This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assess How Useful Sources C And D Would Be For An Historian Studying The Impact Of Total War On The Home Fronts During World War I

702 words - 3 pages

Assess how useful Sources C and D would be for an historian studying the impact of total war on the home fronts during World War I.
In your answer, consider the perspectives provided by the TWO sources and the reliability of each one.

Both sources C and D would be very useful to an historian studying the impact of total war on the home fronts during World War I.

Source C is a primary source from a former American ambassador, James Gerard's "My Four Years in Germany." This source would be useful to a historian as it describes the rations that were applied to meat, potatoes, milk, sugar, butter and soap in Germany. It also explains the class separation between the rich and poor as the rich's life style did not change all that much as they were still able to eat well just for higher prices. This would have separated the classes even more than before, with two extremes- the really rich and the really poor as the working class suffered ...view middle of the document...

The source describes this by stating the lack of coal and explaining the reasons for the public places closing was so the coal was not wasted. The source is only focused on the German home front and does not give an indication on the situation in other countries.

Source D is equally useful, but from a British perspective instead. The source is a British propaganda poster from 1917 demonstrating a woman cutting bread and a British ship crashing into a German U-Boat with the words, "Don't Waste Bread!" and "Defeat the 'U' Boat." The purpose of this poster would have been to persuade people to ration their bread in order to lessen the amount of coal needed. To do this it tries to raise moral and patriotism by saying that by saving their bread they are contributing to the war, instilling a sense of purpose. The image of the ship crashing into the German submarine gives the public someone to blame for the rations they are being put under as well. One of the aims of the poster would be to instill hatred of the Germans, the enemy, for being the ones that cause them to have to save their bread and therefore will want to help with the war effort even more to get rid of the hated Germans. This source is useful because it demonstrates that Britain had rations put in place and tells how the government went about trying to influence people into helping the war effort and complying with the rations. however it does not show the historian the reactions to the poster and if it fulfilled its intentions.

The sources are also reliable as source C is just a retell of what a man saw when he was in Germany without any apparent judgment on it. Source D is reliable as it is an actual poster produced by the Ministry of Food in 1917 and therefore gives a historian an accurate picture of what kind of propaganda was put out there in the home front. Both sources, though they were from entirely different perspectives and were different source types, gave quite a bit of information that a historian could definitely use , along with other sources on reactions to propaganda, other countries' first hand accounts and other primary and secondary sources of similar nature, to assess the impact of total war on the home fronts during World War I.

Other Papers Like Assess How Useful Sources C and D Would Be for an Historian Studying the Impact of Total War on the Home Fronts During World War I

The Role Of The USSR During World War II

3438 words - 14 pages This is a report I handed in for my Freshman Term paper. I didn't get a number grade, but it was an "A." I double checked for mechanical erors, but there might still be some left.World War II is considered on of the most tragic wars in human history, taking the lives of millions of people. Every allied country had somehow contributed to the defeat of Nazi Germany and it's allies, and every country had suffered losses. The Soviet Union, being one

The Impact World War 1 Had on Russia

1759 words - 8 pages reduction in the output of consumer goods. • Consumption by households fell by 25% during the war. Agriculture • The demands of the army and of war industries for labour had a substantial impact on the Russian countryside. • It was the villages which supplied most of the conscripts and most of the additional labour for the factories. • As the war went on, this had an increasing effect on agricultural communities. • Women had to take in a

The Role of Women During World War Ii

785 words - 4 pages women who wanted to carry on working were forced to return home. In addition, employment opportunities returned to their former state, and in 1961 15% of doctors and 3% of lawyers were female. The Equal Pay Commission suggested that pay should not change or become more balanced, but instead women should look for different jobs so that they would not be in competition with men, and therefore equal pay would not be an issue. Finally, women were still portrayed in their traditionally domestic role by the media. They showed everyone that women were highly capable of doing a ‘man’s job.’

Propaganda, Recruitment And Resistance During World War I

2629 words - 11 pages 600,000 volunteers stepped up to support the war efforts. The aim for the end of December was an army of 4 million (which even for the ‘Supreme British’, I believe was a long shot). Conscription would have faced a battering by civil rights activists if introduced in 1914, as conscription was anti-liberal, and a breach of civil rights and individual freedom. In hindsight, with all the protesters, volunteering was an

This Is An Essay On Triumphal Arches, Describing The The Purpose Of Them And How This Was Achieved. Helpful For Anyone Studying History Of Art AS

804 words - 4 pages , but in other provinces also, and there is still remaining evidence on this.Triumphal arches were used for the reasons explained above, but how they achieved this is a lot bigger issue. I am going to first talk about the arches themselves and how they were pieced together. The arches would usually only have one arch for example the Arch of Titus or Trajan's arch, however, sometimes they would have three arches, such as the arch of Constantine, but

Assess How Branding Has Increased in the Last Few Decades. Think of a Brand; Analyze How the Organization Developed Its Brand Equity. Assess the Influence of Branding on an Organization’s Imc. Must...

