause produces a certain effect. Hume’s critique of causation is that we cannot see it, we must infer it. (Lorkowski) For

Related Essays

Assess The View That Conscience Need Not Always Be Obeyed (35 Marks)

1021 words - 5 pages Assess the view that conscience need not always be obeyed (35 Marks) Conscience, an individuals’ moral sense of right or wrong, is the driving force behind many of our actions and decision making in life. A number of people, the most prominent being the German neurologist Sigmund Freud, believe that the shaping and subsequent implementation of the human conscience is brought about as a direct result of environmental factors, in other words

Examine The Reasons For Changes In Birth Rates And Family Size Since 1900 (24 Marks)

1138 words - 5 pages ‘Examine’ Essay Planning Sheet Name: Essay Title: Examine the reasons for changes in birth rates and family size since 1900 (24 marks) | Underline or highlight the key concepts, terms and instructions, by identifying these key elements it will allow you to focus on answering the question. It is important to use relevant sociological terminology within the context of you essay. List the key sociological

Assess Sociological Explanations For The Increasing Number Of Religions And Spiritual Organisations And Movements In Society Today. (33 Marks)

1096 words - 5 pages Assess sociological explanations for the increasing number of religions and spiritual organisations and movements in society today. (33 Marks) Since the 1960’s there has been an increase in the number of sects and cults that are among religious organisations. There are also now an estimated 850 new religious movements. Sociologists offer many reasons for this but the main three are marginality, relative deprivation and social change. However due

Assess The Reasons For The Failure Of The Romanov Dynasty To Achieve Stability By 1917

1353 words - 6 pages “Assess the reasons for the failure of the Romanov dynasty to achieve stability by 1917” The start of the 20th century brought radical changes to the political and social structure of the autocratic Russian Empire. It was a time of regression, reform, revolution and eradication. A short period between the end of February through to the start of March 1917, Tsarist Russia and the Romanov dynasty had come to an end. The Romanov family, who