629 words - 3 pages University, IMC takes into consideration such aspects of communication process as providing full information about products, services by means of marketing promotion, personal selling, direct marketing, packaging and labeling (“all sources of information”) and other techniques and approaches (Northwestern University's Brochure, 1991). Comparing these two definitions, on the one side, it should be noted that first one takes into account any person

Influences On America To Enter World War I: Three Of The Major Events And Reasons That Influenced America To Go To War

894 words - 4 pages fact, two more American ships were attacked; The Arabic and The Sussex. Germany continued and America crossed the threshold.A second reason that America entered World War I was its own economic interests. When Wilson took office in 1913, America was in a business depression. And during times of war, belligerent nations need supplies. The Allied powers looked to America for help and the U.S. did not hesitate. This trade with the Allies helped to

The Impact of World War 1 Part a

2472 words - 10 pages of women changed for the worst during the war. This is down to the fact that it states that women working at a London aircraft works were only paid 15s per week for up to 12 hours of tiring work. This source is useful and I agree with it as it supports my own knowledge that during the war years; the lives of women did not only change for the better, but also for the worse. The source supports my knowledge that the war had a negative impact on the

Support or refute the argument that the prolonged and bloody stalemate of the World War I

1124 words - 5 pages an arbitrary relationship between them would conflict with reality to such an extent that for this reason alone it would be totally useless (6). World War I demonstrated the imbalance of the “Paradoxical Trinity” in which the populace hatred of the war, the commander’s inexperience in trench warfare, the government failure to provide the ends (policy and goals) which prolonged the war and death of millions of soldiers. In

Are Positivist Methods the Most Useful for Studying Society

576 words - 3 pages crimes e.g. the working class. But others say the crime statistics are only a small part of all the crimes committed and you cannot base a sociological theory on them because of the dark figure of crime. interactionists think positivist methods are inappropriate for studying society because what sociologists look at is very different from what other scientists study. It is not possible to isolate people in a laboratory and experiment on them

Causes and Effects of World War I

527 words - 3 pages increase in confrontation that helped push the world into World War I. Finally, there’s Nationalism. Much of the origin of the war was based on the desire of the Slavic peoples in Bosnia and Herzegovina to no longer be part of Austria Hungary but instead be part of Serbia. In this way, nationalism led directly to the War. But in a more general way, the nationalism of the various countries throughout Europe contributed not only to the beginning but

Related Essays

Compare And Contrast Sherriff's And Faulk's Presentation Of The Impact Of War On Those Who Fought In World War One. How Far Would You Agree With The View That Sherriff's Choices Of Setting And Narrow...

1301 words - 6 pages because of their sheer lac of care; they knew that the men would die but they also knew those they lost could be replaced. We can understand World War One further when we look into the psychological impact it had on the men, especially Stephen. During the Somme, "Skylarks wheeled and sang high in the cloudless sky. He felt alone, as though he had stumbled on this fresh world at the instant of its creation." The skylarks here are significant because

Assess The Impact Of War On The Lives And Attitudes Of The British And German Soldiers 1915 To 1918!

1629 words - 7 pages Assess the impact of war on the lives and attitudes of the British and German soldiers 1915 to 1918! World War 1 certainly had a significant impact on the lives and attitudes of the British and German soldiers during 1915-1918 and aspects such as trench life, tactics used in battle and change of attitudes accentuate how the impact was not one of positivity yet one of negativity. For the British trench life was a living hell as their

The Impact Of Freedom On Slaves Both During And After The Civil War

3065 words - 13 pages freedom on the slaves both during and after the Civil War. While the length of this paper precludes an extensive review, sufficient scope will be included to account for how the slaves first encountered freedom, the barriers they faced because of their freedom, and how they fared following the cessation of fighting. The act of ending slavery, by the Declaration, was simple. Enforcing the Declaration was another thing entirely. As stated by

Assess The View That The Impact Of The First World War Was The Main Reason For The Booming Economy In The Usa In The 1920’s

1981 words - 8 pages America’s economy and the combination of the two factors encouraged people to spend even more to cycle it into America’s economy. To conclude, I believe that the majority of the interpretations are in support of the fact that the impact of the First World War was the main reason for America’s booming economy in the 1920’s, with exception of source D. While it cannot be denied that Andrew Mellon had an effect on the economy, interpretation D